High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22829/2018disposed of

M/S Famina Knit Fabs v. Union Of India And Others

2018-11-22Mr. Justice R.C. Kathuria (Retd.),Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu8 pages

GURBAX SINGH 2018.11.28 10:44

!"!#$ %&"

'!# (#!

)" **

!# + ,"

#!##!

# - +" *

".# # " %$ /0% 1( % %02 /0% 1 1%

( 0

!"" 3 4(5'

+%!

62 #" "!

$%&

" ' !"" "'" " (!""""

" )* ("+

( (,!""'

" -. & "'" / " 0'"

+' % *(, ! %

"" "" '23+!4 *5"

', *( 6 !" !" " , 7' !, ( , "!' '"! , ! *"!""

* "" , " "

, ( " # !""1!"! ""

" 8'

"" " '

' +! , #!""'"* (" " ,

- +! " ,

# !""!! "( ! ' +! ""( "

*( 6 " "!!" (" " " * !," , +"

!* * '* !""+! * 9!* '" (, ".5!',"" '/, ' !'! *( 6* ( ' :%

" ! '""+" " !"","/5 #'6(

*5" #! '""+" ' (+"<#= " "

"> "

! %

" "

(+ # !"" 0' "

" ?"

% +' ;

! !"", " '(@ '"" ( # ! ' 60'",*"! "!!"("

' 6!" * ' ' *;& #!"" "' +! ! # ' '"" !" +! (' "

*( 6( " ' " ""' (,5" 9' /" 259/4#!""""

" 59/*"0' ', *( 6( "#59/ !

" ' * "

! $ % ,

A +" " !"" # !""

- % " " ' 6" " " 59/ '

'"" *( 6 ( " ?"

+' & " ' " 59/ 8'

" "

" !""?"

& % +'

59/" !"" , "' (@ " "

" '

", ' '"" ', *( 6 ( " 5'" 59/ !"' *"*" " " !"" "' !"" *"' * ' ( ' ! ! '

( / " ' * % & " '

( B 3 ' 9! % (" """ '

!"" " ' *, " ', *( 6 ?"

* ' " & +'

! % '! !"" * '*, *( 6' - --

$.=' ( !""# (" !"

=5 ( #!"" % ( "'6"0'" * '" '

' (" (, (!" " ' ( ",#"

!""* "! "

+' *""(,!"" * '" 6!!" "( '", "

"' """!"",' #!""

$ -

+' !""'

" " " ' 0'" """ " !"" ! % "

"*"'" " !"" # * ' " * '! 0'"

;

""" ( " , "! # * (, ",) "!""(,!"" ; ' !"" $

!''" "!"" " ' !"" * " !"" "

" "' , !!""!' - # !+'"

2 %4%$&/#9%$& "

0'" ""*"!""*"', ,*"(

+"" * !" " * ' = C;/" ,0'"*" " ' "

" "" " * )" ' * @'"

" " " " *" ! (, " '", ' D " ;

" + " " @'" " " ' " - * 0',

" "' ,*"(' $ " '" !!"" **' " !" "! *"

*(,"'/" * =" !"" ' *" @'" " " (, )"'*

" "'" ,""( " ' ="! """ / " ", ' !" , " " " ' * B '( , " " *"" " " )" ' " ' " - !" +" " ,)* )"''" "

" 0'

" "'" ,"( !"" !! )" ' *"' "" ' ' + !" *"' " +"'

" "' "6 + ", @'" " " ' " - 2D

$ D -E !

" # $ 2

%4 D ;%%E % $ " # 2

%4 D &E % &!' !' # 2

$4- D;

4 -#"'" "'"( )

$;D

&E * ! ( $$ D ; $E

) + /9 $& D

/9 $ D - ( +, - . # -- D

' " - ,*"

!* " "'" *" )" ' , *"(', " "," / )" '"" " " !, 0' '"( " * " ' + " " @'" " " # ' " + ", " ' , + "!*"

" '" ( ( !" "! ' @'" ! ' 0'" ""( ! 2D +! & )' $ D ; E ! " ! (! ( (! 2 -$4 D9 -$%E ! ! "/ ! 2

;4 D;%-E !! ( ' 2

4D$& E )' ) ( ( 2

$4 $ D&$E F D3 F'" 3 F" 2

4 - D %E +,! ! "" 2

4&D- $E ## !, )/ 2

4-D-%;E

!! 0 - '.

, ! ", 2

4 D $

E "

%/ 2

4 & D ; &( - . #

$ 2

%4D & 4 &/ ! $"

4;D%%& "' *" , !! " !"

(, ' !, ' +'

', "( "*"@'" " " " ( * C / !"

-; D ; " ' ' ="! " *" !"" *" ( " "

" , " "( " ! ( 2 /9!; % !&4 C& G # )" ' ' !!" "" '"(' (, '" @'" " " '

" - '! " , !"

(, ' (""" ""!" !"""(' " " @'" " " ("" "!"

(, ' )" ' , *" !" (, ""!""' " - "'" ", ' '((,!

*" !, !!," " 6 ",'!H %/ ! " # $ 2

%4 D;%%"'( 2D!!;;

=; !4 C G / " * * " * " "(""," (,'*" "! " ,

" " , !"

(, ' , '(" #"'* *" ",(, " " ! * *6 )*6

; 39 ;

- " *" ! 239 ! $4IG# "*" "("", ,((" ' '!'G'" " ">*"("",+"" *" (, '*" " " ! " !" ' , " " G # , !"

(, ' ' ( *

" " ! !, !'' ' !!" (

# "(,'' ( ! < # ' "

* " " ! * !! (, )' 8 " " 8 3+!*!!8 %- (

(, ", ' " " / &

& & # %$

$% 24 /

, $ / ( ( 0', !!" ( " ( * (,"' '' # )" ' * @'"

" "

"""*"!"""""H ;/ ! #

&4$D $%- 9

, 2!6" @", 4( 2D!- & !&&4 C&& G D @'" " " )" ' '

" -J @'" " " "' ' " % J"

" " ("' !"" ( '" "/ " * 0',("'*"+ ""!* ' " -.

" % '*' ",6 """"

"!"" *' + ""@'" " " "*" !"" HH2D& +"" ) 1 ) # $ D E* !"

$4D - E) ( 2

"! 2

4D;& E

4 % D $E

$ 2 -4 D9 &-$3 ! " #

%4 D;%%E)K "K!" D

D'!! 2 4 D % E 4" " )

, 2

4 DE

# 22

4 D & E 0" 2

4 D

!' 2, $ ( 2

4-D$- 4 /

&! # 2 4

D -$ " ' " "

!" "! ( * " ' "!' *" " '(" (," '"! ) ! " 2 & 4%D %/"

"" "'*! (2D!

! %4 C % G * ' ' !"

! " (,' !" ' , ('"!" ' ' "!" '*, "'( ' " ' "

' 6"L ,M+ '

HH & /"* ( *" " "" *" !"" " !"" (, + "" + ", *" @'" " " ' " - "'" / " )* !"" " , "" !!""!' ( '""(**"" "! !, " / "

!!" *"""!' !"

( "" ' """ ", (!"" "! @,F'"4 '

( 2@"'F'4 I< '

9 ! " !6" "