High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24613/2017dismissed

Malkiat Singh And ORS v. Charan Singh And ORS

2017-10-31Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

&"&"&"&"$")#*+ $")#*+ $")#*+ $")#*+ ,!-.%!"%'/0!'1"0#*& #"%"%'#*& 2& 0!*!'%'/0!'1"0#*& #&3'1#'"& ,( ,( ,( ,( 4 5, 66, 4 5, 66, 4 5, 66, 4 5, 66, *#&#'"( ,&73*%8!!*/+19$!"#+

*"0#3#"%"%'#*& ,*0#**86%'/-!+19$!"#+

*"0#$!9#!"* 66, + :5;

66, + :5;

66, + :5; 0# 3#"%"%'#*& 0!9# $0!--#'/#1 "0# *1#*& 1!"#1

3!&&#1)8"0##0&%-1!*$7<&&%&"!'"--#$"*+*!1#+7-"!'37*510%+ =3!&&#1)8"0#--#$"*$7< ,+7-"!'37*510%+ =

3!&&#1)8"0#<<%&&%'#*+ !-!'10!* %9%&%'!'1 = 3!&&#1)8 "0#%'!'$#<<%&&%'#* ')*%# +*#&3'1#'"& >)#%'/"0#$&0!*#*&""0##?"#'" @&0!*# -!'1<#!&7*%'/.!'!-A<!*-!+ %-#1!'!33-%$!"%'7'1#* #$"%'

"0#7'B!)5!'1#9#'7#$"+ AAC *&0*"D"0#$"4E * &##.%'/ 3!*"%"%' "0#%* B%'" .0#F!" 0#*# %& ' 1%&37"# "0!" F0#' "0#

<1# 3!*"%"%'F!&3*3&#1!'1!$$#3"#1')B#$"%'F!&*!%&#1)8"0# 3#"%"%'#*& #?$#3" "0!" "0#*# F!& !' *!- #?$0!'/# )#"F##' "0# 3!*"%#& %' *#&3#$" 60!&*! &

@@ !'1

F0%$0 F!& <7"!"#1 )8 <7"!"%'

=&!'$"%'#1' GA)7"%'"0#B!<!)!'1%"0#*#%&' *# #*#'$# .0!&*!

F0%$0 %& !--#/#1-8 /%9#' %' #?$0!'/# " "0# 3#"%"%'#*& 0#3#"%"%'#*&0!9#!&&!%-#1"0#9!-%1%"8 "0#*1#*3!&&#1)8 "0#%'!'$%!-<<%&&%'#*'"0#/*7'1"0!""0#*#%&!<%&*#!1%'/ "0# *#9#'7#*#$*1 ' "0# "0#* 0!'1+ -#!*'#1 * "0# *#&3'1#'"&+ F0 %& ' $!9#!"+ 0!& &7)<%""#1 "0!" "0# 3#"%"%'#*& !*# )-F%'/ 0" !'1 $-1 %' "0# &!<#)*#!"0!&"0#8!*#*#-8%'/73'"0#<7"!"%'

=&!'$"%'#1' GA!'1!""0#&!<#"%<#0!1 %-#1!%9%-7%" * &##.%'/ 1#$-!*!"%' "0!" "0# &!%1 <7"!"%'

= &!'$"%'#1 ' GA ' "0# )!&%& *!- #?$0!'/# %& '7-- !'1 9%1 " %& !-& &7)<%""#1"0!""0#3#"%"%'#*&1%1'""!.#"0#3-#! H7#&"%' "%"-#!""0# "%<# %-%'/ "0#*#3-8""0#3!*"%"%'!33-%$!"%'!'1#9#'!""0#&"!/# <1# 3!*"%"%'!'10!1*!%&#1"0#&!<#"0#*#!

"#* 0!9#0#!*1-#!'#1$7'&#- *"0#3!*"%#&!'1!

"#*3#*7&!- "0#*#$*1+!< "0#$'&%1#*#13%'%'"0!""0#*#%&'#***%'"0#*1#*& 3!&&#1)8"0#7*"&)#-F%'!&<7$0!&"0#3#"%"%'#*&$!''"*#-873'!'1 1%&$!*1 "0# &!<# 1$7<#'" '!<#-8+ <7"!"%'

= &!'$"%'#1 ' GA'"0#)!&%& *!-#?$0!'/#*!"0#*"0#$!&# "0#*#&3'1#'"& %& "0!""07/0"0#8 0!9# @ &0!*#%' "0#-!'1 <#!&7*%'/.!'!-A <!*-! F0%$0 %& '" 1#'%#1 )8 "0# 3#"%"%'#*& )7" "0# 3#"%"%'#*& F!'"#1 " .##3

3&&#&&%'9#*"0##'"%*#-!'1%''#F!8*"0#"0#*!'1!*#$'"#&"%'/ $'"%'77&-8)# *#'#7*"!

"#*"0#"0#* '9%#F "0#!

*#&!%1 !$"&!'1$%*$7<&"!'$#&+1'" %'1 !'8<#*%"%'"0#3*#&#'"3#"%"%'!'1"07&"0#&!<#%&0#*#)81%&<%&&#1 :66, ;

:66, ;

&"&"&"&" + + + + 0#"0#*&3#!.%'/@*#!&'#1 #&@ 0#"0#**#3*"!)-# #&@