High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7209/2011disposed of

(O&M) Balwant Ram And ORS v. Sube Singh And ORS

2021-04-05Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill3 pages

%&'(!&)*'

+,-. / .0 % 1 !'%2&-* 33333,,&..

%* 4&-*5* 657&6 82 !'%2&-* 33333&*,'

!& %*

+ 9: 63 6 :6 :: -&*& %+ -3 ;7-6 82/!<') %&('- ,,.) %-&*,'

!& %'3=3 -3'7 5%%/!<') %&('-%2& ,,&..

%*3 >>> :6 ::/3

((! <%*! %&!33'( ..%2& ,,&.. %* -&% ?& '

-&)'-! *

&@5-&*%'=/*57;&)%%';5*%&@)&,%'

*3 ,,.) %'

*!*,'*&!'(3

- A&-

* ('- .*% 8 %2& ,,& . 02)2 *% !* !1%%&! !('-!*,'* .'(%2&* 1& %&-1*'(%2&'- .)'1,-'1*& --<&! % 7&%0&& %2&, -%&*3 %**571%%&!%2 %%2&1 %%&-2 *7&& 1) 7.A-&*'.<&!7&%0&& , -%&*3 '%)&'(%2& ,,.) %'

3 -3 '7 5%%/ !<') %& ))&,%* '%)& '

7&2 .( '( %2& '

,,.) % ,,&..

%*3:& - &!)'5 *&.('-%2& ,,&..

%* ((-1* !<&-(&*%2 %

'- . *&%%.&1& % 2 * 7&& --<&! % 7&%0&& %2& ,,&..

%* ! %2& *5- )& )'1, A")'

%&*% 8-&*,'

!& %$3

! B&&, 8 <&0%2&*,&)()*% !'(%2&, -%&*/ ,,& .*% ?& '

' -!('-2& - 8/%'! A%*&.(3 2* ,,& . 2 * 7&& (.&! 7A %2& ). 1 % C ,,&..

%* *&&? 8 & )&1& %'()'1,& * %'

0 -!&!%'%2&17A%2&.& - &! / 8 !2-/ <!& 0 -! ! %&! D3 3/ '

))'5 % '( !& %2 '(

8 &< 1'%'- <&2).& ))!& %3651'(*3/ /=2 *7&& 0 -!&!7A%2&.& - &!-75 .3 % * *571%%&! %2 % !5- 8 ,& !& )A '( %2* ,,& ./ %2& 1 %%&- 2 * 7&& 1) 7.A-&*'.<&!7A0 A'( '- .*&%%.&1& %3 '

*& %'(%2& ,,&..

%*%' %2&*&%%.&1& %2 *7&& )'

<&A&!%'%2& *5- )&)'1, A7A%2&-)'5 *&.<!& .&%%&- ! %&! 33/ '

*,&)() *%-5)%'

*3 % * 8-&&! 7&%0&& %2& ,,&..

%* ! *5- )&)'1, A%2 % *51'(*3 / /'<&- ! 7'<&%2& 1'5 % 0 -!&! 7A .& - &! / 8 !2- <!& 1,58 &! 0 -! ! %&! D3 3/0'5.!7&2 !&!'<&-%'%2& ,,&..

%*3 :& - &! )'5 *&. ('- %2& ,,&..

%* *571%* %2 % 2& 2 * *,&)() *%-5)%'

* (-'1 %2& ,,&..

%* %' ))&,% %2& )'5 %&- '((&- '( %2& ,-','* . '( *&%%.&1& %3,,&..

%'3C .0 % 1"25*7 !'(%2&!&)& *&!$ 8-&&*%' ))&,% *51'(*3/ // ,,&..

%*'3 !4; AB51 - ! - !&- B51 -"*'

*'(%2&!&)& *&!$ 8-&&%' ))&,% *51'(*3/ / ! ,,&..

% '3 = C &?2 "! 582%&- '( %2& !&)& *&!$ 2 * ' '7;&)%'

( 1'5 % '( )'1,& * %'

* !*75-*&! %' ,,&..

%* '3 %' '<&- ! 7'<& %2& 1'5 % 0 -!&!7A%2&.& - &! / 8 !2-'

))'5 %'(!& %2'(

8 &< ))!& % E5&*%'

*(5.. !( .*&%%.&1& %'(%2&-). 13,2'%')',A'(%2& ))'5 % A&& 2&E5&*/! %&! 33'(*3/ / ,,&..

%'3 ! '(*3/ /& )2 ( <'5-'( ,,&..

%*'3 ! -& %% )2&! *

&@5-&

! 3 2& * 1& -& % ?& '

-&)'-! *57;&)% %' ;5*% &@)&,%'

*3 ((! <%* ! %&! 33'( ..%2& ,,&..

%* -&*,&)%%'%2&*&%%.&1& % * 7'<& -&'

-&)'-!3 -3 ;7-6 82/!<') %&*571%*%2 % ))'5 %, A&&)2&E5&*2 <& 7&& 2 !&! '<&- %' %2& ,,&..

%* %2-'582 %2&- )'5 *&.3 ,,&..

%* 2 ! *,&)() ..A*% %&! %2&- ((! <%*%2 %%2&A2 <&**5&!*,&)() *%-5)%'

*%' %2&-)'5 *&.('- ))&,% )&3 B&&, 8 <&0%2&( )%* !)-)51*% )&* * 7'<&/ ,,.) %'

* ..'0&! !%2* ,,& .*!*,'*&!'( %&-1*'(*&%%.&1& % --<&! %7&%0&& , -%&*3&&!.&**%'* A/ ,,&..

%* %.7&-%A%'1'<& ,,-',- %& ,,.) %' %2* ,,& ./ ) *&%2&)2&E5&* '%& ) *2&!3 )',A'(%2*'-!&-7&)'

<&A&!%'%2& ,,&..

%* %8<& !!-&**3 ":* ..$ ,-. / 5!8& rts F2&%2&-*,& ? 8-& *'

&! + &*' F2&%2&--&,'-% 7.& + &*'