← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/150/2021disposed of

Haryana State Cooperative Supply And Marketing Federation Limited (Hafed) v. M/S United Breweries Ltd And ANR

2021-04-20Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal5 pages

 

      

    

  !!" #

$"!%&" '$$(  )"!%* +""!%  (% %!"

+" $, &,-

. '%!" "/"%" (!   0      

 $, 

, $ 1 2 , 3 0, 



          



 



!3 3,5  3  6 37 3,-53 2 ,5  -  ,, -5  3 #-, !3,-53 3 01 7 -,   8  3 ,9,  #7 1 ::8 3,, ,,,   ;3 ::8 <1  =1  0,>,  =  00  0 ,9,,  ?- 3 0-., ,75  3 7 5,=  @A 633 6 -,3, B 2 7 5,= ,5,  8A

 (, -7 , 3 0, ,  = 3 3 3  ,C-,  =  ,, D-7 ,  3 ,9,, !3 #-, 3 7 B= 3 -,  3 0-    3 , 26 3 3 ,7-  3 0- 3,-53 ,9,  9 ?- 9>  ,, D-7 , 63 3 ,3 B0,

1 3 0  776 !3 3   00,0,  = , -,, 531 !

"  #     $

 %&   ,9,,  3 0     !"#$%&#$  !'  

$!

  , -,, 531 ,   D-5 ,,1 .    E1 , E@ /1 #35,31 :@A88 A

1  3,9> =    3 7 ,9,,   3 0-  , 96 3 0,  3 0 (!%%)#"* $"!#$!

$!

!'$+",!

-& 

  0>  3 ,, 677 9 ==-  3 7, 7 ,9,, 9> 3 7, -7 , 3 0, 63  6F ,= 3   3 ,, 95 -07

 % 1 63  6F  3 ,, 95 -071 3 5,> 677 ,6,  ,,> 0>  3 ,,  3 7, 7

' ,9,,  3 7765 07 , 

$!

 , -,, 531 ,   D-5 ,, -- &,,   E1 , E@ /1 #35,3 !#$ *$! A8E@ :@A88 A *  ",* !,) & !3 7, 7 ,9,,  ,C-  ,6, 3 =  7-, -,   @ , 63     3 ,9, 1 ::8  3 5,, *,7  3 #-,1 ,,5 3 ,9, 01    0971   > 1 -7>  2  3 ,5 -0 3 ,,  3 ,9, !3 = 677 9 , 9> 3 5,, *,7  3 7  3 007 #0 677 9 52  93  - &

#*&(&'!

&$+&

$!

!3 0, 677 00, 9, 3 7, 7 ,9,, 03>77> , 3,-53 2 ,5  -3    -3 07  3 =  677 9 00,0, ,  ,5,  B5  3-7 , =075 3 0751  &  !#$ *$.*!%%)#"* $"!#  "#'!

% $"!#  !'  $+&

$"&,#  ==- 0,-7, ,  9 0,2 9> 93   3 7, 7

( ,9,, 63  6F  3 ,, 95 -07 !3 ,=   7-  27  -7 =7 , ' "* $"!#)#-& &*$"!#/0 (9,>  3,   7  007 9, 3 7, 7 ,9,, -,  8  ,5,  > =, , 7=   ,9,97> , 63 ,5,  3 ?-,  =0>  3 ,9,7 ,9-7 1#$& "% "* $"!#,

 (9,>  93 3 0,  =F  ,= 007. 7-5 9-  7=   ,= 007 -,  A  3 ,9, #7 1 ::8 9, 3 7, 7 ,9,,

 > -3 007 677 9   -3 =,  63 -3 =  3 7, 7 ,9,, =  + &&, !3   ,9,7 !,9-7 377 9 52, 9> %&3 3-7  3 ,9,  #7 1 ::8 "+

"#1!'*!,$, #-'&&, $, 5, 3 77 ,9,7   3   3 ,9,, 677 9 9, 9> 93   C-7 3,  3 ,  23&#)& #-,& $!'

$"!# !3 2-  ,9, 377 9  -3 07 , 07  => 9

) B 9> 3 7 ,9,,  3 7 , 4!#$&#$"!#,4& $! &# 77  9, 3 7, 7 ,9,, , 077> F0 0 %  7, 3   0  3 ,0  7  -,7=1   21 9, 3 7, 7 ,9,,1 63 -3 =  -9?  -3 ,=  3 7, 7 ,9,, => , #  3 ,9, 0,5 => 9 7- 9> 93   3, ,02 7= = 9, 3 7, 7 ,9,, **(* 



+  ,

 

+ -

 .

/ - /33, ,0,97

 .