Mohinder Pal Kaur v. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And ANR
!"
#$% &'
(%)*+*&, --
!
./ !- 0
0-
!!
"
#$%& % '#$%& ( ) #$%& )" '#$%& ( *****
0- 2 - 3#4"
+
( ( &'
&& & ' & '
%
%, %& -.-/0-+/ 0
& ( &
& ( & &, && %
'
'
1
# !
'
#2 & $& & +34 ( & &, $&# 0--3 5 ( (
6 $& ( 0--378
% , 2
&
'' &(( & &,
( 0#.-#9./:
$ ' %
&#
( 03#---:
& ' & ' &
0
&
, '
' ( ( & &, ; & & &&
(
&&' & ' & ' # % #
'
&&( &' & 3 < &# , , , ( (( % ( = '# >)# #
( #
& ,
'
( & ,
'( & ? % &( (
& ,$
' ' 5( & 8# -/-/0-+/ & & &
( (( & &,
&2 ' &#
&
'
& ,
'' ( (
'
1
@ ' A
B+-
C $ )/3. -.-/0-+/ (
& )&#
% ( & &, ,# 0-+A &+34($&(0--3#
( % $
( 0#.-#9./: #
'
3D( & &, , # 0-+A#
' & ' & ' ( 03#---:
2 &
'% ( &(&
&
2;@ @
%,
(
'
? & ' & ' & , && ( & : && ( %'&
(( ',
(&% ,; &
&% ,# & ' & ' &
3
&& A
& ( & ( &&%
&( , , % ;
& &'
5--5
0 5
6#6+7*, #38#,# *94* 1*$3#,
*:#;
#,( &$7%3+ 1+- !&7(- <#8=;
>7#, #,( #,&$7%37# & && '& ' &% ,?
, && &(& '& ' & & '( &;
& & - -
, 0 &'
63- >#3#;9*$ 0*,:7 1+- 0$#$% &'
=,9#?7# &
&&& '( 4
& ( 2 &
& &
(3D & &, , ? &
0-+/&
& ';& & ' (
:&% , & &&
3D00 3DA
&# 2
& ( && &(& '& '
&(& '&% , 9 )
' '
, ( D ? % & '
( ( &% %' '& %
& / 1( &'
(
( %
, %
A
E
! "
#
$
" %" " $ # $
"
#&
# "
" % $ $ " % # % " $ " $# $
&
%
"
'" $ "
$ #
%
$ " %
"
"% &
"
" $ "
%$
"
# " "
# " #$ $ ( $$# )
$
# " "
# " "
*
4
( + !$ #
% " "
"# '" #
( % " "&
(
+!$
#
%
" "
"# '" #
( #" $ ( $
( % " " ) "
"# '" $
# " "
# " "
(
+ !$ " # # %% " $ #
#" ( $ #
# %% "
"% % ) ", #-
9
"
# ( # " "
# " # " " # " "
# "
# " "
." /"
. "
# " " " ) "
"
", " # . 0
"
# ! % !
" " ) " "
"
# % $% %
"
%/"
$$"" " ) "
#
" %
$ . $" /"
#% %
"
" $%"
D
" 1
2 . "
# ", 1 # # 3 *
# ! $
#
# #%1"
" ", "
&
#
, " " $ $
# #%1 "
" ", "
&
( , #!
" " $ #"
"
% " "#
$ $ "
"#!
" " , ! ! (
"
# "%
% , " " # ""
$
% ) ,"
# "
/
#$ " " (
"
#" % "
4 0 0 ) " % ,"
# ,"" . 0 " %
7$ % % 0 0 ) " 56 2 564 . 3 ", # #
" $ $
# "
% " # " . " # $ " %
# #$ .-8 " $ " 0 " % # :$ :;< )$ <)
8$ 8
"
: = . :=.
<% <
2
> "
$"
" &
.
0 "
" &
.%"" $"
" & ? ""
" & ) . 3 # ? 3 , # #
2 ? "
$
"# "
$ # # % # " " % " "
"
" " %
$ "# # . 3 $ # $ # # "
'" $ % ++0 0 ) " 56
4 0 " % " "#
# $ " ) " $ 0"
7$ % % 0 0 ) " 56 " # " 2
4+ +1 # ## 0"$$ /"
"
+-
#
2 " " '" " #"
5
$ ## 0" " " .
$ "
"
" 0" " "
#
# " 0"
$ . ) # $" " 0"
# "
"
#
0" ) " " 0" " (
(
( $
$
# '" /"
" " $
" " (
( (
$
# %
0" $ % % "# 2@+ 2@2 0 0 ) " 56
5 "
$
$ " #
0
++
2@ 2@
0
# " ) $ " "
" "# 0" "
" " # "
"
$ 0" $
$ #(
#
0 " ) "
"
" # $" 0"
( %
4 . 0" $ $ # % " # " !% " "
""
$ !$ % % $
#
" +A 0 0 ) " 56 # # " +6
0" 1 #
% "
+0
%$ #
"'" $ # $ %
% ( $
" # #
$ "
@ >
# # 0"
" # " (
" # " -
# #" # -
#$ %
" 0" % $ %9 - !> %
"
( B " C #D
% " # -
# "
D . ( &
C
+-0( & &, ,? &
0-+/ E.
0 "
+2"
+3
. -
7% )#+%+ )&@%3%( =,(%3 0%)$*&, &'
$7% )$ +7#44 (%#4$ A*$7 *, #))&3(#,)% $& $7% B3&@*+*&,+ &'
%:=4#$*&, 5 &'
$7% 0=BB48 &(% - 4%)$3*)*$8 0=BB48 &(%
?
20 '"
E ) >
#
" ; #
. " " # # #"
", " #0
.("
#" !% ! ", # 0
> "
", "
% $% %
" $
% /"
$ $ " " "
+A
2.
0 %
#
. .", ? $" /"
% $ # "
.
%
# #
" " ;
" .("A
#
!% %#
$
# #
.", ? %
$% " # " "
.("A
"
"
"
"
# " ; $ 24 " %# #
# .", ? " 9%" 2
"
" ; #" #" "#
0"
+4
"#
# )
) .
. "
. " ; $
#"
" " 9%" 2 $
# #" (
" $ " !
"#/ "
" ( #
->F -
9 . "
2G
.
" # " " #" " $ % 4A" "
4 .
" # $ ( % " #
%
$ F +- ? %(
(& ($&(0--3
(&% ,
'
+9
B ( ', & +09 ( $& ( 0--3# &
(( & &,
&+34( $&(0--3@ #& '( ((& &+34 ($&(0--3
&+40($&(0--3 (( & # &
((& & $ $&(0--3#%(&((( ',# ((&
&& & &, , C ,(
, 2
& C
"
(
%(
' ,& # & &,
, (& C (A/ ( & ;&# &(
( &% , &+345+$8($&(0--3
&G( ' & &
& ;&# , '& && ( % ( & # ( &% ,
&+345+$8($&(0--3# " ( & &, , '
% ($&(0--3
"
, ((&&
&% ,
& +345+$8($&0--3 ++ ?
( ( ( , (
&& , ,' ((&(&+4A($&(0--3&
, & % ( && & ( ((& & +34 ( $& ( 0--3 &+4A548($&(0--3 &
&% ,
%#
+D
, & &+345+$8($&(0--3 ( G&
(
(&% ,
& ,&
!'#
&
'
& ;&# (&% , &
&+34($&(0--3 &
&
!' , & (
% ( ( &% , & +09 ( $& ( 0--3
%
(
(
(
&+345+$8($&(0--3#&
&
, % & (, (
, (( ', , '& && (
, & " ( && &
,: (& ,, , , (&% ,'G& % , &(&
!'# &# &
(
( & '(((& +0
( # (
( &
3D ( & &, 0-+A '
+-0 ( & &, , ? &
0-+/ && #?
( %
& , 2 &
'( %
3D( & &, 0-+A
(( & &, 3D0 (
& C& (( ( & &,
(& '
&
3D00
C
&
$G / ( & %
+/
'
(2 & ( & &,&&
'
3D03
(& ' %
'
3D30 & &
, &'B & & '& '
,( & ,
:&% ,%
3D30 ,
''
& '& '
&% ,'
#
'
(&
(
:&% , &( & '& '
& +40 ( $& ( 0--3
&
(
( & &, ,? &
0-+/
+-00
(
& +34 5+$8($&(0--3#
+-0A
& ' & ' # &
"
%, '
&
& &, & &, , ? &
+3 , &
%( (( &
( ( &% ,&
'(( & &, ' " & ' ( &
, (
' &% , 2 & 2
& & &
( , & ( & '& '
&
' % & +40 ( $& ( 0--3 & ' ' ,&& '&& '& ' , =%
&'B
+.
' ( & # 2 &
, G & ' & , % '
&+40( $& ( 0--3#
" &% , ( # & (
& & ( ( & &, &&# &# ,
+A && '
, #44&A%( & && & ' & ' & ' " &% , (
# ( ,#
'
"
0- "
--
H "':
I :) H I :)