← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5963/2014allowed

Sanjay Kumar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-07-21Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages



     

#$%%&'(')*

 )($#,-%.#)/#0123#4 %$'$')%4 6%4(2( .$#$%#40#)##)7$8%4( %(9)7%)$(  

      

4%(%)$*5 !4.9%4#:7;&#$%4$8%9%$'$')%4 !4'$%(8 #)7'$:77-:#40#)# <<<       8%9%$'$')%4:=8'((%4;')> #(#)($#,-%='$8$8% )7  :#40#)# -'&%8#('-%7$8%')($#)$9%$'$')#((#'-')>$8%47%47#$%7

5":9#((%7,0$8% :#40#)#:4%(9)7%)$)

')$%43(=8'&88'(&-#'3(%%@')>7%%3%77#$%#99')$3%)$=%

'%$8%7#$%#9%4()/2)'4$$8%9%$'$')%48#7,%%)#99')$%7: 8#(,%%)4%/%&$%7 4'%#&$(#)7)=8'&8$8%4%'()7'(92$%=2-74%A2'4% )$'&% %$'$')%4#99-'%74$8%9($)($#,-%')#40#)# -'&%4 )7'#)  %(%4;%7  #$$#-')  ')  924(2#)&%  $  #)  #7;%4$'(%3%)$  '((2%7  ') %&%3,%4:

 #;')>,%%)72-0(%-%&$%7')#94&%(((%-%&$') 9%$'$')%4  =#(  7%92$%7  4  $4#')')>  )  -

   '(  &#)7'7#$24%:

8=%;%4:=#(&#)&%--%7;'7%47%47#$%7

($%)(',-0)$8%>42)7 $8#$8%8#7&)&%#-%7$8%#&$238#;')>,%%)');-;%7')#) #$$8% ($#>%    (2,3'((')    8'(  #99-'&#$')  43   $  $8#$  ($#>%  9%$'$')%4 94%%44%7 B+

,%4%$8'(24$'392>)')>$8%47%47#$%7



  &#)&%-')>  8'(  &#)7'7#$24%    ';'(')  %)&8    $8'(  24$ 7'(9(%7$8%9%$'$')')$8%-'>8$47%47#$%7

7'4%&$')>$8% 4%(9)7%)$#2$84'$'%($4%5%?#3')%$8%3#$$%4#)7$9#((#99494'#$% 47%4(#$%4>4#)$#)994$2)'$09%4()#-8%#4')> .2'&%'$$,(%4;%$8#$$8%';'(')%)&8=8'-%'((2')> 7'4%&$')()

8#7$#@%))$'&%$8%(2,3'((')(4#'(%7),%8#- $8%9%$'$')%4$8#$ 7#$%7  8#7,%%)4%>'($%4%7,2$(')&%$8% ='$)%((%(7'7)$(2994$$8%94(%&2$');%4(')9%$'$')%4=#(#&A2'$$%7 ;'7%47%47#$%7 

:9#((%7,0$8%4'#-24$8'(=#(94'4$ $8%7#$%9#((')> $8% 47%4 &#)&%--#$') &#)7'7#$24% $8% 9%$'$')%4'%

 $=#(24$8%4$#@%))$'&%$8#$$8%3#$$%48#7 ,%%) &3943'(%7  ,%$=%%)  $8%  &39-#')#)$  #)7  $8% #&&2(%7  9#4$0 )

 '$(%-#)7=8'&8#&$=#(4%&>)'C%7,0$8%4'#-24$')$8% 47%4#&A2'$$#-9#((%7(2,(%A2%)$-0)$8%4=47(:$8%&3943'(%8#7 ,%%)%%&$%7%;%)94'4$'--')>29$8%43,0$8%9%$'$')%4(%%@')> #99')$3%)$$$8%9($)($#,-%%$#)$8%4#&$$8#$8#7=%'>8%7 ='$8$8%';'(') %)&8 =#( $8#$ #.$#$% -'&08#7,%%) 432-#$%7 &)$#')')>#-'($%)&%(&)($'$2$')>34#-$249'$27%#)77%,#44')>$8% &#)7'7#$%(43%39-03%)$#)7$8%&#(%D%)&%$8%9%$'$')%4=#()$ &;%4%72)7%4(2&8-'($ )  92494$%7  &39-'#)&%    $8%  7'4%&$')(  '((2%7  ,0  $8% ';'(')%)&8') B+

$8%3#$$%4'(($#$%7$8#;%,%%) 4%5&)('7%4%7#)7#&)($#,2-#40)23,%4=#(#(('>)%7$$8%9%$'$')%4#)7 8%=#('((2%7#99')$3%)$-%$$%47#$%7

#()($#,-%2)7%4 "A2$#

55 $($4#)(9'4%($8#$)% #3%(8123#4()278 #3=#( #-((%-%&$%7#()($#,-%')$8%(#3%;%40(%-%&$')94&%((')=8'&8$8% 9%$'$')%48#79#4$'&'9#$%7 8%&#)7'7#$24% #3%(8123#4=#(#-( &#)&%-%7)$8%(#3%;%40,#('( '%8#;')> (2994%((%7 $8%#&$  4%>'($4#$') 

7#$%7

2)7%4(%&$')( B: : +:

 : + : -'&%.$#$').#7#4:#4=#)# #3%(8123#48#;')>,%%) #&A2'$$%7,0$8%4'#-24$')$8%$4'#-$8#$8#7%)(2%7:94%%44%7  

')$8'(24$#)7=8'&8=#(#--=%7;'7%47%4#)7 /27>%3%)$7#$%7 +

#)7')=8'&8$8%4%(9)7%)$(=%4%7'4%&$%7$ '((2%  #99')$3%)$  -%$$%4  ')  #;24    #3%(8  123#4  #-)>  ='$8 &)(%A2%)$'#-,%)%'$(')$8%)#$24%(%)'4'$0%$&$=#(8=%;%48%-7 $8#$ #3%(8123#4=2-7)$,%%)$'$-%7$#)03)%$#40,%)%'$(#)78'( 9#0=2-7,%'?%7))$')#-,#('( -#&%7)4%&47#$))%?24% 5+'( #)47%47#$%7 

'((2%7,0$8%33#)7#)$: )7#$$#-'): :

8)7('  24>#)" ') $%43(   =8'&8  #3%(8  123#4  8#(  ,%%) >';%) )$')#-#99')$3%)$$$8%9($#)($#,-%=%

#-)> ='$8&)(%A2%)$'#-,%)%'$(%)'4'$0#(=%-- )$8%-'>8$(2&87%;%-93%)$94%(%)$9%$'$')%4(2,3'$$%7# 4%94%(%)$#$')  7#$%7  

  ))%?24%  5"  &-#'3')>  #)$%  7#$%7 #99')$3%)$=%

'%$8%7#$%('3'-#4-0('$2#$%79%4()#)7 =88#79#4$'&'9#$%7')$8%(#3%;%40(%-%&$')94&%((8#7,%%)#99')$%7 $$8%9($)($#,-% %42(#-$8%4%94%(%)$#$')=2-74%;%#-$8#$') 9#4#$8%4%$8%9%$'$')%48#7&'$%7$8%)#3%(#(3#)0#()')%$8%4 (%-%&$%7&#)7'7#$%(=8(%&#)7'7#$24%8#7#-(,%%)&#)&%-%7)$8%(#3% ;%40>42)7'%(2994%((')#&$(9%4$#')')>$9%)7%)&0&4'3')#- 94&%%7')>(#)7=829)#&A2'$$#-8#;%,%%)>4#)$%7#99')$3%)$4%-#$')>

55 ,#&@$$8%0%#4

.2&84%94%(%)$#$')($#)7(4%/%&$%7;'7%47%47#$%7

 #$))%?24% 5$'(#>#')($(2&8,4'%#&$2#-,#&@749$8#$$8%')($#)$ 9%$'$')8#(,%%)'-%7 8%#&$()$'&%78%4%')#,;%#4%)$7'(92$%7,0-%#4)%7.$#$% &2)(%-$'(8=%;%4&)$%)7%7$8#$$8%9%$'$')%4=#('((2%7#99')$3%)$ -%$$%4)$8%9($)($#,-%=%

')924(2#)&%$#)%?%4&'(% 4%5&)('7%4#$')$8#$8#7,%%)7'4%&$%7,0$8%';'(')%)&8$8'( 24$')'$(/27>%3%)$7#$%7

=8'-%7'(9(')> B+

(4%>#47($8%,%)%'$#)$%7#$%7#99')$3%)$')#;24 #3%(8 123#4()278 #3'(&)&%4)%7:'$'((2>8$$,%/2($''%7,0 &)$%)7')>$8#$(2&8,%)%'$=#(>4#)$%7')924(2#)&%$$8%7'4%&$')( '((2%7,0$8%4'$24$ %$#)$8%4,/%&$')4#'(%7,0-%#4)%7.$#$% &2)(%-'($8#$%;%)$82>8$8%9%$'$')%48#7,%%)>4#)$%7#99')$3%)$$ $8%9($)($#,-%=%

$8%9%$'$')%4#&&%9$%7$8%(#3%#)7 8#(4%3#')%73234#9%4'7')%?&%((0%#4(#)7#((2&8$8%&-#'3 (%$29,08'3'($'3%,#44%7 2)(%-4$8%9#4$'%(8#;%,%%)8%#47 )$8%&)('7%4%7;'%=$8'(24$:$8%'392>)%747%47#$%7

#$))%?24% 5&#))$(2($#').2&8;'%='(,%')>$#@%)4 34%$8#))%4%#()

%42(#-$8%'392>)%747%4=2-74%;%#-$8#$$8%(#3%'( ,%4%$#)04%#()')>=8'&8=2-7/2($'0$8%4%/%&$')$8%&-#'3$8% 9%$'$')%4(%%@')>#)$%7#$%7#99')$3%)$$$8%9($)($#,-%=%

   8%  '392>)%7  47%4  8#(  ,%%)  9#((%7  =8'-%  7%#-')>  #)7 7'(9(')>#4%94%(%)$#$')7#$%7

5")$8'(;%40 4%94%(%)$#$')$8%')($#)&%('7%)$'&#--0('$2#$%7)($#,-%(8#7,%%)

55 24)'(8%7#)7'$8#7,%%)(9%&''&#--0#;%44%7$8#$$8%08#;%,%%)>4#)$%7 $8%,%)%'$#)$%7#$%7#99')$3%)$=%$8%0%#4

.2&8&)$%)$') 8#()$%;%),%%))$'&%732&8-%((7%#-$='$8')$8%'392>)%747%4 47%4(9#((%7,0#73')'($4#$';%#2$84'$'%(7%#-')>='$8$8%4'>8$($8% %39-0%%( 8#;%$,%(9%#@')>47%4(#)7,0#(('>)')>4%#()( 8% '392>)%747%47#$%7

5"=2-7)$(24;';%) #&&2)$(2&8')'43'$0#-)% 8%  ,/%&$')  4#'(%7  ,0  -%#4)%7  .$#$%  &2)(%-  #(  4%>#47(

#3%(8123#4()278 #38#;')>,%%)>4#)$%7$8%4%A2'('$%,%)%'$ )-0)#&&2)$7'4%&$')(8#;')>,%%)'((2%7,0$8%4'$24$#)7) $8%$8%48#)7$8%=4'$9%$'$')'-%7,0$8%9%$'$')%48#;')>,%%)7'(9(%7 )-0$4%5&)('7%4$8%3#$$%4'(#4';-2(,/%&$')39-0%%(:=8 #4%'7%)$'&#--0('$2#$%78#;%$,%3%$%72$('3'-#4$4%#$3%)$.2&8#(9%&$ 8#(,%%)'>)4%7,0$8% :#40#)#=8'-%9#((')>$8%'392>)%747%4 7#$%7

5" 8%,/%&$')='$84%>#47$7%-#0#-(&#))$,%(2($#')%7 8%9%$'$')%4'((%%@')>9#4'$0='$8 #3%(8123#4()278 #3#)7 $8%4('3'-#4-0('$2#$%7(%-%&$%7&#)7'7#$%(=8%;%)$82>88#;%,%%) >4#)$%7,%)%'$#)$%7#$%7#99')$3%)$,2$$8%08#;%)$,%%)9#'7#)0 #&$2#-3)%$#40,%)%'$(4$8%9%4'7$8#$$8%08#;%)$(%4;%7$'()-0 $8%,%)%'$)$')#-9#0'?#$')$8#$=#($,%>4#)$%7%-#0:#((2&8: &#))$7%%#$$8%&-#'3$8%9%$'$')%4

4$8%4%#()( 4%&47%7 #,;%: $8%  '392>)%7 47%4  7#$%7

  ))%?24%  5"  '(  (%$  #('7%   4'$  9%$'$')  '(  #--=%7

%(9)7%)$(  #4%  7'4%&$%7  $  '((2%  #99')$3%)$  47%4  ')  #;24    $8% 9%$'$')%4=%$8%7#$%#&#)7'7#$%,%-)>')>$$8% "&#$%>40#)7

55 =88#74%3#')%7(2&&%((2-')$8%(#3%;%4094&%(((%-%&$')8#7,%%) (#99')$%7  %$'$')%4:8=%;%4:='--)$,%%)$'$-%7$#)03)%$#40 ,%)%'$%;%)$82>8:8'(9#0%$&(8#--,%'?%7))$')#-,#('( %$'$')%4 =2-7,%%)$'$-%7$(%)'4'$0)$8%,#('(3%4'$#(7%$%43')%7')$8% (%-%&$')9#)%-

%$'$')'(#--=%7')$8%#4%(#'7$%43(         

-2&@0 8%$8%4$,%4%%44%7$ %94$%4E%(