← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4457/2015allowed

K.B. Gupta v. H.P.G.C.L. & ORS

2015-07-15Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan7 pages



      

   

 

 !"  # $#! %#& '#  #(#"# )* +# ,"         # 

#$-+#+*./ #+" # #.+-0+!+#&*./

##" 1 #+++#*./ ##"  

 !

"# $% &'& +  '#" *!

#.#(

3

+ ! 4 *" #-5!+ 6 +7"!6  ##   

*  .

9!#  :     ##  

 .

9!#: *'+#;& 7!

,*11* <:

 5!( ((7  #7+  !

((69 "&7 7+7 !

  =5!/(  #!& = +; ##;

>+" #+!6+ # +  # !

    !7    ,8 * ?1<:  '++  +  ;  ! !

(#((&    ;#+    "# "(   !#(  @!  ;&  +

#" 

>+;#  +#++" #+ @ +#" :"#7 8 8 3 +#'+( %0=  '++  +  ;  "(     /#!  7" *  + #"  % )  +7" >+" # '++ +#'#-+; "#7+" +

= 6 #.7 $##3 1

*+" #' !;5! (&"" ##*% ) #"# &#

#7+ ###((+ !"#

! '++/# (# %'6# "  !" ##7 "#+,!( 6/#  6+   #/  >+# #*   1

.

9!#:*+0 /# 7 ""#/+9   ./#0"(#@ #"# &# #7+

!7 6++#6 >+7#'"!!"; #+#

## +#"#  ??+ 6/6 7 ??     ??

    ?

 .

9!#  :

*  '++   #  # +77# !7#9:" ""#/( +"#"(;#!6+! +77# !7 #" + " #.77!

 '!+" #/(#   ?

.

9!#:1*7   6++" #+ ; (('+7#7     667 +

0+0.+('7# !7 #" "" 7 0+ 0.+('.

9!#:."" 7 (#



 '++'!0+0.+('

9.

9!#:  >+#7    !+ "" 7 '#!;&+ # ## +#" /##



: >+# #*" #+; ! ##

8 3

1.

9!#:8%./#0"(#@ 6# + "&""(;(## /

# +#:7"(&7 $ +8

7 6 # ## % )* +-!(+( 3 ?

1 .

9!#: *+9:" ""#/(' 6#  #"&+" #'6#  + ## / 1 4  + +" ###   +#' 7#"#  # #!;&+7 #+#+"& +  ; 9   #  /#!  #"#     .  !+*  + #/#  7!

  !6+    ;  # !

   (! 6  ,8 * ?1<:

( 6'++7!

!"##+&6# ;&+ !#A!#+#*# #(;(;!++#/#& 

; ,!( (&*+7  7!

!6+; #/# ,*11* <:((6( +7!

,8 * ?1<:

(#&#/#*;# !

  >+(# !

( !#+#  ++7!

 

;#/#'+! ((' 6"# "( !#(@! !  +'!  6# "# (+# 6* #(  +#6#"( &' (()( # (%

  

" *+,-*.,+ .!+*+## #/#& 6 +" # /( "# "( !#(@! +; /++( 

!  .# 6(&* # #! +"&*+#" !6++/6/

!""#!

& >+#(&* '(((('++7 #/  <!+#+/6 # '+(" 6 ##* +"#!( +7"!6 ##

 :1'!( +'  +  /  +!6+    (  #"(& '  (*  &  ;& :

"- 6  #&"##5!!7 ,*11* <:+;

"'++

! 4;(++  #  # #+7 6 ##@ 6+(7*+7(;(; #( "( & $ (!

/& )(!$0 0

 &  ".112#3%23+ 3 >+(# !

( 

      

  +  +" #+ ## #7#/*+"#7 + #6+#/#+ 7!

  #7  +  "  #&  ;    %  !#+#  !;7  + +#'  (*  !+    #/#&    /  ;&   +  "#  

(7 +#&#  !#+#6 +"#/  ,!(

+!

@;/(0#/,!(""(;(+0

%#& 

  +  +#  + *  +  (#   !

(  #  +

 #"  !;7  +   #  +  ##7     + " #*++; 6/  #!("" 7 ./# 0"(#@*/##  1

%# #,!( 

  ? +!

@;/(0#/,!(*$(:44 +

+ #:7"(&7  &## /*7"(&*+"& ; 9 # '++"#/ 7 +;/ ,!( #:7"(&7 +" #*+"&'  9

# '++;/,!( +'"9(#& ;&   +  7;(  (#&  >+# #*  +  #/#&    /# "&7 (#& 6 6! &   (+#+"+ " # +7"!6 ##

.

9!#:

 ##

 .

9!#: +/; #6+(& ";&+#"  ? 4 +/ +# + (#  !

( # +"#  "#!+##'++#;(  8  

 *+% B;(."9 !#++(!

# :



   !

 "# $% 

!# %  %$ #$&%$%  $% '!   $( $%  !  

  # $%  %   !$$    "  

   !#   %     $%      $ $ )



 *!# %

$$%"" +

+ #!  , - -, -.- #!

 *!# %

$  $% $%       %       !# %

 *!# %

$$%  '!%$

$   '!  #%         !# %

# *!# %!  $%  "

%  / !

 "  "

       !! "%  #   "

      #

"

 % /   &"    +"# *+" #'#:7"(&   #!("*/##



.

9!#:>+ +'! 

.

9!#: *'#/ !" +" # # (" 7#+ +#&#>+ " #+ - '(6++7!

+'; 6" +7'7#+ '++' ( +#7!

#

+; "+" #;&+7" !+#&*+7 

  ;  #/#  >+  7"!6   ##    

.

9!#: +; "'+ +" #+(#& ( +@; #/#*+7!

* "* 9* 

!

 &7#"#  +"# +" #C +"#7 +6# +7!+"&7 *;(/ 6++ " #' ( #+7  >+# #*-" 6 /'+;/*+  "

; 65!#(&/#;&+# ('('

;&+% B;(

 ."9!# '4( (!"##/;((' .# 6(&*+7"!6 ##

.

9!#:

       

  .

9!#  : *  #      >+ #" ### !

+#/#7!

 +# ;  *  &*'+ "# +#7 + #7+

#" # "& +##