Sanjay Kumar v. Central Admn. Tribunal And ORS
!" #$% &"'() '*+$, #$% -&.&/012&
3(1( &42(&*1&,5&46&575(
(84(
!"# $%&'(# )*%
(''
"
!"# $%&'(#
(' "
+++
() 9 .&/-6&,4'&, "58
:::::
(' ",$
5 8 ;&88'& *" 5 & 42(& *1&,5&46&5<5&(=45>&4&/?.1(4'"5( 1'5&66544&4$ $$
#$ ;>1 @ <8&((4
#A#B#$#!#B &4544&4
#$A;>1 @$$< 4(2((65 ?88'& #A#B#### #$A,?5*/5('&2 "(6@&(45('B&882"(84
;(84 +*"5<&('5'&&4@3;&@9&<?5&"15 4'&8852&('5'&&4@3;&@9&<'(C1 186&"8&/,5&(*.'4
9 .&/-6&,&4'1(&88&6*5&""5 8 (1*24 5& (84
( &41& (1 "
94'&41'&7 (&'5,5&46&5;"(5D 9 E<'&1(4 & &4(2 4&4 $!
, ?5*/ &88'&( "
'12" &1(8((,'14658("'5'&&4@3 ;&@9&<?'&4,"?5'55?58((&41"?5'5 8(?&(141@(4'&6/,8( "-'5414&( &6/&4&5" '&6/ 58('*4C1&"'&" 58("'5'&&4@3;&@9&<?&(&(14)@ -
&2"5 ( F1&"'& $#5(&4&4?5"'& 5(8'&4 '5'& &4 3 ;4< ( 4@ B# +
9&' ?5 &4 '"'& "2 & '6G4 (1 &415/?5 /&( >8'(8'"&4( " ?5'5 "'&B&6 ( &&&*
+ '5'& &4@3 ;&@9&< ( 4@ 9B#
@4@ +
6&46 5 8('*4 &6 2, ?&( (&4 5 &4(25&5(&2?14*$!@+#/&(?5 /&(&6 &>&"-'5414&('&6/'&44&( 5&(4&"'8 "&88'&("42656*/?&(
?&(&(&6145&&(852&'1&'"'&,5 4&"*5"58( $ %%,5",55&4'2845 &6 " + /&( &(
&4, 51(, ?&( 6* " 5 &"248( 344&4$#B$
#$+,58?&( &(=4(1*254'12("5(&48(,?5'5?41/(1*24
34'4&4$ +
#$+;>1 @$<,58?&("24 5&5?&(4'&46*"5(&48(*6&6 5( 6&4,58(1*24&8(&4&4
+
#$+;>1
<, *1 5 (&2 ?&( '(44 */ 5 (84(, ?5'5
- '(&452&88&'554
! @" #$+ 34244&4$%
#$+,5'28&15/ ?&( 44 &? &''(( 5 8 5 & ('B828'(( '28&'"5&"244, 44&4
#$+;>1 <,58?&('&4"5 ?
(84 +'2244('"?'&44&( 5('8'(('41'4 %
#$+, ,;$<18&2;
<;
< &4;
<3&4&(;-< ?'&44&(,&2/,( &.;
<&4 -&.&/012&;-<;85<?=85?&6( ?6 5(1*(C1482?5'5=8&'4165612,5 &"24 6&88'&?&(?54&??582((" &"(5?5*8&'1&(,?5'5?&(&?444 4&4 %
5 &4 '1( "15 '44 5& 5 8 '5&645('&4&882"(84
51655 6&88'&"4*" 5(&4"5&15(5 ?(&2"4*"5?&(5&5844 8((((5&4'"'&"2&'6G4(1&4&45 &*('"5(&2,5('&44&1?&(.'4 (1&/,5 4(2((45 6&88'& 5 ?88'&?&(&( 4(2((4 51(, &( 8 5 8('*4 C1&"'& " 5 8( " '5'& &4@3 ;&@9&<, 5 8 ?&( 2&'1& &4 5&625& /&(>8'&(&@9&&4?&(((5&+ /&("&6&(
%
585&4(1*24"12>8'"%%25( 5&4"&@9&,?5&((84
@3&4&(?&(
5&6 8&@2 >8'"29&/ ## 1/ #$# 5&4 '"'&(*((14*/5&4B15//"5'1(B&6 ( &&&* ?5 5 (1, *1 5 8( '&(, &( 8 5 "2&(165145 65"2&',(1'5'1( (8' 5 &@9& ?&( ""4 */ 5 (1B&4B15/
5( (1'5 C1&"'&"&4'"'& "25'6G4 (1, &4 15/ 14 &/ -&1 " 5 &@2& &4 4(85&,5""'&(84(5&4&"41858("&@ 2& 65 "2 5 '8 ?5 5 9 , 5&46&5 (&4 "1'6,*1&@9&?58(((("&4'"'&"2 '6G4&415/?&(&884 (('&&882( "5(&48(?2&4?51&4'"'&
!
5&5&45&4'1("58,&88&(4 58&8*=&4&"5?5&5("'&425 (1*2((( " 5 &4 '1( " 5 8 5 6*/ '4&(12&4&*,?&('5&64*/58 *"5 5'5&65&882"(84
;(84 +*"5<,44(1*((,",5(('(? 2&4444&4$
?,5?&(&&' *?58&4""'&(84(*"55&5 ?&("'&B&6"5&4"&@2&
?"5"&'5&5?&('"'&B&6" 5&4"&@2&,&&C1&"'&, ,5'&44&(514 * 2&' ?5 &4 '"'& "2 & '6G4 (1, &4 15/?5 /&(>8'?&(C14*"1"4 '14 *'45&58@&88'&448((((5(C1(
&&C1&"'& H&4'1("58?&(1&* 6 &/ >&28 &2 " &/8( 4 " &882 (&*(55&58((?515&4'"'&5&*&884 (5?4('2& 5&*('"5'5&656*/ '4,58'&*824165&5?&(4 "&4'"'&
$$
5&(((&4&*,?4"4&/6&/ 8(/5281644( 614""'(2&41
8(&4(4(2((4 ;
)*%
(''
". /
(' ".
$%01# $%01# 2 -, 45 7 7 68 49 :;
< ) 6;
7 7 43
) 6;