Chandigarh Administration & Anoher v. Central Administrative Tribunal And Another
!
"#$$%&'&()*$+,$-.
/"(0&1"-/0+&(&'#-"#&(#/-21/3$%-$#"-4.$5"-#+$(#02%"#&(. /"(0&1"-/ "(#/$- $#&#&($-'
6$-'2'
$(#-"70+&(&'#-"#&*$-&,2("7./"(0&1"-/ "(#/$- $'5(0$(#'
! "#$% &'()*% & +,' *)) $ ! "#$% &'()*% *) $ ---
-$'$(#) -'/&'/ "8"7.0*%"#$.
-#/$5$#&#&($-' 99999 *) $.& /"(0&1"-/ 0+&(&'#-"#&( /"' &+521($0 #/$ -0$- 0"#$0 :
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
$"55$"-$0&(#/$8-&##$(#$'#"(0'$%2-$0 +"-?'2#&(#/$ +$-&'# %"#$1-4%"(0&0"#$'"(08"'"#3-#/$7&'# %"(0&0"#$' %%-0&(174. -$'5(0$(# <"557&%"(# 8"' %"77$0 - 0%2+$(#' *$-&&%"#&( "(0 02-&(1 #/"# 5-%$''. " 0&'%-$5"(%47&'# 8"' 257"0$0(#/$&%&"78$,'&#$(
@/$++&##$$/"0+"0$ %$-#"&(,'$-*"#&('"(0/$8"'1&*$("(55-#2(#"55$"-,$-$#/$ ++&##$$(A @-'2,+&##&(10%2+$(#'"(02-#/$-*$-&&%"#&(
$'5(0$(# "55$"-$0 ,$-$ #/$ ++&##$$ "(0 '2,+&##$0 %$-#&&%"#$0"#$0 @&''2$0,4#/$ (&*$-'$7/&$#%#$- *$-&&%"#&(#/$'"&00%2+$(#"(0'%-2#&(4#/$"557&%"#&(-+.#/$ ++&##$$2(0#/"#-$'5(0$(#8"'(#$7&1&,7$"'/$8"'*$-"1$ "(0 "%%-0&(174. 8"' +&##$0 &( #/$ 7&'# $7&1&,7$ %"(0&0"#$' /$ "-$+$(#&($00$%&'&(#/$++&##$$8"'&+521($0,4#/$"557&%"(# ,$-$#/$.-$'27#&(1&(#"778&(1#/$ -&1&("7557&%"#&($ 2-#/$-%(#$(0$0#/"##/$&+521($0-0$-&'7&",7$#,$'$#<"'&0$(#/$
/
778&(11-2(0')< &!
/$ /"' $--($2'74 "778$0 #/$ -&1&("7 557&%"#&( ,4 1&*&(1 ,$($&# -$7";"#&( &( "1$ ( #/$ 5-$+&'$ #/"# "557&%"(#<-$'5(0$(# 8"' " 1*$-(+$(# $+574$$D &&!
/$ &+521($0 -0$- &' %(#-"-4 # #/$ "%#' "(0 %&-%2+'#"(%$'#/$%"'$.+2%/7$'''$##7$05-5'&#&(7"8D &&&!
/$C201+$(#-$7&$025(&'(#"557&%",7$##/$"%#' "(0%&-%2+'#"(%$'#/$5-$'$(#%"'$D &*!
$'5(0$(# <"557&%"(# 8"' -&1/#74 0$%7"-$0 &($7&1&,7$ ,$&(1 *$-"1$ "' #/$ "1$ 5-$'%-&,$0 &( #/$ -$%-2&#+$(#(#&%$8"'A4$"-'"(0-$7";"#&(25#A@4$"-' - %"#$1-4%"(0&0"#$'D *!
/$ %"(0&0"#$'. 8/ "-$E8$-$ (# 8-?&(1 8&#/ /"(0&1"-/0+&(&'#-"#&("-$E8$-$$(#$0--$7";"#&(25# A4$"-'8$*$-.&(#/$5-$'$(#%"'$.#/$"1$-$'5(0$(# (#/$0"#$+"?&(1"557&%"#&(8"'AA4$"-'"(0
0"4'"(0"''2%//$8"'*$-"1$(#/$0"#$#/$"557&%"#&( 8&(1##/$"%##/"#/$8"'(#"*$-(+$(#$+574$$"(0 %270(##"?$#/$,$($&#-$7";"#&(&("1$25#A@4$"-' ,$&(1 %"#$1-4%"(0&0"#$D *&!
/$ *$-7?$0 #/$ "0*&'$ 0"#$0 : @
(($;2-$ < 8&#/ #/$ -$574! &''2$0 ,4 #/$ 3$%-$#"-4
$-'(($7./"(0&1"-/ 0+&(&'#-"#&(.8/$-$,4&( #$-+'
27$#/$ 2(C",&*&73$-*&%$' 27$'.F*$-(+$(#G +$"(' /"(0&1"-/ 0+&(&'#-"#&( "(0 #/$ F*$-(+$(#
'$-*"(#G+$"('$+574$$#/$/"(0&1"-/0+&(&'#-"#&(.,2# '&(%$-$'5(0$(#8"'$+574$08&#/B63.8270(#,$ "*$-(+$(#$+574$$"(0.#/$-$-$.#/$&+521($0-0$-&' 7&",7$#,$'$#<"'&0$/$-$7$*"(#5-#&(#/$'"&0+$+ -$"0'#/2')< =
! "
"
#
"
$
#
" " % & $ /"*$ /$"-0 #/$ 7$"-($0 %2('$7 - #/$ 5$#&#&($-'. "55-"&'$0#/$5"5$-,?"(0"-$#/$*&$8#/"##/$-$&'(-%$"(0+$-&# &(#/$'2,+&''&('#/$7$"-($0%2('$7-#/$5$#&#&($-'"(0#/$8-&# 5$#&#&(&'7&",7$##/$0&'+&''$0-#/$778&(1-$"'(')< "!
/$-0$-#/$&',"'$025("55-$%&"#&("%#' "(07"8(#-($-$"'(,2#+"(4D ,!
(%(#-*$-#$0 "%# &' #/"# -$'5(0$(# <"557&%"(# /"0"557&$02(0$-#/$ %"#$1-4"(0/&'0"#$,&-#/&' :$8"'8-?&(1"'
$"%/$-&( 2'&%&(B63"# #/$#&+$%7$"-&(1#/$#$'#-#/$5'# 2'&%!&(
/"(0&1"-/D %!
/$*$-<"77%(#-7&(#/$2(%#&(&(1B63&' &(&'#-4 .*$-(+$(#(0&""(0&#' &(&'#$-&'#/$ /"&-+"(#/$3"(1"#/"(.8/$-$"'#/$$52#4/"&-+"(&'
0
#/$ &(&'#$-3#"#$"(0"(&%$-#/$ &(&'#-42+"(
$'2-%$'$*$75+$(#.'5$%&&$0,4#/$$(#-"7*$-(+$(# - #/&' 52-5'$ &' #/$ 6&%$ /"&-+"( #/$ 3"(1"#/"(. 8/$-$"' #/$-+$+,$-'"-$ "7'"55&(#$0 ,4#/$$(#-"7 *$-(+$(#-+"+(1'#'$(&-&%$-'#/$ &(&'#-4
&("(%$.$$(%$.-?' 2'&(1.$"7#/"(0$5"-#+$(# $-'(($7 "(0 -"&(&(1 $#% /2'. - "77 &(#$(#' "(0 52-5'$'.B63&' "(&('#-2+$(#"7$(#-"7*$-(+$(# "(0&#'$+574$$'"-$"7'$(#$0--$7";"#&("1$&(#/$ %"#$1-4*$-(+$(#'$-*"(#25#A@4$"-'D 0!
$$-$(%$# 27$#/$ 2(C",&*&73$-*&%$ 27$'
8270 (# %+$ # #/$ -$'%2$ #/$ 5$#&#&($-'. -. #/$ %7"''&&%"#&(.8/&%/&'&(#$(0$0#,$5-C$%#$0,$-$#/&' 2-#. &' ( 7(1$-
" &( *&$8 #/$ C201+$(# -$(0$-$0,4#/$&*&'&($(%/#/&'2-#&('
123 ( 3 4455
6 5157&87 98 : ;
5.
<<<***$$&/0 !.8/$-$&("'/$70"'2(0$-)< '(
!
#
)
*
" %
+
"
)
,
! #
+ "
- #
. "
/
+
- "
+ +
#+
#
! #
" #
"
#
0
+ #
. "
#
"
"
#
- # !
$
"
#
)1
!
!
!
!
#
! . 2
),33
4
! 5 ! 4
! +
4
"
" "
"
"
"
#
" "
#6
# "
#7
+8"
! %
. " : 8
# #"
+ ; ""
"
$
- # !
#
"
+8 #
%
# % " +
"
. "
+8"
<
$ "
""
"
#
:
))
+8"
!
+#
+8"
<
%
+
"
!
#
!
! #
="
>
- # !
?))
0
"
!
$ . <
! 7
"
$
.
< - ""
#
$
# #
$ ! +
#
$
+
""
"
!
!
#
+
+8"
! +8"
. "
2 #
?)) # #
!
#
)
:
# +
- # !
! +
%
- #
"
$
#
- #
!
& /$-$ &' ( -%$ &( #/$ '2,+&''&( - "8"7 #/"# -$'5(0$(# <"557&%"(# 8270 (# ,$ %('&0$-$0 "' " *$-(+$(# $+574$$"(0%"((#%7"&+-$7";"#&("1$"(08"'.#/2'.*$-"1$,4A 4$"-'"(0
0"4'/$-$'5(0$(#<"557&%"(#8"'$+574$08&#/B63 8/&%/*$-<"77%(#-7&(#/$2(%#&(&(1&'#/$ &(&'#-42+"(
$'2-%$$*$75+$(#.*$-(+$(#(0&"/$-$-$.-"77&(#$(#'"(0 52-5'$'.B63&'#"?$(#,$"(&('#-2+$(#"7$(#-"7*$-(+$(#"(0 &#'$+574$$'8270.#/$-$-$.,$$(#$0--$7";"#&("1$&(#/$ %"#$1-4 *$-(+$(# '$-*"(# 25# A@ 4$"-' &(&'#-4 2+"(
$'2-%$'$*$75+$(#&'"7'"$(#-"7*$-(+$(#"(0.#/$-$-$.# "''&1(0&$-$(#+$"(&(1##/$0$&(&#&(*$-(+$(#.&(2-*&$8. 8270,$7$1"7742("%%$5#",7$#/&(1##/$%(#-"-4/"',$$(5-02%$0 #-+"0&$-$(#5&(&('"'#/70#/$-0$-#/$2('2'#"&(",7$ '"(25'/#2-,'$-*"#&('.(1-2(0-&(#$-$-$(%$ &'+"0$2# $'27#"(#74.#/$8-$#&#&(&'0&'+&''$0
& +,' *)) $ *) $ &'7=% &'7=%
. 84 5;
;
;
5> 8? 9@
:
+ 5@
;
;
> 82
+ 5@