Dhan Raj And ORS. v. Satpal And ORS.




   
  

!"#$#%&'&() * +!( !,!($"+#-'

..#//!("'

 0#-'1'

!".!/!($"+#-'

 #'.($#("'

 )  23  
4 3



-#'#(")5 -!-1/!6$7%!"#6-"+#!..#//!("' -1(&'+//86$7%!"#6--#'.($#("'  9+#"+#-"+# #.-"#-'/%!/(#:'.!.#-;!8<#!//:#$"'## "+#,1$=;#(">  <#-##--#$""+# #.-"#--("  9+#"+#-"+#,1$=;#("'+1/$<#-#.-"#$&("+#$&=#'"> 55 55 3

6
;.1=(#$&("+#.-#'#("-#=1/!-'#%($!..#!/&'"+# ,1$=;#("  !($  $#%-##  $!"#$  ?* 6  .!''#$  <8  "+#  /#!-(#$ $$&"&(!/&'"-&%"1$=# $+% 6 !"&!/!6!&-;&(="+#,1$=;#("

!($$#%-##$!"#$@6.!''#$<8"+#/#!-(#$&7&/1$=#

1(&-  &7&'&( 6  !,.1-!6  7&$#  :+&%+  "+#  '1&"    "+# !..#//!("'+#-#&(:!'$&';&''#$!($"+#%1("#-5%/!&; "+#  $##($!("'  :!'  $#%-##$  !($  $#%-##  -  .''#''&(    "+# .-.#-"86;#("&(#$&("+#+#!$("#"+#./!&("6:!'.!''#$&( !71-"+#$##($!("'

55 -&#!%"'"+#%!'#!-#"+!"!'.#-"+#!;#($#$./!&("   "+#  ./!&("&'

!..#//!("'  <#-#  "+#  /:#-  1-"6  "+# !..#//!("'+!$&/#$!'1&"-$#%/!-!"&(""+###%""+!" "+#8+!7#<#%;#"+#:(#-"+#'1&"/!($;#!'1-&(=A!(!/' ;!-/!'!'"+#.-.#-"8+!'("<##(-#$##;#$:&"+&("+#.-#'%-&<#$ .#-&$/&;&"!"&(+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'%/!&;"+!""+#$&'.1"#$ .-.#-"8:!';-"=!=#$<8 !;,&!''!($ !$+!4&'+!('(' !($:&"+(# -!<+1'(4&-.! !;6:+&%+&'-#/#%"#$&( !;!<!($&-"+#8#!- ?3!"#-(6 !$+!4&'+!($&#$!($7&$# ;1"!"&(     6  !;,&  !''  <#%!;#  "+#  '/# ;-"=!=-  !($

-!<+1%("&(1#$"<#"+#;-"=!=## '.#-"+#;1"!"&( @6 -!<+1'/$+&';-"=!=##-&=+"'"!(" !;'(4!(+&8!6 -#'&$#("7&//!=#+!;!-#-&&("+#8#!- ?@4 
("+&':!86 !("  !;  <#%!;#  "+#  ;-"=!=##    "+#  /!($   !;,&  !''

;-"=!=- $&#$!($+!'<##('1%%##$#$<8"+#$##($!("'!("

!; !/' $&#$ !<1"  * 8#!-'  !=6  /#!7&(= <#+&($ "+-## '('6 (!;#/86+!$& !;6+!=/& !;!($;!-!"++!$& !;!/' $&#$!<1"@*8#!-'!=!($+!'<##('1%%##$#$<8+!( !,6 4#'+ !;6#7 !,!($-!"! !;;!-!"+$&#$!<1" 8#!-'!=!($+!'<##('1%%##$#$<8+&''(%++!-!''+!=/&

!;$&#$!<1"?

B8#!-'!=!($+!'<##('1%%##$#$<8+&'

(/8'(!%+(! !%+(! !; +#/&;&"!"&(--#$#;."&("+# '1&"/!($+!'#C.&-#$+#-#-#6"+#./!&("&' !..#//!("'+!7#

55 <#%;#"+#:(#-"+#;-"=!=#$.-.#-"8
(  "+#  !;#($#$  :-&""#(  '"!"#;#("  &/#$  (  <#+!/   $##($!(""+-1=++&'/#=!/-#.-#'#("!"&7#'6&":!'$#(&#$"+!"

!;,&!''!($ !$+!4&'+!(+!$;-"=!=#$"+#$&'.1"#$.-.#-"8 :&"+ -!<+1 
":!'!/'$#(&#$"+!" -!<+1'/$+&';-"=!=## -&=+"'"!(" !;
":!''"!"#$"+!""+#;1"!"&(;-"=!=#:!' '!(%"&(#$!""+#<!%A !;,&!''!($&'("<&($&(=(+&;!($ !"#-+&'$#!"+6+&'/#=!/+#&-'
":!''"!"#$"+!""+#%("#'"&(= $##($!("!($#!-/&#-+&'!"+#-+!$<##(%1/"&7!"&(="+#/!($!" 7&//!=#  +!;!+#-&6  #+'&/  !($  &'"-&%"  !"&!/!  +# !..#//!("'  !($  "+#&-  .-#$#%#''-'5&(5&("#-#'"  +!$  <##( %1/"&7!"&(="+#/!($!"7&//!=#!"+(&!(4!/!(6#+'&/ !,.1-!6:&"+ "+#&-;1"1!/%('#("+#;!(&.1/!"&("+#-#7#(1#-#%-$:!' $(#  !"  "+#  <!%A    "+#  %("#'"&(=  $##($!("  !($  &'  &(%--#%" +#-#-#6.-!8#-:!';!$#-=-!(" $#%-##--#%7#-8  .''#''&(&(!71-$##($!("
(-#./&%!"&(6"+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'-#&"#-!"#$"+#!%"'

'"!"#$&("+#./!&(" 
":!''"!"#$"+!""+#%1("#-5%/!&;:!'(" :&"+&(/&;&"!"&(

-;"+#./#!$&(='6//:&(=&''1#':#-#-!;#$)5  9+#"+#- !;,&!''!($ !$+!4&'+!(+!$;-"=!=#$ "+#'1&"/!($&(!71- -!<+1'(4&-.!!'!//#=#$&("+# ./!&(">

5@5  9+#"+#- -!<+1'/$+&';-"=!=##-&=+"'"!(" !;

!'!//#=#$>

 9+#"+#-%1("#-5%/!&;&';!&("!&(!</#>

@ 9+#"+#-"+#./!&("&'!-#'1%%#''-'&(&("#-#'"!("

!;;-"=!=##>

* 9+#"+#-./!&("&'+!7#<#%;#:(#-'"+#;-"=!=#$ /!($<8#/1C"&;#>

 9+#"+#-./!&("&'!-##("&"/#$"$#%/!-!"&(!'.-!8#$ ->

? 9+#"+#-$##($!("'!-##("&"/#$".''#''&(!'.-!8#$ -&("+#%1("#-5%/!&;!($%('#D1#("&!/%--#%"&("+##("-&#'&( "+#-#7#(1#-#%-$>  B 9+#"+#-   "+#  %1("#-  %/!&;  -  .''#''&(  &'  :&"+&( "&;#> 



#/&# (!$$&"&(!/&''1#:!'!/'-!;#$)5  9+#"+#-'1&"&'(";!&("!&(!</#> 
''1#:!'$#%&$#$!=!&('""+#./!&("&' !..#//!("'

!($ %('#D1#("/86  &''1#'    6  @6  * !($  :#-# !/' $#%&$#$ !=!&('""+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'
''1#'?!($B:#-#"!A#(1. "=#"+#-!($$#%&$#$&(!71-$##($!("' 
''1#:!' -!;#$!($"+#'!;#:!'!/'$#%&$#$&(!71-$##($!("' ('#D1#("/86&''1#:!'!/'$#%&$#$&(!71-$##($!("'

5*5 ('#D1#("/86"+#%1("#-5%/!&;"+#$##($!("':!'$#%-##$!($ $#%-##-.''#''&(:!'.!''#$&(!71-"+#$##($!("'+# &($&(=':#-#!&-;#$&(!..#!/ ""+#"&;#!-=1;#("'<#-#"+&'1-"6"+#/#!-(#$ %1('#/-"+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'+!'%(%#$#$"+!"&(7&#:"+# /!"#'"/!:/!&$$:(<8"+#.#C1-"6!;-"=!=##%!(("%/!&; "&"/#("+#<!'&'#/1C"&;#+#-#-#6+#+!'(".-#''#$"+# .-!8#--$#%/!-&(="+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'"<#"+#:(#-"+# '1&"/!($("+#<!'&'"+!""+#"&;#"-#$##;"+#;-"=!=#+!' #C.&-#$ :#7#-6"+#/#!-(#$%1('#/-"+#./!&("&' !..#//!("'

+!'.-#''#$"+!""+#$#%-##-.''#''&(%1/$("<#.!''#$&( !71-"+#$##($!("'!'"+#;-"=!=#+!'("<##(-#$##;#$ $#%&$#"+#'!&$&''1#6//:&(='1<'"!("&!/D1#'"&( /!:&'-!;#$)5 E9+#"+#-"+#&($&(='-#%-$#$<8<"+"+#1-"'<#/: !-#.#-7#-'#!($!=!&('""+#-#%-$>F
!;"+#7&#:"+!""+#-#&'7#-:+#/;&(=#7&$#(%#( &/#"'+:"+!""+#/!($:!';-"=!=#$<8 !;,&!''!($ !$+!

4&'+!(  &(  !71-    -!<+1  !($  /!"#-  (  -!<+1  +!$  '/$  +&'

;-"=!=##-&=+"'"!(" !;+#./!&("&'!-#"+#/#=!/+#&-' !(" !;.#-1'!/%.8"+#;1"!"&( C  '+:'"+!"&( "+#  8#!-  ?6  &( "+# .-#'#(%#   -!<+1 ;-"=!=##  !($ "+# 3!;<!-$!-"+#7&//!=#6;-"=!=#:!''!(%"&(#$&("+#.1</&%

55 +#!-&(=%%-$&(=/86"+##("-&#':#-#;!$#&("+#-#7#(1#-#%-$ !($"+#'!;#!-#<#&(=%!--8-:!-$"&//$!"# 7#(:+#("+# ;1"!"&('-#=!-$&(=&(+#-&"!(%#"+#;-"=!=-!($;-"=!=## :#-#'!(%"&(#$6"+#'!;##("-&#':#-#%!--&#$-:!-$+#'!;# !-#<-(#1"-;"+#%.8"+#!;!<!($&-"+#8#!- B5B?

(:!-$' +#./#!"+#/#!-(#$%1('#/--#'.($#("'&'"+!" "+#;1"!"&(:!''!(%"&(#$!""+#<!%A"+#;-"=!=-!($6 "+#-#-#6"+#'!;#&'("<&($&(=("+#;
":!'1-"+#-!-=1#$ "+!"!'.#-"+#;1"!"&(6"+#/!($:!';-"=!=#$- '@ 5 &(%#  "+#  7!/1#  :!'  ;-#  "+!(  '   56  "+#-#-#6  "+#  -!/ ;-"=!=#:!'(".#-;&''&</# +#  ;!""#-  +!'  <##(  '#""/#$  <8  "+#  !1"+-&"!"&7# .-(1(%#;#(""+#(2</#1.-#;#1-"&(



   
     

 &7&/ 1-"!'#'*  6:+#-#&("+#.#C1-"+#/$"+!""+#-!/ ;-"=!=#  &'  7!/&$  !'  "+#  .''#''&(  :!'  !/'  $#/&7#-#$  "  "+# ;-"=!=-+#;!""#-:!'!/'%('&$#-#$<8"+&'1-"&(     

 
 


   * @

 &7&/ *@6:+#-#&(!%!'#.#-"!&(&(=""!"# !"&!/!!($

  6&":!'+#/$"+!""+#"!"# !"&!/!!($   <#%!;# "+#.!-""!"# 1(,!<:&"+##%"-; *!($"+!"$1-&(= "+!""&;#!($#!-/&#-6"+#-!/;-"=!=#:!'.#-;&''&</#+#'&;&/!-

5?5 7&#:':#-##C.-#''#$<8! 1//#(%+"+&'1-"&(
 



    6
 B 1(,!<!($!-8!(!?

  +# ;-"=!=# :!' ;!$#%;.1/'-&/8-#=&'"-!</#(/8:+#("+# .-7&'&('-!('#- -.#-"8%":#-#;!$#!../&%!</#""+# "!"# 1(,!<$;&""#$/86&( ?6"+#.-7&'&('-!('#-

-.#-"8%"  :#-#  ("  ;!$#  !../&%!</#  "  "+#  "!"#    1(,!< +#-#-#6"+#-!/;-"=!=#%1./#$:&"+$#/&7#-8.''#''&( :!'=$;-"=!=#
"&'"<#("#$"+!"$1-&(="+#&-/&#"&;#6 !;,& !''  !($  !$+!  4&'+!(  $&$  ("  %+!//#(=#  "+#  #("-&#'  &(  "+# !;!<!($&6:+&%+!-##C&'"&(='&(%#/(=!($(:6!"#-';!(8 8#!-'6"+#'1%%#''-''!&$;-"=!=-'%!(("'!8"+!""+##("-&#' !-#:-(=!($;!$#!""+#<!%A"+#;-"=!=-
"<#&(='6&"&' +#/$  "+!"  <"+  "+#  1-"'  <#/:  #--#$  &(  +/$&(=  "+!"  "+# !..#//!("'!-# :#-#(""+#;-"=!=##&(.''#''&("+# '1&"/!($
"&'+#/$"+!""+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'!-#&(.''#''&( "+#'1&"/!($!'"+#;-"=!=##- '@ 5+#&($&(='-#%-$#$ <8<"+"+#1-"'<#/:&("+&'-#=!-$!-#-#7#-'#$ :6%;&(=""+#(#C"D1#'"&(!'":+#"+#-"+#/:#- 1-":!',1'"&&#$&(=-!("&(="+#$#%-##-.''#''&(&(!71- "+#$##($!("'>
!;"+#7&#:"+!"'1%+-$#-'!-#&//#=!/ (%#&"&' +#/$  "+!"  "+#  ./!&("&'

!..#//!("'  :#-# &( .''#''&(   "+#  '1&" .-.#-"8!';-"=!=##6(.''#''&(%!(<#$#/&7#-#$1(/#''"+#

5B5 ;-"=!=#&'-#$##;#$
("+#:-&""#('"!"#;#("6"+#$##($!("'+!$ $#(&#$"+#;-"=!=#!($+!$%/!&;#$$#%-##-.''#''&(("+# <!'&'    "&"/#  !($  ;!$#  "+#  %1("#-5%/!&;6  :+&%+  :!'  !//:#$ :#7#-6  '&(%#  &"  &'  +#/$  "+!"  "+#  ./!&("&' !..#//!("'  !-#  "+# ;-"=!=##&(.''#''&("+#'1&"/!($6"+#.''#''&(%!(("<# $#/&7#-#$""+#$##($!("'1(/#''"+#;-"=!=#&'-#$##;#$ 
" <#&(='6"+#&($&(='<"+"+#1-"'<#/:=-!("&(=$#%-##- .''#''&(""+#$##($!("'!-#'#"!'&$# '!-#'1/""+#-#=&(=$&'%1''&(6&"&'+#/$"+!"<"+ "+#1-"'!%"#$&//#=!//8!($&(.#-7#-'#;!((#-&(-#%-$&(='"+# &($&(='"+!""+#-!/;-"=!=#:!'(".#-;&''&</#!($"+!""+# -#'.($#("'  +!7#  !&/#$  "  .-7#  "+!"  "+#8  !-#  "+# ;-"=!=##&(.''#''&("+#'1&"/!($
(7&#:"+#;!""#-6"+#.-!8#-;!$#<8"+#/#!-(#$ %1('#/-"+#./!&("&'

!..#//!("'&'!//:#$!($"+#$#%-##- .''#''&(=-!("#$<8:!8%1("#-5%/!&;&''#"!'&$#!($"+# %1("#-5%/!&;"+#$##($!("'!/''"!($'$&';&''#$ +#  !..#!/ &'  !%%-$&(=/8 !//:#$  "  "+# !<7#("#$ #C"#("   :#7#-6  &"  '+!// !/:!8' <# .#( " "+# $##($!("'  " -#$##;"+#;-"=!=#!($'##A"+#.''#''&("+#/!($

3

    * ',A'