High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3043/2009dismissed

Om Parkash And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2016-01-06Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal13 pages

! "# "

$% &' ( ))** + , ! ( ) %

+& $' #(-

'))** ((' ' . #/#, ! -*&#(- ()/!*#(-

) , ' #(- 012 .*#(-

)

34 %*

())*0 ' 1(0$ (( )(5!'6 5*.#' 5! ($ 0'

4 %*

))** *( - !

#7 # 8 ($0 ($) **0* ($* '

5!'( 34 0 *)*

$6' ( **0(''5 0 5* ($ #)) (' $)'*/ *%.

!%*

%* $ 09 * *( -**0 0* ''5 ( - ')*5! 5&5!) ( 0'0$ $) ' -**0 '-**0**! '( )

% '! * ( ( '- ( ' ' ' ) '($ ) # '$ ') . '% '!* (/ $% '! *( 0 ') ( 6** :/ (#, -( ( (( ;

)( ( 1$ 0 5

) (' ( ' ( *! <' ( .$)*$ (5!'($ ) ( ( 5! ' ,0' 6 . ) 6 = *!# '( ',0'6 # ( . $)*$ ( ;

;5! 0 (' **0* ' . ($*'( 0 *)*

**0(''

- '() !% '!* ( ( !

' ! '% '!* (<' $

. $ 0 ' ) 0 .'$ (

1$ .)(5!'$) ' !:

$ 6' ( . ( ' -**0 '( '( ) % '! * ( 5! .! 0 ' 6** :/ (#, ')( ( 1$ 0 '$ ;

* 0.' ' ) )' '$6' ( . '( '( ) ' % '! * (# ' ' . ($*'(5!'( ' ''

. ($*'( & . 0 **! .** ' )*

' '() '* % '! (''. ( )*5 09' )51 5!' )*

(' $*!$$5 '$ ($* ( '. 0'' ' '% '!* (#' =. ((5!'( ('!**0**!

($*'( ' ' ' )*

<' # )*

)) '('' 5' =. ( 0 *0* ( > 6%6 ) ' $) ' 7*#' $5 *( 4 ' 5 ( 5! ' ( ** **0(''

. - '( ' '$ $( ' ' $ 6' ( . #.0 $-(* 0.'- * ' ) * **0( ' '! '-

) - $! .' ' )*

( ' ' . ($*'(**0**!**0( *!' '$ . $-(0 .'$ ( 1$ .)( (' ($* -!. ( & ) ' ( )(5!',0'6 ' **0('/ $ % '!0'1$ ' - '% '! * ( ( *( ) ( 0 $ ; % 15 +**06$$ ? (0* # " 1$ ( .)(5!' 6** #:/ (#,

;

@ ( ( #. )

. (5!'6 ( ') ) $)*$ #

' A( '$ . $-( ( )

.' ((- ' )' '/ $% '!:

' *$(')' @ 0 '. ( ' )* (/ $% '!'.

' ($) '' ')' .'' @ . (. ( )* 5! ) * 0 ' :

' .!# '$ 5! ' )*

' 5 00(# ' ;

;

( ')' '-**0.0 $-( 5 0**0* ( ' A( 374 '5 )*( 0 ') # **. . $(5!' *6

7 34 B'' ' )*

*( - ! #7 # 8 $'( ($0 ($) **0* ($* ' ' = %% 4 B'' ' ( & . 0*!# **! ( $* ( ( **0**!

($*'('' )*

( .'

C%% 34 B'' ' )*

*( 0 D>E)

$ ( ' $ ($0 ($) *$( 5!'$ $'( ($* **'( *A C%% 4 B'' ' )*

$ 5*C% 374 B'' ' )*

' * (C% 3"4 B'' '-* , ' 1 ( ') C% 3;4 B'' '5( 1 ($1 ( !) C% 3>4 B'' ' ' )*

" -*(') ) C% 4 B'' ' )*

C% 3 4 B'' ')*

-(*0*

8> 6%6'$) ' !C % 34 B'' '' 5 *(5!

'$) ) C% 3 4 * 3"4 2'') *(-( < *6 (( (1 *! ('*(')*

& 5 !.& ' '( <' )*

0'5*'' '5 (

' . $ ' ( '.' ' '

.($*'(B $ *(5!

'.'''

. '(.' ( '*$(' $ ) ''

.( '* # ' #.($*'(%*

' '.

*0*$ ( * '. 0( 5!'( %*

'*@$ (' 0'5 %B 6' ($

' @ ($* ''5!'% '!<' )*

' 5*'( (.' ''.

; ( )* .) . '

)' ($(*!# ( '- ($*'( ' A( ') % '!* ( *( 0)' # ' #. $5 )

5*''' '.@*-*!.' 9' (. )

!* <')*

.'*)) 0%B' ($( ' @$ '5 ' '# ' (( 5 ! ($ ) $ !

$) ' ! 3;4 < * 6 ($( ' -( 1(0$ ( ( (( ; " %*

$ ( * 5 '*. ))**6 (' ))*.($( -(1(0$ (( (( " > 3>4 * 0.''0 ( ))*#* ( * '))** $( **. 05 *= *.

34 B'' ' ))** *( ($0 7 ** 0.' '**0*($* ' ''' ) C 354 B'' &) 0 -.' ( !

$ ' ) ' )*

'*(50- 5 5*(5C 34 B'' * ' $)*

> -( ) ((5!')*

''' .(.' 9' #.''.

*( ' **0* '

'$ 0 ' ) )*

*1C 3(4 B'' '**0*($* '

')*

8))** . 0#*0*#-(5 (& 0' *)*5! ) * 1C 4 :'-' (* ( * ') ('- *) ('$ * ( 3 4 ? ( * '))** ' (( ' .' ' )*

)) '( ' ' ' ) ) 5 0 ($ # '! ( 0 ($ (* $' ) F@% ($(*!# ' ))* # - ' '- (($ ' * (5! 0''*( 5*(-(

$' ) $( '))* :

#' .

' ) ' -

*# ' )*

*( '- & &('( '0' ' *( 0'6 <'

$ '' (5!')*

. .' !($ G.'' ''.(

9' !) $ =

.'' . (5! !-( F-

(( 0'* (($ (.'') '6 '

))* '5 $-(5 '6 0 ! -

*)) ( ') ) ( 0($ %*

(( ** !' $ 0$ *#'. '' ( )* .

.' ' )** ( ) . '* ')' #' # ' (& 5!'( ' $-* '$ ( -. *!

('% '!* (#' 5

5(5!')*

- # $!'$ '

(5. )*

('( #')*

' *( 0 ' ($ ) ( # ' # ) $) '5( .

0 '$ $

0 ':

( F-( ''('& !'

($ ) #'$.*('-0 0 '$<' *6 '5 () $($(' ('$.)'*(5!'*. ))**6 34 = ( $ .'' ' ' (5!')*

( 9' <' ) -' .

'$* ('*( ) -'$.' !

-( ( #')*

'$ . (!

' ) '. ( '* #

' #'= .'' 5 0 ( % '!* ('5)')*

5!'% '! 5! 0 .*(5

0 :

'- ( 0' #( .*('-5 **( ) @)* .' ' . (G.'' ' . '* <' (&

'. $ ') ''

. ( '* ('$.($*'( <'= .''5 .'' '($*

. ) (( 5! ! ( 5! ' $) ' ! ($(*!# ' ' -H- (( * )!

6$$ # 5 - * 0 ( <'*( . ) .' ) . (<' $-*. $() ' ( )(5!',0'6

'5 1$ ( )(5!'' ! ( ' <' ) ( ''.' '( 0( ') ' ( )(5!'$) ' !# '5 !$ ($* ((0

' ( # '

5 5 0' 5 = ( 8) 8*0* ) ( 0 '** 5 (0 ' 0 ') ' !

.' '( ((5( . 0( '

) ') - '<')*( 0 '

*( ) -H-'( -( '$ '.'$ '5 ( 5!')*

' <' -(

('.@ ($0(''G'.

$' .@ 0 9' ('.$'

.@ 0 '* <'$

%B) (' ')* #$ ! $ . '.

(5.'*)) 0%B# *!' $. (F- ')'0 )' ('-5

& '$

5 ('.

$') '''5 ($*'( ' ($*'('*( 5) -(.'' @(

9' 8%* '* ')' #' #' $ ' )*

5 0- ( $ 0 ' ($*'( <' #' ($* ( 5!'' ! 0( ' ) ) ' @( '*

5'*( 5 $* ( * ( *) -( ( ''( -. ( & 5!'' .'

($0 ' )*

' 5 !

*- ) ($0# ' $)

5 = ( ( *( 5 ( -H- ' **0( ($* .'' @( )* '

5* 0 0* #')*

'- *( ) - ' # ' # ! .& '

5*&( ') ) 0 ! * ')*

( 0$) <' = *. $*( '0 ( ))*( ** $''= ) =

(

5( . @ ($0 (')*

'6)*(.'' #'

'$ .@ 0 '* ' . I 5 *' (& 5!'(

'. $ F- '. $ ( ) #

5 5& 5!')*

')*

'- ' .

*0$ *'5 (((5!' )*

'.''($* ''5 (

) ( 9' *!<' ( '( ''($* '& )* ) '$ $(5!')*

'* '

' 0(.''*$

') I - ' $

. '.

**0* ' '% '!* (#** ' & 5! ' ' 0( ' ( ) '$ * ( (($* ' #

5 5(5$* ((0 '

'( #) * *!.' '-( $!

5. ' ) ' $ ' ( <' **0( ($0'' )5* $) 0@* ( ' ' ' )*

' 5 !

-( ((( 5! '$ ($ ' 5 0 ((5!')*

!) . (#& 0') ) !($ (.') '6 # ')*

' *(*(0 -( ) -'# .& ' '(

5$(51 $ '$ .''

5*0**! ( ( I (= *! (' !

. '( $( ') ( 0) 3 4 ?& 0 ' - ! (-( *(5!')*

(# @) 5$('

( 0 ((5!'6 5*.:'5'*(' )*

' *( !'0 -( #. 0 !

'' ( '6 '0* ( ))*6 = *!#'))***!(-( $ ( ' 5!($(

$ %