← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7259/2011dismissed

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Geeta Devi & ORS.

2019-03-13Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

  

    



 

  !" #

$

%%&& '"! () * +  ,"

-%       ." "

'  *!%/ + 

" , %%&&

"

0"

"/ + 

" "% 

"

!& 2+/ + 

" "%

"

"+ 3!)" 2+/ + 

" "%

 5" &6 / , 

,  " , &) () * +  + ," &7& "%"+

(, 5",) ."8, 9  , :"

!7,  &) %  !" (

,  ',& /  , +") ,  (, 5",) ."8, "!7  7"

"6 , %  +&&7 ! 3&

;

 , 7   -"   ," ,&" ! "8, :"7 "7"

<-;

=;

 ," " " ""   ,

7 +,&> ,  :

! ;

% )

, ,  "!"7  , +"6 ," ,&"  " )87 %!",/ , ,  +,& +" !" !   ",  7&7 "+7 :6  "+" (?6 9 "%

> , (, 5",) ."8, , !

" ?!"  , ),%> , ,  ,   .!,%?& < %&

") :! , !!):  , ?!"  , @ 6  

;

;

> ,   -

1 

" ,

 !"

(  /

;  5  "7"  .

& (  .!/ &)7  )%

- & )%&7 "/ "+"  !""

,

7 +,&  "% 



, &) %   7+  "% 

-% 

/ / 5/   %!  %%"  & %" " )  7 , &) %  %"67

"  )&

 , %&7

, %"/

&& 7 ! "

")

A,," ,   B!  

8 %& !  ", " 7&7 "+7

+,&

<-;

=; :6 "%

 "!&7  ,

5",) ."8,  &&7C ..

!

 %"

+/ ,," , &) " &  6  )%     , @  ) , )C ..

A,," "%

    , &7 +&  

+ "+7 &C .- 

;

A,," , !" + & , ")    

!" % &6C .- 

 -&

  , , %" & +  !%% "

," "%+ &)

 !%% "

," / , &)

* + %%"  .A / !, 3!)"/ -7"  #&"8/ 



-D/ -"  .A/ ( (,&   .A / (, '8  .A;/ (, D?!& <B  .A  (, $ 8, 5,/ #")& ,&)  .A1

 , ," ,/ , "%  ,+ @) "%

5 ) .&  -A  "%

 9 (?6  -A : "7  !)

 " ,"7 "7!)/ , D":!& &&  , &) %    )%

- /

/

E  "  , &)E% " %6:& :6 "%

/   ?

&6  +"&&6 , " F1G %" !) ) , 

&7

, %  && !& "&H

D, " &  , !"  )%6 77"+   , %%"

, , # !" :6 6

&7 , %" %%& %"67 , , ) : %/ , )%!7 " :    , %%&& 9 !"  )%6 : : &+

 &:&6  %6  )%   , &)



, %%&  7+  "% / , %!  %%" ,"

!7,  !& @% "%

=

,+ ," &"  !&

" , %" : 7 7 ,"

!7, , " "

D, " 

")  "7!) + :6 &"  !&

" , %%&&  , ,   ,  , 8 %&

;

;

/ ," ,  -  "7"

    "  %" 

) " , ," ) ,> , , "+"

,

7 +,& &&7&6 + &+  ,   , " "%&6 & :6 ,) , 8 ,  , , ,   ")  "+"

 ,

7 +,&  6 % 

) !" )%& 6)

"%

5  ,  ! 6 / ,"

"/ , D":!& , "

7&6  )  ,  &!  , !, "+" , ! ,  :6 ",  7&7 "+7/ "," ,

7 +,&  B!   "%

   &&7 "+" " "

7&6 "

! :6 , &) ?!  7  )%

 )6 : )  ," , , +"6     " :6 , !"  )%6 :

" , D":!& < +"/ , D":!& , " ""  ) 6

.A; '8/ , , %"

+ , !&" +"

,  7+7 & )"

  

+ I@ .A;E 7 , ,   B!  , 8 %& !  ",  7&7 "+7

7 +,& :6 "%

/ !"," 7 , , % & ,   & 7 ,  -  )

"+"    &  :6 "%

 , , &  ")&  )%& !" (   

; .#/ ,,    .

& (  .! !"

( 1  #"

.

# :6 , # !" ,"!%   -

1  "7"  )

"+" )  : 8   (?6 

(,,%& 9 "%

D, D":!& , !"," " ""  ) 6

.A

( (,& / , %  :

! "7"

 -

1 

" ,

 !" (   

; .#  %"

""

, # !" 7 , ,  +77 

"  , 

  %"

+7  %6

 -  I@ .

7 ,  :&:& "" , : ! 7 ! (?6 - "  , ) 6

.A1 $ 8, 5,/ #")& ,&)  , # !"

0 #/ *!"7  , &

: )/ , , :"

!7, ,  & & J( '"! (?6J 7 ,   @

"  "  ,"7/ ," .A (, D?!& <B/ - " 3%"/ .!,%?& < %&/ *!"7  , :

" " , %"

+ & :&& I@ .AE /  %6

$- I@ .AE/ , !))"6 I@ .AE  "!B  "%

 5",) ."8, I@ .AE;

D, D":!& , & , , %  &  %"



;  

, "/ ,,

" "6 " " " :7 "%"

!  !"     

                

        

    

        

                                !

     !      !   # 

            #

 

   !        $  %

    & '

$ %(   "))*&+,-# .$/%&. &  

     0, 

 001  "))    

    

20    $  %     

1 !       %&+3 !   



          )  4

   $       

 5"-,6 7&7  

 &+ !      

                '

 08 001%*&   )4

       

        

     

    

 5" 

 

      %    4

 -,6  5" 

  

   , 9

 

             

)   

 

   

 



 

 

 - 81%20:#&7    



    

     )4

 

  

)   

 

   

     



  

 

    ;

  &!       

'       



                     

   



    

        .

     

 

  

)   

 

   

 



 

%   

:      

)  

!

   







 

      $  %                         

   %  

 

!"#$%&'   ()  

*+   

!"#$%&', 

     



       

    D,  7

  !7, " 7

" ""+7  ,  &! , "%

 9 (?6  !,

,  :6 , ",  7&7 "+7

,

7 +,&  ,  !& 6 "!&7  !7 ?!"  5",) ."8,  ,, , !!):  , @ 6  , , %& D,    "  :,&

, !"  )%6 , , &6  & 77

 - 7   ,  , , +,&  B!   "%

 :7  "+" " "

%  "

7&6 " + 

6 )"

D, @ "7!) + :6 &"  !&

" , %%&& 9 !"  )%6  , "%

 9 (?6 ,  %& &  %6

, "+7 &/ ,"

"/ , !"  )%6  !&   7 , ) @)   

 ! ,,"   7! "  7 )    + :6 !,   D, D":!& , & , , %  %"

  

, "/ ,, " :7 "%"

!

" "6 " "  !"

 <              2                   

= 

                

 

     

  

      

             

   

            

    

                           2     

     

;   

        

             

    

       

       

           

 

              

      $  %

    

          $                  -  $

.  %   

  *  

,#%&/!(0"! 12" D, !7,  , " ) & :6 , !"  )%6  :?  , : 8 , "%

   ,+7  +&  

+ "+7 &  , )

  !

 , "7" , : "!8/ ,,   !" KA,," "%

    , &7 +&  

+ "+7 &C .-  L

 D, !

%"

+7 , !  !%  "%

!"  )%6 (!, !"  )%6  !& ,+ && !% "%

  %"

!  %6

, "+7 &   , ,  %"

! , , !"  )%6  !& ,+ :"

!7,  " " ,"

+  " "7"

 -  ) " +,!&"  / ""

, "+"

,

7 +,&/  %6

"+7 &  8 ) ,)/ ,,  , ) %"

, ,&&



" ) 

,+ : ) :6 , !"  )%6  7 , " " !)) 

D, &) , !))  .A1 $ 8, 5,/ #")& ,&)  , # !"

0 #/ *!"7  , " " "&7  ")&  & J( '"! (?6J/  -

1 

 !" (   

;  .#/ , , %  :

! &7

,&&  +&:&6

-#

, +,&  B!  , " " !"7 , "

@) / 

B!   8 ) ,)  :,&

, !"  )%6  

,," "+7 &

, !  +&:&  ,&& & !",") "/ , +77 

"

, ")&  )&6 ( (,&  , : @) :6 , &)

B!   8 ) ,)   ,," , , 8  %   , "+7 &

(?6 !  , ")&  "  D,"

"/ , !" # )%6 , &  ,"7 , :!"

%"

%& !%       8 +7

,  ,  %6

"+7 &    %& & :6 "%

 9 "+"

," %   "7!

D, 7 " " :6 , D":!&  && "     :   : ":""6 " ""

 !  ""6  , +



 +&:&  " "

7  )"  , %%&/ , )  )  "7&6

 5"?

 

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

 '# !+,

 "&#