H.D.F.C. Ergo General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Vinay Kumar And ANR.












 



 

 

    
 !"# !$% )*'+  !

,!& , )-&'! + .! /( +     
 
 

 
 ! 

!0 +(0&!12+3 + -!23.12+3!.( ! !0 4),!'12+3!.!( + 


 









5..!6& 3$3+ .+ +7)! 0&!8..!.% )$7$()'(  !

.3.$ .$"..($)8. 8$& ++ 7!$)7).+!3!.3.$ 8!.$$ &!9

5."3 "!.! ! "5.3.$ &!+855((!5.8 !.+ ($)3$+. '&!! .5.+!3!.3.$8 '($) .8 !.+(!:+.3.$7).+!&+ 2%%0($18$.5.8 !.+ .!3.$+!3 7)  .!+!3!5..!+!3!8.! +/4.0.!'. '3$$" +7..'8! 8!:".! +.+(!:+ .!3.$$7)5.+!3! .5((!"+8 !'

.3.$ 8!.$$ &!7).7& +!)8$$. .($&! ".':.'':8!1 (!

 $+ .3.$ +8 8.. .&!

+7:1. 3.$8" 1$ 7)& (! 8." + ++!3 5.$!'!+7).+!&".+!3!. ".5((!'

. "

5.% )!(&++.$'!. 3.$ ."!& +..+!3!++ ;!+&! + & .&$+ .3$.:) +.3.$8...$(+ ..$.5((!5.+)8 <. 7!1  8..8 8. .3$+)(!+. ($)5.($)87&".  <. 7!1  1 +).!.. +83$+$$.=  7!1    2/8!!++ + %/8!"!+ 0&.

$.10&>-.7! " %/  ++ . 7!1  5. !$+"+ $'8..( !2 % 3"

!  8  (( +   +  .  & +    .  !(!   .  ( !

'( )..:).3.$8$ .3.$ +8.  +:)8..8(!3++7).8 !.!(! 3. ) 

!(&+ $'1 (($ +!0

?
.*"$0!32&.!)21 <=8$+7). &!+
 
$' "..$'(($ ')7!"$+ +. )+!+()/=$:.).$' 5.!' *:2+$.$$8+.$'3+8!+++

+ 0('7!1  " 8...% ).((!.+ .
&!  "..!+!!! & ++!37 +

 @ %  .3  .!+  $!

+  & $  !  .  (!   +  " .!&"..((!?7: = 5.+!3!0 +(-&'! .' ;($ +. .   +  .  ! +  /4.  0.!'  +!3 "  .   +  ((!  !

$+ "."+(!:+.!!(33.$ .!3$ $ ".7& +!)8$$..($A.$".+!'.5((! 0 +(8.! +/4.$$ "&(.&(($!8 $ .8$$.2%%0($.'$8. &++ $)&!

!& +  8  '  &  (!  +!3 "  8)  .  3.$  !

$'7 " .5((!!'.+!3!?+ +7&3.$:) .3 "7 $ .3.$1..+!38..3.$ !+ $!' +! 17&8$! "&(.($   !'.'7$5.($!.+.(8 .($  $$+&(.8 ! !'.'. +  < *!

+  & $  !  .  ( !?%  
'( ) &7'.. &!+++ :$$! 7$("&!+. 3.$ &!+5.6& !+7).'8..!.  (! $+!3!1$3 ".3.$& ++8..:) +1 8&$+$$8. .'7 "$" (! +"&!+. &!+(!(!) +. +&8&$+7: 7)! 7$) (!&+ '

*!

+& $!.( !!!!+
$&. 0 +!+ !'!
''!$,.$:"$)8..!+ & +!

?

B5.&!+.$$:$$! 7$("&!+ .3.$ &!+!'$!+'" +' 

   +.'( ).$$.3

 $$'! +&$$;' .3.$ &!+! )(!.!! )+!3!!'($) . &!+% .3  )+ !7!:+8 .3.$ &!+.$$ 7$& ++8.& (!(!  (!&   7 "  :    (!3   &!.!

+'"!$ +.3.$ &!+7+!3

7!. !)!(!!+1 ); 

.+'"! )&!.!+'".3.$.$$ 7 !$). &!+C8 !:D  5.. $)(!3 3$3+ .+!'   .6& 8..!.( !?
'( )$7$().$'!

 ! 7$);(3+ +!(&+.! 7$ (!&+ ' .!"3.$'".+ .& 0 +( -&'!8 .'$!8...8&$+.3$3. 5((!16& 8..+( +! 8! . + !&' .,.$!$ 8.!8.&.:) ."

 % .10 +(-&'!8 $ 8 '( +  7)  .  ! +  8!: "     +'     .!  5((!

7$ " ".'8 !(!:+ '.!3$ $ ..!8. . + &!!+&$+.37 '!.

8)!+8)!'.3.$8. .8 .'$ + &$+ 3!.3! 7$);(+.3.$7$ 7!+ +)$". 7$ : ).8&$+.37 .( . :)88.0 +(-&'! +.3.$8$$$ 18&$+. ).3!(&++.$'3! ".. 3.$'(!. 3$)92&' ".0 +(-&'!.+$. 3.$& ++&+ +&".1').37 +! 

 2$$:.'$&  (!  . ! % !3$.!+$)8!++3!$$.& 8..

.
'( )'&.3+ 7&   $&+ " 8!

" :)$ ++3.$5.)&$+.3$) (+..3.$.&$+ 7$(!:+!& ++8.. :) + ++!3!7 5.(&$  .. &!+.$$:$$! 7$("&!+.3.$ &!+ (!3 &!.!+'" + $ +   (:7&8 !E+!3!

$3 ".:) ."

 8. + (!:+'!3.$ + $$ .'7B"&!+$$! 7$(D"  .5. $: $)+&)"&!+ "$!+'"! '     

 .3  )'!+ !7!:+8 1


!..3.$ &!+.&$+ 7$& ++8.& (!(!(!& 7 ": (!3 &!.!+'"!$ + .3.$ &!+7+!3 7!. !)!(!!+1  );  .+'"! )&!.!+'".3.$.$$ 7 !$). &!+C8 !:

!0&!!.( !!$ !+!. $
 &'!  (&  /+!$ 
'' 1  8  $.    /3

 @  !'4-&!3E ! $% 
 *++++

.)1  8..$+!3!$3 3.$& ++ 8! &!$$%+'!!0&!!. !!.$ "$..(!  7$  .'  &1  7&    %  "  .!&".  .  !+!1  %   +  .    ! + "&.7$!"!(.=.!+!!(!+&+ ?

 B=!&$     3"  !(!  (!(!+  7)  /)$ 2  !3$  .  5!'  0 ".  '(!3+  . '   7!  .  0&!3)!   + &7'+ .  .!

(! $:'$8..'0&:.+3.7*!  1.$:+.3.$1":)8..' +8  7.!' +. .!(! $+8)8.!( %/. 8.!7 '  +.5!'0 ".

$:+.3.$ +:(:)8..'17&(!&$

%/!3$..!.$.:) .3.$!

3.$8 $:+ +& (! 8 "

.3.$8. 5!'0 ".8 ! " &!C $$+.7 ( :)1..&$+.3 '  + %/ +.&$+$.3. ++3! $$ "8. %/D  .!+1.:($ 8$$:

!&! :

0&:.+3.7 . $".8) 5. &$&  .( . !$)+! !'.

.5.!+!!3$..+!3!.0!(3.$.+ '(!3+.' '+7!.0&!3)!.
'( )5. +!3!+'+..$.0!(.'$ .7.!' ..75.' ..3.$8 .(!: "$8.

&'!7$3.$ +'$$ "!8+!3$$!(( "7)! '$5..+!3!$3.0!(&".8 (!3+  +&(7$.1 +.!!1&$+7!"&+. ! 7$!8 : !3!5!'0 ".++ ' 

.  %/  .  .  .+  (    .  :)  8..  .  8&$+  .3 '  + . %/ +. ++3!.($

  .(! 1.!' *:2+$.!&!

+  "..3.$&$+ 7!3!+7).($ +  !+!(!8&7'+F.!8 +$) $+" " %/ 8..($8..8$+"+ +!"!+.$$8 "+)F.! 8 +$) .(!.8 ! ' ".
'( ). .5.(!1.!' *:2+$.;' +.&!'

 .!% . %/!!++.' 0 +(-&'!1 8 '  +..:)8$ ."

 8.7).' +

.!  &'    ': "  8!  8  '  +  83!1    . ' 0 +(-&'!!!++    '  +. .:)8$ .3.$5.!' *:2+$7!3+.  !3$+7!8.'.'+&.' %% 
'( )  !    !(! 3  ':    '(    8  3!  . '($)E+!3!.$' 1 &!+E8 !

7  ?&+

! 7& +7).' .'($)8.').3 7 +!(!&!3.47!.&!! 83!1. &'   .    (!3+ 5.  !'   *: 2+$  '    .  $& ..3.$8 $& ++ +.!  4& !!4 .$' 3$ .!' +  . ($)8.. (!3+5.!+!++

+ 0('7!1  (+7).!' *:2+$6& 4&+$  +  +' !3!+!8.!.! $ 8&$+7!38+% !! "8..!+! 8!(!+ "  .$ +!+ $3 ".5((!:) ."

 8. + ).$'8&$+7 3  4&5.+ . ( ! ..3.$8  &!+" !3!+ 7).($)

 @ 5.% )8&$+78$$+3+!?!' .$&&. 8. +6&'. &  ! + .7! ;(&!&(.$+ !(&+ $'.3.$7+ 8.!.:)8 (!&+ (! !' !+ !) $$"  .!&$+ .33 '" +.8.$ 8! "$$ &! !7) . '+ .7&($ 8$.'& $3 " 3.$& ++!.(&!( ($) +!(&+

.$' .$".$&.!' + 8..! !!+.8!+'($)+.! 5.!'   !!7 !&+ +!+!$)0&7 $4&.7

+ 7).!' *:2+$.&".$ ! "')7 .++!  = 2!+ "$)1 .6&  (+  8!+ "  . ) + 3&!.$' "!& +.!.

.6& 8..8!'+7)!0&!! 8!8(!+ < 38.731% + '! .( 8.. +'+ 


 


  ! "











   #