← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3342/2016allowed

Parkash Kaur & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2022-09-14Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj16 pages



  

       

           

 

!"!

#$%&% 

'

('

 ) (% 

 ( *

)  %    +$ , -+ % (. (% 

 %        

      !"#$ %%%% . (% 

 / %0 -1     &  $ "    ''()''*  + " ,-./0   1

"  & "    "

  1   2     

   1 3  2      -  '  "

$ 4

     56  2& ""  & "

2 7  2 "  8             1 3  2      -  '9      &   -:0:'0-6  &  $ 1;, 5-0 1          

 

 "  ''     < "1       "$     -.:/ =      > < ?@A   "     &      ' 7  :   +  B9+B9,,   &   $      &&  " 11       $ 1 ;,  -60  --0*'0-5 1   "  ''    <  



-.:/             "9     $  9    C"   " &   13

 2        1 $&     13

 2 "1   13  2       &  "

&     "&       "

#"  D& !" " <D &   &       $ $ "1  

 12  ;, '(' '(0.'0-6&  1  "  50')'0- , + -:(0 =          >,+?@  &   6'        -:.6 + <      D "  

"$    " "      1     "   -*5 + +    " -.*'=        >+ +?@& $2 11 2+ 11   

"

 2  C"  & "2    $1 1  $ 

"

   C"     $

1    $         

  +  1  &         

         1 3  2 &   "  &   

"

2#"  & "     "    2 $2 &2   

   # 1 

  + 

      A      +2 &  &   9    1;,   2  $  "

    13  2,&   "      

"        1  1     ;,

'(' = " @ E"    1  "    -*(    + +         1 3  2 &   " $2 B"  1  , +

       F     & 1 "

  7  <  E"   1 & 



   '(-0'0-(    &    <    1          -(-''0-(<   1  

 & E"   1&     

"     1  

"

   C"       &  1 1 11 "    13  2" 1 "

2&  ,& "     E" 2&   "

 1    1 # 

 9A  C    1  "   

1 "  &    " 1

    0*--'0-(    2 $2 &2   

     1 ! " + B   $     -&     1       $ , &    2     2  1 1    1 3  2 &        2  D"  1 + 

 &< "  "#$D" 

1  + 

   18          1   1   9 99 2 "

 "   "1 &  "  

   "      2 1"      -'&  "

2  & E"  "21 D

 "1 2$  "

 " &    F 

"  " $2     "   &            ""   & "

2D  #"1  D?$"  +"   -/0.'0-*  

      

    '





 !   

 " 

? F   "$2  "       "

   $& #!$  

  

 

 

           

          

 

     

         ! 

 "        

 

  #      

    !    $ 

  

     

 

       %    #% 

 & !        !       

!     

 

'! 

   



  

#  !  



#

     

          & !     !  

 # !( !)       

      

' 

  *         



 !   

 *  

  

!     # 



 + 

* 

%&  ' () *

 + 

   

         

    

 

! #      

        

    

 #           ,  

        



    

    

 

    !      

   -

'  &

,   -

          '    

! 

  * 

 '-

.

#  

 %    

     *   



    

       

    ,   #       !#  

 

 

!

     

      #

                 ./01

  ,   !  !  2    * .33    4 (       #  ! 



       !  

#  

  + 

 %      '#

5   #% 

  /0 

 ,   ,       

 $  

 *       !

     * -     -      # !

   

    

* !                   '    *  !

  

 *

 -

'

   0

 1/,   ,)  

 

)    

   

  ,  !  !  2    * .33  .6.*  & !

 ,        !     

    ,         

)  

 

!  



   

#  

!* #%    !  ,   !* !    !   !

      #   

  !    

   #

 



 

  ) ,              -   !        

 

  *  #%  !

!   

 #  

    !

   #    

  

   45

( *  *  5

     

  %     *      

           

 !        # 

  

   #   

 

  

 )# #  !    ! 

#

   

 ) #   

  #    

!   !#  )  !



 

  *    !     #   #     ,    

  *       # 

     ! #% !      #    

               

*        



 /  !

  1  #   

  

    *  **  #

   

   # %      

%      ' ! 

   

!# !    

  !      

 

 

#

   

 $  

  *

 *       

     5 % '

  #!

!#       

  #  ! 

 

  

  )*    #   %     * *          

   



   #

#     *!  *# %     

    #    #

  ! + 3 23& % )  +*'



1



1      

/ !



( *    ! 

  7      

    

#

#

   -

'

   6 ,      # !       !   # 

* !8



  *   * 

 



 

  *   

!  

   # 4  

3  

-   + 

 

5

 #

 %      $     ! #  %    9& ! 

:!   

 ,$   # ;

  9 * 

 ;

 

8 2 8

 $        

 7  #:8



 

    #/0&

 6 '  

!    #

 #   "

# 8 

 

 

 

  

, 7

, )   2!   !    %    

 

               

  -  

        %   # #    & 8



 

    ' & 2   8 3 

      #     #   

      

#     %        5    !   !  % '     & %8



 

    , 1  -

 -       

          #   # '*             !      

      *

      #    8



   

"

 2!$   3& 2 

         # 

5  

#   %       :

   

  *2 %#<88

 

      -

 '

      6!

 

)!

 % !   #    :

    = 8



    -

' %& 2   /  -  !        

#  %  ,!

    >8



    -

 '

          

   

   

        20

 +  !     !

   



 ?         *    ! #  #        

#     %      :

   

    *  # 8 

  

   -

'

    % ' '  

3 -  !     



 

     :

       

*

      #  %  8

 -

'

   '1 7 !

  )

-     '       

!     !##       8   #

      

   !            

   # $ *# 

   

   ,!

:

      

  

  * 8



    % / !

 ( -  !      

    %     * 

 *  * ' ! 8     !    ,!

    *8 2 8

 

   -

'

   % ;!!

/!

 %3 2! 1   !                 :   ;   ;   > 2 #   

*.6@,       * 5 

      -    , !

 

  ;  <> 8



   -

'

    '

 ' % )  ,   !   ''#

5  #



 *   #  -

'

     

   #  2 8 



    

  !  



90* 

;  < 8 ! - ) =  

'

 !      



     



,2 ?        # '    , !

       =2 8



  -

'

!  @   !

    A 

 



 5  ! 

 #   

      !# 

 !8



 

   #         #   



   

   #

!  *  

       *    # 

    + ;"      #"1   +" 

   :.

   

!

9   >  3&

  ?

<   "/ &    +"    $    "  BC,      

    

         

 !

     

  #  # 

 



!

    

   *  

         *     '  

 

   

 



  #   #*# 

    !

 



          *     *!

     

!



 B C,0

 +  6

 *  ) 

  @ " 

  

!



5* 



  *            

 

   #   != D 

*.@@ #    

  ,     

     #      

    *          %  > !    1

$   $   

 @ :

    %   

 < !$* !

   * %

  @

 5

    :

%

# B C   



        

 -   / -  25 *25 251 #  #

 

  

 

    

    

  

 *   



       

  ! #  *0 *0@@E5 BC   *

   F 0G #

      

    



 @@*6E5  #    

   

   , *  



 

 #  **6 0E5 



 

*

     -    

E  #,    



  **@E5     # 

   **6 0E5 

 





 #  * *00E5    = 2F"    #

 .     

 

 * 

* 

%  > !   ?

 / 1

  #  

 

    *  

   #     

    

     



 

 #  *.6*3 E5 B0C ,!



 

 < !$* !



  * %

  H   / 1 



 6*E5  #   

!   

 -  * 

   

       #

 ,  



 

 

 #  *36*3 E5/ *.6*3 E5I6*E51+

     #"1   +" 

      8 &3 % ) >  3&        



!

 :.     F        E"    $& (.         

!   !       

  !    005

 

2

 *.6   

  ! 



 ' # 

     

  

*  

 # %   - 

 

 6   

 

  8! '! 

   ;

  = *  = '  #  6@  *   

     :  &

 * 2 %#* 

    ,  

      ' # # 

 

-    + 2       $    #"1     D?$"  +" 

   /0 

> +

      ::.  %

  F       "

   $& (  %J 

!   '  K#%8        

5

 ,               #!

   K#      '  ' # 8* 

5

 L! 

 % J  

!   !        # !

   #        %             !  

     -     -    # !

   

      <    '    6

2!

   @ +  6

 * 1

  @

:"

% $ !   5

 2 /

*  + 

 @

:"

% $ !   5 1

*       '

'  %*  !

  

 8  !!#      8      !    

 



        '       !       

 

      *

   #

 +   "      9 &      

"$ 

  $    & F2 

 

 

       13  2 & "      1    

 12 $2 $   ,   "        1 "1        & $

   A 1

" &       13  2& "$# 2"  " $2

           " E"         $

"

 E"   &  1$2  E"   1 $2B" 1     <     1  # 

 E" 2 "

$2 "#$  D"  1  + 

  &  "11  2  " )"      "      $2  B 

    1     "

    $

 & 1    "11  2   $#        $2   11 1 2   1F 

 



 $"      1  2    $2   $  &2 $    2  '0-* &       "  



  1           9   $ 

"2 +"    2

" 

      &   "   13

 2 D1 

"& &        +"   &  

"   ""   & "

2&"  $    G

 

  "

       #"1       $  F       1  1       #"1  E" 2      '-    + "   , -./0       & "

  & $     "

2    &2 &" &  1      "      

 $ $      $1   "           $ 2 "&    )#"     +"  ,  $       1    &  

    $2$21    " 1 &  "    F     $1    "   2 

" 2   &  

 1 

$ 1   &  &#      $2 ,&    $ 1 "  1 1   1      &  #"       +"    $ 1" 2F   2  $ E"$   F     ,             1    #"1   $&"$$1    &   F          1 3  2    $        #"   $   1  $1 "        $     

2 1     "   &&"$     $     $    & 11 "       ""

$  D1    $  F E"  &           E""       $ &     , $"  " &1  &   

 .

        &  '60)9   2     " $  2 &2&1  2$ 1&  2   F 2'002 "        1 3  2 "$

"  6:000)97221"

 -)5   -(000)9  "  2      &" &  " 

5'000)9 " 1   & '/2 1

     2  

       -.:: "  -:&"$    &&$2 DH$"  +"    ' %  > !   >

1

$   $        :

%     "     "

    /*(000)9    "  *0000)9     &  "   + D   1F 

     "  "1#"1      "      -.::

    ""           &  1 

           

$2      $1            

1       $11 1

"2     "     

(6(000)9 = /*(000)9   $     "  2 &  "    -: I *0000)9 2$ &      @  &    "        "11   

    E"  2 $  $"

  1          -0J      -  '  60J      56



 12  $ "

     "      1   & " "  

!

!

# 2" (32 !#4 # 5 

64786 9 :#   -4' -0J 

(6(00)9   546 60J 

'/:600)9              $    

 7  ;< " 

 &"  F "     $   "    69  "1 # 2 " $      $2 &                 

   2        1 &    "      

   2  3(J "    1   " 8   &

 12           0. (% 

 1 %&%%        

3 ? 'E  4BEK ? # 4BEK