High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3072/2019disposed of

State Of Haryana Through Collector, Gurgaon v. Subhan Khan And Another

2026-04-09Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja12 pages

! " #$%$&'( )

! " #$%$&'( ) # ( " # ( " # ( " # ( " *+

, , , , ( (- ( (- ( (- ( (-

. /! ) $" #0!#1"$" /! ) $" #0!#1"$" /! ) $" #0!#1"$" /! ) $" #0!#1"$" 2233 2233 2233 2233 4 4 4 4 /$' 5 ( !

/$' 5 ( !

/$' 5 ( ! 2 2 2 2 #- #- #- #- 6'0!&$/ #! 5!/ $& 6'0!&$/ #! 5!/ $& 6'0!&$/ #! 5!/ $& 6'0!&$/ #! 5!/ $& %,- ,7 & 1("1 ,8

, 2233 9:

1 ; ,' <5=< , 9:

1 ; ,5 />/=, 1 ; ,& )

;1 ; ,,%)

;1 ;

,,2 ?3 , ,%// 1 ; /=,7 1 ;

,,2 ? ,:#<<1 =,= @@@@ 5!/ $&1&, 3 5!/ $&1&, 3 5!/ $&1&, 3 5!/ $&1&, 3 AB 4 <<, ,12, 37 ,>

. .

+D'&E

C* 1*+*

C + 1

.1 +. F

*1 , 7> 33

3 ; , = << G= ;3; 3

G= , : 7,;81

,7> : ,<

B '8 8 2, 31 33> 7 3

783

3(,&= >1=,

, 7, ,, H ,#=, ,#=, ,#=, ,#=,I

A B ', 38 >1 2, 1 , 3 78 ,2 ?3 ,1= ,;= ;33 > =,=13 =1 (, "=,=>, < ;

* * = = ,/*. 0 G= 1+* ,,H+* +* +* +* I,2;38 ,2=732=,21 <381 J ,K >, < ,:1 =,=L = ,/ +* 2 780 G=#33, ,,H0# 0# 0# 0#I *1 ,78 < ,: ;

3= M*1

?E2, ,=2 , 2 ,<,

?E2,

, ,,< >3 7 >, > 33, =,87 = , +* A*B >>,; , 13 ,2, ,, ,79,< /+ +*,, ,, 3 ,#=,1 < 7 2 ,38 2 ;

1 3 ,E > < ,: ;

3= M F1

?E 2, , ,,2; =, AFB

33> 78 , 33 ,:#<<7 ,#=,78 8 3> F*

3 H/<%9 ,4/ ,8 /<%9 ,4/ ,8 /<%9 ,4/ ,8 /<%9 ,4/ ,8

,I 4

F 2 78 #=,

31 < , ,< 7 : 3 , #=,

33>7,;

-E J2,= 3 >, 2* <2=>

!K!K , , 783 #=,73

,38> =2 9= >< 673 /=2,< #=, 5=< , 4, ;/ , %,

1F*/## .1, < 3 7 > =7G=38 ,< 9= >< 673/=2,<#=, </>6 =2, = < />6 =2, 7

2= 783 =3 ,> ,3 , ; = </>6 =2, 1 1 2, = 78 / 3 ,1 , ,G=, 7 , , 2=,2 ,<

3= #, 28 ;,8 33 7 , ,3;

2 ; = 2 , , ;> 7 K < =, ;,1 2,3= =, ,< ,9> , 3 7>< , <2,; = : 7 ,#=, ;,1 < ;>7 , 33 ;

3= ;>7 ,< 387 2, = 78 3 ,1 <8 21 < =3 ,G=, =,, , 783 ,#=, , >381<2=> 783 =,73 < , , ,< 7 : , #=, , , < ,

, 7 < , 3 3,

8 ,, 782 ,2 , , , ,7 , 3 (, &= >1 "=,>

. G= 2, 2, >8 , 1=3 7 22, 1 < , , 2 ,38L A.B ,

,13 ,#=,, , <2=>

,78< ,:;

3= , .1

?E2, ,1 3 78 8 3>2, 3 78 3 ,1 / 33 ,: #<<1 =,= 7 , #=,

#! /- #! /- #! /- #! /- '! 0 !5!# !!/!- '! 0 !5!# !!/!- '! 0 !5!# !!/!- '! 0 !5!# !!/!-E B

<2=>>

, 1 3 =3

2233 ?/ 33 3 =3 ,2,> ,: #<<1

=,=1 =7< 3 , #=, 22, 2, = 78<2,2,2,2;0 =3 3 !KE!KE =3 ;7 <,38 , , 32,,= , 3 < ,:;

3= 78 0#1 =1 <2=>

2 78 3 ,#=, 3 737 3 3 / ,:#<<1 =,=,7 33 '! 0 !

'! 0 !

'! 0 !0(N!/- 0(N!/- 0(N!/- 0(N!/-E A+B %, , 1 3 =3 , ,2 E3 , =7< : ; ;

3 73,, 1 2,; 3 ,3

,<> 2 , 3

!K%E 2, = 78 , ,< , 0 =3=1=7< 223

O = 7 2, 2, ,1 ,; ,<

!K %E = ,, 3 ,#=,, ,=> ;>, 22,2, 22,

;=, 3 , = ,<> 27

= = ,/* +*11

* =12, 8 7 < , 3,, 1< ,:;

3= ,G=, 7 ,E 3 2, ,,

,,7 33 , 32, ,, 78/ ,:#<<1 =,=,7 < ( /#$// (!/ "- ( /#$// (!/ "- ( /#$// (!/ "- ( /#$// (!/ "-E AB

; 3 =3 , 2 , > ,=> 2,7: 33 ,, =7 =7< <

7 ,2 ?3 , A B ' ,2, > =,,1 3 3 2, = 78 3 , 33 / =,, , 3 < , ,2, = ,= ,-E /

/ 2, = 78 2, = 78 2, = 78 2, = 783 ,-E !K7 !K7 !K7 !K7 / ? / ? / ? / ? ( ( ( ( , , , , 5E 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ # , # , # , # , '

%, '

%, %, %, %, %, , , , , 433 > 433 > 433 > 433 > !K%E * ?

E. F1

?E 1F

=,= !K%E *?*

E *F1

=,= /

/ 2, = 78 2, = 78 2, = 78 2, = 78/ - / - / - / -E !K7 !K7 !K7 !K7 / ? / ? / ? / ? ( ( ( ( , , , , 5E 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ # , # , # , # , '

%, %, '

%, %, , , , , 433 > 433 > 433 > 433 > !KE *.?+ F

E +1

?E .

1 ?E

=,= !KE * ?+ F

E+ +1

?E F1 ?E

=,= !KE +

?E 1

=,= !KE* +

?E 1

=,= !KEF

?E 1

=,= !KE.

?E 1

=,=

!KE

?E 1

=,= !KE+ *.?

?E 1

=,= !KE

?E 1FF1FFF?E

=,= !KE *+?

?E 1

=,= AB ,< 7; 731 7 3 !KE !KE

+ F 2, = 78 2233 E/ 2, 2, 2 = ,/* +* 1 = 7 ,3 =2 =,,<,1 9 ,

> !K%E !KE !KE 3>

* 780# > 2, G=1 7 , 3 ,< , 3 <2 ; ,>

3 ;PE E;P3 ,3 ,<>2 , 3 !K%E 1!KE !KE 1K, ,= ,-E ( 3

( 3

( 3 ( 3 ,<> 2 ( 3 ,<> 2 ( 3 ,<> 2 ( 3 ,<> 2 , 533 533 533 533 ,

, 533 533 533 533 ,

, !K7 !K7 !K7 !K7 533 533 533 533 ,

, 5E 5 5 5 5E ?*

+? ?? E. !K% !K% !K% !K%E

+??

? +??

. F?

E ?

? E. !K !K !K !KE ??.

??.

E+ ?

E !KE* ??F

EF F?

+E !K !K !K !KEF ??.

??.

EF . +E

+E !K !K !K !KE. ??.

??.

+E +?

? +?

!K !K !K !KE ??.

??.

? +E *?

FE.

E F +E

? E . +E ?

E. ? +E

* +E *?* +E

F +E F +E +?

E 5 *+ +E

, * 3 < ,3 ?

; 7;1 3 2 ,3 ,<> 2 , !K%E 33 !KE !KE = , 3 1 =1 ; 8 2 <3 , =, 2 3 ;

3= ,, ,1

,< 3 7 , , 2=,2 ,< < ,:;

3= A B =

,< K 1 3

!K%E 2, > <,;= ;33 > =,=1; . ,3 3 M F1

?E 7 2, 1F

?E2, ,1 >> 32, 7,3 =2 ,

> < ,: ;

3=1 2 3381 : 3 78 I732K#=, ,,< 34/ ,8 1,2, ,,< 34/ ,8 1,2, ,,< 34/ ,8 1,2, ,,< 34/ ,8 1,2,

**##;3 F+I

**##;3 F+I1111 2,>;

3= 3K<23 , , 3 > < ,: ;

3= <2=3,8 3

G=3;

2 >, 2

+ ,< ,,< 3I ,,< 3I ,,< 3I ,,< 3I =2, , K, ,= ,-E J

1, ,<=323 < 33,231 ,2, 7 ;

3 73 ; , < > <2 / , 3> 3 <2 < ,> = 1 3> 3 2,>, <2 < 2, =3 7 8<= 73 , ,<>< ,:;

3= =7G=381 2238

G= = < 3= 3=K< 8=7 = , 35 9,= , 35 9,= , 35 9,= , 35 9,= ; / %=9 71

F /## *

; / %=9 71

F /## *

; / %=9 71

F /## *

; / %=9 71

F /## * , #=, 3

33- Q 3 , , , ;, 3 K<23 , , , <3 ,3 1>, 3,=3 > K<23 ,1 7 , 1 7 ,

2 N3 7><2=3,38 : 8 ,< 2,1 3 > ;

3= <3 , 3 3 38 ; 7 , , 7 33> 2=, , 33> 33, , 7= <

G=Q

+ ; 7,, / << / << / << / << />;/ %1

/>;/ %1

./##

./## , ,E9= >7 #=,3

;

,=2,

,< ,=< ,, ,<=323 ;

3 73 , , 1#=, 33,38> ;

3= K<23 ,=32,

33 ,,, >1 3=3 > ;, > ;

3=,< 87<,>,==L A B

:> =

!K%E

1 , G= 2, << ;

* C ,<> 2 ,= F<17

!K%E

= = ,/* +* 1= 73 22, 7

;=, ,2 ?3 ,; >>, 2 33

= , =,= =,,=,,= 78 => ' #381 %, / 1 ( < 1 ", ,:1

1 %,3 %=<2 , <<, 3 73<C 78 3 ,#=,<2=> A B 2; >

,, 78 3 , #=,7 < , 3; ,, ,23 3 2 3

;

> 3 = , G= 2 .

K, ,= ,-E J . < %N* 0 3 # =3 7 ,7= 78 ,2 ,EK < 12 3813 = 73 72,=<

>, 2 3;

3= ;,> < 8 < , <<, 3, 3, =, 3 < =,,=22, 78 < %N / (,

< 1

2,; 23 > 3 ;

,= , < K> =,=, ,= ,<23 !K%*1 3 , = , =,= 1=,,= 78 =>' #381%,/ 1( < 1 ", ,:1

1%,3%=<21 ,RRRRRRRRRR KKK KKK KKK RRRRR < 8 =,,77,; 3 !K% = =:, =,= , 3

2, =,,= 78;

,=,

= , =,,= 78;

,=;37 <

3RRL

; , ,8 ;>72 =78, 3 =3,2,> 2233 ,;, >1= ,=< 1;

> 3 3

2 3;

3= 1 22, M O2, =<FO 7>, ;,7 2, 1F

?E2, , ,; ,<

!K%E <+1.

?E2, , A*B

, < 33 3 2 ,3 ,<> 2 ,

!K%E , 1 2, < =,+ 5 3 < ,3 , 3 !K%E 2, . ,3 ;,1 2,= 3 2, = ,, 787 1 7 , , ,= ,3 7> 3 ,< < 33 231 , ,1 ,, 3 3 2 3

;

> ,7>= ,, 3 <<, 3 2=,21 ;> 33 ,8 7 ; <

3 ;

3 73 31 :2> < 3 !K%E 3 ,< 2 ,

1 =M O;,7 2,2, , ,; ,< 3

!K%E 1 < 33 , =3 =

,=2< .1 ?E2, , AFB =,,1>;

G= ,, = ,2=732=,21 <381J ,K >, < ,:1 =,=L =1 2233 ,=

, 83 2<=< =3P , , =,K2 =, 2,; >

3 ,==, 3 <=1= ;32< 7<2 A.B /<=3 =381 3 =3 , ,2 ?3 ,

3 #=, ,<

* + = = , / * +* 33 78

+ + 780#K, 2,= ,/ +*1 3 = < ,;= C 3 K 38 22 2, ;33 > =,=(,"=,=>, <

,2=732=,21 <381J ,,= /=73'=3 >1

, 3G= ,,L < ,:;

3=,2 G=

338,E M*1 1 .

?E2, ,; , ,

. F

.2 78 #=,

+ 3 H < 0 3 4 / ,8 < 0 3 4 / ,8 < 0 3 4 / ,8 < 0 3 4 / ,8

,I,3;

2,, K, ,= ,-E J# ,>2=3 ,

,=<

7;1 =23 ,

,< 1 #=, , ; 3 ,;72 ,38 2 < , ,78 33 K 7; 3 ,E

2233 3 3 ,;<2 ,

, *1 1 .

?E 2, ,1 ,<

= , /* ' 13 , 33 373 ,

33, =,87 ;

3 73<1= ,,3;

2,; L 0 =3 ,>7 / 33 ,: #<<1 =,= ;7 73,;,

, , 7 ,2 ?3 ,

A.B !; ,<> 27 2,;=

G= ,, =2=,=

* + 2,

;

* 1 22, 223 MO2, =< , 8 ,

<12, * <

?E2, , > 38

, ,<;

3= 78#=,7 3

!K%E A B , >381 < ,: ;

3= , 3 = , G=

= ,<, .

.1 ?

?E2, , 2, , 2, , 2, ,

= ,/* +*

13 , 33 373

, 33 =,87 , 2,; = ,2,; +* < =2

3 , 33 3 7 3 , 3 =<7 ,,=2 A+B #G=381 ; = <

, 7;1

32, ,, , ,,782 ,38 33

, ,< 3 3 78/ ,:#<<1 =,=

,,78 < AB N,;, 3 , ? ; = ,= 38 K2,

3?,E79

, 3>, 3> 3, ;7 <23

1 8 33 7 37,8 : K= 2, 78 <;> 22,2, 223 7 ,3 !K=>#=,

B 332 > 223 1 81 33 3 2 5!/ $& 5!/ $& 5!/ $& 5!/ $& 2,3 2,3 2,3 2,3

1111

. &$("!

&$("!

&$("! : N,2 :>?, )? N,,2, 73 )?