← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16352/2023disposed of

Sant Kumar v. General Manager, Northern Indian Railway And ORS.

2024-03-21Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal10 pages

    



!

"

!

#$

!%&'

() !'*+,+(- ..

/%-& 012%3

4'&+&+(-'3

5'3,1,

'-'3%6 %-%7'38 (3&9'3- -:+%-

%+6;%< %-:

(&9'3,

',=(-:'-&,

 

> ?  .

/

 /?



       

 

         !  "  #

$

 %

 &'

%  (

)))

 /?8

.

3%6

*

+         ,,-.,,/      "        0 

  1

      (  

0  (   #   0

,

+   *2 3, *454 $  "  '

# 0 

6  *3 *3 ,3,* #   0  #  #   

    (  +     #    '

# & 0  7   *3 *3 ,3,* +    

  '

# 0  (

       *5 3/ ,3,, 89  5: 

    



0               

43; 

  (0

<

          #     0  

 #        (    (

  + 0      (0     3/ *3 ,3,, 89  2:      43; 

  ( +       #       =(

0> ,3,<    ?

0> ,3,<  #   

 0  +     

     @ 0   @ 0  *4,<   @ *&A:

B          

$

 %

 &'

%  (

  (     #       =(

0> ,3,<    

     9  =(

0> ,3,< +    (0 *4,<              +     

 ' 42<422.   +

0  '

# 0      ,< 3A ,3*4 

  '

#  8B( C B : '

 *4A4 8  D

16',>:

     2  "  '

# 0 @ (   8"'@ :



*  

 '

 22,   *4A4 '

 

    

0   E '  "  "$ 0 B  8 

?>:   (    # >  +  

    *4,<   

0      (          

"   (0 (        %( ,3,* #   #    0   (  #

  +  #       =(

0> ,3,<    ?

0> ,3,<  #   

 0  +    (   

  

 0  #   

    ( 

     *4,< 

-

"      

       (       #   

/

+     #             *4,<   #  

0   

  #      0   (       *4,<     

 *4,<     ₹42<422.    

    ( 

 

+   0     ,< 3A ,3*4 89  '2:   (0 0  '

# 0 #    '

 22,  *4A4 '

   (

 (0     ** *, ,3*5 +

 

 '

            (#  



 

 



      



  



 

 

 

                         

  

  

 

                 





 

   !



  

        "#$

 

 



   % $  &     

        

       

'   



( #  )



'     



%   *       

+&,+-&

    



  .   





' / +

      

     

 .   (  /  +         

 

    

 

  /  * +   

 



(   & 

 +&,+-&

   



 .   



 

' 

 

  . 

  (   &    

   



   +&,+-&

    

       ( 0  

 

   1 2   * $3#0    



         

   



    

 *( 4 5  *+ 

/ *+       

  (6





 !

" 



   #

  (

 '

 22,8<:  *4A4 '

   

      *4,<  

     

  E'""B   (   (0 

    + '

# 0 7            ,4 3A *444     ** *, ,333 8   9  ',       ,- *, ,333:     

 0  C  # 0     (    0 

  (   (0     "   0        #   (   

  0 

  ( +        (# 7- %8 *   

 9  8 ,  



(  

$0:0

;9< 8$$3=3  *2- 5 (>>    ) 1 

     #3(4($333                                          

      

 

    

       

     



            (         

 

 (  #(     

9    

                                

  

  

     

 

    

    

 (  9

    

 .    9 

            

      

 

    ( *        

  

        

   

     

   



(? *3

+           #

 #      (  6   (0  ,3   '   # & (  ,3*- 8  D

*&>:

 ,3     F   (       0  #  (0  0

     0 

(  8A:

  ,3  ,3*-        0  1   (0     (     #      (       "    (     0  0  

0 (    

 0    (  

&         (   

  0    (

 ,3  ,3*-      (# 7#:(5 8 

(  $  5  @                       

% +    @       

                  .       

 ( # ; @                       

   (

0  5                  



  ( 4 5 @       



!

     

% +   

 !

     

    

      

     % + 

         

                           

  

 ( "

   @     

  



  (G H@  

 I **

=      ,3  ,3*-       (0 7          7      ,3*-  +  (0        ,3*-  #

      (0       0     (0 #  

   

 0    #       0 #  (

*,

+         

0             

     *4,<  "        *4,<  #  ,3*-     (   +      (          0    0 #   

0 (     (   

+  0     #   (  0  *4,< 

#

 ,3*-    

     *4,< 

*<

"     #   '

       0  (         0  + '

  (  0 

     '

        '

 22,8<:  *4A4 '

   0 

   ,3*- 

 *4,<      '

   (  +   '

      # (  0   0   #    (           *A

+

     " $"

%!

  

% &

  '    '

 ()  "* +,-./ 0 '' .10  (   '

  '

 #        

0 (  +   9    $      7#=(-  *            

   

  !

 

               

      )   A (*8 2



   ;  B)   A (*8 2



   ;   #::$  = -22 C>C % $ -2;2 3#4D    $4 

 



%-22(C==8 =3 7$4(        



 

       

 

          

     

          ( 2 !



   

                



   8      

   



   



    

     

 

      

   !

 

   

        

 

 

  

 

  

       

    

   

   

 

  

     ( 

 

        - #0

* E   F   



   

  

   

            

   *  (

       !

 

 *2 ;

        ,A@2   

   

        

          

                   

              

       (? #3(

     -  *     

     2

             

   



 

     

         



 !

 



             

 

    

    

  

1



 (   !

 

        

2   )  

2



  

  

 

- *     (?



*2

"  #   (        (0         *4,<  #

  

0    

 0  +   

(  # - #   "  (0       #    

0   

 0          $      

*-

&   ( 

*/

  8:  0 

    

  /?

!

..

G    ,  H,5      H,5