← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2879/2009dismissed

Huda And ANR. v. Sat Pal And ORS.

2018-02-05Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar24 pages

     !"#  "

"$%&'$'()   *+*(* ,*("$-$./0$(1213&1+*('*(13$ //$..*(14 -$424 *1*.*('*(13$ $4/('$(14

*0) 5!6   !7 $4$(1)  

    

     

      

 *8,&$3*9*1: 



 

  ! 

"

# $ !

$% &  "

'"&

   (" ) "

      

           "      *+*,-**. "/"

 

  " 

 

)  & " 

  

 "

 

 !



 &

  0.*1

 0.+1"



 

2""

"     

 !

"

.3   ! 

"

 .433# $ $% " "

      *+*,-**.            .,*+-**-     "/"

 &  "   &   

5-  6 7  !

 "



&"  "

 8"  /"

) 

  '"

    &  

       &  

   /"   " 

" (85 :+  +  "  "  -4.-.4++  "

;+ *- :**<2    

  .*1         

   



  "

;. -* ,3:<2   

 " -:1        "

   ;  = *. +3:<2                

 

 

 

  & 

   0.*1

  9  "      "      "

  "    

" 

 " 

       



  & &  & &  

      

 "        & &.+1"



  " 



    

  6  7  !

   "  

5-   "

.3#.%    &  -=*,.44."

5-  "

;> 3. 3+:<2 "

 &&

9 

 " 

"

0.*1  "

 ;>3 .34<2&    

 "

   9   &  "



5-" "

 " 



&0.+1"



     

5-"   .-...44."

.3#-%

 "

;= .+ +..,-<2 "

"    &

 .>*-.44- & "



.3#-%  "

;3 ,- ->=>-<2  "

 &

  "& 

  

"

.3#,%   

  ->*3.44-"  

    "

 ;3 >= -3+:><2 "   

"

.3#>%  .=*4.44- ""

  ;+ :, .:+>.<2  "

    ?

  "    "

"

  & &    .+1  "



   "

" 

     @ "

  ?    

 &"

 2 2 

 !

 " &  

   2   (8 /"  

<& 

 2      

 

"  

  "

)   &     .+1  "

  

       

 !

& 





 3

 !

&

 " "

.3 "

;

 ->..-*** & 2"

.3#>%    9     



5-   ? "

   

  

    &; 

5-

  & "

.3#>%  .**.-**.    "

 "

 &;,.>3 

 !

      &    ?  "

   "

 &   

  

"  "

  !

   

& " "& 



  

 !

 "

;= ,: ***<2  -:19

" 

    "

"  .*1

 "   



"   



 " " &  



" &

     

5- "   *+*,-**. &       

      "



 .3#:%      !

              !

  "             &       .,*+-**-  

    ?  ( "

.+ 

5 -"  ,..*-**- 

   "

    (8  ,* 6  

 "  " "



" !

  &  

     !

  " .+#.%#%   "       

5-"  "

.+ #-% .=.--**-)

    

->"  "  

5- 

  ""

 "

 &  

 "   .+1"



 ) "

"

 ;" ;&"

 !

           

    

&   "  "/"

   !

 "

  &"

 

 !





 '   

'" "  :* !

   

   

 

  "  *+*,-**.  .*1        "

      

   

  ;" ;&"  !

  

 

  /"  (

 " 

  "

(75:+ +  " 

  -:1 "

   

    3:1"



 " & 

 9       

  

           !

  



 &

  



< 

   

     6 7&  "  

  "

     



 & A2  

   

 

 



 

 



   

 

   



      

      

 

   

         

 



 

 

 

            

     &

  "

  

  "

    & " .*1   &       &;= ,: ***<2    -:1





   &  " " "  



 

 !

  &     ("  "& A2



       !"           "  !

#  "  !!#  $%    &" '  ( )&      

"  $ * ""++""   ", !- + .##  " /" + ( )&&##,#'" ##" " #$#$  0122 

      +""    "#   ,"#% 3" "

#" " % "  "#     ,  3  ! " " 0122 

    """$#"  ! "+012) 

 4  "+ .#. 

$ "/"+ ( )&&012)  5#+6

               ("  " 

B "

("  

                 & & .+1 "



 5;" &"&       ("     "

      &                  $

"("  

 

  



 & .*1

 

B &  "

("   B2. !   7  !

 ? 



& &.+1 



 ;" ;&"  !

"

 & !

 & &.+1"



  B &  '



'" "  :*  ("    "



       '" ((" 

  "

     '   ("  && & '"&

 

  (" 

 ("   

B&"  (" 

  &"

   + #%  



 .+1"



 

"



 

  "#%'  (" &  &  & &      & 

  .*1

  

B  &  &"

  ("   ("C  



    



&" .*1

"

 8"    ("   '"&

  $ " ("



  

 & "



 0.+1  ("  &"



   &

   ("  "  '"&

<

"   "  "

"

 

& &.*1

  



 &  "  

  & 

     

  "   &"



<

  &    (" &&& '"&

 

 !

 

         " !

 (" '"&

  -:*>-*..    

   $ " (" & '"&

 ("     $ " ("  & .#&!!# +   '"&

 ("  

 ("          $  "  ("       

   *=*+-**4  (" "

 /"      "

 /"        

   ("   "

 /" )  &    

 (" 

  & "              

&    

     ("    "  "

  "

 /" A2

  4  "+ .#.  $ "    +  /"    +     (%"  $"

)#!"&  %&' 

B  &" &         "

    

<

    "

           

 "

.3  "

    "  "

9 " &"

   7  "



   :*  (" "

    "

  "

 

   '" ( ("  ?" :*  "

  

 "

"  ("     !"# $  % &  '$$ 

 ()  .3*4-**4   &

     ("

 & 

< 

"



 !

   &  & " 

"

  &  .+1 "



      "



   "

5- ?  "

   "  " &"   "



       "         

   "

  &   &  

 "

 

 

D "

&" 

  && &  "

 "  "

"& &   

  &       

D "

&"  "

.3 #,%  

   "/"

 &"

.3#>% .+      "  ;& &

'"&

"  "

 

    "



< 

"



   

"  "   "

  

   "

"

  

 "

""

 "

B 

   " 







;= ,: ***<2 



          "       

  "

           

     & &    "

 " &   

 "

 &&

   & 

       

" "

"    

"              "

    

   "

 &    &       "

  "   "

/"  ("    & 

<

 ((" & 

  "  '"&

 ("   "  & "

   "      ("   



  &"

        "

      

<

  &    "

/"                        

    )

  .: .3 :*   .433 " A2 *"  + $,-    

9 "

""%+"%"

+ " $:

" 

##$! &  %"

"" %$!$%, #"

 

"#        $ $

  $   .

 $

   $ $-/  

"%"

+; + #"  !%"  +  "%   "

"  "%'    "% "

#"'" "+  #+"%#" $ #",'    $ '   "  "  '     <  1++  %  $%  "  "  -",'  ##  !"    "

+

- - "!+ % % '- %!"#%-  '

##=$* #>"

!"+  " + "

+'$" !  !"  &+"

",  '+"%'

-"

$% "

+"+,",  "$# !! "%+$", " ' <  1++%'+ "

$"-",'

;"! ", !"#%"    "+"% #",-  !"#%

## $!$% "

+- " ! % $ !+"   ?+ "

++# !%  "  , -  !"#%""-  

     "  / $:

"  '    .   $ +"%  ""+ #' <  1++  %'  $%  "  "  -",'  ##  !"    "

+

- - "!+ % % '- %" +  !" + #"  $ #",'$ '   %$'"++ +  - #"%!+ "%'+"%'!"

 ! +-  "" 

## "! "+ # "+ "

""%'

" "   !%$#" !+  # + #"$ #",'$ '

 #"$ &+"

",  '+"%'

-"

$% "

+"!

"+" " $:

"""%"  %! "

!!  +       "  +  ,",      "$#!! "%+$", " '

 < 1++'%+ "

$"

-",';" ", #"$ #",   $ '          %  $'  "  ",    ++  !" $:

"+ - # "%!+ "%!" !+  # &"%! ",,$%"+  < 1++ " "  "   "

%'- "!+ %% + +   ""      +   '  !+  "

!!# .

+&" " +" ""' %$! $ 2      .

+ &"    % ""     !!#  +      !%  +      !  +   %  % '  +       +       !!##"  -  !"  $%  ++"     + +#", !!#"    9    .

+  &"   %'  +

",     !!#'  "+'  %         !!#+"%!

   

;

 +  9 .

+&" %' " 

-""""!!#"" 

$ #+'"%- "!+  "

 + + '##+ +"% !", "-   < 1++  !

 "+ ! ! +  +%",  #+   #,?%!!%+ "%!

"#"    ";

+6 2  .

+&" 

##" !

" "   "!4 #"% ! "-  ,",  "$#!! "% +$",  = &"% ! "  ,,  $% "    + .

+  &"   "   $:

"    % - " ! +""%% +  +   ""      +   '  !+    "  !"       /%    @""'

(%"'9-"". "%2#""",)!"' " +""" %$! $6 2        /%    @""'

(%"'9-"". "%2#""",)!"' %""  "!"+  !%+   !+""%% '+    +   !"- !"$% ++" + +#",  "!""   9 /%@""(%"'

9-"". "%2#""",)!"'%'+

",  "'"+'%   !!#+"%!

  

+ 2        /%    @""'

(%"'9-"". "%2#""",)!"'

##"!

" "   "-  

", ! >8

 

   -/0+ 1  $      .  $ 

  $ +

-/  /  -  !

#%!"  &'%!

"

$%  /@""!

"

$%  &  % ++ "  &

##$ +"#"

##"$*  """%   #,#!",  # 

## 4  " """% !", " !+"%  ,"A"+-  "$;""  ! +$%"%  %!-$%  &   # , #"

  "8 5"

 

((" 

  " 

 & & "

"

 !

/" & @  



  "

        

  '" ((" ?") (" 

 '"  ((" ?" "

 '"

    (  ("    "&     ?"     )     "   ?" '" 

((" " & " (" ;   & " '"&

  $ "("

  "  +#34 55   ,  21 '   $ "("  4 (( ' " ((" "

 

  '" " ? ?"   

 ?" '"

    "

"  '"&

  5 "3

< #6

+.



   $7(

8 &    $'"&   $ "("     /" ??" '" (("

  "

"& B '" ((" "& ?"

 

 &  8"  

"

    

 

 "

   /" ?"  '" ("    "

   &     "     "

     "



 '" " '" (("   C 

& ) 

:* 

     " #-% !



 ((" 

  &" & & 

  & &         "

    /"     & @   "2 #.% :*    

              E 

   

 !

"

 " :*#-% !

  '" (("      "

     B    ?"      "2  

  ("  (("              "

 &      "                

" ((" ! D 

  "

)  "



 & ((" "'   &

"2 #.% :* 9

 " :*#.%  

   " 

 !

"

 ""

 &      "

) ? ?" '" ("  9    ?" '"          (" )        (  (" )          :*#.%   "    "&  "2 #%

    " 

"

   !  ?"

'" " 

"

 

 '"  "

 ("  

   ("   "   $ "("       

  

 "

 '"  ?"    

 !

"

"" 

'" ("  " (("  "&   /" ("      

 "   "

  ?   "   

  !

  "

            "   

 !

"



   

 !

"

         &     

 "

      "  

   5    & "       ) "

 ("  "& ) &"")?" &            ?" &          

 &         

 "

 

  ("  "         ("         "      

 "    "    "

9

 "   "

     &    ("  

&                "

      @                &    

 "

)   &   &    7 

 ("     ("

   '"    ) "

   

  ("

   

  ("   

  &"       &        &    "&& 

<

 !



 &.+1"





"  

 

 7 

  

? 



 "    ;" ;&"   



"

 & !

 &"



 0.+1 2""

9    

 !

    

 

 

 

  



" "





& &  

  0.+1  "

  

                 

<

  & "

 

<

  

  

    

 "

-*

  ""

&"& 

)         /"     ("    "       " & 

 "

.3

  

  "& 

"& "  "

.3   & & "

  

&

 & .:    .:

    

      "

     "

 ;&"      

<

     

    &  .+1 "



  " "

"

    &"   



"

; 

   $  "  ("  

  

        & 

 !



  &

 0.*1      & .3    "

"

  

 !

 6 & &  " &"



.3   



  " &  -=*,.44."

.3#.% !

    "

.3#-%  " .-...44.   "

 "" 

 & "   "

.3#-%

 !

 .>*-.44-     "& 

 

 "

.3#,%  ..*:.44-  

  & " "



.3#,%  

<

     "

.3#,%

 "" 

 

6  " "

.3#,%  

   5       

 

" "

.3#>%  ) "  " *..-.44-    

<

 " &  "    &9   

 

 "  "

 

&

"    5"     "

 

"

        

<

    

     "    " " &"

"

        &   &     "

    

 !

  &            " &      

      &" "



.3#.% ) "

 & "  .3#>%  ->..-*** & 

.**.-**."   "



   &     &

  

  





   "

.3#>% !

 ->..-*** /" 



  &   "

"

 && 

  

7 "/" 

 6?A24 -3.--***    "  "

  

  & "

.3#>%   .**.-**.)  & "

; ,.>3 & ?

 "  "



 .3#>%      !

    6?A2.*              .44-""

.3#-% F#,%   

     -***      "



&  .44-

   

"  '" "

.3#>%    -*** -**.  ""

.3#.% .3#-% .3#,% " .44. .44-

   

 " 6?A23 -.*..44,& & 



 -:1 "

 &"

9 )  &" &

 -**."

.3#>%    "

 " 

"

.3#.% .3#-%  .3#,%  & " " " +)          " 2  

 

+ "  

 

"  & & -:1 " "

 

9 " "  



  

  

           "         

/" "

"  /"    & .3#.% 

 ""     "   

   /"  "

 " & 

< 

  

 

<

  " "

"

 

  &  "  

5-  " 

   

  "    "6  "

       ?      "       &    

 



  &     &     

            &

  

  &   

   "

  "

"&

   !

  "

;= *. +3:<2 

"

;,.>39  "    



 

"

  "

/"   ("   ((" & 

  "  

< 

 (("  '" 

  "       &    '"&

     "  

   

    

   $ "(" ?" '" ("    "



 '""



  

           

<  

  "

   "

  /"   "

      &  

     &   

   6?



& ""

 )  "

 " 

<



& &  

)  

   



"

      "

&  " "

 )   "



  '""  "

       (" "



      "'""



  

 '"&

 2   ("     



  &"    "  "

 

9  "



      & 

"

 "&  "    "



  

?" '" ( (" )            "  "

   

   -:1 

   "

;= ,: ***<2 "

  "

 "

'   " 



9  

 

 



     -:1  & "

3:1 ;= *. +3:<2

" 

;

  &  "/"

  ;= ,: ***<2 

   "

 "

 ""  "

 

  & 







"



 0.+1    

 .+1"

 

  "   (" "

"

     ;";&"  !

 & 



0.+1   

 " & 

  "

 '" (("  ?"     "

/"  "  "

< 

& 

<

) '" (  ("       &        "

"

:* (("  & 

  "    &   " 

 5 &"

 "

      

   &   13 $,2*+: = !7> 3&-*(&?*243&@  "

  !;",  " B

 5!$# B