← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2640/2012disposed of

Amarjit Kaur v. Kamta Paswan And ORS

2018-09-11Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal28 pages



      

!

"

  !#$!

!% &'(  )*+,-*

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2 !

  !#$ !

!

 '+,-*

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2   !#$!!

!

 5+65376-

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2 $   !#$4!

!

 6-+,-*

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2   !#$$!

!

 *9,-*

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2 #   !#$8!

!

 3*,-*

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2 :

  !#$#!

!

 '+,-*

..//

0*- ,) 123* 

.2   ! !

!

 32*,-*23*

..// 0*- ,) 123* 

.2 '



    

 

 



  



 

 

   !" #

$$$$

 

%&'

(  ""  )  *  +,

 - ./ -/&-  "

0

( " 

 +,

 - .& -/&-  0

( " 

 +,

 - .- -/&-  *0

*

( " 

 +,

 - .4 -/&- 

0

( " 

 +,

 - ..

-/&-  ) 

( " 

 +,

 - .6 -/&- 

 

( " 

 +,

 - .

-/&-  0

( " 



+,

 4&-7 -/&-  8

 ( "



 )* 

"" 









   *



   )   #   ! "  + *    : : ) 

  

 



  

 &

-  **

 # *  

 &

 "" 

;



 



  "" 

%-'

 ;

  * * /4 /4 -//7

/. /4 -//7

   < 

*  

*

;

*  0

* < 

* 



* 8 =

* 0

*



  0

*

*0

*

 ** "

 *  *

 

  )*  8 =

*



*  *  # 

0

* >?@

   *



 

  )*  )

*  "*

 

 

"   1     ;

*  

 ;

 ;   



#  

  ;

 

   =  ;



 

  *

    ;

 ;

 

 

*  



*  

  *  ;

"     0 8 =

*

;

* 

 *    *  ) A"

* 0  < 

*  

* 0

* 

*





* < 

* 



*

*0

*

 "   

  *

#  * ,

 ?

 

   

# *0

*

  <  ! * 



 )

*



 *  

 )

* " "   5 * " 

%4'

! 

  

%.'



 &

 "



 

 

*  ;*  ;



 &



#  

 *

 

 **     

  # *   

 &

"

  

 "

 

 

%6'



 !B & )

* #



0  *0

* !B -  



   !# ""

 # + A

#   

     ?

" )

* !; , =,  ) ?

"*   ;

A!

 ;

  #

 ) *  >#@  )

*

0  *0

*  

" "   ;

#*  ;   

** 

 **  

  #  ;

 

  



  *

=  ;



  "      * )    "# 8 =

* 

;

*   

# 

 , ?

  

  # 0 

 " 

  "

? *0

*

    0  *0

*

 <  ! *  % '

8



  ?

"

* " *  ?  "

  ?

"   "   ;

  *  #



* ")  



  #

* 

  * "   "   8 =

*   " 9 





 

   9 

*

 ""

 

# 

  



 

# ?   ;

AB - ?

"     ;

*  "#



 

  )   



 ;

   )* *  " 

"#

  ;

 ;*  * 

* "

  

"#  *  *  "

 *  , /4 /4 -//7  ;



 ; 

  ;* * **  

 

*





 ;

  " 

  

 ;

*   # " 



 " 







)*   ?

" 



" "    ;

 # ;

 )"

 #   

%D'

;

*E  

 &    

 ;* *



   ;



     ;* *

 

 ) );  

, 



); )#  

 ;* *

" )

*

*0

*   "     

 ;* *

 B   ;

   

   

 ;* * *  



 *   "

 ;

)  #@  

   &6 A A* &7F7

 -/&  ( 

 &4F !  (  &7F7   **   

 & )    ) # **  6/6/G *   ;

  ; 

#  ) "

 ;    

   ;

 * 



* 

  





%F'





 #  ;

" 

   

 !"#"

!  $  %

&  

  !"  '(()   '))    *    

  !"  #"

 +   !  

   ! 

),-.%

&

+ )-- %!   "/ /

 #"

     **  

 !"  012  '((3032

 04*25-'

 !!6

""

 7!/ + !

#"

 * 8 

 !"9 ))3,$'((,

!7 !

'- (5 '()(  "7"!0"

/2

 *  "7"!0"

/2



  ) 

 # 

  ** # 



 ; 

  ;*

 

%!   "//

#"

     **

 !"7"!0"

/2

 !!6

""

 7!/ + !

#"

 * 8 

 !"7"! 0"

/2

 #  ;

 "

)

   

 ) # ** ? 6/6/G

   

  !"  #"

 !

*   7!/ +0'((,2).:;3 5:) ?

! 

 * ) # **   ;

  )    



#  ;

  #

  ;

   ;

) 



) 

   #   )    



   "

  

*  "  * 

 *    "     *   ;

  

%7'

"#       "

* ) # **

   * 

 

 & 





%&/'

* 

 

 -

 )    

 )

* !;

"

, =, 

?

"

 ) * * *  

 *    =*    " 

    * C(

  #

"

/7 &- -//.

/F &- -//D * 

   C(   -D /4 -//F - /4 -/&&

 

 "

* *   



 ?

"

C     " 

 

*   -D /4 -//F  

 - /4 -/&&



   5(   # # * * ) * )

* !;

"

, =, 

   

   * C( #         " 

  # *   "



  #

 *  C* =,  

       " 

  # "

C*

    " 

  *  # # )

 *  ? * *    #   "

 ?

"   # " 

 *  "*  " 

 

" )*

     " 

%&&'

=



"

 

 *  @  * 5(     ;

 *   * 



  # C( 

 5( 

%&-'

 )  

*   !" #

 

  



*  " "



 * 

%&4'

  

 &

-

""

  



   

" 

   #

9 ':3($'()'

%&.'

=  < 

*

-.

# 

*

*   ) * # "* 5 "

" A &6///@  "

 

!B

 ? *    "  

 *

# ) ;

 >

* !"" *

 ?

"



"

*   

)*   

  "  



A .///@  " "#  

" "# "  A .///@

 "   

"



 "#  1*



* -.

#    ./G

  ./G A & //@ ./// ./&// I& //

)* "# "   A 6 //@ ./// J & // I //

  

"

 6/G "  

 ? )#

*

A -F//@  " 6 //- I -F//

#



#

" A 44 //@ -F// &- I44 // 1*

*  

   *

#!#"

1!*  "// '((,0.2% ''

 &F





#* " 

"

;  A /.F//@



A 4////@

    

 ?



   *  7!

/ +!

#"

% +! 

 !"  '()5 )'5(



# 

"

" A 4.F//@  /.F// J 4//// I

4.F// %&6'

  )#  )

 6/G

 ) # **  A 4&D.//@

"

 @  



A &.-7//@

 # )

    

"

" A &D.6//@ 4&D.// K &.-7// I &D.6//

%& '

 

" A &D.6//@   #  D 6 

 "

*    E

%&D'

B

 "  

  

 9 ':3)$'()'

%&F'

=  0

*

) 6/ # 

*

*   ) * # "* 5 "

; A &-//@  "



)

 

A 4///@  " 

"  

; A .-//@  "

 

B

    )

*  

 # "*

  ";

 A &6///@  "

 ?

" 0

* B .

 # ;

  ! 

#

 

  0

*

  ;

 #

    #" *  *  #"   0

*

>? B.& B.&-   #" *   0

*

  .//  ";

 "



?"

A F///@ 

 * "   " A &-//@  "



  * *

*     

%&7'

"#  

" "# "    A .-//@

 1*

*  

6/ #    -6G



 -6G A &/6/ .-//?-6&//I&/6/

)* "# "   A 6-6/@ .-//J&/6/I6-6/

  

  &4 "  

 ? )#

*

A &D6/@  " 6-6/4I&D6/ 

#

" A 46//@  " 6-6/@ &D6/I46//

A .-///@ 

 46//?&-I.-/// 1*

*  

   *#!"7"!0"

/2

 &4





#* " 

"

;  A 6.

///@



A D////@



  

   *   7!/ +!

#"

% +! 

 !"

7"!0"

/2 

# 

"

" A & ///@ 6.

///JD////I & ///

%-/'

  )#  )

 6/G

 ) # **  A 4/F///@

"

 @  



A --67//@

 # )

 

  

"

" A F-&//@

%-&'

 

" A F-&//@   #  D 6 

 "

*    E

%--'

B

 "  

  

9 ':3'$'()'

%-4'

!   

   "

  -. /F -/&&     ! "  + * 

)

%-.'

 0 #  



 "



@

& >?  *  "  E  "     

"  ?

- C *

 *

 0 

 *   ) 0     @ * *   "

 *

 "

  )#

4 + " ?

.

@  # ** *

 9 



  *



9  0 

6 C

"   *   * 

  C ?  * *# 

-6  4

< 4#"

!6

  7!/ + !

'())032  04*2-)5 5L) ?

! 

 *

 

  

 "  "

  )# 0  %- '

,  6-*3  0  1  2 -*  ).;

<)223*=!

4% ( %>/(4 ! 5L) ?

!    "

  )# 0   * "

"

  )#



 *  # " "   *  # )   "

  " "  " * 

;

#   )  #" #

;  )

"

" 

 " )0  

* #

    )

  

    

 " ;*

* 0  

%-D'

   7=  "

 !/*   "/ /  '().0.2  04*2:,: 

 5L) ?

!  " "  9



) E

) 

 

9  )  A  )

  

 !"

"

  )#

 *  # )

   "

  "

"

  )#



 *  #

%-F'

 4

  >

 6 +#"

  4"



  !'().0.2  04*2,.3 5L) ?

 * 0  0   *   0 # * 0  "

9

"



   ; ?    "  *  E  " ?

 E  "

  *   *



 

"   *  ? 

 *

  5L) ?

! 



A -/ -/ 

%-7'



!=     #"

  *    7!

/ +

 '().0.2  04*2 ,,: 5L) ?

!   4/G  )# 

"

   "    )#    &//G   )# C

  " ;*

* "



*  " - 

  ?

! 

 " A .-6/ 

%4/'

 !! /     #"

!6

 ""

 7!/ +'().0326!* 02.3'' 

 5L) ?

!   "

  )#



" ") "

   # *

 



" 

" 

 "  "# 

 &//G *  #  5* ! 

* D/G  "

 ?

!  

A &

  *



 

A - 





"



A &



 ?  * "

*#

%4&'

 < 4 #" !14" *  8!  *  7!/ +



  !'()(032 

04*2);; 5L) ?

!  **

 

)  *

" = *

*  0 

 0  

 "  

" 0 #



 ) ;

0 

) " 

 0 #  ;   !   ) "

"  "

 "

  

%4-'

  0   4/G "

  )# * * = )#

  ")  ;  )#

 )#     *  )#

 ;* "

 )#

%44'



* "  ;  )#  4/G   *  "

 "

  )#





 "

A &F///@



 *  *  # 0  

 

A & ///@

  "

A 4/ ///@

  *  #



 " 



A F///@

 

A &////@



*

A &6///@

 0#" 

A 6///@

#   *

A F///@

  * 

# 

" )

 A ./F///@



#* ) # **

A -/.///@

 

 # ) " 0 

%4.'

  *   "

  )#

#*  A -///@   *



  "

 "

  )#  



   

 # "



   

    )   

 )     ) 



" # * #  *

%46'

   

    !" #   

"



 

  





! "

 + * 

) 



*# "

9 ':3.$'()' %4 ' =  

*

-.

# 

*  @ 

 ;

 5 "

 6///@  "

 "   

*

 

B@4

    

* A &-/// @ " )  

  *  

 "   A 6///@  " "#  

" "# "  A 6///@  "

 "   

"



 ;

 1*



* -.

#    ./G

  ./G A -///@ 6/// ./&//I-///

)* "# "   A D///@ 6/// J -///I D///

  

"

 6/G "  

 ? )#

*

A 46//@  " D///-I 46//

#



#

" A .-///@ 46// H&-I .-/// 1*

*  



  6) 6*/0*)?%-.*(

 &F





#* " 

"

;  A D6 ///@



A 4////@

    

 ?



  / -* ).;<)20 *;6323*%-.*(



# 

"

" A DF ///@ D6 ///J4////I DF ///

%4D'

  )#  )

 6/G

 ) # **  A 474///

"

 @

 



A 767//@6/G



A &F77//

 # )

    

"

" A -7D&//@ 474///@ 767//I-7D&//

%4F'

 

" A -7D&//   #  D 6G 

 "

*    E

%47'

B

 "  

  



  !#$$!

!

 %./'

=  < 

* 



*

-.

# 

*

 8  # "  

 

!B@4

  

 8 + M

    

) 

* 

# "*

*

A &6///@  "



  

 

  "  



A .6//@  " "#  

" A .6//@  "

 "   

"

 1*



* -.

#    ./G

  ./G A &F//@ .6// ./&//I &F//

)* "# "   A

4// .6//J&F//I

4//

  

"

 6/ "  

 ? )#

*

A 4&6/@  "  4//- I 4&6/

#



#

" A 4DF//@ 4&6/ &- I 4DF// 1*

*  

  6) 6*/0*)?%-.*(  &F





#* " 

"

;  A

F/.//@



A 4////@

    

 ?



  /-*).;<)20

*; 63  2  3*    %-.*(



# 

"

" A D&/.//@  F/.//J4////I D&/.//  %.&'

  )#  )

 6/G

 ) # **  A 466-//@

"

 @

 



A &6F6//@

 # )

    

"

" A &7 D//@

466-//@ &6F6//I &7 D//

%.-'

 

" A &7 D//@   #  D 6G 

 "

*    E

%.4'

B

 "  

   9 ':3;$'()'

%..'

 ) # ** ) *# 

;*

) 

*#

  "

A - 

*



%.6'

) 

  "

  !#$#!

! %.

'

= 

;

*  0

*

-

# 

*

8  + M   "  

 

!B@4

  

 8 + M

    

) 

* 

# "*

*

A &6///@  "



  

 

  "  



A .6//@  " "#  

" A .6//@

 "   

"

 1*



* -

#    ./G

  ./G A &F//@ .6// ./&//I &F//

)* "# "   A

4//@ .6//J&F//I

4//

  

"

 6/ "  

 ? )#

*

A 4&6/@  "  4//- I 4&6/

#



#

" A 4DF//@ 4&6/ &- I 4DF// 1*

*

 

  6) 6*/ 0*)?%-.*(=

 &F





#* " 

"

;  A

F/.//@



A 4////@

    

 ?



  /-*).;<)20 *;632 3*%-.*(



# 

"

" A D&/.//@  F/.//J4////I D&/.//

%.D'

  )#  )

 6/G

 ) # **  A 466-//@

"

 @

 



A &4.6//@

 # )

    

"

" A --/D//@ 466-//@ &4.6//I --/D//

%.F'

 

" A --/6//@   #  D 6G 

 "

*    E

%.7'

B

 "  

  

9 .)',$'()'

%6/'

=  8 =

*

- @-D # 

*

 ;

 5 "

" A &6///@  "

0

*   

 

B@-

  

 ;



 ;*



* 

* A &6///@  "    *   ;

5   

  **  

 ) 

*  1*

)  "  



A 6///@  " "#  

" "# "  A 6///@  "

  

@"

 1*



* - @ -D #    ./G

  ./G A -///@ 6/// ./&//I-///

)* "# "   A D///@ 6/// J -///I D///

  

@"

 6/G "  

 ? )#

*

A 46//@  " D///-I 46//

#



#

" A .-///@ 46// H&-I .-/// 1*

*  

  6) 6*/0*)?%-.*(

 &D





#* "



"

;  A D&.///@



A 4////@

    

 ?



  / -* ).;<)20 *;6323*%-.*(



# 

"

" A D..///@ D&.///J4////I D..///

%6&'

  )#  )

 6/G

 ) # **  A 4D-///@

"

 @

 



A &D.///

 # )

    

"

" A &7D7//@ 4D-///@ &D.&//I&7D7//

%6-'

 

" A &7D7//@   #  D 6G 

 "

*    E

%64'

B

 "  

  

") && -/&F % ' 6( 

  B  ;*  M

B  ) M