High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/32177/2025allowed

Sunil Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Another

2026-01-09Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

?6#"

$#!

7#!** & ' $"(#!

" "# $% !& ?6#*0$'#"* "# $% '#) "# $% '#) "# $% '#) "# $% '#) "# $% 0 $ "# $% 0 $ "# $% 0 $ "# $% 0 $ + + + + !#*#"+ !#*#"+ !#*#"+ !#*#"+ $+ !& ,-. ,/ $+ !& ,-. ,/ $+ !& ,-. ,/ $+ !& ,-. ,/ $ '

1+ !& $ '

1+ !& . ,/ . ,/ . ,/ . ,/

;2 6

2 2 2 2 !6 3('#7 1(. '7$) "# %$ !6 7& 1(. '7$) "# %$ %$!

$! "(# 0#"

$#!6 *6 ( *(0 . # $! !& 6 <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< 2 2 2 2. 6 =2> . 6 =2> . 6 =2> . 6 =2> !#*#" 0#"

$ ( * 5## %

#' '#! #)"

$ :@ $% "(# .

,. *##3 1 4 *( 1 $% 01#' $!'#! '

"#' 6,6,: =#A!# -> > 0 **#' 5& "( (# # !#' '

1 *"! "#

!*" **.

! . 9(#!#5&. "(# # $#! ( * * 5## '#) !#' * 0!$)

#' 0# #!*$ '#! #)"

$ @B=> $% "(# # .

)$0

" ) *# $6 // /, "

#' C ! D##" 1( 7#!**

!8 ' '

!#)"

$ ( * 5## # **#' "$ "(# )$)#!#' "$ !#1 *"#! '#! #)"

$ ,- $% "(# . , 1 *" "(# 0#"

$#!6 6 2# !#' )$*# %$! "(# 0#"

$#! ( * "#! "#' "( " "(# #

01#' $!

!'#!. 9(#!#5& "(# 0#"

$#! ( * 5## '#) !#' 0!$)

0#!*$.

* 9 9($

. !5 "! !& ' * **"

5 # "(# #&#* $% 2# !#' )$ *# ( * %!"(#!

"#! "#' "( " "

"(# 0#"

$#! ( * 5## %

) "#'

"$ "(# 0!#*#" ) *#6 2# !#'

' )$*# ( * !1#' "( " "(# #

01#' $!'#! ( * 5## 0 **#' #)(

& ' 9 "($" )$0 1 9 "( "(# ' "$!& !#4 !##"* * #7 * 1#' '#! #)"

$ @ $% "(# !6 66 =#)"

$ @B $% "(# >6 2# !#' )$*# ( * "#! "#' "( " "(# 0#"

$#!

9 * #7#! ' & *#!7#' 9 "( "(# *$* $! 5

#E$5

# 9 !! "*6 2# !#' )$*# ( * %!"(#!

"#! "#' "( " 0!0$!"#' #A#)"

$ $% 5

# 9 !! "* "(!$1( %

& $% "(# 0#"

$#!. '$#* $" )$*"

""#.

9. 7

*#!7 )#6 2# !#' )$*# ( * "#! "#' "( " 9(

# '#) 1 "(# 0#"

$#! *

#' 0#!*$. 7 '# 01#' $!'#!. $ *)( * "

$ * !#4 !#'

'#! #)"

$ @ $% "(# !6 66 =#)"

$ @B $% "(# >6 ( * 5## !#)$!'#'

"(#!# 6 2# !#' )$*# **#!"* "( " "(# 01#' $!'#!

* #A % ) #

!5 "! !& ' **"

5 # "(# #&#* $% 9 '

*. "(#!#%$!#.

# "$ 5# *#" * '#6 2# !#' )$*# **#!"* "( " "(# 01#' $!'#! ( * 5## 0 **#'

"($" 0!$0#!

& *)!"

1 $! 7#!

%& 1 "(# "(#"

"& $% "(# !#0$!"

*5 ""#' 5& "(# *#!7 1 )$*" 5 #6 $*#4#"

&. "(# $!'#! '#) 1 "(# $#! * 0!$)

#' 0#!*$ * **"

5 # "(# #&#* $% 9 '

'#*#!7#* "$ 5# 4 *(#'6 6 2# !#' " "# )$*# ( * %

#' !#0 & 5& 9 & $% %% ' 7 ' "#' ,6,6,/.

"(# $!" "$' &. 9( )( * " 3# $ !#)$!'6 *5 ** $* " '# 9 "( "(# * ' !#0 &.

# !#' " "# )$*# $00$*#' "(# 0!#*#" 0#"

$6 G(

# !#%"

1 "(# ) *# *#" 0 5& "(# 0#"

$#!. '#"

!1#"* 9#!# '7 )#' $ #!

"*. )$"#'

1 "( " '#*0 "# ** )# $%

# ' $5

# 9 !! "*. "(# 0#"

$#! '

' $" 00# ! 5#%$!# "(#

$!"6 $*#4#"

&. "(# 0#"

$#! ( * 5## !

1("

& '#) !#' *

#' 0#!*$. 7 '# 01#' $!'#!6 " ( * %!"(#! 5## 0$ "#' $" "( "

"(# # !#' $!" 5# $9 *)!0 $* & '(#!#' "$ "(# 0!$)#'!# 0!#*)!

5#'

'#! #)"

!$)#'!#. - =#)"

$ @B $% "(# >. ' $ % "& $!

!!#1 "& * '

*)#! # %!$ "(# !#)$!'6 2# !#' " "# )$*# ( *. "(#!#%$!#. )$"#'#' "( " "(# )$')" $% "(# $#! ) # !

& #*" 5

*(#* ( * '#

5#! "# '#% )# $% "(# D'

0!$)#** '

**# $% "(# )$)#** $ $% 5

6 ))$!'

&. '

** $% "(# *" "

$ ( * 5## 0! &#' %$!6 B6

( 7# (# !' "(# # !#' )$*# %$! "(# !

0 !"

#* '

) !#%

& 0#!*#' "(# !#)$!' $% "(# ) *#6 :6

(# * 9#

*#""

#' "( " $ 0#!*$ ) 5# '#) !#'

#' $%%#'#!E0#!*$ #** "(# 0!$)#'!# 0!#*)!

5#' '#! #)"

@ $% "(# $'# $% !

!$)#'!#. - * #"

) $* & '(#!#' "$6 "# 9 "( " "(# 0!$7 $* $% #)"

$ @ !# ' "$!& "!#. ' & $)$0

)# "(#!#$% 7 "#* "(# #"

!# 0!$)##'

1*6 "(# 0!#*#" ) *#.

( * 5## #"

$#'

"(# $!'#! ' "#' ,6,/6,B 0 **#' 5& "(# "!

$!"

"( " 5

# 9 !! "* 9#!# !#)# 7#' 5 )3 #A#)"#' "(!$1( %

& $% "(# $#! '. "(*. "(# 0#"

$#!. '#*0 "#. ( 7 1 $"

)# H 3$9 #'1# !#1 !'

1 0#'#)& $% "(# ) *#. '#

5#! "# & 7$ '#' ( * *#!7 )#6 !"(#!.

"(# $!'#! ' "#' ,B66,B.

" ( * 5## #"

$#' "( " $5

# 9 !! "* 9#!# !#)# 7#' 5 )3 #A#)"#'I (#)#. 0!$) $ '#! #)"

$ @ $% "(# !6 66 9 * **#' 1 *" "(# 0#"

$#!6 2# !#' )$*# %$! "(# 0#"

$#!

( * *" "#' "( " *$*E 5

# 'E $! $5

# 9 !! "* 9#!# #7#!

#A#)"#' $ "(# 0#"

$#!6 " ( * 5## **#!"#' "( " $ *)( * "

$. * !#4 !#' '#! #)"

$ @ $% "(# !6 66. !#1 !'

1 '# #A#)"

$ $%

$ 1 *" "(# 0#"

$#! ( * 5## !#)$!'#' "(#!# 6 $9#7#!. "(#

$!" 7 '# 01#' $!'#! ' "#' 6,6,: '#) !#' "(# 0#"

$#! *

#' 0#!*$ 9( )( * $" *($9 "$ ( 7# 5## #A#)"#'

)$%$!

"& "( #)"

$ @ $% "(# !6 66 /6

* $!" % '* "(# )$!*# '$0"#' 5& "(# $!" 5# $9 "

"(#* * "$ "(# 0!$7 $* $% #)"

!$)#'!#.

-6 (# $!" 5# $9 ( * )$ ""#'

"& 5& ** 1 "(# * $ '#! #)"

$ @ $% "(# !

!$)#'!# $'#. - "($" )$0

)# $% ' "$!& !#4 !##"* $% (# # !#' $!"

5# $9. 9(

# '#) 1 "(# 0#"

$#! * 0!$)

#' 0#!*$. %

#' "$ * "

*%&

"*# % !#1 !'

1 '# #A#)"

$ $% 0!$) $ ' 0!$)##'#'

#)( #!6 )( $!'#! 5# 1 7 $ 7# $% ' "$!& 0!$7 $* $%

9. ) $" 5# **"

#'6 #)"

$ @ $% "(# !

!$)#'!# $'#.

- !# '* * '#!+ C@6 !$) $ %$! 0#!*$ 5*)$'

16 @6 !$) $ %$! 0#!*$ 5*)$'

16 => % & $!" ( * !# *$ "$ 5#

#7# =9(#"(#! %"#! " 3 1 #7 '#)# $! $"> "( " & 0#!*$ 1 *"

9($ 9 !! " ( * 5## **#' 5& " ( * 5*)$'#' $!

* )$)#

% *$ "( " *)( 9 !! " ) $" 5# #A#)"#'. *)( $!" & 05

*( 9!

""# 0!$) $ !#4 1 ( "$ 00# ! " *0#) #' 0 )# ' "

*0#) #' "

# $"

#** "( "( !"& ' &* %!$ "(# ' "# $% 05

*( 1 *)( $6 => (# 0!$) $ *(

5# 05

*(#' * %$

$9*+ = >= > " *(

5# 05

& !# '

*$# )$*0 )$* 0 )# $% "(# "$9 $!

1# 9( )( *)( 0#!*$ $!'

& !#* '#*I =5> " *(

5# %% A#' "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 !" $% "(# ($*# $! ($#*"# '

9( )( *)( 0#!*$ $!'

& !#* '#* $! "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 )# $% *)( "$9 $! 7

1#I =)> )$0& "(#!#$% *(

5# %% A#' "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 !" $% "(# )$!" ($*#I =

> "(# $!" & *$.

" "( 3* % ". '

!#)" )$0& $% "(# 0!$) $ "$ 5# 05

*(#'

& #9*0 0#! ) !) "(# 0 )# 9( )( *)( 0#!*$ $!'

& !#* '#*6 => *" "##"

1 5& "(# $!"

** 1 "(# 0!$) $ "$ "(# #%%#)" "( " "(# 0!$) $ 9 * ' & 05

*(#' $ *0#) #' ' &.

"(# #! *0#) ) *# = > $% *5*#)"

$ =>. *(

5# )$) * 7# #7 '#)# "( " "(# !#4 !##"* $% "( * #)"

$ ( 7# 5## )$0

#' 9 "(.

' "( " "(# 0!$) $ 9 * 05

*(#' $ *)( ' &6

J=B> G(#!# 0!$) $ 05

*(#' '#! *5*#)"

$ => !#*0#)" $% 0#!*$ ))*#' $% $%%#)# 0 *( 5 # '#! #)"

$* ,. ,B. /B.

/. @. -. -. -B. -:. -/. -. -@. --. B,,. B,. B/. BB-. B:-. $! B/, $% "(# '

# $'# =B: $% @/,>. ' *)( 0#!*$ %

* "$ 00# ! " "(# *0#) #' 0 )# ' "

# !#4 !#' 5& "(# 0!$) $. "(# $!" &. %"#! 3 1 *)( 4 !& * " "( 3* % ". 0!$$)# (

#' $%%#'#! ' 3# '#) ! "

$ "$ "( " #%%#)"6 =:> (# 0!$7 $* $% *5*#)"

$* => ' => *(

& "$ '#) ! "

'# 5& "(# $!" '#! *5*#)"

$ =B> * "(#& 00 & "$ "(# 0!$) 05

*(#' '#! *5*#)"

$ =>6K8 6 $$!'

"# #)( $% "( * $!" 9(

# '#

1 9 "( 7$) "

$% "(# 0!$7 $ $% #)"

!$)#'!#. 1 *" ))*#'

"(# ) *# $% L$ 76 " "# $% !& . ,=> =!

> $ 76 " "# $% !& . ,=> =!

> -;

-;. (# ' * '#!+ C-6 (# #**#"

!#4 !##"* $% *#)"

$ @ $% "(# !666. - %$!

** )# ' 05

$ $% 0!$) $ 1 *" 5*)$'#! '

'#) 1 ( * 0!$)

#' 0#!*$E$%%#'#! & 5# * !

F#' * '#!+ = > !

** )# $% 9 !! " $% !!#*" 5& "(# $!" * * # 4 $ %$!

** )# ' 05

$ $% "(# 0!$) $ ' "(# $!" ( * "$ % !*"

**# 9 !! " $% !!#*" 1 *" "(# 0#!*$ )$)#!#'6 =## $( ! 76 " "# $% # + ,,@ !

6 6 :/>6 =

> (#!# *" 5# !#0$!" 5#%$!# "(# $!" "( " "(# 0#!*$ 1 *" 9($ 9 !! " 9 * **#' ( ' 5*)$'#' $! ( ' 5## )$)#

1 ( % *$ "( "

"(# 9 !! " $% !!#*" )$ ' $" 5# #A#)"#' 1 *" ( $9#7#!. "(# $!"

* $" 5$' "$ " 3# #7 '#)# "( * !#1 !' 5#%$!# ** !$) $ '#! *#)"

$ @=> $% "(# !666. -6 =## $( !

76 " "# $% # + ,,@ !

6 6 :/>6 =

> (# $!" ) $"

**# "(# !$) $ * ""#! $% )$!*# 5#) *# "(# $

)# * *3 1 %$!

"6 (# $!" *" 5# 0!

% ) # * "

*% "( " "(# 0#!*$ ( * 5*)$'#' $!

* )$)#

1 ( % *$ "( " "(# 9 !! "

$% !!#*". 0!#7 $* **#'. ) $" 5# #A#)"#'. '#*0 "# !# *$ 5 #

1#)#6 =## *(' & ("$ ' $"(#!* 76 0#!$! + -B " // ' #7#'#! 1( 76 " "# $% 66 + --B !

2 =

( 5 '

> @>6 = 7> (# !#4 "# ' "# ' 0 )# %$! 00# ! )# *" 5# *0#) "(# $ !#4 1 *)( 0#!*$ "$ 00# ! $ *)( ' "# " "(# *0#) )#6 )( ' "# *" $" 5# #** "( , ) # ! ' &* %!$ "(# ' "# $%

** )# ' 05

$ $% "(# 0!$) $6 =## ! 00 1 '

$"(#!* 76 " "# $% &*$!# + -/- !

2 @/ ' ($3 "

76 " "# $%

!& + ,,=> =

2> ->6 =7> G(#!# "(# 0#!

$' 5#"9## ** )# ' 05

$ $% "(# $ ' "(# *0#) #' ' "# $% (# !

#** "( "( !"& ' &*. "(# ))*#' ) $" 5# '#) !#' 0!$)

#' 0#!*$E$%%#'#! ' "(# $ ( * "$ 5# **#' ' 05

*(#' 1 6 =##

5 1( 1( 76 " "# $% D 5 =H > + ,: =@> =

2> // ' *($3

! 76 " "# $% !& ' $"(#! + , =B> =

2> ::,> =7 > (# !$) $ ( * "$ 5# 05

*(#'

"(# #!

' '$9 *#)"

$ @=> $% "(# !666. -6 $! 05

$ "(# 0!$) $ ( * "$ 5# % !*" 05

& !# '

*$# )$*0 )$* 0 )# $% "(# "$9 $! 7

/ 9( )( "(# ))*#' $!'

& !#* '#*I "(# "(# * # ( * "$ 5# %% A#' "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 !" $% "(# ($*# $! ($#*"# '

9( )( "(# ))*#'

$!'

& !#* '#* $! "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 )# $% *)( "$9 $! 7

1# ' "(#!# %"#! )$0& $% "(# 0!$) $ ( * "$ 5# %% A#' "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 !" $% "(# $!"($*#6 (# "(!## *5) *#* = > =)> *#)"

$ @ =>= > $% "(# !666. - !# )$D)"

7# ' $" '

*D)"

7#.

9( )( # * "( " "(#!# 9$ ' 5# $ 7

' 05

$ $% "(# 0!$) #**

"(# "(!## $'#* $% 05

$ !# 0!$7#'6 =## 9 !

0" 76 (# " "# $% G66 + - !

2 /@>6 G(#!# "(# $!" *$ $!'#!* )$0& $% "(# 0!$) $ ( * "$ 5# ''

& 05

*(#'

#9*0 0#! ) !) "(# 0 )# 9( )( "(# ))*#' $!'

& !#* '#*6 '7 * 5 &. 0!$) $ ( * "$ 5# **#' 9 "( %$! )$0 #* *$ "( " $# # )( $% "(# "(!## )$0 #* $% "(# 0!$) $ & 5# %% A#' "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 !" $% "(# ($*# $! ($#*"# '

9( )( "(# ))*#' $!'

& !#* '#*. "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 )# $% *)( "$9 $! 7

1# ' "$ *$# )$*0 )$* 0 !" $% "(# $!"($*# ' !#0$!" !#1 !'

1 05

$ & 5# '# $ "(# %$!"( )$0& $% "(# 0!$) $6 ''

)$0& 9

5# !#4 !#'

9(#!# "(# 0!$) *$ !#4 !#' "$ 5# 05

*(#'

"(# #9*0 0#!6 =7

> " "##" $% "(# *#!7 1 $%% )#! ( * "$ 5# !#)$!'#' 5& "(# $!" * "$ "(# ' "# ' $'# $% 05

$ $% "(# 0!$) $6 =## ! ' 76 " "#+ -:@ !

2 -/:>6 =7

> (# $!"

** 1 "(# 0!$) $ ( * "$ 3# *" "##"

"* $!'#! "( " "(# 0!$) $ 9 * ' & 05

*(#' $ *0#) ' & #! *0#) *#)"

$ @=>= > $% "(# !666. -6 )( *" "##"

1 5& "(# $!"

* '#) !#' "$ 5# )$) * 7# #7 '#)# "( "

"(# !#4 !##"* $% #)"

$ @ ( 7# 5## )$0

#' 9 "( ' "( " "(# $ 9 * 05

*(#' $ *)( ' &6 =## ! ' 76 " "#+ -:@ !

2 -/:>6 =A > (# )$'

$* *0#) *#)"

$ @=> $% "(# !666. - %$! "(# 05

$ $% !$) $ 1 *" 5*)$'#! !# ' "$!&6 & $)$0

)# "(#!#9 "( ) $" 5# )!#' * M !!#1 "&M ' !#'#!* "(# !$) $ ' 0!$)##'

1* *5*#4#" "(#!#"$

"&6 =## #7#'! 1(

* #5 76 " "# $% 66 ' $"(#!+ --B !

2 @ ' 1( 76 (# " "#+ -:: !

2 @>68 @6

* 0#!"

#" "$ #"

$ "( "

* 5& $9 *#""

#' 0!

) # $%

9 "( " 5#%$!# ** 1 0!$) $ '#! #)"

$ @ !6 66. "(# $!"

*" !#)$!'

"* * "

$ "( " "(# ))*#'. 1 *" 9($ "(# 0!$)

* *$1(" "$ 5# **#'.

* 5*)$'

1 $! )$)#

1 ( % 9 "( "#" "$ #7 '# !!#*"6 * %$' "

!#4 !##"

* )$*0 )$* & 5*#"

"(# 0!#*#" ) *#6 0#!* $% "(# 01#' $!'#! ' "#' 6,6,: !#7# * "( "

$ *)( * "

$ 9 * !#)$!'#' 5& "(# $!" 5# $9. $! 9 * "(#!# & "#!

"$ D*"

%& "(# %#!#)# "( " "(# 0#"

$#! ( ' 5*)$'#' $! 9 * '#

5#! "# & 7$ 1 !!#*"6

-6

(# 0!$7 $* $% #)"

!$)#'!# ( 7 1 *#!

$* !

$* 4 "(# !

1(" $% "(# ))*#' )$)#! 1 ( 0!#*#)# "(# )!

0!$)##'

1* $1(" $" 5# ' ) $" 5#

7$3#'

) * ' ) 7

#! #!6 (# !#4 !##" $% !#)$!'

1 $% * "

$. "( " "(# ))*#' ( * 5*)$'#' $!

* )$)#

1 ( % *$ "( "

9 !! " $% ( * !!#*" ) $" 5# #A#)"#'. * #5$'

#)"

$ @ $% "(# $'# $% !

!$)#'!#.

* "$ 5# *)!0 $* & )$0

#' 9 "( 5 *#' $ !# #7 " "#!

# $ !#)$!' $% "(# ) *# "( " !#1 !'6 $ '(#!#)# "$ * ' !#4 !##" 9(

# '#) 1 "(# ))*#' * 0!$)

0#!*$ 7 "#* "(# 0!$) $ 0!$)##'

1* "#' 1 *" "(# ))*#'6 ,6

#)#. $ *#% 0!0$*# 9$ ' 5# *#!7#' 5& 3##0 1 "(# )!

0!$)##'

1* 0#'

1 1 *" "(# 0#"

$#!6 *. "(#!#%$!#. 00!$0!

"# ) *# %$! "(# #A#!) *# $% 0$9#!* '#! #)"

$ :@ $% E#)"

$ B@ $% !6 66 ' "$ 5!

1 "$ #' "(# )!

0!$)##'

1* "#'

"(#

1(" $% "(# )$0

" ) *# ' 1 *" "(# $#!6 6

7 #9 $% "(# 5$7# % '

1*.

"(# #"

!#"& $% % )"* '

!)*" )#* $% "(# 0!#*#" ) *#. "(# 0!#*#" 0#"

$9#'I ' "(#

01#' $!'#! ' "#' 6,6,: =#A!# -> 0 **#' 5& "(# # !#'

1 *"! "# !*" **.

! . 9(#!#5&. "(# 0#"

$#! ( * 5## '#) !#' * 0!$)

#' 0#!*$ '#! #)"

$ @B=> $% "(# .

)$0

" ) *# $6 //, "

#' C ! D##" 1( 7#!**

!8 * 9#

* "(# $"(#! )$*#4#"

0!$)##'

1* !

1 "(#!#%!$. !# 4 *(#'6

@ 6 #'

1 00

$=*>.

% &. *(

*$ *" ' '

*0$*#' $% ))$!'

&6 = 2 2 2 2> !& ,-.

!& ,-.

!& ,-. , , , ,/ ( 7 G(#"(#! *0# 3 1E!# *$#'+ #*E $ G(#"(#! !#0$!" 5 #+ #*E $