← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2922/2012allowed

Sushila Devi And ORS v. Kulwant Singh And ORS

2025-09-12Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

   



!

"#$

  %  #&#'

"#$  



 



     

      $ () ** * *

 

  

  

  !

" !

# 

  $ #  %& " '()     " **** * *       

, #      -   ,)

  ""

 '

( + , !

.



(  #

 " //  0

"!

11 2#

!

3 + , # "( "(   ( 

/!61!7%  

  69  (!

"" 

:

(

 0

"  ""

!

""  

 # ( 

  

"#  ;( "(   ,)

 + , !



 #" " 

 ;  , "  # < , )

*

** *)*) * -

 " 

# ( %

 "  (    ,)

 + ,



   , " #!

)    

,

 ( "(  , " 

 

 = &  

 " 

# 

    "

"  

, " *))+ *   .4, ( '

"  Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another ,

-*&.

/ & 01 2!



   ( "(     (   % >30     

            

   

      

              

   

     

 

      

 



      

          

   

         !"#$           

%#  !"&$

   

&'   !"($      



 31)

       

        *           (+,                  





 



  

  

-  

   

 

      

      

 $         .  /

 

         

                *  

 

                     

  



         

      32 

                   (+,         

    (+,          

       



  

         

             

 

        

    * * * * * * 42. )     

 

    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %!

%(

$ 

    

 3!4

%'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3 !&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  



   

 3!!(!((

35 (''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

/ .4, ( '

" 

National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. ,

-*-6  #

  " //!

/-% /1  0

"!

11!

#

  " % 25 "  

?  (  ( 

"@ 2A5  " ( 

   " @ 2'5  "  ,

#  ) ( 

@ 25

 , #  " 

 !

( )!

 !

"  ( #

?  !



 "  @ 2B5 C  " #

"   # ## 



( :,@ #%( )  # ? )    :(

"  % >52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++      

  7  !+++++  

   7 !+++++ 



 

         

      

   7/

0  9 

 





       



   

%  

  



  

   :    

       6                     

     



 

    

   

  

  

   

  ; 

       

          

     

        

  

     

 



   



               

   

*

     

            

  

 

  

     

 

!(+++  7 &++++     7 !(+++  

    

                    



    <              

  

 

 )     

               

  

    

  

   !+,   

) 

 

 



  



  = = = = =

- 59.3)   

  (+,   



 





 / 

  &+

    

 #+,  

 

&+ (+

* 

 

 (+'+

    !(,6   

    

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

 



  

    &+

6  %(,

 

  &+(+

 !+,

 

 (+'+

   

  

 

     59.5.             

          #+#%0> ?  



    59.6. 

          

  0> @ &%/

 59.7  

       

59.87   

        





 

    

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

  

    

  !+,  

A 6 .4, ( '

" 

17/1 # 18 #& 1#'

/.1#9):/:0 ";1#&1/18:1<&< &1/0< ,

6

* 2# " 

*1 81;

/1 &. 1

 1#19* 0<:*&. 1 

  "  (

  (  "  % B216  <

  C  0 8         

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

 *  

D  D  

   



 D     D  D 

 D D  D  

      





 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  



%!! Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D  

   

     

 /  D

%!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

      

           

  

   

    

     

              22  



 

     

       3 /     

 

  

E     

 

       

   

  3 /                

   

            

 

  

      

 23 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

   

* 

       

        

    

                

 C       

     

    6 6    

    

      

  

   

           

   

 24   

    

    

 

   D

  D   C  0 8*  





     

   7 &++++  

  1 ,  



  "   - )   ( ""

  



 " 

 + ,

 )   

"( " 

=7%  (

<

, "" ( ((   + ,

  ) ( # #  " !

  

  !

(  # #

? 

"  (



   , " #!

 ; 

 "

' )*   & 



 ,) .4, ( '

, # :( !

  

  

-

( # "" ) 

 %"

(   " "(   " "  ( % % Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded 

) &"(

=7% C  " =9

17% 2=9 =5 - "   

?  7=

67% 2/- 7= = +

&"(

=6 2/-%65 = 

 /  

")

!6!7% 2=6DD/5 / E B 

1!7% C

B? 

1!7% E '  (

!=!7%  

 =1!7%?



 =1!7%?-

 =1!7%? 018/.

#10:# 

=63=

>

 "&'0:# (  ,) + ,

-=56=

>

#<1#'

"1/&#0 %= %=

> 

63

-56

  #

  

""!

,) .4, ( '

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma 

3 5R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation   % *&.

/ & 01

5=  

 %"

(  

  9  ( " ( #(  #

( 





F   & " '()%  $ -

"  " ( "(   

  

+ ,



   (

#( "  ")

:( + ,

" ,  " ( "(   

 

"" ( 7

 !

   ,)

 + , !



  - ( 7

  " #

,< "" 

+ ,  

 

" 2 5!

# )!

   #   * *

    G 

  < 7% <

I 7$

  , I