High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4177/2015disposed of

Mukul Gupta v. Ifci Ltd And ORS

2015-05-29Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan12 pages

!"#$#%&'&()*

) +, - .-, // / !"#$ "% & &# // /

#$%

% "

" &' (

)

" &+ , - !

" &. // / .-,0 / 0

* * ! &+1 0

3 34

1 *

0 ! " $ &+ ,* !0

7+7(+7', !

5 !

/ " 0 / &

7+7(+7',*

"#$% & && '()&*+ ,+ "-+./ # #"0"1234+* /"+ "055

5 "+5"" ,6 ,+,4"07 8'9)4 $9 : 5 "123 "+ , "2, 6 0"

,,3 "0 .

56 , "0 /*3";, "0 5%+5 + 5"35,5+5",:" ,+2- "*+5,/"

/55""0, , / 5,/:5336"26"36 2; ",5+5. ** "* 5 52+3,# 5. "0 0535.

**3,:"+335/20"

5, ,,,5"-+.,"

55"35, ,,,5"-+.,533 52+3, , +*# 5,"5055, 4,,5"<+., 54"0 ;62+"

5=" **3, "0 /*3";, "0 5%+5 + 5"3 5,5+5", .5, 5,5" "0 /./ :55 5

-+ 5,5 5" 2;"123+-2 ;5."+

5. 65"#($ $=#%>## #9#!#

52+3,3 ;"5052;"1235."+ :533 3," 2 **3, "0 /*3";, "0 5%+5 "33., .5,"

,"0/./#

5-5 4 55"3504

;""6#"0 ;

5. + 5"* / 5. #?

7+7(+7',

0 !

()*&+"

*& * ,

-* .* */** (0

1-1 0

)0 )*&+"

*& ( 2* *"

&:.

)0 * *

/ * )

* 0 !

&+1 *

" 0;$

0 '+

* )

% )0

34 * 5($%% , 6 "

&*% +& * 2 *& 3&$&("7,'7+77:"*

@ A#0 ",5 5. .+/,6 -+./,"0"1234+* /"+ 52; "+,3 " 055.,"03 45.3<+."2;+, : "3 3"6 /,,+005 5

" "3" # ,"5."03 ,5.3 <+. 5 ," 0 , /552535; "0 :

5 *55"+ 5 3A5 ,* "0*+235 0+ 5",5,

" 5,2,",235,*",55""03:: 2;005 /,565:#@ *

7+7(+7',*

* *

7+7(+7',"

0 ! 8

5 !

&:.

)0 )*&+"

*& ( 2* *

:." * ;:"+3 0"

2** "* 5+ 5"3 52+32,+*5 5, 5, "23"

56 "053**3 +3,, 3 ;

B5,,,+ + 5"3 52+354&"2- 25. ,"+3 " ,+00 "+. ,+2,53 ",, 5,2 +,"03"

5""0

52+3C50

52+3, 35/55+/2

; "3

+5% /*,55.,5500 5, ," 56 5,"2- 56# 533,* 535= 52+35,,+* 5. "00535.**3:"+33520"

5, -+."

55"35, -+.,"5052;."6 /# :533 " 2 ,, ; 0"

5,5+5" " . * 5"

* /5,,5""

B&*",0 "** "63.5, "

;" /*3";# ,."6 /,33 /5

5 ",+35":55."+ -+5 530"

+/5

:5 ..

56 053**3.5, 5,5""0/./ " 5.5, 5*35 ; 5" /55""0, #@

0 "

* *06 &,24

&':+1

)0 ! @ A&# D#!'

) E ,+"

; * "65,5", :5 .+30 ,"0/55, 5"358 " "3 "6 + 5". 5, " "3"6 ."6 5.2"5,

"55","0005355"5 3+5. ".55"%:5 :3 "0 **"5/"0,00 /*3";, , 5 5*3, 5 3+5. 5 , "55",

.+35""00, #:"+35 0 :5 5."0 /55, 5""0/5"

55,F #4"0 ,,+"

;* "65,5", .+35.0 ,"0 /55, 5" " 5 , "0 +5 /5"

5;+ 5"35,5+5" .+3"

;/,+ "0

" "3 ,"+3 2 /55/3 "55", "0

".55",:33, "55","0005355"" 56 ,5;"

2" 6"2 "/*35:5 2+5 / "0;&";/./ 358**"5/"0 ,00 5. "& 5.

/55, 56

" "3 "6 / /./ ,"+3 6 "/ ,"+3"2;B 3 " "335.

. ;#":6

5"3* + 0"

,3 5""0 5.,000"

85.5, 5*35 ; 5","2 6"36 2; /./ 5,30# " ,,5. .

56 ,"0/*3";,"05+55,5+5", :" ,+2- " *+5,/ "

/55" 0 "/ , / 5,/:5336"26"36 5"+

"*55" ** "* 5 52+3, "+32 ",5+ 533 ,+ 52+3, "+32* ,5"6 2;<+5 53

7 "0 8"05, <+.#G/*,5,,+**35H#@

* ! *0

0 8

/ )

0 !

0 "0

0 !

0 *

* !

(* *#$ -5 % - & -2 *8 -2 % * * , 5& &2 9"#2"$-,&2 &"

*% * * 0

31:

* *

5 !

* 08

/ * 0*

)*&+"

*& ( 2* * *

5 !

&+(24

)0 "* * @'55) ,* "0, "I+,5" "505 5""0 4 "6 / ",5+5. + 5"3

52+3 :533 5 3+33, 5,*+, 5,5."+"0"

*,,2;

./ ,**323" + 5"3

52+3# 4+ 5."**35," 5,5.565:"0-+./5 )*&+"

*& ( 2* *02+5B

5,"0 B +56*": ,"04#?

" !

/ *

7+7(+7'," )

! !

< 8

5 !

&+1

5 !

7+7(+7',

% * *#$ -5%- &-2 *8 -2 %( 2* * *

5 !

)

&+1 *

* )

++:

0=$

0 '+

0 " *

! %

( *

& # * $*% , -"

& *; 0 :7 7 - 7"

* * -+ 5,5 5""05."+ + 5 3A"0 ",5+5"5, "+ 5:5 /,B

5, "05,",+2- "; , 5",B *

, 5",:5 B* ,,3;* "655 5 3,#J+ B

5, "0 -+ 5,5 5" 5, 5,

5" ; 5 5, "

1 B

5, / 3; 2 +, 5 5, 3:0+3 " " ,"# 6 ;

/*35+"0-+ 5,5 5"/,5:533"

5 53;2 B

5, ,+2- " 5 ,30&5/*", 35/55",#,"

-+ 5,5 5"5,"5,3 56 /;0"

350 :5 /; 2 "25 5 ,+5 "

" /" * ,

522;,+# 5 53;"+ :533" 5 *55"0"

5+ 5 3A : *55" , 3 56 /;

:5 :5"+ 25. ++3; " "+,

* "65,I+33;005 5"+, /;#.55."+ , ",". 33; +*" /55""0I+,5", :5 / 32"

B/55" "0 65 "

,235, 5."0"

:5 :

55, 35/# 5."+ "," 0"

,"+ "0**3.5, 5,5""0 "+ "

52+3 "

,"00 ","2;,,+/5.-+ 5,5 5"+ 5 3A"255.

350# E 55,"*"..

56*55" "/"6 " 52+3 "

65,305* "652;,+ 5."+ "

/33;:533"* /52; 55.*55" + 5 3A"0",5+5"/ 5 ;

+ ,+"22;*,, :53336* ;

**3;5. " 5 " ,8 ,"

" / 5 ; ," , +* G/*,5,,+**35H#?

()

& * %%2 *%<;2& 0 * * *#*0 4 #*%, 5"

% 6 &*3&$* 0 :1 - "

: * 5 3A5,"/","

+5"

+/6 ,+"

;* + ,#5,"3;: ,+"

; /5, 5 3; 533&,+5 " / /, "0 B "

5 ;

,5+5", ,0"

5, : 6 ;65 ,"0,+5, 5 I+,5" "

: * 56 "

*+235 :

"., ,"

5B 23;/5B+** 65""0*+235 5-+ ; 655 5""0*+235 -+,5 I+5 5 "+ ,/;2 " 5 3A"0",5+5"#J+"+ /+, 6 ."" ,+005 5 ," " 2;*,, 3 56

/;* "652;,+#?

( 6 "

& ,-%)" &8 6 &*3&$&

! $ $ !

0 "'@@("

50 * )

0 ++:

$ **9 !

(= &

&*,-*8*>*& * (

1- "* *

5, " ," :; 5/*+. "

,"+3 2 , ,5# 0 ,*" "# ; .523 .

56 .5,"5 5,,++ 4 5" ('$)"

5"8+ 4 5" $ , "+36653

/; 2; 0535. **35 5" + 4 5" K' )# B* ,,5"1;* ,"1+,54 5" K' )5,:5"05/*"

8, :55 5, 0"3 " "3; 2"

": 2+ 3,"

.+ "

;" * ,":"/;200 2; 5" 8 + 4 5" ('$) "

4 5" $# J"

52+3**33

52+3 /*": "*,, 5 5/"

,+ 4 5", K 9 I+5 "

5 / , :55 05B 5/, +3# 5, +, 65 /5,65323"..

56* ," + 4 4 2"B*55"+,00 56# 0"

+3;

5."+ "6 3""8,33: 5."+ :533"

5 53;" 5*55"+

5 3 A "0 ",5+5" 50 00 56 /; 5, 65323"..

56* ,"5, +3**35, :5.

5."+ 5/ ,56"365. "6 ;"0B, ,,

0, " ;*,"0*+235 /";+,"028, " 05 535,5+5",#"+ 65:

:5335.:5 *55",56"365. 33." 5"80"

"6 ;"0 *+235 +, # 5."+ /+,8*5/5 3.5,35", 2; 35/4L.5,3+ ,0"

"6 ;"0,+ +, "+"/,36,5,/+ , ;""3; "5 "/* ,56* + 0"

"6 ;"0 +,2+3,"65,. ",5+5""0I+,5-+5 532"5, 0"

,,3 "0 .

56 "0 ; ..

56 * ,"#

533,+ ,, 5."+ /+,5,5,20"

6535. /;+ 5 3A"0",5+5" * ," /+, B+, /5, 65323 + 36

,+#?

* !

* *

0 * 90!* ) ++:

/ 8

/ ! #0* !

! 9

! !0

3)*&+"

*& ( 2* *

0 0

! 0 !

#0*

* )

! !* "

/ " 0 "

" !" !

9 !

/ 8

/ " 0 "*

! !

! ! !*0 ! * / 0

'77(+7',

', ! ! 0

0 / *

.-,

!1*0

<;"5