Mukhtiar Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS





   
   

   !"#"$% &

 '()*"

+,"$-* $.* +#  ""$ +# / +#(# ,   +0 $  $.* +#  #1$. $#
 


 !



  


!



,% '+',2 *(+"

3.4!

 +* 1 ""$ +#  !



"


$  *"#  1 ""$  "5 .  ($. +  +"!5 #  67    * $#"("$
$."

3* 1 ""$ +#* 4 1+ 0 .+"##( $!  8+""$ * $ (+ ! +"+ +"+9( #*"$-* $""!

"$#.

 .: : "##( .($. +, !"$* ;

$.!9("#""$!3 :<"$#*+=* !>?3  .

 .  & :  ($. +  , !"$ 6    * ! $.  +.  .

 .

6 :<$$ @(+  A&?4". 8*"!** 5 $.* 1 ""$ +#8 #

!9("+ .+* . 4 51B $."#1# 58+)# +   * .(+- +*3 "#+"! * )<$8"#+"!* CC +?  (+* +1+ 0 +* #D $B .

."+ !"$-* + #1$. $#+ 5 # * 5 $.* 1 ""$ +#+B*

!9("#""$ #*  !9("#""$1+! ."$-## $.# 5 1# ."$ +B# , !"$<?*  "-*

"+B1 $# "$ $.+ $#1 + $!0"$ ;

$.!9("#""$3 * D"5"

"$ $. # 5 B $!3 &<* + "$  + +  ++ . #= &!>?

   *  1 ""$ +#  +  8$ +#  "$  1## ##"$    *  5 $.

#(+"$- D"-* D"#8 :D"#8 $#"#"(  .8"*"$* + 4 $(  #

4"55 -  * .(+- +*3"#+"!* CC +4 +$B $ +0 $ "##( .

$""!

"$.

 .: :($. +, !"$* !558 .D0 $""!

"$.

 .& :($. +, !"$6* !+ !9("#""$ $.    4"55 -   * .(+- +*  +  *  1(+1#    . 4 51B $  $.

("5"E "$    5 $.  #  ."#1# 5  8+)#  +   "!  .

 .  :  : <$$ @(+  A?($. +, !"$:* !8 #"##( .* 1 ""$ +# 8 +..

 .6 :<$$ @(+  A&?8 #1 ## . +* 1 ##"$- *  +. $. 4 $  +* 1 ""$ +#* . 5#+ ! "4 .*  B($   !B1 $# "$3  $  !"$  * .  D $  ) $   "$  (+* + $!    *

!9("#""$1+! ."$-# $.* 0 + #"558$ +#"$1## ##"$* #("5 $.* 0 +  5#!(5"4 "$-* "+5 $. $.-+8"$-." + $!+1# +* 5 ##B $00 +#!!+."$-* 1 ""$ +#3*  !9("#""$ 1+! ."$-#* 4 5 1# ."$4" 8, !"$<? *  &!  $! 3* 1+ # $8+"1 ""$ & ;

+$ .  !($# 5  +  *  1 ""$ +#  #(DB" .  *   * 1 ""$ +#  +  "$  1*0#"!

5  1## ##"$    *  5 $.  "$  ."#1(  $.

!B1 $# "$* #$D $1 ".* B
8 #!5 "B .* "$#(!* !"+!(B# $! #3"$4" 8, !"$<?*  &!3* $""!

"$# ($. +, !"$# $.6* !* .5 1# .
8 #(+* +#(DB" .

*   *  1 ""$ +#  * 4  B4 .   + 1+ # $ "$  .

 .     <$$ @(+  A?+ #1$. $++ 5 #"$-* 5 $."$9( #"$D( $ !"$* ## +D $ ) $* + $  3*8 4 +31+ 0 .*

5"D +0D -+ $ .* 1 ""$ +#"5  .

"5 . $.!B1+ * $#"4 + 1+ # $ "$  D +  *  11+1+"

  (*+"0  D0  "$!+1+ "$-  * -+" 4 $!  #+ "# ."$* 1+ # $8+"1 ""$ $.."+ !"$D "##( .

# *  (*+"0!$! +$ .. !". * + 1+ # $ "$ @1 .""(#50"$

"B D($.B $$ +"$ !!+.

$! 8"*5 8   +* +"$-5 +$ .!($# 5+* 1 ""$ +#31 +(#"$- * 1+ # $1 ""$ $.8"*( @1+ ##"$- $01"$"$$* B +"# * !

# 38 ."#1# * 1+ # $1 ""$D0-+ $"$- 5"D +0* 1 ""$ +#"5  .

"5 . $.!B1+ * $#"4 + 1+ # $ "$+ "#"$- * 15 # #+ "# ."$* 1+ # $8+"1 ""$D + *  11+1+"

(*+"0
"#."+ ! .* "$*  4 $ + 1+ # $ "$D "$-"5 .D0 * 1 ""$ +#8"*"$ 1 +".$ B$*+B.

03* # B #* D . !". ."$ !!+.

$! 8"*5 8D01 ##"$- #1 )"$-+. + $.

 + +."$- $11+($"0* +"$-* B8"*"$ 1 +".(+ B$*#+B* .

 + ! "1+ 1+ # $ "$* 1 ""$ +##* D  $"5 .5 . $0 4". $! #(D# $"

 * "+!5 "BD + * !$! +$ . (*+"0"55* B  +"#. !". .D0* # ". (*+"03 # (#9(#* 55D B "$ "$ .D0* 1 +" # $ ! 

%  &' ()*+ "

 $!

% -D#  &'