High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3716/2016dismissed

Bhajan Lal v. Permanent Lok Adalat (Pus) And Others

2017-12-12Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)!*!'+!, #"%"%'#- .& #-/!'#'" +0 1!,!" 234 ,1 %&"-%$" 5-" /6,#74 !8!- 9)!,%!'1")#-& #&6'1#'"& 9( 9( 9( 9(:

+9 ;;9 :

+9 ;;9 -#&#'"( 9-!-#'1#-%'8);!/<*41=$!"#4

-")#6#"%"%'#- ;;9 4 2+3 ;;9 4 2+3 ;;9 4 2+3 ;;9 4 2+3 )# 6#"%"%'#- )!& $)!,,#'8#1 ")# -1#- 1!"#1 ? 6!&&#1<@")##-/!'#'"+01!,!"234!8!-9)!,%A)#-#%'! "#- -# #--#1 " !& B")# +0 1!,!":C <@ D)%$) !' !66,%$!"%' %,#1 <@ ")# 6#"%"%'#- 5'1#- #$"%'

")# +#8!, #-=%$#& 5")-%"%#& $"4 EF -&)-"B")#$":C)!&<##'1%&/%&&#1 )#&' ")#6#"%"%'#-8"!1/%&&%'%' #$) &"@#!-%'")#

!<! -56 ,,#8#&4 9)!,% !/65&4 .%,,!8# )!"!5-4 ;)!-!- '

F >!'11#6&%"#1 4G"D!-1& ##!8!%'&"-#$#%6"

)# &' ")# 6#"%"%'#- )!1 !,& !66,%#1 - !1/%&&%' %' ")# #$)',8%$!, '&"%"5"# #7"%,#!'1$%#'$#&,,#8#!" )%D!'%' > >D)#-#%' )#8"")#!1/%&&%')#6#"%"%'#-)!1!,,#8#1,@/!1#!'!66,%$!"%''

> " -#&6'1#'" " D%")1-!D ")# !1/%&&%' )%& &' !'1 -# ###!,&8!=#-#/%'1#-' >!'1")#-#!

"#-&#-=#1!

,#8!, '"%$# '

> !'1 D)#' ")# -#&6'1#'"& 1%1 '" -#6,@4 ")# 6#"%"%'#- %,#1")#!66,%$!"%'<# -#")#+01!,!"5'1#-#$"%'

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

-/%'8-#&6'1#'" !<5"%"&1#$%&%'"D%")1-!D -/")#$5-&# !'1-#I5#&"#1 --# ")# ## +#!-'#1$5'&#, --#&6'1#'"& J)!&&5</%""#1")!" ")#6!-"%#&!-#<5'1<@")#85%1#,%'#&%&&5#1<@")#,,'1%!5'$%, - #$)'%$!,15$!"%'D)%$)!-#!,&!66#'1#1<@")#6#"%"%'#-!&''#75-# %' D)%$) %" %& 6-=%1#1 ")!" K%' ")# #=#'" ! &"51#'"G$!'1%1!"# D%")1-!D%'8 <# -# ")# &"!-"%'8 ")# $5-&#&4 ")# D!%" ,%&"#1 $!'1%1!"#& &)5,1<#8%=#'!1/%&&%'!8!%'&"")#=!$!'"&#!")##'"%-# ##$,,#$"#1

-/")#&"51#'"4!

"#-!1#15$"%' ")#6-$#&&%'8 ## '"/-#")!'

& G256##&'#")5&!'1',@34&)!,,<#-# 5'1#1!'1-#"5-'#1<@")# %'&"%"5"%'"")#&"51#'"G$!'1%1!"#D%")1-!D%'8 -/")#6-8-!//#L )# $!&# ")# -#&6'1#'"& %' ")#%- -#6,@ %& ")!" ")# &' 6#"%"%'#- )!1 !$"5!,,@ !""#'1#1 ")# $,!&&#& ! "#- ")# $5-&# )!1 &"!-"#1 $$-1%'8 " ")#/ )# )!1 !""#'1#1 ")# $,!&&#& -/

> "

>"%,,)#!$"5!,,@8"!1/%&&%'%'")#'&"%"5"#!" )%D!'%"%& ")#-# -#4 &5</%""#1 ")!" '$# ")# &' ")# 6#"%"%'#- )!1 !""#'1#1 ")# $,!&&#&4")#-# -#4)#%&'"#'"%",#1 --# ")# ## +#!-'#1 $5'&#, - ")# 6#"%"%'#- )!& ")58) 1#'%#1 ")!" )%& &')!&!""#'1#1")#$,!&&#&<5"%"%&',@!'-!,&"!"#/#'"

#")!"!&%"/!@4")# !$"-#/!%'&")!"")#-#!-#'#7!$"$6@ ")#1$5/#'"''#75-# <#$!5&#%''# ")#$6@")#-#%&'1!"# D)%$) D!& !""!$)#1 !& 7 D)#-#!& %' ")# ")#- $6@ ")#-# %& ! 1!"# /#'"%'#1 D)%$) D!& !""!$)#1 !& ''#75-# )# +0 1!,!" )!& -%8)",@'"<#,%#=#1")#1$5/#'""#'1#-#1!&7 <#$!5&#%"1%1'"<#!- !'@1!"#'D)%$)")#!66,%$!"%'D!& %,#1 ")#!66,%$!"%'%&&5</%""#1 <# -#")#$5-&#!'1")#&' 6#"%"%'#-)!1'"!""#'1#1")#$5-&#")#' 1# %'%"#,@ )# D5,1 )!=# <##' #'"%",#1 - -# 5'1 ")# ## <5" % ")# !66,%$!"%' )!1 <##' &5</%""#1 !

"#- ")# $5-&# )!1 &"!-"#1 %#

> !'1")#&' ")#6#"%"%'#-)!1!,&!""#'1#1")#$5-&##=#' -!1!@")#' )#D5,1'"<##'"%",#1 --# ")# ##%'"#-/& ")#6-=%&%'& ")#85%1#,%'#&!&/#'"%'#1)#-#%'!<=# )##=%1#'$#%&!8!%'&"")#6#"%"%'#-<#$!5&#")#$5-&#&"!-"#1 '

>!'1")#-#&6'1#'"&)!1!,,#8#1")!"")#&' ")#6#"%"%'#-

> !""#'1#1")#$,!&&#& -/

>!'1")#"D!66,%$!"%'& &5</%""#1<@")#6#"%"%'#-!&7 !'1''#75-# !-#'"")#&!/# '=%#D ")#!<=#4")#-#%&)!-1,@!'@-#!&' -")%&5-"" %'"#- #-#%'")%&6#"%"%'!'1!&&5$)")#&!/#%&)#-#<@1%&/%&&#1 2;;9 3 2;;9 3 2;;9 3 2;;9 3

)#")#-&6#!0%'8G-#!&'#1 #&G )#")#--#6-"!<,# #&G