← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3563/2016dismissed

Varinder Singh And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

2016-02-23Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal4 pages

  

       

   

 

      

  

  

     

   

  

    !" !#" !$%&'!(!)"* +%,&-!#!.+#"!&/)" !&/'!*"0 !*1+    2

 3



  

  

 !.!"/"/+)!#*4''#/!5!&-6" !#!$!7"/+)+8" !/#.,!48+#.46 .4#/"6  9/"  4)/"4#6  )*.!7"+#  /)  2%)/7/.4,  4)&/'4#  *"+..4'!+8#!7+5!#6+84,,!'!&!:7!**.46(!)".#+(+"/+)"+" !.+*"+8

/!8  4)/"4#6  )*.!7"+#  4)&  #!"#4)*8!#  "+  2%)/7/.4,  +#.+#4"/+)

4)&/'4# 8#+( 4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+) 45!.#!8!##!&" !.#!*!)" 9#/".!"/"/+)



 !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*9!#!4..+/)"!&4*4)/"4#6)*.!7"+#*/) " !  +88/7!  +8  2!&/74,  88/7!#  +8  !4,"   4)&/'4#  &(/)/*"#4"/+)

!"/"/+)!#*+ "+$+/)!&4**%7 +);

=>?4)&.!"/"/+)!#+ ;$+/)!& +) =>?

  !&(/)/*"#4"+# )/+)!##/"+#6 4)&/'4# !:!#7/*/)'

/*  .+9!#*  7+)8!##!&  -6  !7"/+)  ;>@A@ A  +8  " !  %)$4-  2%)/7/.4,

+#.+#4"/+)  7"  =?  9 /7  94*  !:"!)&!&  "+  " !  )/+)  !##/"+#6

4)&/'4#   "#4)*8!##!&  " !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#*  5/&!  )+"/8/74"/+)  &4"!&

  ==<  "+  " !  2%)/7/.4,     !#!48"!#  " !

&(/)/*"#4"+#  )/+)  !##/"+#6  4)&/'4#  5/&!  )+"/8/74"/+)  &4"!& ?

 !:!#7/*/)'" !.+9!#*7+)8!##!&%)&!#" !4-+5!.#+5/*/+)+8,49 +#&!#!&#!"#4)*8!#+8" !7+)"#+,+8+88/7!+8B!*" +)"#+,4)&24,4#/4 #4&/74"/+)  #+'#4((!C  8#+(  2%)/7/.4,  4)&/'4#  "+ /#!7"+#!4," !#5/7!* 4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)9 !

;

==;

 !

9#/".!"/"/+)!#*9!#!"#4)*8!##!&-47D"+ 4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)5/&!

,!""!#&4"!& =    !.!#/+&*.!)" -6" ! 9#/".!"/"/+)!#* /) " ! 2%)/7/.4, 4)&/'4# 94*+#&!#!&"+-!"#!4"!&4*.!#/+&+) &!.%"4"/+) )4%&/"+-$!7"/+)94*#4/*!&9/" #!'4#&"+" !'#4)"+8*74,! +8 >"+" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*48"!##!"#4)*8!#"+" ! &(/)/*"#4"/+)  9 !

  ;

   * +9  74%*!  )+"/7!  94*  /**%!&  +)  ;"+!:.,4/)4*"+9 6#!7+5!#6+8!:7!**.46(!)"(4&!9 !

;

-!)+"!88!7"!&8#+(" !/#*4,4#6



 !9#/".!"/"/+)!#* 45!7,4/(!&.4#/"6+8.46*74,!8+#" ! .+*"+84)/"4#6)*.!7"+#/)2%)/7/.4, +#.+#4"/+)!5!)48"!##!"#4)*8!#"+ 2/)" !   !6*+%' "8+#E%4* /)'" !

+#&!#*.4**!&8+##!7+5!#6+8" !4,,!'!&!:7!**.46(!)"(4&!"+" !(

 !6 45!4,*+ 7,4/(!& .#+(+"/+) "+  #+%..+*" +8 /!84)/"4#6 )*.!7"+#9 /7 /*47"%4,,6)+"!:/*"/)'/)" !

/)4,,6" !6 45!*+%' "8+##!"#4)*8!#8#+( 4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)"+ 2%)/7/.4,

;

 !#/-%)4, 45/)'*!#/+%*,64&5!#"!&"+" !/**%!*/)5+,5!& /)" ! #/'/)4,..,/74"/+)8/,!&-!8+#!/"7 +*!"+#!$!7"" !.,!4+8" !9#/"

 .!"/"/+)!#*-%"&/#!7"!&" !#!*.+)&!)"*)+""+#!7+5!#" !!:7!**.46(!)" (4&!"+" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*%."+<  ;9 !)" !* +974%*!)+"/7!94* /**%!& -6" !#!*.+)&!)"*"+" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*74,,/)'%.+)" !("+ !:.,4/)4*"+9 6" !#!7+5!#6-!)+"!88!7"!&

3!4#)!&7+%)*!,4..!4#/)'8+#" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*5! !(!)",6 *%-(/""!&  " 4"  " !  4)/"4#6  )*.!7"+#*  4..+/)"!&  4,+)'9/"  " !  9#/" .!"/"/+)!#*-%""#4)*8!##!&"+2%)/7/.4, 4)&/'4#  45!-!!) .#+(+"!&"+" !.+*"+8 /!84)/"4#6)*.!7"+# %"" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*&+ )+" 45!4)6.#+(+"/+)4,45!)%!*  "/*8%#" !#*%-(/""!&" 4"+).4#/"6 9/" " !  */(/,4#,6 .,47!&  4)/"4#6 )*.!7"+#* *!#5/)'  /)  " !  2%)/7/.4,

4)&/'4# " !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*9 + 45!4,#!4&6*!#5!&/) " 4"74.47/"6/) 2%)/7/.4, 4)&/'4# 4#!!)"/",!&"+.46 .#+"!7"/+)



 !  847"  #!(4/)*  " 4"  " !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#*  9!#!  +#/'/)4,,6 4..+/)"!&4*4)/"4#6)*.!7"+#*+),6/)" !+88/7!+8" !2!&/74, 88/7!#+8 !4,"   )477+%)"+88+#(4"/+)+82%)/7/.4,

+#.+#4"/+) 4)&/'4# " !&(/)/*"#4"+# )/+)!##/"+#6 &(/)/*"#4"/+)&#49/)'.+9!#*%)&!#" ! .#+5/*/+)*  %)&!#  !7"/+) ;>@A@ A+8" !%)$4-2%)/7/.4, +#.+#4"/+)7"=?9 /7 94* !:"!)&!&  "+  2%)/7/.4,  4)&/'4#   "#4)*8!##!&  " !  9#/"

.!"/"/+)!#*"+2%)/7/.4, +#.+#4"/+)  4)&/'4# 5/&!)+"/8/74"/+)&4"!&  ==<   !#!48"!#  " !  &(/)/*"#4"+#  )/+)  !##/"+#6  &(/)/*"#4"/+)-65/#"%!+8" !4-+5!.#+5/*/+)+8,49#!"#4)*8!##!&" ! .!"/"/+)!#*  "+  4)&/'4#  &(/)/*"#4"/+)  5/&!  ,!""!#  &4"!&  =  

; #!*!)",6  " !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#*  4#!  *!#5/)'  4*  4)/"4#6  )*.!7"+#*  /)

4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)9 !#!" !69!#!+#/'/)4,,64..+/)"!&   !

.!#/+&&%#/)'9 /7 " !6*!#5!&/)2%)/7/.4, 4)&/'4# 94* "#!4"!&4*.!#/+&+)&!.%"4"/+)   !(+(!)"" !69!#!#!"#4)*8!##!&"+

4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)8#+(2%)/7/.4, 4)&/'4# " !6 4#!  -+%)&  -6  " !  !#5/7!  %,!*  4)&  !'%,4"/+)*  +8  &(/)/*"#4"/+) )4%&/"+-$!7"/+) 4*-!!)#/' ",6#4/*!&4*#!'4#&*" ! !:7!**.46(!)"(4&!"+" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*/)*./"!+8" !847"" 4"" !6 4& 4,#!4&6-!!)#!"#4)*8!##!&"+ !/)'!(.,+6!!* +8 4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)" !674))+"7,4/(.#+(+"/+)"+" !.+*" 9 /7  4*)+"4"4,,-!!)7#!4"!&-6" !  !

E%!*"/+)  +8  "#4)*8!##/)'  " !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#*  "+  2%)/7/.4,  +#.+#4"/+)

4)&/'4# 8#+( 4)&/'4# &(/)/*"#4"/+)9 !#!" !6 4&-!!)+#/'/)4,,6 4..+/)"!&74))+"-!!)"!#"4/)!&-6" ! +%#"+83494*)+*%7 ,!'4,#/' "

4*477#%!&"+" !.!"/"/+)!#*

?

 !  #/-%)4,  4*  #/' ",6  #!$!7"!&  " !  7,4/(  +8  " !  9#/" .!"/"/+)!#* !&+)+"8/)&4)6(!#/"/)" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#*4)&" !#!8+#! " !9#/".!"/"/+)*"4)&*&/*(/**!&

 ! " #   4-#%4#6  ! "

%,4"/ #