Hari Dass And ANR. v. Davinder Pal Singh
CR No.4227 of 2023
!"# $ % & %''% #% ()"
*"(&(& "
' +"
' '
%,& #"
%-.& /) "'0 #" (
!"
!#!! $% &'( )* + , - - + +)*
#.
!#!! $% &/( )* 0 +- $- , ( ++ ++ 00 +- $- , ( ++ #.
!#!! +)*&+
1.23+
!00 & !
&+
$% & (
* * )+ + + 4 ++ 5 + ++ , - $++* ) +
( .
)*&+
& +
)+ +
+ &+
++) 6
7 + ) & +
* )+
+ "
+ $%&!(1.2 3+ !00 + & / )* * $%&.( + *1)
*1 ) & & * &+
0 +
1
& 5 + )* * + * 28. !# &+
6 )+ + * 7 +)
7+ +
7 + )
)+ + &+
+0 &
#.
!#!!
7 + &+
+
+ *
+ + +
3+
+ 0
!
"#$$$%&'
()*3 +
+ ) %+ 7 + %+ + - + : &
'
7 +;
++ 0
+0 & 7 + + + & +)
* +**+)6 7 + +
# < + ) ;
++ 0 ++ + ++& )*
+ 0 < + )
+ 0 +* +
+ ++ < +) ;
++ 0 + ) 7 +
+ %+ *+ )++
7 ) )*+ +
!
Before coming to the merits of the case, it would be essential to examine the law on the subject. In the case of Bhartu Vs. Ram Sarup, (supra), a Full Bench of the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High examined the rights and liabilities of co-sharers. It referred to the decision of a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Sant Ram Nagina Ram
Vs. Daya Ram Nagina Ram, AIR 1961 Punjab 528, in which it was held as under:- "
+
& +)* , 0 *
+,
,- ./,
,)0*)'12#3 ++
+& $ (& +* * + $!( *)*& *+ ++ ++) ++* $.( + * +* )) + ++ $"( )+ % & )* ) + ++ &+*)%+ ) + +6+ &+* + $/( % & ) *% $9(=*& * ) + 6 & $8(> & +
)*& *)* ) %)* ? 3+* +)*, .% ( %2 %/& % %2 +' %3% %2 %/& % %2 4' 0 %515@)+;+++
& A7
+* + & + ++ + + ++ ** ) + 0B+* & ++ + * +
&
+
%+ ++ + ++& 7 )
, < 5 0 4567--'!
89
:: 6 ;+7! )0($ (<& + & %+ * )
& & @ ++) +* * )* + ++) & ) ++&6 + * )
6 % * + *)*) &
%+ * + + &
)++* +++ ) +++ > & ) + + + ) ) ++ ) & +
+ * +
+ *)* ) ? 3+* ;++ - )% ( +'
%2.% 014' 0 %5 , 5@)+
) 5 * 5 0 +% %!)% .& /)+'.7% % .& /)1 45 4&,&-5485 % + ) 5@)+, +
& / 1
+) $ ( & * * +6
& ) *+ *
*
+ & $
( * $
(7)* & + * * &
+* 6 + * * $ (7 & + & & 6 + 7 ++ *& * 6 )
& * % *
& ? 5@)+5 0
) 5 * %
%-9&')% +' %2.& /)1 45 4&,&-5$ 3+* - 5@)+;++ )% ( +'
%2 .% 01 4' 0 %5 - , 5@)+
) 5 * 5 0 %!)% .& /)+'.7% % .& /) 4' 0 %5 + & !
7 +5 +0 <
+ +)* 5 +0 <
5 +0 < ++ + & C
< % C
-
C + +0 < )**+ & 3
%+ 6 C .
D"$"& #(.
D9$.&"(.
D8 $'&#(!
D!.$#&9(6 C
C
* ) 6 ) ) + )* 3
5 + 0 < ) 6 ) +0 < 7 +* * + +
+ )&
+ 8!96 ! + 7 ++ )
+ + +* * + - ++ B & ++ + % +
.
7)* +%)*3
5 + 0 < 5 +0 <
)+ + + & * * * 6 + +
& ++) 7 5 + 0 < ++
+ 96 +
++) ++ & * )+ + )* 7 +
96 + ++ & D& ++ 6+
+)* * %+ ) & +0 < + 96 +*
7 B * + +) 5 +0 < + 9 6 + 3
)+ 7 + + + +0 < + C E
)+ F5 F F
) F 5 +0 < +
96 + C .
D"$"& #(.
D9$.&"(.
D8$'&#( !
D!. $#&9(6 C
6 C
*)* *) * # * )+ +
* ) )+ )+ 9!###
+ ? 5@)+
) 5 * 0 % - + .%( %2.& /)+' ')"
.& /)% # ()"
'1 45 :%7"
%-# + & '
+ +
)*& )+ D%+ + & + + ** +
@ $ (++*
?
.
3 +* +
& )*0)+ - *
!# '& 2 &+
& * ++ ) ) + ) - + + + ++ + & +
& )) ++ + & 7
+ 7 + % )
)*& +* 6+ 7 ++
)*5G)+;++ Bhartu Vs. Ram Sarup, (supra),)*, Sant Ram Nagina Ram Vs. Daya Ram Nagina Ram, (supra) )* ,
!
" 48!%
)* + ) + & C)
* 5 ++ *
)+ + ) ) ++ +* & ++ + + *+
* +*+)*;
++ 0+)6 +
+ + ++ & ;
++ 0 +*
++ B+* 7 *
++ *
; 7 7
* +* 4+9 < =:5 '!;
;4 76;
#<$0#$#&