← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/714/2011allowed

Balwinder Kaur And ORS. v. Dmt. R. Venkateswarlu And ORS.

2025-09-05Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

  

     

  

!

"#$% &'&"

()  *

!

# + &+,-+ % *. (. * 







    



   %  /0 1.

1  1

1    



 



   !  # 

 

  $   



  %%%% 1

1

.

&   

'     (    )*)+,)&)  '$  



 -#  '

 . 

#  

 "  &//

    &0++

2  '

34

  #

# ( 

#

&5*6)))78  ( 

  9+:









 "(



 

 





,6)5,))0 ,   

 #   

  ;



#   '$    '

    

 

 ;

  ' 



 



' $

1   0   10 

  1 5  



#8

  #

  '$    '



     '     

 $     '   

# '     

* 

   



 8<  - #$

  #$  (    

( $ '   #



#  '$    '



( $ ' (   

 $

#

 6

<



   



   



 /  '  



     5=85+ $ 

(  #



 

# $   ( #    '    '

 .

 #    (

   5+ $   #

 = <  



 '$ 3'  # -

Sunita Vs. Vinod Singh 2025 INSC 366   3' ?

-

  '

#   (

  $   ' 

 (

   #    ? 

# 



 8 

  

  

 !" #$

 % 

 &  '           ( ((( !  " #  

 '## 

 )

 

         # 

   

    

 )    )

      

*+ !  " # $

 , 

  !- ' )

 )         .         )  )      

    .     

/

(( !

" #) 

 $

'

 )

 + 0*+ !" #- 

 -1

  !- '

))   

 + ((( !

" #- 

 '   # ) # 

  



 )

2 # 3 !4  # ) 

 

 # #  #  )   

 

  

)  )

##

)

*(      )   ! !)

! !)





    

1

 #

 

         )

  / *(#   

  

  +( Moreover, in the absence of material indicating to the contrary, there is no inhibition to accept the age of the deceased as per the Post$Mortem Report )   

    # 2 .  5      

3 -  " #'

2( ((( !" #$ 

 '#) 

(6    

) 

#  4 7 8   9 &



"/( '    -  *(       #

  #

     

   

 

 :2

((( !1 ;)  / 2( ((( !" #) 9. $ 

 '#

      

< + < 

'

    !

(# (

 

 "(

( $   5+ $   #





0  

      '



( $ 

#

  ,))))78   #

  

  ?  

     

 

     '    .

(

'    

      ;

   (

-

 1

0 03 

 1 

&) 3'  # -



Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 4 (

1&6#-  &#

""

7   

#

#    

#  

 8 @30  

           

     ) #

  1#   



      .         #      ## 

 

 =



 

) ) )  )  

)#

  1# 

    

   

!

  " *'  )   

  # 

   / *

!

" 2 ') 

 # 

   2 0

! "

'

)

 # 

   11 315 )   

  #



  )

# #8 

 

  (6         #

      1#       )

 #



 %

)  #    

     )





 #

"'  . 

 $   >

*

  

  .  )

 )



#

 

)

#

8    

  

  

        ) 

   

   #

  )  # 

  # 

  32    #

  



)



 #

(6 )

   #

  1#   (6 



  ) )  

  # 

 

 )) )

 

 



!   

 #

  1#    

!

 



  ) .  ) !

 * * * * * * 42. 5     #  



  

"2'  "#### -   ?

 .  '

)  ) #   #  "  

#  /( /

/ '

 

  4!+ /0 *( 4!0 * *  4!  *0 2( 4!

2 2 2  4!* 20 (   

)

   4!  

 4!

 0 0( 4!+ 0 0  4!

 00 +( && 3'  # -



National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 4 

5 1 58 7

   



"   &// &/58  &/+

    &0++

 (  8 14 



    ( ?

 #  A 14 " 

 (

(

 A 1-4 (

 

'

$(  A 14  ' ( 

 

 #$  

  

  

  ? 

  A 1B4 .

 



( 

   

   ( 

 # !

'A  8# $

?  $

 

!

(# 



 8 @52. @ conventional heads

  )   )  )1# >A8  

  /

(((  )  

  1#      (( (((

)  

 (( ((( )       

  

    

  

1 

>  -

B  

    )  



 

   

    

#

  )





#  

C .  

   =

@ =



 



 

#

 

# 1   .





 

 





 



       #   , )   )    1        

   

         

          ## )  

.  .

 

=  ) #



 

. 

 

)  .   1

 8    

    

 



             



 1#  

  

(((  2( (((     

(((  #     # #                 #  # #  D

    

 

    !

  =

!

5  . )



 

 )    =

  

      

#

     



  (6 # 5 #      )  

 

#  59.35     

(6 

   )

 # # ) # 

>  )  )  2( 

 



*(6   ) ) 2(

(8  ) )  ( 0(  



 6@



 

 1 59.48  )! # "

'

1  

2(6   



)

) ) )  2( @ 

/ 6) ) )  2( ( (6) ) )   ( 0(

  

       

 1

 59.5$   

 # 

 #

  1#  

 

  #*( */ -F G)) #    59.6. 

 #     -F H) #2/ >  

 59.7 

  ##

 # 59.8

 





    

   



1# 

 

((( 2( ((( 

(((#  



   (6   < &,

3'  # -



'-

+#

+"&# +,  -6 +:

0;-;

< =".

+&  -

9;

>&>#&  -  >#"

4 88

1 2 7  

 (

#9

=#-

"&6#

 # + :

>;

1&6#

  ( (

  #

  

#   



 8 21@

D  

3 - A )  



) # 

  )           ,             

(

8 #  I

I # 

  )   #  I#

  

I  I#



I I

I 

)

    #   # 

  

 

 )      5   #    #

    )

      1  

)  #

 / Spousal consortium            #   

#   !)) ) # 

  #

   I # 

  

#





 



I // Parental consortium 

 

 # 

         #

         I#

  

#



 

     #      

 I /* Filial consortium          #

 

# 

  

  @



       . 

 #

     

 #

               

 #

#    

 22

##    

  



 )  



#4 



) !

    J  

   1    

       

# 

)    4 

     #   #

     ) # 

  

   

) #

 # 

  

  

  #

#   234

F@  

  #          

 8 )#

  

 



   #





  )       

        

3



)  )

  #







 @ @ )

) # 



  ) )

 ) # # #

)   # 

 

    ) 

      

 24

 # 

)

)   # # )  # 

I  

I ) 3 - A8

#

 )  ## # )     

2( (((   

  01 

&5 < 

   '$ 3'  # -

'

    !

(#        

 )*)+,)&)   

($ 8 #       #



#



  #

 8  8 Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded &  $ <

#

,))))78

, .

  6):

&))))78 16):

,))))4 

      ? &75  &))))78 15))))C &75 4 *  <

#

,))))7815))))8&))))4 * 

&6    $

5/)))))78 1,))))C&,C&64 / 

B &+)))78 = .

  B? &+)))78 + 

-   &**)))78 "



 *+)))78?& .

 *+)))78?,

 -6+"

; + ".2)8 ) ? <&, ; +

#

   '$  '

 ".2)*) ? +> +,<

- &+

".)2*) ? 28 2*

&*     

 

 '$ 3'  # -

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  (  25  R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation  

* 1&6#-  &#

""

 ) 8 #   (    0:



   #





(

#   

 E  &6       

     #



#  ( 

  

 '

    

 



$

!

(#  '

    '

    #



#  ( 

  



#7    )*)+,)&)

#7     



 ' 

   '

 &/ (     $    

1

1



*. (. * F   

 (7 8(

H7

  '

H