← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/458/2015dismissed

Rajeev Rana And ORS v. Chandigarh Administration Etc

2024-12-19Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal9 pages



    

 !"#$#$

! %!& !"#$$  

    

 



  '"  ()'

$ *

 ))  ()'

$ *+, ' )      

   

  !

   "

     "

#$%  

&&&& +, ' )-  '  (   ! )  *  + "

 "  " 

, !

 



#

   -  "        "

 

 .! ! 



 !   / '012

 03#4   

  !!!   .

+  "

 5

  !

,

'23'63'0( - #''*

5 "



".!!    6     .+

 

 

 / 0 (78 ) * 

  !   / '012

 03#4  

( "

"

9

  :* 

! 61'3633;"

 "'

<;

333,# 

   .    " 0< =3 333,#   

 6=>

!

-2- ,     ! -    

.!?=>

  !.   

<3+

!+

.!  "'

0;

=3 333,# !   @ 

"

!

!!

 613'633<( - #6*  1   / '3

 !

 + 

.-  

13+"





"A

  / ''



   

 

  "'= +"



 "-  

+  !'0

.! 

!  

31+ "



 "! + "  "!

!!

! 3= 

+

!

+ "- "" 

 !

0  + - 6?36633<( - #1*   3=31633<   / 0

+

!.! +

++8 "    !

 = 7

 -

+      



 !  .



/ 0@ .



 



""!  

 / 0  



  



!+   !    '03163'6 ( - #0* .

.+





@"



633= !+

 

!

 !

'230633<( - #=* .

  / 0 B / ?

/!

7

! C !  2



/ 618

  .  

!

 !.

-3-   !+

 !! !!

 

   / 0   !

( - #2* .

 

.

  .

   / 0  !  ( - #?* ! .

"

  " 

 .!

  %  



 6'3163'6 ( -  #;*

  

 .! ! 

 .  .+ !!

 C 

 

   .

 

/ 0

 

! 

? $

   

   "!.+

    623?63'1( - #'* 



""!

  

  .

  .+ "!!+ 

  ! .    "!!

# 

."



  

  !. "

""!





/ 0 !! ;  

 "

       6=3<63'1( - #<* .+

""!

/ 0 5 

!+"

 +!

  ! !+ 



 

 

  

 

! . !

 "

      '23'63'0( - #'3*

.!!.

.+

 



 

!!





  "



  !



 

  -  <     363<63'0 ( -  #''*    .+

. '<''63'0

""! 

-4-

  

  !.!

+- " "'=3063'6@

 !  . 

     +  '2'663'1( - #'6* '3  .  .+

@

   .

.+

""!  / '

1   . 



+ " !,   



'<''63'0 

. 

. 8 

  5  "  "!!

!   @ .

 +!

   

'230633<.

 

8.+

 

  @ "

.

 

  .+

 C  

 623?63'1     .

 .+

 !!

 '2'663'1

   '230633<

.! 

 .

 

 31 +   -  "  .! " '23063'6 ''  / 0"!

  





-  "13> 

  @ . 

  !

! 

.!! ! 

 

 5    8 

! 

 ! C  

 

 "   "!

  

"!"!"" ."

""!

+ 

. !

 @ "

. 

 . '2'663'1  - "  .! '6 D !"



   

-5- '1 @   .

 .+

    ! 

!

   '2'663'1  

 .+

 4 

     - "  .! "'=3063'6@  "

.

.+! 

!

  

"!



.



'2'663'1@"



 8

 

 

 .+ "!  

         !+  

 .+



  

 '2'663'1D 

! "

 



 !

613'633<( - #6*

+ - .





! !

 !

  ! ''  ! '0     .

 " 31 +  "

.!

  !

"





   !!+

  "

 '2'663'1 D 

! 

 !+  

 

 

-  +!!! .

+

"

 

.  '0  

     ! !

 .

    !!! + 

 " -  + "



 D ! "

 ! '0

!!

 !



 

!  

31+ "



  "   @   .

"     '230633<

"

31+  - '=3063'6 D ! .

 C  

 

 

- 

!  

 !!

  !

 

! .

-6- .

.+

!

  

 !

D ! "

.



" . '230633<

 # 

  " .

! 

   +     - 

     "

31+ "

- +

 





!. !! 

 

-  + '= B 

. .+! !"



 '2  "    

    %        !!

  !!

 !

613'633<

.

  . 

   %

! !  "

       !

/ '012

 03#4   

   11; 5  +   '

<;

333,#%  !  !+  !''

 !

+



 !.

!!

 

 '= + "



  " -

  + !'6 

.!

 !.





.!!!'1!+

 "





! ! .  

 ! '0  

 

.!

 !. !  

31+ "



 "! +

"      ! '' @  !   

  !!

 "!

!

 .! 



 "

  ! ! .  



 +

!

 .! 



 -  3= +  + !

+"

!E           .$/0

1 ! 23/ 134%&31 !51667/4! 3 3/ 466 33513/1!48 2 93/43 2:&%31 !; <1 431 ! 2 2  !

84!&513/3/ 310%6430 1 9!31 !1!&64% 47 $

-7- $/7%161!< !3/ 13 /4667& !

%&31!4&& 4!&513/ 3/ 7%161!< 064!

- 5/1&/ 9% 3 & !2 9 3  3/ 401346 2 %!=47 > 6 09!3 4! <%6431 !? %161!< %6  #- 4! 3/ 0

1 !

 2 49& !3 64! &/13&3% 46 !3 64!3/@ !1!< 64!>5/  40061&476?$ A$ 2 4<9!3431 ! 23/ 13 4946<49431 ! 23/ 13 /4667 0 9133$ $/ &31 ! 23/7%161!< !3/*131!4&& 4!&513/3/ 401346 2 %!=47> 6 09!34! <%6431 !?%161!< %6 # /466 /4  3  7 & 9063 513/1! 3/  84

 2 9 3/ 43 2 61 8 2

1 ! 4  0  64%  $ / 43 2 & 90631 ! 5166 7 3/ 43 2

&103 240061&431 !2 0

1 !3  &&%083/7%161!<1!

94! >!!:% 3 401346 2 %!=47> 6 09!34! <%6431 !?%161!<

%6  #? 4&& 904!1 78 & 90631 ! & 3121&43 2 9 3/ <1 3  ; B%46121  &/13&3 5/  %0

 3/ & !

%&31 ! 2 3/ 7%161!<-

13/7%161!<1 46 & 31213 /4 7!& 90634&& 1!<3 

4!&31 !064!783//1291!1 1!4&& 4!&513/3/401346 2 %!=47> 6 09!34! <%6431 !?%161!< %6 #$/466 33 5/ 2416 3 & 90633/7%161!<513/1!3/42 4131961913 /4667 <1 !4! 3/  00 3%!1383 & 90633/7%161!<513/1!!:321 84

 ! 3/0489!3 20!46384 %! " >1? 384 >78 !3/ 410 1  23/ 84

?CD 23 346 & !

1 431 !9 !8 23/ 13$ >11?!84 >78 !3/ 410 1  23/ 84

?CD 23 346 & !

1 431 !9 !8 23/ 13$ >111?A 84 >78 !3/ 410 1  23/ 84

?CD 23 346 & !

1 431 !9 !8 23/ 13$ >1 ?3/84 >78 !3/ 410 1  23/ 84

?CD 23 346 & !

1 431 !9 !8 23/ 13$ > 1? 3/ 84  >78 ! 3/ 41 0 1  2 3/  84

? AD 23 346& !

1 431 !9 !8 23/ 13$  2% 3/ 3195/43 /4667< 4!32 3/0% 4!1! 3/42 410 1 -3/ 343 221& 1!131430 &1!< %! *&31 !  23/&34!3/466 33 /466/4 ! &64193 4!8494< $ '? 

+  -

3=31633< ( - #1* 

!+

"   '230633<%  

8  " .

  





- 

 



-8-

 

%  "31+ 

"

 '=3063'6/  .

 !   '2'663'1 

    .+  

  4

 

!   

     C 

   " 

     !+.   '2'663'1

 



!  



 

!

 - !2!;

 

F ! 633? ( "

"



9633?!:*  ! "    3=3;63'0 ( -  #'*     

 .

 "

!.

 

3?

8+

-

+ !..

8 +!

  

3?+

 

"  

8 



3?+

!+ !.

. .!



D !"

 ! !

   

!+ ';   

 

 

 7

 +

 ."





  603'63'?

! 



.

! "- "

.+.!.+

E .)1 32 2% 3/ 4 <%9!3  !$$E$ / 0 !!3 /466 400  3/  % 3 47 %3 3/ 3 346 49 %!3 2:3!

1 !2 3433 7048476783/03131 !

$F '< "

 6=3063'?

  !!       .+ ! !

  

 -  " +.!.+

 16 ;;

;<2,#D !

 

"

 



8

E

-9- . %!

6 2  3/  91!1 431 ! /4  /4!  4 &46&%6431 ! /346 !<513/!5 3 2 %6 -4&& 1!<3 5/1&/3/ :3!

1 !2048476783/03131 ! 1

$A--#G; )4 ! & %!

6 2  3/ 03131 ! H  319 3  /4  1!

%&31 !

$  = % !3 G$$E$F 63 "

'63663';!

! 

!

 +"





8

E .)4 ! *!1  & %!

6 2  3/ 03131 !

 0  2  9  3193  H1!

%&31 !

4 3 5/3/ 3/03131 ! 1 0 04 3  94H3/0489!3 2:3!

1 !2 2IA--#G; ! 31!3  2

43$$E$ = % !3 E$A$F 6' "



8"

    



  

 !

+

 

   3=3;63'0 ( -  #'* 

  

 "

 

 !

 !!! +

   -  " .+ 

 "

 '=3063'6  "- + "31+ "

'230633< 

" 

"  B 

"

"+ 

 " 



    

"

 "



 .   "    

!+ >

 ))?  >+, ' )?      #$$