← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4679/2015dismissed

Superintendent Engineer Pwd D&P Water Supply & Sanitation Division And ANR v. Haryana Govt Pwd Mechanical Workers Union Etc

2026-01-22Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari4 pages



            



!"

'() *+ ),-.-*/ $!$!      



  



  

   

:

    

!





  

  

 #  $ %

   



.    / 

/ # 



0 /  

# "

/ 

 

 & $ 

"

' ,  ( % %    

#   

   /   --2,--3 *

$   % 

 %

 -"

-4"6 ;/<

72=



 $  '& 

( )& *

 

%

 # %  #  

",%( (7    % % ;=  $  

'&

  

    





  #

",%(7  



-

)

 #  ,  (



% 

    

 &   

*

%  #

   >

 ",%(7      * #

* 7"?@36 67"@@?      

         

%  %   %  B

# 8      -2 4@ -4 4-4

;/<

7A= *  .   *

' *

 

> (    

'  <  #  !7

  

 

  

            

           

    

 





 

$' 

    

    

          



   

       

          $ #



   %                





 !  " #

 &

     ' ( )$     ' ( )   



   

   

%    $ '       

 

!"#

*'"#

  

%        



  $(





          

          

     

 

   

    !"#

*'"#$' 

      

  







$  %  

  

 " '      . 

    

 

      

         + & % 

 

   $ $' 



%      ,

  ,% !

 "  - - $ )1234

 )114 5; "   &      . + +

 /    0   ,% !

 "  - $ )1231

 )114 5/  ,  .  +

 /     0    

)6$31$)114$                



   <   

&



      ' " #

  $/

% %       

" '  

. $          

 

 

  $ 

     

 

     

  

!"#

*'"#



 



' " 9  " 6  $ 

  %

 

    

  

%   

 

  

, ,%'  - $)721 43

 )114    '  8 %  +

/        )4$9$)114 

   

,  ,!"- $)737)

)117  "  ,    .  +

 /   

   )9$4$) )11:$

          

    



   %    

 

    

   

   

  !"#

*'"

"#       

  

$      



    ,

.     

  

$ =

 

 

  

$   

  





&

*' "  #

   

 2$9$)1 11:)4$9$)11:$    

   



         %$    

    



  







 



 $>

$  #(   

 

    =



",%( 7 

  #  C

  % &  C

$ % & 

>  

",%( (   &   %  B 

8 (

   = # 

 (  

( & 1-.2-..)1

 



 D --



-4-2

  ,  &

!

E,+

!

E,+