Gurdial Singh v. Land Acquisition Tribunal Improvement Trust And ORS.

   


   

 
   

 !"#

$%& '&()*)+,-  .

 



        

  
 ", / 0"1
 1 

/ 0"1
  11  2&*&+%, "22)%$31$)+)4 '5($%& 2%6&7&%)%)+&2 "21
$%6&8$4 '5($%& 2%6&3725&3&+%29*%  $:&*6 )+'$8 6)*2'&2*6$88')*7*& $;9+(67&%)%)+*;&$2)+<
* 

4 -4 - 4 -4 .4 .4 -.$+'

 $+'.

4$*(33+=9&*%)+* 8$>$+' $(%*$2&)+585&' >&5&24%6& $(%*6$5&;&&+&?%2$(%&' 23


 6&8$+'>+&26$* )8&'%6&72&*&+%7&%)%)+)379<+)+<%6& $>$2''$%&'   47$**&';@0$+' (=9)*)%)+2);9+$8497+$<$2 2 *62%4/%6&2);9+$8/#4>6&2&;@(37&+*$%)+>$*$**&**&'+$((9+%

$(=9)*)%)+    8$+'  6&  $>$2'    %6&  2);9+$8  6$*  ;&&+  $((&7%&'  ;@ 3725&3&+%29*%497+$<$2+8@%6&8$+'>+&2)*$<<2)&5&'

 

2)& 8@4%6& $(%* %6&($*&$2&%6$%5)'&+%) )($%)+'$%&'

--4)**9&'9+'&21&(%)+ %6&9+:$;>+3725&3&+% (%4

-

2  *62%4  /%6&  (%/#4  1%$%&    9+:$;  $((2'&'  *$+(%)+  2  %6& '&5&873&+%  *(6&3&  A+>+  $*  2$+*72%  $<$2  &5&873&+% 1(6&3&4 97+$<$245)'&>6)(6$2&$3&$*92)+< $(2&*4 A$+$8*$+'

3$28$* $772?)3$%&8@  >$*  $(=9)2&'  ;@  3725&3&+%  29*%4  97+$<$2   )+  %6& ;9+'$2)&* "9+)()7$8
33)%%&&497+$<$2

8$+'4$>$2''$%&' -- >$*7$**&';@0$+' (=9)*)%)+
88&(%24 3725&3&+%  29*%4  97+$<$2  2  *62%4  /%6& 
88&(%2/#4  5)'&  >6)(6 (37&+*$%)+>$*<2$+%&' 2%6&$(=9)2&' 8$+' <<2)&5&'$<$)+*%%6& $>$2' %6&
88&(%24%6&8$+'>+&2 )8&';:&(%)+*4>6)(6>&2&2& &22&'

%%6&2);9+$84>6A&&7)+<)+5)&>%6&3$%&2)$878$(&'+2&(2';@%6& 7$2%)&*4'&%&23)+&'%6& $)25$89& %6&$(=9)2&'8$+'$*9+'&2, B)+' 8$+'

$%&7&2$(2&)+ 

6$6)8$+'

-4C

DE

$2$+)8$+'

4C4  DE $)2"93A)+'8$+'

4 4 DE 6&$ 2&*$)'$>$2'6$*;&&+)379<+&')+%6&72&*&+%7&%)%)+ 0&$2+&'(9+*&8 2%6&7&%)%)+&2E8$+'>+&2*9;3)%%&'%6$% 2 %6&7927*& $**&**3&+% $)25$89& %6&$(=9)2&'8$+'4%6&2);9+$8 6$* $)8&'%$772&()$%&%6&&5)'&+(&;29<6%+2&(2';@%6&8$+'>+&2 A&&7)+<)+5)&>%6&8($%)+ %6&$(=9)2&'8$+'6&$(=9)2&'8$+'6$'

<2&$%7%&+%)$8%>$*8($%&'+
6$+')<$26E7$22$'$+'>$*>)%6)+%6& 39+)()7$88)3)%*%6$*7%&+%)$8 292;$+)*$%)+6&*$8&'&&'*72'9(&'

C +2&(2'6$5&;&&+>2+<8@')*($2'&'+& %6&3>$*7&2%$)+)+<%%6& *$3&2&5&+9&&*%$%&6& $(%%6$%%6&8$+'>$*;&)+<*8')+*3$8878%*)+ %6&$2&$)*&5)'&+% %6& $(%%6$%)%6$'7%&+%)$8 292;$+)*$%)+ &

92%6&2*9;3)%%&'%6$%$ 8$+'$+''&5&873&+%$* 2$+*72% 2&$%6&2&478%*6$';&&+*8'$%%6&2$%& 32&%6$+ 
 +& (22&7&2$(2&& 92%6&2*9;3)%%&'%6$%%6&$(=9)2&'8$+'>$*+%$;)< (69+A4$*)%>$*3&2&8@ $(2&*4 A$+$8*$+'

3$28$*+(&)%>$* 8($%&'>)%6)+%6&39+)()7$88)3)%*$+'>$* 292;$+)*$%)+4%6&2&>$* +=9&*%)+ ($%&<2)*)+<%6&*$3&$*
6$6)4 $2$+)2$)2"93A)+6& 8$+' 2;&)+<9*&' 292;$+)*$%)+8*&*)%**)<+) )$+(& ;&)+<
6$6) 2  $2$+)  &  92%6&2  *9;3)%%&'  %6$%  %6&  &$28)&2  $>$2'  $**&**)+<  %6& (37&+*$%)+F
 4-C4DE7&2$(2&47&2%$)+)+<%$(=9)*)%)+ +&$2;@ 8$+'4  >6&2&  +%) )($%)+  9+'&2  1&(%)+      %6&  (%  >$*  )**9&'  +

- -4;&2&8)&'97+$+')+(2&$*& 2%6&%)3&<$7;&<2$+%&' +%6&%6&26$+'48&$2+&'(9+*&8 2%6&3725&3&+%29*% *9;3)%%&'%6$%%69<6$**&**3&+% (37&+*$%)+;@%6&2);9+$8>$*+ 6)<6&2*)'&46>&5&24*%)88%6&3725&3&+%29*%;&)+<<&+&29*%%6& 8$+'>+&246$'+%)379<+&'%6&$>$2'6&2&>$*+&5)'&+(&8&';@%6& 8$+'>+&2>2%6(+*)'&2$%)+"*% %6&*$8&'&&'*72'9(&'+2&(2'

7&2%$)+  %  7$2  ()%@4  >6&2&$*  %6&  8$+'  >$*  8($%&'  32&  %6$+  E A)83&%&2*$>$@%6&2& 234+&$2 9'A)2)5&2%>$*$8>8@)+<$2&$4%6& 8&5&8 >6)(66$'%;&2$)*&' 2'&5&873&+% %6&$2&$0% $39+% >$**7&+%;@%6&3725&3&+%29*%& 92%6&2*9;3)%%&'%6$%2&8)$+(&+ %6&&$28)&2$>$2'7&2%$)+)+<%$(=9)*)%)+ 8$+'4>6&2&+%) )($%)+9+'&2 1&(%)+ %6& (%>$*)**9&'+

- -)*%%$88@3)*E78$(&'4$*%6& 8($%)+  %6$% 72%)+ 8$+' 6$*+%;&&+ *6>++ $+@*)%&78$+

 72'9(&'+2&(2';@%6&8$+'>+&21)3)8$2)*%6&7*)%)+>)%62&<$2'% *$8&'&&' ?

#'$%&'   - 45)'&>6)(6 ;)*>$* 8$+')+%6& 2&5&+9&&*%$%& 5)88$<&$72$8$>$**8' 2
 4DE0($%)+ %6$% 72%)+ 8$+')*$8*+%*6>++$+@*)%&78$++%6&$;*&+(& $+@ &5)'&+(&8&'+2&(2';@%6&8$+'>+&24%6&$>$2' %6&2);9+$8($++% ;&*$)'%;&9+2&$*+$;8& &$2'8&$2+&'(9+*&8 2%6&7$2%)&*$+'7&29*&'%6&7$7&2 ;A

8$+'4) %6&8$+'>+&2)*+%*$%)* )&'

>)%6%6&$>$2' %6&
88&(%246&6$*$2&3&'@% )8&;:&(%)+*4>6)(6 $2&2& &22&'%%6&(92%6&+9*)*+ %6&8$+'>+&2%725&%6$% $**&**3&+% (37&+*$%)+;@%6&
88&(%2>$*+%:9*%$+' $)2+%6& ($*&)+6$+'4+'9;%4%6&8$+'>+&26$*72'9(&'+93;&2 *$8&'&&'*4 6>&5&24++& %6&3)*2&8&5$+% 2%6&2&$*+%6$%%6&8$+'7&2%$)+)+< %6&2&%)*8($%&')+7$2()%@4>6&2&$*%6&$(=9)2&'8$+'>$*8($%&'$;9% EA)83&%&2*$>$@ 23%6&()%@$+'$':)+)+< 9'A)2)5&2 *(8$)3&';@ 8&$2+&'(9+*&8 2%6&3725&3&+%29*%$+' &5&+;*&25&';@%6& 2);9+$8)+%6&$>$2'4%6&$2&$>$*8>8@)+<48&5&8 >6)(6>$*2&=9)2&'

%;&2$)*&';@%6&3725&3&+%29*% 23$A)+<)% 29*&6&&$28)&2 $>$2'7&2%$)+)+<%$(=9)*)%)+ 8$+'4>6&2&+%) )($%)+9+'&21&(%)+  %6& (%>$*)**9&'+

- -4($++%;&2&8)&'97+ 2%6&2&$*+ %6$%8($%)+ %6&8$+'7&2%$)+)+<%6&2&%6$*+%;&&+*6>++$+@*)%& 78$+72'9(&'+2&(2'1)3)8$2)*%6&7*)%)+>)%62& &2&+(&%78%*8'

5)'&*$8&'&&' ?

#+%6&$;*&+(&%6&2& 4%6&2&)*+3$%&2)$82& &22&'

%;@8&$2+&'(9+*&8 2%6&8$+'>+&24>6)(6($+*9;*%$+%)$%&%6&)278&$ %6$%%6&$>$2' %6&2);9+$8)*+%:9*%$+' $)2

 >&5&24>& )+'%6$%%6&&+%)2&8$+')*$'3)%%&'8@>)%6)+%6& 39+)()7$88)3)%* 7$2%)*$;9%%)+<$2$'&3$+$%)+< 23
6$+')<$26E 7$22$'46&+(&4)%($++%;&')*79%&'%6$%)%>$* 292;$+)*$%)+

(=9)*)%)+>$* 2 '&5&873&+%$*2$+*72% 2&$4>6)(6+23$88@)* 8($%&'9%*)'&%6&()%@ %6&8$+')*8($%&'>)%6)+%6&39+)()7$88)3)%* $+')* 292;$+)*$%)+4)%8*&*)%**)<+) )$+(& ;&)+<
6$6)2 $2$+)4 6&+(&4%$**&**%6&(37&+*$%)+>6)8&($%&<2)*)+<%6&8$+'$*
6$6)4

$2$+)2$)2"93A)+)*+%)+(+ 23)%@>)%6*&%%8&'72)+()78&* 8$>

2$**&**3&+% (37&+*$%)+ 2%6&$(=9)2&'8$+'6&2& 2&4%6&$>$2'

 %6&2);9+$8%%6$%&?%&+%)*&22+&9*$+')**&%$*)'&6&&+%)2& $(=9)2&'8$+')*')2&(%&'%;&$**&**&'F
 -4C

DE7&2$(2&4)&4%6&2$%& $**&***&' 2(6$6)($%&<2@ 8$+'6&8$+'>+&2*6$88$8*;&&+%)%8&'% *%$%9%2@;&+& )%*$5$)8$;8&%%6&39+'&2%6& (% 2  %6&  2&$*+*  3&+%)+&'  $;5&4  )379<+&'  $>$2'    %6& 2);9+$8)*3') )&'%%6&&?%&+%)+')($%&'$;5&6&>2)%7&%)%)+**%$+' ')*7*&' $((2')+<8@ $:&*6 )+'$8# 9'<&  $2)+'&21)+<61)'69# 9'<& -  .

3A 6&%6&2*7&$A)+<D2&$*+&', &*D 6&%6&22&72%$;8&, &*D