High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24537/2017dismissed

Diwanshu Sharma v. State Of Punjab And Others

2017-10-30Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

"#$ $%&'&()

&*"('+,-+"./"

$#&#&($.

1$.','

-#"#$ ,(2"3"(4#+$.'

$'5(4$(#'

.$'$(#)0 ./"(+&.647%"#$ .#+$5$#&#&($.

$#&#&($.6*+5''$''$'"*$".'&59/"&( $%+"(&%"9 (:&($$.&(: ./-"(#;(:*"9('#&#,#$ (:&($$.&(:$%+(9:<6 &'#.&%#-"(:.,.6&'"::.&$7$4 #+$"%#&( #+$.$'5(4$(#0..&:"#&( $5".#/$(#6 -#"#$ ,(2"3 &( +"7&(: %('&4$.$4 +&/ &($9&:&39$ .

"55&(#/$(###+$5'# ,(&.(:&($$. $%+"(&%"9! #+"'3$$("7$..$4#+"##+$.$'5(4$(#0..&:"#&($5".#/$(# &(7&#$4"559&%"#&('(9&($ ..$%.,&#/$(##7".&,'5'#'&(%9,4&(:=

5'#' ,(&. (:&($$.' $%+"(&%"9! 7&4$ "47$.#&'$/$(# 4"#$4

= > 5'#' *$.$# 3$ &99$4,5 ./"/(:'##+$$($."9 "#$:.<%"(4&4"#$' $#&#&($.3$9(:'##+$$($."9"#$:.<"(4+"4 ',3/&##$4+&'"559&%"#&( .#+$5'#&(?,$'#&(,('$9',3/&#'#+"#"' 5$.'%+$/$ '$9$%#&(6"*.&##$(#$'#*"'#3$+$94"(4#+$ &("9/$.&#*"'

#3$4."*("'5$.5$.

./"(%$&(#+$*.&##$(#$'# $#&#&($.+"7&(:

5".#&%&5"#$4&(#+$*.&##$(#$'#+"''$%,.$4/".@'#&'',3/&##$4#+"# $7$(#+,:+6('5$%& &%.4$.+"'3$$(5"''$4.$2$%#&(:#+$%9"&/ 5$#&#&($. .#+$5'# ,(&.(:&($$. $%+"(&%"9!3,#"

#$.+"7&(:

%(4,%#$4"5.%$'' %,('$99&(:"9&'# '$9$%#$4%"(4&4"#$'"#(($A,.$

0=+"'3$$(5,#&(5,39&%4/"&("(4&(*+&%+#*%"(4&4"#$'3$9(:&(:# #+$$($."9"#$:.<("/$9<-"(4$$5+"@""(4 "(&'+..""(4*+ '$%,.$4"9*$./$.&#5'&#&(&(#+$*.&##$(#$'#6+"7$3$$(&'',$49$##$.'

"55&(#/$(# "7&(:.$5.$'$(#$46#+$5$#&#&($.&''#"#$4#+"7$3$$( ."99<&( ./$4#+"#+$+"'(#3$$(%('&4$.$4 ."55&(#/$(#(#+$ :.,(4#+"#+$5''$''$'"*$".'&59/""(4*+&%+&'(#"'5$.#+$ $''$(#&"9?,"9& &%"#&(5.$'%.&3$4&(#+$"47$.#&'$/$(#&$"+.$$$".' &59/" ,(&.(:&($$.&( $%+"(&%"9(:&($$.&(: ,('$9*,947$+$/$(#9<".:,$#+"##+$*$".'&59/" 5''$''$43<#+$5$#&#&($.&( $%+"(&%"9(:&($$.&(: ./-"(#;(:*"9 ('#&#,#$ (:&($$.&(:$%+(9:<6-"(:.,.&'"+&:+$.?,"9& &%"#&(&

(#$?,&7"9$(#&(%/5".&'(##+$+.$$$".'&59/"'#&5,9"#$4&(#+$ "47$.#&'$/$(#(',55.# ',%+%(#$(#&(#+$&59/""*".4$4##+$ 5$#&#&($."(459"%$4(.$%.4"#(($A,.$ 099<!+"'3$$("47$.#$4 #"(4&(*+&%+#+$ 99*&(:(#$&'.$%&#$4)0

" #!

$% &'()()*+, -*-

! )/ ++01 %

!23

! !!

#4 1/ &

# &'(560(60(7, #1((+5

4 0/ ++5

&'(560(60(7, #1((+5

$/ ++51 ,

#9!

!! :

221

!( 4.

2 #

;< &%$0,5 %75#=:.1 (,( &'4*4>"*?(%%4

' / %7/ ++0@4*4*?(%%4

%,/ ++6

4*4>"*?(%%4

& / +++ $ < A

2 &*),5$

%/ +++ !23

!* 4 ! 0

! , B"

*4!/ +06 !

&'+($%*%77(B, " / 4 7/ %775C 7$("(#& &%"#&(4"#$4 BB(($A,.$

!3<#+$ 7# (4&"6 &(&'#.< ,/"( $',.%$$7$95/$(#$5".#/$(#

4,%"#&(!+"'3$$(.$9&$4,5("(4&(#$./' *+&%+#+$&59/",.'$ (4,'#.&"9 .4,%#&( (:&($$.&(: 4($ 3< #+$ 5$#&#&($. ./ -;6-"(:.,.&'#"@$(#3$.$%:(&C$4"'$?,&7"9$(###+$

D ?,"9& &%"#&("'"9'#+$&59/",.'$"*".4$43<7".&,'-#"#$".4' $%+(&%"94,%"#&( +"#"5".#6%,('$9+"'"9'.$ $..$4#9$##$.'

4"#$4

"(4 >

&'',$4 3< #+$ -;6 -"(:.,. "# (($A,.$ 0B%99<!#"''$.##+"##+$*$".'&59/""*".4$43< -;6-"(:.,.&'$?,&7"9$(###+$+.$$$".'&59/""*".4$43< #+$.-#"#$".4' $%+(&%"94,%"#&( #&'".:,$4#+"#,(4$.',%+ %&.%,/'#"(%$' #+$ .$'5(4$(#0..&:"#&( $5".#/$(# %,94 (# +"7$ %('&4$.$4 #+$ 5$#&#&($. &($9&:&39$ . #+$ 5'# ,(&. (:&($$.

$%+"(&%"9!,('$9"55$".&(: .#+$5$#&#&($.*,94"9'".:,$#+"# #+$$A5$.#&(#+$',32$%#&$#+$99(4&",(%&9 .$%+(&%"94,%"#&( !+"'"9'&'',$4"%//,(&%"#&(4"#$4

(($A,.$

%99<!"(4"44.$''$4##+$ - ;*+&%+*"'&(#+$("#,.$ "

%9".& &%"#&(#+"# "%"(4&4"#$("/$9<-+-+,3+"/".:"(4 *+*"' '$$@&(:"55&(#/$(###+$5'# ,(&.(:&($$. $%+"(&%"9!"(4

00 5''$''$4 #+$'"/$7$.<?,"9& &%"#&( &$ " * $".' &59/" ./ -;6 -"(:.,. *"' # 3$ #.$"#$4 "' $9&:&39$ 3< '#"#&(: #+"# ',%+ ?,"9& &%"#&(*"'$?,&7"9$(###+$+.$$$".'&59/"&((:&($$.&(: "*".4$43<7".&,'-#"#$".4' $%+(&%"94,%"#&(-#"#$"%#&(&'

"9' #$./$4 "' ".3&#.".< "(4 7&9"#&7$ .#&%9$' "(4 = #+$ ('#&#,#&( (4&"3<',3/&##&(:#+"##+$5$#&#&($.(#+$3"'&' *$".'&59/"5''$''$46&'(9<%9"&/&(:$9&:&3&9&#<"(4(#"(< *$&:+#":$#*".4' 5''$''&(:',%+?,"9& &%"#&( (#+$.9&/3 ".:,/$(#."&'$4&'#+"##+$/$.&#*"'#3$4$#$./&($4"'5$.*.&##$(#$'# %(4,%#$4"(4&(',%+#$'##+$5$#&#&($.+"''$%,.$4"+&:+$./$.&#5'&#&( "'55'$4#%"(4&4"#$'*++"7$3$$(&'',$4

$.' "55&(#/$(#

$9&"(%$+"'3$$(59"%$4,5(#+$2,4:$/$(# #+$(E39$5$A,.#&(

!"""

#!$

% & '""'"9'" ,99$(%+2,4:$/$(# #+&',.#&((

) *(+ !"'"#,$

% &

-",#3,##.$''#+$%(#$(#&( #+"#"%"(4&4"#$5''$''&(:"+&:+$.F3$##$.?,"9& &%"#&(#+"(#+$/&(&/,/ 5.$'%.&3$4 ?,"9& &%"#&( . "5'# %"((# 3$ ,'#$4 ./ #+$ C($

%('&4$."#&( ,('$9 .#+$5$#&#&($.+"'3$$(+$".4"#9$(:#+"(4#+$ 59$"4&(:'(.$%.4+"7$3$$(5$.,'$4 #&'3<(**$99'$##9$4#+"#&#&' .#+$$/59<$.#5.$'%.&3$ ?,"9& &%"#&(' ."55&(#/$(##"5".#&%,9".5'# (#+$ "%#' 5.$'$(#%"'$"'5$."47$.#&'$/$(#4"#$4

=(($A,.$ !#+$ $''$(#&"9 ?,"9& &%"#&(' 5.$'%.&3$4 . #+$ 5'# ,(&. (:&($$.

$%+"(&%"9!*$.$##+$ 99*&(:$

$%#)0

!"!!#!$"%

&$ ' (% " ()%(!!"%( !*$(%*$ ()%(!!"%()'"

&$+$+!!*(%*$

*$+% (

$" "'"

&$"!* )(%,! (%-!"%+. "%(+%+ +% (/ +$4%,/$(#'.$9&$4,5(3<#+$%,('$9"(4&'',$43<#+$ -;6-"(:.,.(($A,.$ 0B%99<!"'"9'3<7# (4&"6 &(&'#.< ,/"( $',.%$ $7$95/$(# $5".#/$(# 4,%"#&(! 4"#$4

BB(($A,.$

!"(4#+$%//,(&%"#&(4"#$4

&'',$4 3<#+$6 &(&'#.< ,/"( $',.%$$7$95/$(#67# (4&"

(($A,.$

%99<!4(#%(%9,'&7$9<%(%9,4$#+"##+$*$".' &59/"+$943<#+$5$#&#&($. ./-;6-"(:.,.&'"+&:+$.F3$##$.

?,"9& &%"#&(#+"(#+$+.$$$".'&59/"&((:&($$.&(:"*".4$43<#+$ -#"#$".4' $%+(&%"94,%"#&(5".# ./#+$4%,/$(#'.$ $..$4# +$.$&("37$6%,('$9+"'(#"47$.#$4#"(<#+$./"#$.&"9(#+$3"'&'

*+&%+#+&',.#%,94.$%.4" &(4&(:"'.$:".4'5$#&#&($.5''$''&(:"

+&:+$. ?,"9& &%"#&( &( #+$ '"/$ 9&($ "' 55'$4 # #+$ $4,%"#&("9 ?,"9& &%"#&( 5.$'%.&3$4 ,(4$.#+$ "47$.#&'$/$(# . #+$ 5'# ,(&.

(:&($$. $%+"(&%"9! (4$.',%+%&.%,/'#"(%$'(3$($ &#%"($(,.$# #+$5$#&#&($.(#+$'#.$(:#+ ,99$(%+2,4:$/$(#.$(4$.$43<#+&'

,.#&((

. %"'$',5."! 7$(#+$.*&'$6#+&',.#9"%@'#+$%/5$#$(%$#:&(#"(4 $A"/&($4&

$.$(##$%+(&%"9$4,%"#&(?,"9& &%"#&('"(4# ./"(5&(&( "'.$:".4'($?,"9& &%"#&(#3$."#$43$##$..+&:+$.#+"(#+$#+$.

"#+$.%,.#'*,94(./"99<.$ ."&( ./$/3".@&(:,5(',%+"($A$.%&'$ "(49$"7$&###+$$A5$.#'&(#+$ &$94

.#+$3$($ &# #+$5$#&#&($."%99$%#&7$.$"4&(: 4%,/$(#'59"%$4.$9&"(%$,5(3<#+$%,('$9"#(($A,.$' 0B%99<!6

"(4

%99<!*,94"#3$'#&(4&%"#$#+"##+$*$".'&59/"

0=0 5''$''$43<#+$5$#&#&($.&'',$43<-;6-"(:.,.&'$?,&7"9$(###+$ +.$$ $".' &59/" ./ "-#"#$ $%+(&%"9 4,%"#&( ".4 "(4 "' '#&5,9"#$4&(#+$"47$.#&'$/$(# 7$(5.%$$4&(:(',%+5.$/&'$6#+&' ,.#%"((##"@$"7&$*&( "7,. #+$5$#&#&($."(4#+94+&/$9&:&39$

.#+$5'# ,(&.(:&($$. $%+"(&%"9! +$($7$.'5$%& &%?,"9& &%"#&('".$5.$'%.&3$4 ."5'#6#+$ &(%,/3$(# .',%+5'#*,94(#3$7$'#$4*&#+"(&(+$.$(#.&:+##'$$@ #+$3$($ &# $?,&7"9$(#./"#%+&(:?,"9& &%"#&(&(#+$"3'$(%$ "%9$".

'#&5,9"#&(&('$.#$4&(#+$"47$.#&'$/$(#&(4&%"#&(:#+$5*$.#+"##+$-#"#$ .#+$ $%.,&#/$(#:$(%<"'#+$%"'$/"<3$6#%('&4$."(4"55&(#',%+ &(%,/3$(#'5''$''&(:',%+?,"9& &%"#&('(#+$"47$.#&'$/$(#&(?,$'#&(6 #+$5.$'%.&3$4?,"9& &%"#&(*"'+.$$$".'&59/" ,(&.(:&($$.&( $%+"(&%"9(:&($$.&(: ./"-#"#$$%+(&%"94,%"#&(".4. ./"

.$%:(&C$4 ,(&7$.'&#< . &('#&#,#&( +$.$ *"' ( &(4&%"#&( &( #+$ "47$.#&'$/$(##+"#%"(4&4"#$'5''$''&(:"($?,&7"9$(#?,"9& &%"#&(*,94 "9'3$#.$"#$4$9&:&39$+$5$#&#&($.%"((#%/5$9#+$.$'5(4$(#'# #.$"#+&/"'$9&:&39$ .#+$5'#&(?,$'#&((#+$3"'&' ?,"9& &%"#&( 3$&(:$?,&7"9$(###+$($5.$'%.&3$4&(#+$"47$.#&'$/$(#$7$(& #+"#3$ ' (#"@&(:',%+7&$*#+&',.#*,944."*',55.# ./"&7&'&( $(%+2,4:$/$(# #+&',.#&(/(0 1

) 20 !""3 #'$

% &

444 "(4#+$.$9$7"(#5.#&( *+&%+.$"4'&(#+$ 99*&(:

#$./')0

! !

* 2

! 8

B/ ? D/

< "

> D

B 2 /

4 ?2

;< &%$0,5 %75#=:.1 (5( .

$)%77, ! !

2 9

! !

C ! !

! !

2 !

* !

2 !

= /

! ! !

/ 9! ! ! ;

! 8

B/ ?

< "

2 !

C +$.$9&"(%$59"%$4 3<%,('$9 ,5(#+$2,4:$/$(# (E39$5$A ,.# &(

. %"'$',5."!&'

/&'59"%$4 +$&'',$#+$.$&(*"'"'.$:".4'.$%.,&#/$(##9"''0"(4 9"''01 '$.7&%$ &( #+$ -,3.4&("#$ ,4&%&"9 -$.7&%$ &( #+$ -#"#$

"+"."'+#." (4$. #+$ .$9$7"(# .$%.,&#/$(# .,9$' #+$ 5.%$4,.$ .

.$%.,&#/$(##5'#' 7".&,'%"#$:.&$'+"43$$(5.$'%.&3$4 (4$. ,9$ "%('#&#,#&( "(47&'.<//&##$$*"'$(7&'":$4"(4*+&%+&(#,.( +"49"&44*(" ,.5&(#%.&#$.&" .'+.#9&'#&(: "99#+$"559&%"(#'+$

$(4&(:5.#&( #+$%.&#$.&"*"'##+$$

$%##+"##+$"559&%"#&('

',%+%"(4&4"#$'5''$''&(:/&(&/,/$4,%"#&("9?,"9& &%"#&( 5"''&(:

0>0 #+7$.("%,9".'#"(4".4"(4F.$4,%"#$4,5#5"''&(: #+'#"(4".4(9< *,943$%('&4$.$4 .#+$&(#$.7&$*"(4#+'$*++"4'#,4&$4"37$#+ 7$.("%,9".'#"(4".4*$.$(##3$%('&4$.$4 ."55&(#/$(#+$(E39$ -,5.$/$,.#,(4$.#+'$5$%,9&".%&.%,/'#"(%$'"(4*+&9$%('&4$.&(: #+$?,$'#&( "55&(#/$(##9"''0F9"''015'#'+"4#"@$("7&$* #+"##+$.$%,943$(2,'#& &%"#&( .%"(4&4"#$'*+5''$''?,"9& &%"#&('

$?,&7"9$(##--A"/&("#&( .(##3$%('&4$.$4(#+$2,4:$/$(# &#'$9 "(#$ %",#&(*"'&('$.#$4#+"#',%+7&$**"'3$&(:#"@$((#+$

"%#' #+$%"'$"(4*"'(##3$,(4$.'#4"'9"<&(:4*(".,9$

,(&7$.'"9"559&%"#&(

.#+$.$"'('.$%.4$4"37$6#+&',.#4$'(# &(4"(< &( &./&#<&(#+$"%#&( #+$.$'5(4$(#4$5".#/$(#&(+"7&(:#.$"#$4#+$ 5$#&#&($."'&($9&:&39$ .#+$5'# ,(&.(:&($$. $%+"(&%"9!"'+$ %(%$4$49<4$'(#5''$''#+$+.$$$".'&59/" ,(&.(:&($$.&( $%+"(&%"9(:&($$.&(: ./"-#"#$$%+(&%"94,%"#&(".4"(4*+&%+ *"' #+$ 5.$'%.&3$4 $''$(#&"9 ?,"9& &%"#&( &( #+$ "47$.#&'$/$(# 4"#$4

=(($A,.$ !

$#&#&(6"%%.4&(:9<6&'4&'/&''$4 01213124 9,%@< +$#+$.'5$"@&(:F.$"'($4) $'F +$#+$. $5.#"39$) $'F