Union Of India And ORS v. Attar Singh And ANR
!"#" $%&&
'% ()'
& * *'
** ()'
& *+,**
!"#$ $%"& %'#'& ($ ))))) *'
** -&.
)/ * $ &$+$%'',$-
./**0.01 23 *4 % 5" 0 -
+ 5%'& ,%'+$&#$% ,%$2$%(( % 6 5%'74&5"8$+$& *$%5%''8 $5((
5" ,(($ %5'"'-(-9.:;.:
('(&$, $%$%- < 0 =% '%+'%+ $ ( '% ( *$'
$%$,$$
%5'"(>
% ?9.:('($%5 ( *&5$%-$%5$'
5"$ '% 56$%5%5' '%" <+%,,%<%
5"$ '%"<+7 +&$,%(5(( *5"$5%'< ./**0.0123 *4
5" '%+,'%+ $B ,-( 75' -#( %
' %
! " "#$% % &%'
%( ) $%
! " "#$% ./*0-++ 9 @$%<$% '% % $%< ,$,$$+%('8$$%5'%%+ 1 ++ (%+$%%$-8$ *8% '< (-<+9..10.0*- +%', &$$% %'% "
%59."%(<+8$$ ( % %'%++ (%+$%%$-8$ *B $%-
(+ 0C.1*AA*& $ 8% - +%''" 3%- % 8% (
((,(-%"+$ %&$5%(8$+$& * 8%'-%'" +$%, (-<+ ; $ '' 5" 75' -#( % &%'
%( )* +%2 %4&8$+$$%%'5+ 5"$ 5%' $ - ./**0.0123 *4& %"
((+ <, $ - +& 8$ $% , $ - +%'
3%-%%$-($D$'+% 8%( ((, (-%"+$ %%$%-$5%(8$+$&$D$$%5
+$%, (-<+&+$%- '"' ($5((
- $D$(%<% ';% A(6 '- '( #%%'" %" 8% & *AE07 $% $ % %5'" $% 5 +%+ 5"$- '" ,$<++%% &$&' ( $5(( $'<% %%9.% 90($ B ,-&%'
%( )* +%2 %4%%
>9.$ +% $% ( %" % $% 5 + % $ - ( %
''%F %++ %+ ( -'%" <+ $ $%< (%' 5, + %"
+- ,, $% $ %
''% 8% %-(+$% %5"$ %"$ ((,(-+$ %%5+(%" $<++ %$-(%++ %+(B, ( %
''% 8% +-5 $ % ( $ +%''(+ % 'G$ %-5(+-,% $%$ % +'
$%<5 + - +%'3%-%
$ %++ %+ ( -'%" <+& 5 $,$+ ,,$%%"+$ + 8%+%'' (5"$ 'G
% %$%<5+ 8, +-$++'$%$ %5'" -'%"<+(%+& %
'+%(- ( +%' % %
% (- #'% 2 4 (
%%,% $0($ ($ & 8$+$%(''8
>2 4$+%(% %5'" #$5%
$'
%8$%3%+'"$ $+% $(H
%5'"'% -'<+I 90 ($%(% <&$
%+, $" (%' + $% $ $% ,<%"%
( & %+'%'"8$$(+$
% %5'"%<%'%5'$<++ ( $%
''%%$-(%++ %+(-'%"
<+@$,,$,$$%(% (%+$ %+,$"-+$%+%''" %
$- (B+5% $ ( $ +%' % ' ; % A (
'- '(#%%'"%"8% & *AE0F&$%
''%' ( - %
5(( - $(%<%5+( %"< ++ $8$%$%
''%8% ((,(-J%' K2
' "4I%$ -(%++ %+($<+&8''5 -
$%$%
''%8% $"+%'% -%'
+ % $ - ( , $ <+ %
% $ $%'$ $% %G '%+ <+I C $&% $' '('%8' 5" 75'
-#( % ! " "#$%
+' #%&1 * $2"$ *0&%"((+<,$- +&8$$%
,$- +%'3%-%%$-($D$'+% 8% ( (&5L'" ((,% %5'"&' $5( ( 5" ,(($%-%$ - 8'
5 $%$ %5'"(( %5%5'$ '%"<+ '<%
%%($B ,-+' #%* +%2 %4%%
>1 "$ (%
%'$%
''%24 %$L&8$$&% < %'&8$ $% %%,$%,( %% +- '($(,%,-&((
5 ((, (- - %5'" 8$+$ %5%5'%,,%<% 5"$-'%"<+& ' 5,% $5(( , (((
%5'" $ %
''%24 $ 8'
+ $%& $ 5% ( #+'% *204DA/D2 #4 5"$ "((+& <-( %& 9*.*0..*&$%(%
5(-% %<%'%5''"%- +
2;4 '8$<%' (<+&% %" $ +%," ( - + '
- $%5< ; @$%<$% '% % $' C @ %" $ -
B ,-24% 24% $(%''$%
%' 8$+$ %$++ ( , ((($
% - &8$ % + / $ -%'($-%8''5%G (5"$ ,$#%8''%5"$ 5%' ,%,%
%'($ 5( $-&(%"&8$%,,%' $
I / $&% $+B ,-($ 75' - #( %, -$ "$%( ) $% ! " "#$%
((. / $(.01 $%-$%5+ %,%% $% 5$'
$% <,$% %5'"%5 -'%"<+ - '"% ( +%5%++ +%''"
8$ %5'"8% + %$-("<+&'<%
%%%% 2
! !
"
#! $ !% & '# $ ! % !
! !!
!
(
!
!
! !
!
! )
!
!
#
! #
"
"
#! $ !% &'# $ !%
2C4
!!
#! # !
! #
*
"
#! $ !% +
!
! !!
)
#
* ! #
, !
!-
$ !%
#
!
! !
! #
#
!
#
! #
!
! . !
#!
# !#
# (
/ ( !
#
#
#
! !!
!
!
0
,
+
!
! !
!
!!
/ (
11 !
!!
(
!!
#
!!
E =% $%5%5' $% ('%8$%<,5' 5"$ 75' - #( %&%'
%( )* +%2 %4&+' #%* +%2 %4 %8''%, -$ "$%( )* +%2 %4 A M , <8 $ ' ' ( '%8 ' &%'
%( )* +%2 %4& +' #%* +%2 %4% , -$ "$% ( )* +%2 %4%8''%$(%+% ++-%+($ +%$%%$-('+& *8%- +%''"3%-
2/4 % 8%( (%'' +% 8%'"%( * <+(9."%8$$ &$8%( 5 ((,(-$
%',8$$(%+$%+, < +D-%%' %' - +%'+ $%55,$+ $8$#$%$ %5'"%5%5'-'%"<+ $%5,&$% %5'"$%5%5 $-'%"<+ % $ ( +%%G%8%"$,$( *+'%-$5(( 5" ,(($%- (-9.:;.:% $' '('%8+' #%* +% 2 %4 *. $%,-$%5% **
+&$%5+(%" <"5, $ - ./**0.0123 *4$$5%($ (%+ $ ' ' ( '%8&
*0 ++ ,'"&$8 - *9 ,%
'+%24&(%"&% ( . *'
**/ .+,**
/ *
6- @$$ %G,D%
H @$$ %5'