← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5184/2019disposed of

State Of Punjab Through The Executive Engineer Provincial Division v. M/S U.P. State Bridge Corporation Ltd. And Others

2020-03-05Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal3 pages



          #$%&'%()*)+,  - 

    $#$%& .+/#0 11%22#+$     3   !4*  $#$%)'5% 1#$)+6$'#+'$7%* %*1+'%+$*  !,  86!

  96

%*%+$, !#.#:97.#+#;; .+/#0 !97#+'<#+);':(#$%;#+' !#=%%7#+'<#+);':(#$%; &%*1+'%+$*#+'  >>>>>>>  96; 6"

7%)+*$#+$#11%#2&)2%'.+'%%($)+-?&$7%0)$#$)+#+' +()2)#$)+($;

@&*7$;$7%

@($")*')%($%'#5#)+*$$7%'%'#$%'

 1#**%'0A$7%'')$)+#2)*$)($.'5%;#2#+'7#')*=)**)+5#+ #112)(#$)+&)2%'0A$7%#11%22#+$$#$%.+'%%($)+-&$7%

@($ 6%#+%'  $#$%  (.+*%2  *.0=)$*  $7#$  #*  1%  %($)+  "  &  $7% ==%()#2.$*;==%()#2):)*)+#+'==%()#211%22#$%):)*)+& )57.$*($; &*7$;$7% ($"$7%$#$%8*#112)(#$)+&)2%'.+'% %($)+-&$7%

@($<#*%B.)%'$0%'%()'%'0A#==%()#2.$0.$ )+$7%)+*$#+$(#*%$7%*#=%7#*0%%+#'/.')(#$%'.1+0A$7%'')$)+#2)*$)($ .'5%;#2#+'7#<7)(7.$#$$7%$)=%&1#**)+5&$7%)=1.5+%''%<#* +$'%*)5+#$%'#*#==%()#2.$ +$7)*%5#'%2)#+(%)*12#(%'+# (==.+)(#$)+  '#$%'  ?    %(%):%'  0A  $7%  $#$%  &=  $7%  )*$)($  %**)+* .'5%;#2#+'7# <7%%)+ )$)* *$#$%' $7#$+  @ '')$)+#2 )*$)($.'5%<#*$7%+2A.$<7)(7<#*'%*)5+#$%'#*#==%()#2.$ #+'$7#$+2A+#+'#&$% @ $7%.$*&'')$)+#2)*$)($.'5%*; #+')+%#(7)*$)($)+$7%$#$%& .+/#0<%%#2*'%*)5+#$%'#*==%()#2 .$*   $  7#*  &.$7%  0%%+  *$#$%'  )+  $7%  #&%*#)'  (==.+)(#$)+  $7#$  +

CD   )%  $7%  '#$%  <7%+  $7%  )=1.5+%'  '%  <#*  1#**%'  0A  $7% '')$)+#2)*$)($.'5%;#2#+'7#;)$<#*+$'%*)5+#$%'#*#==%()#2 .$ 6%#+%'(.+*%2&(+$%*$)+5%*1+'%+$*#+''%*+$ ')*1.$%$7%#0:%&#($.#21*)$)+ %($)+"&$7% ($=#A0%#':#+$#5%.*2A%&%%'$ 7%*#=%%#'*#*.+'%, E#+*&%&1%+')+5(#*%* "

FFF FFF FFF "22*.)$*#+'#112)(#$)+*;)+(2.')+5#112)(#$)+*.+'%$7%0)$#$)+ #+'+()2)#$)+($;

@@&

@";%2#$)+5$#(==%()#2')*1.$% &#1%()&)%'3#2.%1%+')+5)+#+A():)2(.$)+#+A')*$)($#%#)+ %*1%($  &  <7)(7  #  ==%()#2  .$  7#*  0%%+  (+*$)$.$%';  *7#22  0% $#+*&%%'$*.(7==%()#2.$

:)'%'$7#$+*.)$#112)(#$)+<7%%$7%&)+#2/.'5=%+$7#*0%%+ %*%:%'0A$7%.$1)$$7%(+*$)$.$)+&$7%==%()#2):)*)+ $7%==%()#2.$*7#220%$#+*&%%'%)$7%.+'%*.0*%($)+" *.0*%($)+"G 7%#&%B.$%'1:)*)+(2%#2A1:)'%*$7#$#&$%(=)+5)+$ &(%&$7% ($;<7%%:%#==%()#2.$7#*0%%+%*$#02)*7%';#22 *.)$*  #+'  #112)(#$)+*  1%$#)+)+5  $  #  (==%()#2  ')*1.$%  )+(2.')+5 #112)(#$)+*.+'%$7%

@($" #%%B.)%'$0%$#+*&%%'$$7%'.2A '%*)5+#$%'==%()#2.$ *1%1:)*$%($)+"+2A$7*% *.)$*4#112)(#$)+*<7%%$7%&)+#2/.'5=%+$7#*0%%+%*%:%'0A$7%.$1) $$7%(+*$)$.$)+&$7%==%()#2):)*)+4.$#%+$$0%$#+*&%%' + $7% )+*$#+$(#*% $7% .+')*1.$%' &#($.#21*)$)+ )* $7#$ $7% #112)(#$)+&)2%'0A$7%$#$%.+'%%($)+-&$7%

@($;<7)(7%2#$%'$ #(==%()#2')*1.$%0%$<%%+$7%1#$)%*;<#*&)+#22A#'/.')(#$%'.1+0A$7% '')$)+#2  )*$)($  .'5%  ;  #2#+'7#  +    +  <7)(7  '#$%  # ==%()#2.$7#'#2%#'A0%%+%*$#02)*7%'#$#2#+'7#<7)(7<#*+$$7% .$&'')$)+#2)*$)($.'5%;#2#+'7##*#$$7#$$)=%$7%.$&

C-D '')$)+#2)*$)($.'5%;#2#+'7#<#*$7%+2A.$<7)(77#'0%%+ '%*)5+#$%'#*#==%()#2.$ $<#*+ @ $7#$$7%.$& '')$)+#2)*$)($.'5%;#2#+'7#<#*#2*'%*)5+#$%'#*#==%()#2 .$0.$<)$71*1%($):%%&&%($7.*;+ $7%.$&'')$)+#2 )*$)($.'5%;#2#+'7#0%)+5+$'%*)5+#$%'#*#==%()#2.$')' +$7#:%$7%/.)*')($)+$1#**$7%)=1.5+%''%#+'%*.2$#+$2A&$7#$ %#*+#2+%$7%)=1.5+%''%)**%$#*)'% 7%#112)(#$)+&)2%'0A$7%#11%22#+$$#$%.+'%%($)+-&$7%

@($*7#22+<0%12#(%'0%&%#.$<7)(7)*(=1%$%+$$(+*)'% #+'#'/.')(#$%.1+$7%*#=%)+#(('#+(%<)$72#< )+(%$7%1#$)%*7#:%0%%+2)$)5#$)+5&$7%2#*$#0.$#'%(#'%; $7%=1%$%+$.$0%&%<7=$7%=#$$%<.2'+<0%2)*$%')*%B.%*$%' $&)+#22A'%()'%$7%#112)(#$)+&)2%'0A$7%#11%22#+$$#$%.+'%%($)+-& $7%

@($%F1%')$).*2A0.$+$2#$%$7#+*)F=+$7*&=$7%'#$%&%(%)1$ &#(1A&$7)*'% 7%#11%#2)*')*1*%'&)+$7%#0:%$%=*

 -   C 96D *7#=*7%    H7%$7%*1%#I)+54%#*+%'

, %*4 H7%$7%%1$#02% ,%*4