High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2719/2012allowed

Kashmir Kaur v. Union Of India

2018-12-10Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan6 pages

! "#

!&' (% )( " " "*

!"# $"

&' ( &') !"# *( !"# $" + ,,,,

- %.

! % #"' %$"

* ' #"

"$* # *

% $*% /0

1#% +& )* & ' *

*# * 3'

45644674

0% */' % *2 # *2 -* $ $ " 9 */' %:. /08*# #% *)"$

* '"8 *#* ' * *% $"#") *" / 3# #% **" / * )*

"$ # 8*#8"'% /# 0$"#" * *""$ ') ' + #% + ) & )* & ' /0 $*%*2 #% *) **" "'2#") *"$" "$ ";'/* *2* 0'"8

8*# ##" *2"

"4<654676 /"'<=> )

;'/* *2 /"

))' 8* ?

* $") )* "@"A 'B *8 /8)*

*" $%% "8$") " " #% *)* *8 #"8 *2

"" $%% "8* $'#% *)

*#( $" 4 #% $"))* *

#"$* % *! "8! *#(8 %" '*2

') * 8* )8 $*% "/ %$"$ 0*2 !) )

*#% **" % (

2" !*2 0 0*#(' %%2

" "$ %%8** '!*8"$ #*"74<-."$

0 # -* $$ " 9#:. '#

* "*%

$" 0#") *"' #*"74=+"$# "#" * *""$*!

% %

*2 */' %$ )

$"%%"8*2* ' +

! #% +

* '

""$#"*" 2"?

%$ B+7 8 #" +?

)* % " *)"0 #% %0 "44654676 ";'/* *2- .

%$"' *$")*2 8 " !* * " * ) * # @"A '/0 *8*#% ! %0*)"*2$"))* *" "@"A ' *" 2 ! 4661+"*)$" *2 *#( B *8 /8 *"$"))* $%%

"8$")'*2 " " # )"("8 /"' "4<654676 $'#% *) * $$*

!* "8

!%%*2

2* ))' 8*?

*$"))* "

@"A ' *"*2 %#")

) "

0*#(* #"$)0% *! * *2 )* 8" ##")

*)*%% *")* /'*#(8 %" '*2*#* #" +?

)* *"

)/$";

) $' * #" +?

)* *" "("8

8;'/* *2%$")

% " " 03"'0*#(*

"8* "/"

*2 * % "

"%$") /"'>66 B+4 ) *2 +;'/* *28 * % *! # )"* * #"44654676*!*28 "

))' 8*?

*$"))* *""@"A ' *" 0 * "' *%%% *2 /"'7466 %$ * "' " 0 *" )* +;'/* *2

2 %*#($")*#(8* "8** #!

%* "@"A ' *" *8"'%

/"'466 ) 8 * * *" $ ) *2' / #("* * # ?

0 # )"("8 /"'*#* "$ "$;'/* *2 #" +?

)* *" ) *2 " 44654676 %"28* # *"" )""#0#%"$ * *2/"'8 *#"%"' ##")

* "*#( 8* "8" C' *" ( ""8) 08* "8 )* *"$" %"$*#( %02*!/0*)8 ") 0 *#(8* "8 /' " "?

#%0))/')/ "8!

, '/ C'%0 *#(8 $")*$")4"<')/ 8* "8 *8 $" ))' 8*?

8 C''"$76+7> " "" * 46+4> " "" * % " ** #"# " "("8$ # " 0*#(8 $"' $")/"

0"$ ;'/* *2*3 ) * ) !/ * /%*! /0*/' % *) %0" 2"' B+7 *$* *#" +?

)* *" " "("8

"$ +;'/* *2% !*2") )0#" * "

**" '# *2% *#"$ ) *#(

$")?

)* *"# "/"'2""' *#% *)$ # * )"$& )*& ' "'% !/#" * /0*/' %*8*#

#% %0 2"*2")* )

""()"0 % "$" *2*#(8*#8* ""

"$#" + ?

)* *"$ * *) $ #*!* # /' 8"'%

*$'

" 0 " "!"8*

/"'2"#" !* # +7* " 8*# "8 " **#(" 0 '"*0" !%8 #"!

$") '*2 " % #/0;

#"' %$"

)'#)

* *)"$ *2 '

" *)"0 "$ 2'

"$ * 8" / ?

)* 8* ** # /"'*)*2"$ * "8! '

"2"*2"'2 *)"0"$ B $ *%"

#* 0 ) ( /%*2"/ * "$8*##% #"'% /"' * $''2 " )") " /"

08 #' *" *#

*2 )"$ $"' %0*2/8

#( "$/"

08 %0*2* #(3'* 8"

*8 /"( %$8* 8 /"( *2 )8 % "/"(

- $")8" # *2$""8 #'"$$$") (% 8*##"'% "/$"' "'

/ * "$ $" ** /*2'2 /0% #"' %$" *$ /"

0$ %% $") * '#0 "$ # "

""$* #"*" % #"' % %* " #* *""$ ?"' *# $ % ! &'

() $!

* 8*#"/% '

)"' ##" *2" #*2%* # '

" %* #* *" % * '# *'

*" *8"'% /!0 *$$*#'%"

$%% "8$") ' *# /%

2 8 "* " *""$ *#("8!

/ *#($"' * "#( "08"'% !/ *$$ 3'

2)*

75= ?"' "/ ! ) #"$ /"

" 0 )* 8*%%"/#"#%' *! ""$""% *3' "

2$"8*##% *)$"#") *"#"'% / ) * * "8! ) / #"$*#(8*%%"2 *!#% % "

2** %/' 8*%%/"#% 8*## /

* # 2 /0$*%*2 $$*

!*"$%!

$ # /' 8*%% *$" 0 * ' # / #* " $ # "8 " *2 #*#') # 8*# "/ %8*$")# "# ) #% * # 2 "' /0%

*2 !* # 2"*2"* ) /0 *

%$* "' %"28* '$$*#*)"0" *#( $ 0 * % *! "' )* 8" ##")

* *)" *" 8 *#( /"

*"8/' 8*%% *$'

0 " "!"8* 8*# *)0#" * "

**" #"'% "/

* # 2 /0 0 0)%0 * *2 $*2"8 /" "$ ) )

8"'% "/ '$$*#*'% * ")#"2!* #

*% /%" 0?

**2 "80 !%% '# %"2

* #$") # $"#"))**2 '*#* "$" #")*2' /"'<+= )*)"*2$8 "#"))* '*#* #"'% ! "*8%% 08 # 8* % "

!*$** ') ") )*2 ! ( # *%%* "

*" ""8 # $")

#* *""$) * % !

*% /% *)0#" * !*8 #% / /%" "! /"

** % "

*) $ #* /%* *#( % " # * *'

"/ (

2* #*!"$$ # *#(8

$"' ""/# ' * '#0 "$*#* 8"'% %8 0 / " */*%*0 "$%"" *2 *#(/# ' "%*)/"$

08 % ")* *2

% "$ *% "/*2 0*2"#" " "8 ? *! #8

"$* "'*#($") #"$*#* /' $$"8 ' '## $'% '# *'

*" * "'8"'% ! 0 * *"* "% *2 *!*8"$ *2#*#') # "/

2 '% *

% '## *) '2 3'

45644674

0% *) */' % *2 # *2 * C'

+#% * %

"/*% $"#") *""$ =% # "!* *" ' %!

+#% 8"'% % "/*% $"* DEF "/# %#'% $")

"$$*%*2"$

*"*%%

0)"$ #") *" - .

; 7674467G 3 /&

& (!0

1 "23(

*4 !3 /&

& (( 0(