M/S Gobind Enterprises v. State Of Punjab & Others
!"#$# "% #& % !# '!(!"&)(#&(&
* +"#, !(!" , -( ( !&"# * *. /012*343+5*%/34 /012*34+/3/ #"" ! #(6""#('& "7(% 7'(!"%
#!&"$"!
"# # (#)% 7'(!"%
##"$ " !!8 999 & $"!
&( ""
:" '&(::" ) )!&"'
'(!
# "# (!"
%$(" <(#="!66 !!""%1( (!&( ( *"$ " !!8(#"!&"!(!,!#<(,!&# ", "#!&"
, -( )# ',:!,#(:# ,'"(#="!'!% > ?&"#"
( !"##"
"##" !( @!&"'!0A &"$"!
"# '(##< ) , " (:"( $,#'&("
<$# ,'! # '"&"::"# !&"!(!" , -( @(==,0 #=" # '" $,#'&(" B !& , -( ( #6 ,! " !&" !(!" , -( &"
$"!
"# !(:
'" '"", "#!&"'!&"$"!
"#&( !(=" $#"6 " #" ! #6&( (:* '"( " "#(: ::%+ ::()"*(,:$,#%1(
..
(!&( ( B"#"!#" !&"#" !" $#"6 "&"
'"# (#="!
66 !!""%1( (!&( (% 8
' ,'!" ($&< '(:7"#
'(!
!&"$#"6 "&") B#!&8 %
% .B"#" , &B'(,"
!
'" (!"
B( ," !(!
)!&(!!&"$"!
"# :
( :"! "$ !6(#="! ""* !&"!'= , ,# )7"#
'(!
( :,#"! "$ !% !&"!'= B( :
( :"! ""
C" "!
"#
:" #"$:< (!"
&" #"$ " !%( !"# ' "# ) !&" #"$:<% #"
!"#(!" !&"
"6( "!
"#B( #"'!" < !
'" (!"
! "$ !!&"
""% !"#"!( $" (:!<% ( :
)B& '&!&"!'=B(! ""
C" *"$:< (!"
B(
:" #( ) !&" ," !&(! @(==,0 ! ( ()# ',:!,#"$# ,'""!
"##"'"
7" :"!!"# (!" 8
#6!&"
#"$ " !!&(!& ( :,#"! !( 7(:
:
'" '"( ! "$ ! ""#",:!
'
'(!
# '"?
#=" A 8 #"$#"" !(!
(!"
B( 6( " ! "'#"!(#<% , -( ( 1(# %&(:
&"$"!
"#
:" ; 8
&" B# ! $"!
B( $" 7 " # "# (!"
&"
#"$ " !B"#" #"'!" ! "'
"!&"#"$#"" !(!
!&"$"!
"# < $( )($"(= )# "#B !& ($"# !BB""=%( !"#(
# )( $$#!, !< &"(# )!!&"$"!
"# &"#"$ " ! 7=" *,:"8.1 !&", -( )# ',:!,#(:
# ,'"(#="!?
" "#(:A*,:"% >?&"#"
( !"##"
"##" !(@!&"
*,:"0A7 "# "# (!"
( '
'(!" !&"!'= > &"#"$#"" !(!
!&"$"!
"#B(#"-"'!" <$( )( $"(= )# "# (!"
.;.
&"#":"7( !$#7 !&"'!( !&"*,:"% ##"( < #"
"#" '"%(#"#".$# ,'" ":B.
" # " $!
"" "
" "
# % " % % #
" " ""% " & '( " %
# % " %
) % ) " )
%
"!%
%
)
%
%
)
%("
# % "
* +(
# %
" ) " ) )
) )
%
)
%
"
.8.
" #%% # )
%
"%( ,
#" )
"
" %
" )
%
)) % ) ( , #% - ) % # .
#& #"/
0" ..#%% / % /1 %%
" , , ! 2 )
%
)) %
) (
" , 2 & # "
3)
%
"
"
%% 3 " )
%
3)()
""
)%
# (
%* 4")
%
!
5) (
% " (
!
4"("(
!
( / # )4,!
( 4" ) )!
( + ")
%
3! ( &
%
#
#,
. .
23
) # & #" ("
(
% " % )
%
3"(%" %)
%
3)3
) # ) ) " & # " , . 2 & # "
"" 3 "
" () ) " " &
# " ) )) " )"&
#
( "#) " 3 " )
%
* +( " )
%
)()% %% # #
, 6 2 " )
%
%"%
# # % "
%7 8 , 4 "#!&"'!% $"# %, :""D"6$!" %B !&,!)#( !
.>.
:
'" '"%'( "!( :
&( <$:('" #$,#'&("%(:"%!#()"( $#'" )
()# ',:!,#(:$# ,'" !&" !
" 6(#="!(#"( *"$ " !'
'(!" !&") !&"$"!
"#%(&"B( '(##< )(:"%$,#'&("( !#()" ()# ',:!,#(:$# ,'" !&" !
"
6(#="!(#"(B !&,!&(7 )(:
'" '", "#!&"'!&"'
'(!
# "# &( "" '&(::" )" !&"$#"" !$"!
"&(7"'6"!!&"' ':, !&(!!&"$"!
"#6,!(7( :#"6" < ($$"(:, "#!&"'!
( (:< !&"$#7 !&"'!( !&"*,:"B,:
&B!&(!!&"$"!
"#'( !"7" !#"( ()# ',:!,#(:$# ,'" !&"
!
" 6(#="!(#"(B !&,!&(7 ):
'" '", "#!&"'!&"(#="!
66 !!""&(!&"$B"#, "#"'!
;?
A?
A !&"'!!'
'(!"!&"
()# ',:!,#(:$# ,'" ": ) )!($"# !#( )B !&,!(7(:
:
'" " &"6 (:
" # 7= )!&"$B"# , "#"'!
;?
A?
A&(7" ""
$#7 " , "#*,:"8.1 !&"*,:"&"# "# '
'(!
$("
, "#*,:"8.1 !&"*,:" ( # "#$(" , "#"'!
; !&"'! $$"(:&( "" $#7 " ()( !!&"# "#$(" <!&"66 !!"", "# "'!
; !&" '! # "# (!"
% "D,#" .
;% ( ($$"(:( :"# "#( !&"($$"(:B,: :
"()( !!&"( # "#, "# "'!
8 !&"'!
&" ," #( " 7:7" $,!" E,"!
('! ( ! B&"!&"# !&" '
'(!" ) B"#" @(==,0 # #=" # '"F B&"!&"# @(==,0 ()# ',:!,#(:$# ,'"# !FB&"!&"#!&") B"#" ": 7"#"
!&" !
" 6(#="!(#"( 1( (!&( (#!&"$"!
"#B( )!#( ) !&"#"
.
.
7 "B !&" 7:7"6" ! $,!" E,"!
('!( #"6" < ($$"(: "
)(7( :( :"()( !!&" 6$,) " # "#%!&"$"!
"#
#":")(!" !!&"(:!"# (!
7"#"6" <
:
)!&"($$"(: '"!&"$#"" !
$"!
B($"
) !& ',#!% ,'&'
#',6!( '"
!&"$"!
"#
:"( ($$"(:B !& ;
(< #6! (<!&"(6"&(:: " "'
" <!&"
$$"::(!",!&# !< 6"# !
,# ) !&" $" " '< !&" B# ! $"!
7 " # "# (!"
!&"'
'(!" ) B"#"#":"(" $"!
"#0$# ,'!
( "6( #( ! :(=& !&" (6" !&"*") !#(# " "#(: !& ,#!&" (6, !B,: "="$! !&"
D" "$ ! ( (!
(:
"
( =
(::< #($"# >6 !&( :
=".B " # ,#!&"#$"# > 6 !&!&"#"( !"#&" 7"!6" !6( "&(:: ", -"'!!!&",!'6"
!&"($$"(:
8 &"B# !$"!
$" (''# ):< !
"#$"%&' ( !
-