← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3145/2012dismissed

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sukhvir Kaur And ORS.

2018-03-12Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages



    

 !""#$%$&'( 

  

     

      

 (

 

   

     !!

 

"

       

   #  $%  &'    &'  " 

  ()*+,-"./+. 0 12

'  3 2&& 4

'  "  + .()*+,-"./+. " 

  ()*5.,"./+.  '  "  * ,(%*+,-%./+. "  + .(%*5.,%./+.  '  "  *()*5.,"./+. 66666     

  " 4

(%*+,-%./+. 

! 2!   

   "   7

" "   2  (%*5.,%./+. 



    " 7

"" 

  ! 

    "  !!  

 .*/+./+. 

 72      

 7

'  ( &   7 " " 

8 7

9'472 

!   " 72   %

4

4  7

 !  " +,':-'///;%  "

 "  

 <2 4 2 " (%*+,-%./+.' 

 % 2 

 

&  !& '4

724 2"(%*5.,%./+.' 

&   !  " !    7   ! 

72 7

=4 '"7  2' "

7&  "!(%*+,-%./+. <"

2

'  .,+/.//>' ?

&  &

& 4  = 4& "=  !&'  "

<  '0     4 !& "!    0      )0%+*%%+:+:?

& &4

 &   @ 2   

!0 #

0 ) 

=&4 2 ).,'1 3

7 7 &)0%+#%>.-,'44

!&"! 0   4      

 & &  !

 2 & '  &     "! 4&    "' ?

&  &  = 4 &     ' 4

! 

&  "  7 "" 3  (   ' (  )+5+5   .,+/.//>     .:>;**:;*/,%;,.: #

&  

" 

!   +AA"     '+>55"  '8  9 &! 

  "   " ?

&  &' 4 4

 *- 2  " &  4

4&

  4 

 "!

=4

:/'///;%

 ! "!""  B"!

4 4&" !

   

" 7 44 ! 2 

 !  ! 2=  4

&  7

    "& 

 ?

&  & 

    !  

   4 4

   72  ""&7 7 &)0%+#%>.-,'44

7&  



& & !



7    & 

     "  "

   

?

& & 72

  "!

' 7     "  4

  & &  ! "  

   /+/,.//>   '  7

 4  &  !  2 ! "  

+.'///;%

 2&+;*   4   

C " 

!   " D+-E'  

 !  " +,':-'///;%' 4

   +/'///;% 4   D

 "   !E' +/'///;% 4  D"

C +-'///;% 4  D 

"

E

& 4   FAG !

   " 

&& 72 7

 & +," !& 

$%     

         



 



   

 !"# $  %   &   

'  ( ' ) 

 

 &  

 

 ' (

 *  + '

 !  $  ,  

  $  *           ("- . .  /& (   

'  0

  ,1 "# 

       

         2   

3       ("- . .  (  &  

   

   

 

    



     

  & 2       ("

-.. ( *  



            (

(  ! 



  *  

  

' 

 



' !"#$  %      2       * 1 0

 &       &    



 '



  %

  

 

          

'     &     & -445

'     &   

  

     $     

  &  +67448" 

      

   



'  ,    

   +67448"  

 &   



   

 

 

 

 * 1 +     





'



/ & &                  

     

   

 '     



 

* 1+ 

  

  

   

  

 ' 

'         +-4448"*    & &



 

   & 

&

 &  



.  . (  *





 -445 $ 2 -59 : ; 

 8# 

'   0   &  



 1   





 

'     &  

   +5<4448" : +94441-;=

 &&  "!  "  ' 

 %  ! 2

"   

"  &

 !&

     " 

 % 2 

&     "      

 4

 4&

   '    %

 4 B       

4

+.'///;%! "!

 B"!

"' 7

4& 2

 !" 



  " 2  '  7

 4

 B   !  & !" 

 !!! &  7"  

4  

  !      '    "    %

'

&   

?

& &4

1 

4&

  4 

 B"!

=4

&

  

 B   

   "!   '  4

  4& +.'///;%  ! '

2      

 " 

2  "  HC@%*; " 0

 0 7  'HC@%,;

722

@ 'HC@%-; HC@% A; 

 72 

 H   

   '    2'      

?

& &4

! 272

  "

   "   "! /+/,.//>  .*+/.//>  

   "      

     4  2& !

2 &&7 4 ++'-//;%  +.'///;%!    "' !" 

 

7

  ,/'///;% ! 

     "    %

 

 " 

&   

7&*-2 " &' !  "D+AE4

B 7   "D+-E'

 3&! "=E7   C  

"   ! "

#$% &'('& %) %'(#  *++,  -  .*. !

2'    %



  "!   D"   E

4

D   

 E 4"3&! "=E7  C   

" ($'%% /%0 ' ()! %1 (#$*+.23  $!$ .++,

   "       !&         

 ?

&  & 4

4&

    4  B      @%*   # !"4  

   

4

+.'///;% !  "  "   %

  

 4&!   ,/'///;%!   7   

" 2&  ;!   

!  

& 72    " 

 % 2'  

4

4&

  " "!/+/,.//>  .*+/.//>    "  '7   "'  !  2'

 4 4

4&4 

  "    

    ) ! C   

 7  7"  7

  "2  7

    

4

 4&

2 "

,/'///;%  !   =   7  4&   ! "

2'  4 

7 73  ! C

!   " 2 

 &   '     "        

   7  "& 72 7

"



 

2" 

F  +.'///;%!  & 2' "& 72 7

  ""    

4

+.'///;% ! '    &      7  2"!  '    

 4

 *- 2  " &  "' 

&    3&! "=E7  C  

"   ; !  "D+AE4

B 7   "D+-E!

2'  4"

4

472=E7  C  

"%1  (#$ ' 



  "  ! 4  D"   EF,/G   "!  

!" :/'///;%     

 =4 '   



!"  

 "

 4   ! '     "         ! "! 

7 73   "!

C  & 2' 

(%*+,-%./+.'" 7

" "  ! 2'  !

 (%*5.,%./+.'"  7

"" 

'

4!&  !"   C     

 %

 

7  "   !  " A'>>'A>***   7   !  " ! 

 2 &    !' "

4&!

$% ) " *%  +#,+ !$&

%  &#-" +.'///// 

,!,."/.%/"#!% ,/G ,'5////  ! +-&!0+1$&#-" +A'5////

   &&, +$&#-" .'/+'A////  &#-" 2 ,'.5-// 3 &&, +$&#-" !".! 2*"*,#!$& +'>:'*+-// A-::.A: 4 "*,#!$&%!5 .*%/".%& +"2/"&%"% !0"*"#" %"*+;* ( &&, +*"/"&*"&#1$



 

  1 

  &  

 1    ; +'*+'-,*** 6

,+!$/+$". +: .+'/,'A>***  ! + +%%  *"/"&*"&#1 :$



 

'1

;  &7"&!$& +" *%' 8%%"%! !" +-'/////

,&". +"2/"&%"% +-'///// 8%%#&%.!$,- ,/'/////  ! + -,&!#-/"&% !$& .+':,'A>***  -,&! +." *1 5 .*"* +,':-'/////  ! +&0 &#"-"&! A'>>'A>***

 "      ! "! 

 7 

   

  !    !

'

&  72 7

   ! 

"   F:-G  !"!  "" & 

!   

 

I 

+.'./+5  89

 :    @   &;

J K ;) @  J K ;)