← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3453/2016disposed of

Ranga Oil Carrier Th Its Prop Gaje Singh v. Union Of India And ORS

2017-03-01Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

    

  !"#"$%  

& $'

"( ))" ) $*+ )#  ""$ )# , )#-# $"$ $*"

$*+ )#  #.$* $# 

/



01#2 ""( ))" )  ""$ ) , )#-# $"$ $*"

$*+ )#  #.$* $#  

 

    



 

    

 

    



 

   





   

!"

"!%&' 

 " "   #

   $  % &'

( )    #

  *+

,-

./

 '

&'

%  '' %  

  .0 .

.,

$

 % '

&'

  / .- .- 12' 34 5*%%$67 #$  % #



5*+

,-

./6



'   %%   8 . ./ 52' 36 #$ 9 :% * ; 59:*;63

%% %$ 2

!<=% '%$ ) ')  % &'

 % '

   % # %%  ' 

 %

; '% 

 

  3#

3    

   #'  #'   "   

> '    % #



  #%$  %%$ % 

>

%  



 % &' 

*

 ?

*%' .5#6 #'   %%$ '   #

#%$

% % #%   % '

$

 2 .

.

$ %



 '% #   ' %%  #

 %<2

 

 2%'    %

.

) ')

,

  % '%   

 % # "   % '   

$ %  

" "  

  8 . ./ *

  $ "

  $ %  ') #

  '

2

 

' *%'

 ?

,56 @ 56  ?

.5#6  ?

! ! *

-



' %  

  .0 .

.,   % ' &'

,

;

0/

8

;

) ')    < 

 %    9

 "    ,  .,   #   $    $ "

  2 ' '  " $ %  $

/

# 

 

  '  &' ')

 #%)%

) ') 

# 

 

  '# **:A   %% ) ') % # 

 

 '# %% #% '#%    * **:A %

9 "

B %%   : 

    "    .- ./ 

 

% 9 *  *'  $  

"

=%   ' "

>

*' *

,  3      

 

           

   



     



    !

 

         "#

"$ !  



! % =

9*  :

9*  ' '%

'#   

'

'3 %!

(") (

)$!

"(*!!

#+ $!'

(

,-

)$

&.

/0,1 &) ,,00 &2

)$!

(33*!

(3 & #' &()"* + 

 ,    

)-& ""  . )/

# ) -  #"    01

3 "

4 1

* 43 5)1



            0  ""  "  , 

  -   1   

    



      

   



     



    !  

         "#

 "$ !  

  /



 "1

1 )* 8&9 ).- ,1:        

; *0    . 

       6  & < 0-)&

 "") , & #' &()"* + 

) , =

- ;

&  *   & )  3  *  +#)  5  ) , =  &  > )  3     ?  "  *@ #   &  >  & &'' > & 4 &  & #' &()"* + 

), =         ,     .     + 6@@    ?

          "   B-=& BB & #' &(      /*@#   /,- ;CC .   

 :0, 



   & #' &(      /& 4 &  /,- A .       

    :0     

     .   

 :0; 

  ? 0 1

?)"

,    

 "0  D 

"   77 +8&13&3E!

3 -6A 

 .- ) , 77 +< 0- &

 "") ,F

9  '  ' 

  # '% 



'%  # % % ' 



'%  #  "

$   $

 '# " 2 #'  

9  #%

"  ' % /  "

$  $      

% ' #   ' &'  

 #

/ % '



%     '

'3 %3  , =?) 

)     0

  ?) +  

 + E99999999999999999999999999999999999999999 +   

  

 @. (  .(   0  ?  0

  ?



 @0   .   +" 

 

# @   

  "" ".."



 D  0"



    "

 E99999999999999999999999999999999999999999 +  , = 

?

  

   (  (  "   # -@-  ", = ""  ( (

0"



 )# -

""  (("

  

  # - # -( 

  (  (  "

   

  )    D"0        )           E999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ;

.   ". (.(



  

     ?        '  

    , =  ?        

 

. (.( + # 

  @ ""

  

 @ ""    .  

       .   .    



      0    0  

@

     "

  

   0'  "    6 /    0  "

   

       /+    ?    D   0      



 "   "

7       , =  !7     6@@    ?

9999 9999 9999 9999 9999 9999 9999 9999

   7  @ ""

0  !7  G E9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 +

    "" "

   

 "   +?

    @ ""  

    

 

@ ""     67 % .  

       .   .    



 "     0    

@

  "

   0'   0"  

   

 ", =   "     +- = "       6 3  D  "



  

   +

?      +  5 ".  +; 5 ".@.2 "" + &

   0  "  --  "

  !*-  



  / ( 0 5   + 3  D?    

  7              5 D 

0    

D       + ( "

.. ""+3 7 +A 3""?@" 

 ".. +3 7  + - "

  -  ", = -

2,2)2,,2 2,,,2+3 7; +C "+ ?  

  3 0 "

+3 7  +

 "3 0+3 7 + (   0 #  "  

  + ?  +3 7 +  3 0+(

 0 " ,  .9# H +; =" -?

* ? 

"")&35    "5    +    + 3  "?#

"  != )"

 ".. "" +,  )" "H   

"      D     0 ?"

 ".."= ,  + " "#

"

     0# 3 A 0* 0

"=  4?<I

"

 ,  

A + / (  <   "

  &0  -  +3 7A +A /(  5   5   #   .   3 +3 7 + , 0  .    -    < +3

9    (             

+C , 053 +3 7C +  ( ..  " 3 = ( /(   &0  +3/&  

   

,&6 ; 

    "  = ,)  "

   " (  +  /?  ( 

 

  "    

    " 3 0          



           0' +

 ( "  "&& (     (0    "

@  ? .

*%'  '  $  

% $  "'% #  $  %

9 % ' # '# "

  '% 9

, ! % C   %    **:A %

# '# "

 '

# #

" ' $ '  %% #% " '  

 *+

0-./ ./

 % '%  ' %

"

 % #  

# "  ' # 

9 %   D 

  <  :% * 5 

*+

,-

./6

  " ) ') 

 "

<  ! *$ 

 %% ") '

 % 



+    $ %% %$  



.

' &'%$

' # 

%

# # '

9 " ' '

 "'% # %%   #$ '#%  %% %    ' 

E'% "

  

 )     %



  #% ) '  '    

 

"'% ' '  '    

'

%%  "'% &'   

:%   %"$ %#$ &'    

' 

('   "'% % # %#% #   ' %$ % 

  % # " $   / .- .-

*+

,-

./

%  / .

./ % *+

0-./ ./

%  .

.- ./

9   $ 

)  %%  '  '   %$  %  %%$ "

%%   $ 

   %$  '%  " *' #% &' % 

"

'

 

,

9

 

 %$ 

 " "

'

    8 . ./  %% % ) ')   &'

>" "   $ "%%  ' %% % )

 ')

-

9   

3 *%' 3, .

5#6

9:*;

 %   

' % ) ')  % #% '% % "%%   '

%

 &'%$ '  # % #%  '%$

% ) ')

9  *%' 3, 

 

 %  " '  

$    % <) ') $  " '



$    %$   

/

+   "

*%' 3,56 56 .5#6  

 ' '#% " 9:*;

 #%$ % 2

 

=

# 2 '#% ' $

 ' #% %  

#%'  "'% ) $ ' % , *' 9 "'% # 

#$    '#% ' 

9 ' 9:*;

% %   %"$ '% #   

 &' '%$

%' ' #'    '%     

4

9

 

 %

 %% % '% % 5% ' "6 %'

   &'%$  

    "

 %    " '% )

*%' 3,56

 

9 '  

# .- %$ 

 ) 

 &' % ) ')   '

2

%  ;3   '#% A:9

# %  % 

  %%$ &'%   "  #'

9!

< 

 &'   $    2  $  3  &'  A:9  #

''%  # "  #%  ;39 

+  # $  '   #%  

'   

 "  '#%  "

 



 % # 3 

>" "'% # %#$ % % $ %#%  ' %"

    %$

32,4 5 3   2  65 2  

 

& ( 

+ + )#.

7"$'1) #$ *8

# + + )) .) 9( 8

#1