State Bank Of Patiala v. Commissioner Of Income Tax And ANR.

 


!"

 #!$%& %"'%%% 
%(%"

































 
 

 
















































  






!
 " # $ 




























 

 
















































  






# $ 
 )*  
 

 
















































  






!
 " # $ 

"%+, -&.

+"$!/ 
/$0%1#(%"2%

#$!/ 

 -&.

+"$!/ 
//%( %%.%  % &'


(
)*  + "
%#& *
" (
)* (

"
$  % * 
  (
)* (

"
 $   ,,,, //345$  "

&- 
"


$ 

.
/ 010(
123
!
0101
 4(
$

-



50(
051
!
152(
 $  *'(




6


+
 
 


**

7+*(

   (
 
"*
8

 .
/010

4

   "
$ 5 
"
" -
"


44 9)

 
:(
$


8'
 $  
/(
"
)

 






9
  '

(
;)

;:(
+"8'

8& 


"


 
 
2

"



) (
30
9
"(
"
;) ;:(
 $

-



(
+
& 

" -
"
 
8 

"




 
 
1

"
) (

"
8


+"

"(
" 



+

(
+"8'
"


+
 

$

- "


 4 "

8




8'
"
< 







" $ (

"

$

-



50
!
051(

" 
"
+ 


-
 
8'
"
)

-
= 
9
  '

(
;)=;:

"
"
$ 
"




'
 
'

"

 $ 


'
"
 $ 

"
 

"
* 



'( $

-


8
 

  

"

(
+"

"
"

 "

8

-



.
/0101

4(
"
" -
+

" - 
"



 '

"

(
"

+ 
$

8
  

"
 
8

-
-
 
"
&


"


+ ( " (
8

-

*  )
$
"
$

- (
"




 
 
439:
 "
) 
+
 

2
 
"




+
$




21(
 
 
494:

"
) 

"
 

"
 
+
"  -
+ "
"



(

"
 

8 5 "(
$ 
 


  (
 "
+
 

 

-
$

(
 
$ (  
$
 

"
 
"


* 
) 

% "

  '

(
;)%;:(

"
8  


  



$ 
> 0?(
8'


-


 $





-
?
$  (
+"

"

+

"
 


$ 
  "

'

"







$
"

 '
152
 


+ 
+ 

  

"
$ 




>
0?

 )
"
 $ '


'

"


"

$


  
494:

"
) (


14
9)

 
:
+

 
 

1
!
2(
+"

"
$$ '
 


'
"
6  $* 
 
 
1(
-

-
"
 

"







'


'

"


"

+
$ 
8'
 

-
 
8& 

444
9)

 
:
8'


-
"
$
"
"


 $


 "
(
"
8
 
 
"
 
"




"
* 
 (

"+

-
"
$ 




)%
"
8
 
8'
% "(




 "

"
 

"


"
)=

$
"






"

 
 
2

"
$

-(
" (
+
-

8
 "

8'
"
 

(
+"

"
+ 
$

8

) "
  $'
+ 8



444
9)

 
:(
$

-
 
$
* 

&-
"


"
+
+
* +

"
)% (
"
* +

*
 "



"
8
$

0 "

8& 

+(
"(
& 
8'


-
"
$
"


$
"

)%
 "

+


"

$ 

" $ 
"

 '
(
"

$ 
 

"
 -"

"


'

(
 

-'(
"
"


8 *
"
"

"
 $



+
 
"
)=

5

"


"-8 
 (

"




' 1



$$ 
"
 * '(
"


+"

"
"*
8

 
8'
 $  
/(


-
"

 
 
1

+ "

 
2(
+
-


"+
"
+"
"



$ 

-

"

8 6
253(
+
8

-
$ 

(

 

"


"
)=
"
$ 
"
8



>
0?(
+"

"
+


+
 


6 


4(1((@5
+ 
8'


+

-
"
 

$ 




 
 '
+

-
$ 
>
?

"
)%
8'


-
"

$ 
  "

'
) 

-'(

-
"
"
$

+


 "
  


50



"

)%
"
8

$ 


8'
% "(

 
8'
"

-
"
"
+


8 * "
"



"


(
"-8

 (
"
 $


(
+



"
'

6  2 



"
$ 
" (
" 8


"
"

+
 8

8
6 "
 -
+ "
"

$- 


44( +"8'
"
8& 

"
8




 '

"

( 8

-
 
8'
"
)=
8'
8



-
"
"
 8'
7 -"


 

       

)9<:

/4

:
 

4
9)

 
:(
"
"
-


" #* 

"


# 
"
 
8
$ 
$
"
&- 
 "



)$$
 8 (
/+
"

 "(

  
"
)%
 $ A
 




"(
"
$ 
+
 -"'




>
0?



 
"
 
8
$ 
$
"



"

)(
 -
 "


      !
 

  "

!

#$# "%&' ())'
 


2(

"


 3 



"
#* (

"
"
" (
"
&  
"
( 8'


-
"
$
"
 

'
$

"
8


"
 $ " '
 
+

(
"(

14(


"
)=
" 

8 *
"
"


"
 $




"
)%
+ 
 $
 
 $





"

8 

" 
 
 
"
$ 
>
4444?
  -"5


"
"
8

$* 
 
"
+ 





"



$
 
 

-'(

  "
+

* 




 
.

"
-

-


"


"




+""
"
)%


 $

-"

8

  
$ 
  "

'(
 

-  


$  (
+


"
$

"
"
$ 
+ $


 8

8
+

"
- 
"


'(
"



14
 
 
"
'
6  

 

-
"
"


 



'
 
'

"

+"

"
+
"

 

'
6  

.
/ 010
 
123

4
"


+"

"

"*
$* 
+ "
"
)=






   

  

           

   !    "  #$%%&% '"'( )" "  *+ %, '# *  - ).  ))"" *+ /,))" " 0    1)  2  *#  '#     *    1)  2 *#" )#""3

%%%%% &" '#")) " )"'# 4) # "" 5$%%/&%  " )"$/ *'# *$%%/6')6  ') " )#$%% &%/)65$%%/&%   

   

 / 

 !7$ %3$% $ 4"

& 8!9 :

-& -)1);

 )
$ 

"
8*
+
-


"+
"
+"
"



"
8 6
+
$ 

(
"
)=
"


+
"


 >
0?
 





4(1((@5

"



"


5 ( 8'
+

-
$ 
>
?
 '(
8'


-
"
)%
$ 


 

 "

'

B$

-

* +
"
 
"
"
)%
"
8
$ 


8'

% "(
(


+
 

8 *
"
"



"


( "-8

 (
"
 $




"




$

-
"
 
"
"



"

' (
50
 
051(
 
 
494:

"
 

21
 
41
 





$
"


+ 

"
8


"




"
$*



 
1 $* 
"

  "
8

 
"
  (

"
 $ '

 '

"
 

"
* 



'
 

'


"-8 

"
 $


(
8'


 

"
$

"






"


 $ 

"



 
 
9:

 

2

"
"


"
"
"
8




'
 
'


 

'

"




'

 "






-
$ 

-
 
 
1
+


8'
"



       

!"#!

(
+"

"
"

"
8 
 * 


$

&

 
 
1(
"



'


"
 

"



'

6 (


8



"
8 
 '
-
"
"
+
 

"
$

"







'


'



"
8 

 '
 "


(
"


$
 &

 
 
1
+ 
&  

#* 
$

" 

-
- *

 3 " ""'# <""" 3&3&$%%3= # '  " )  ""> )&$4

    " ' ))"  6 )  " 4%&<?6#   " "@ 

6'"'6 )#""'#  < "  "4

 

      6  )"#  '   " "  '6  '

 )"" )#'  6  ))   " "'# )  ") ))#" )#)) )    #       '     " A@ A  = " " 4

))  " 6 (('# <))#  = "   )"#  '6"    )"   )     6 """" """ 3&3&$%%3' " ) ") ))#" )#)))# ;

4 "

* +
+
+

$% &  $'             (     )

*  +  "  !

(
 
" 8& 




8'
"
#* 
"
"
+ 



8
-


"

(
+
& 

#* 
$

"
&- 



'  )'6  '6""'# <= # '         6   ))   " "'# )  ") ))#"

 )#)))#)"! ) -"4 B'" (       <  ))#     = "  4   )) )# "4



 "" "  "4

   = "4"  '( < '="@   "  )"' )   "  )#;

 

'(

,  '  -    ()

.* +/" +
"
"
 
"



"
8


 
 
494:(
"
-


"




"

" 
8
 


 
"
 

"
)=



+

$


"


$

) "



+"

"
"
'
8
 $
 
"
8  
8
8'



 

) 

-'(
"


 
 
2
+
6 " #* 
$

"
&- 



) # 6"" 64

'"

)'))# 6)"#' )" "4 '&83:4

 "4

   '"C   " "4

:8: <      = "              )" ?)#)"  ( "= '6)')  ?6" "4

83:          <    6#  "       )" " @  6 <"# "

'" "4

383:" <6@ " ") "

" #

/&

"

&

 ) "4%  )"6@ " "  D)  <"'"      )           ")   ))#  "   )#  )) )#;  "



$

-
"



+"

"
"
'
8



21
 
41(
" (


"+
"
"
+ '

 

"
$

"







'
 
'

"


" '

"

* +

"

$

 +(
"
$ 
+
8
 



-



"



"


 (
'(
"
 
 
-

-
"
"

8'
" )=(
+
 
8

* 
- 



-



"




"


'
152(
+"

"




8+ 0

.
/0101

4(
$

-




'
152( "
+ 
$

 8

8
+(

* +

"
$

$

+
 
+

* 8'
"
)$


  0
 1%   ' )

# *2

". #
+"


"
8
"
"
&




8
 

"
8



"




8
    
$

+"

"
"
8





 
" -
 $

+ 
* 
- 



8 *


 


  
1

#* 
8 *



 <    @ "'6"4

" !08":



 &   )"'" "'6" " )))"")"= "  <('(' 

E  )

 F# 6 & '#  "  )#    "    "  6.       <')6 "

    = "    &         &  )

  &  " ?6" 6 " A')6A) "4

 )"

6  '#          <    &       '   A       A   ' & C )( "

  )"' 6"  & < 6G  &H &''"  ))) &"" A  A6"""')!   '&  6 )"(

)<  A  A& ' )('  '# <?     ) 

    <        & 

6""A '))A)     6)6)(')< 6 

 "4

   @ "'6I"!08":

 1))#")""A')6A'  )""A A4

?6   -  

 "A')6A1)&" ""  "")""A A  "  )"6'#  <C@  ')   )6     - ) J/

"" 3  <'

 "))7 $  "  "  '#    "   

    "        K    ')6B    4

&& ' 6"  "K')6B4

"     '   '#    K B      <      "                 K    ')6B  "  '   )"      '  )  ")))""



 )" 6'#   <     ))#" 

  ""

"   K')6B )"K '""'#  B < 6

6 A / D  "       6)

))"'#! """ ;

1 "


$

-(
" (
8

-
'

"



  

"



8

-


"
8 6
+

- * "
)=
"
&


$
"
+(
" (
8
* +

-
"

  

+"

"
"
8
"


8
$

8
" (
$

-

* +
" 8*(
+ 
$


+
 
"


14
9)

 
4:


"


44
9)

 
:
(
 

-'(
6 " 7/$085 9 7//3459  %5:
5 $;5 $;:   









 54