Deepak Devkishan Ahuja And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others




   
      

 !"#$!%&'&"() * +*  



 
 





  









 
  


























    










 ) ,- * .
/
 .* 0   

!

 
 "

#
$


 

%%#
$

 
  


&


'%#
 !


 

( %' 
) "#
$

   
*+





,,,,,
/
 .* 01* 23   - .

 
  



$
/+0

 ) .
*"
  


#
+1+2


3  "

4&
 "
*56

--17+1+6


$
617#
6+1#
-+1)
 
& 
 %
8#
-071
 
$
+6
 
&99" $#

%$

   --#
 
*"


 
% "'
%%
 
$ 3 %
$ "
  "
  9
  
 
%9 :$99 
"9 

-7-++1+6


;


+

+ 
$ 
'
 

 "

1+15+1+/
.
 
8 

 

'
$



 
% 
%
8 :&%%3
" 
 


.
 
8 #

"
 
9 
$
" "
 
$99 


' 

 


 
"
'
$%%

2   

 

#



$
9


+

= $%
" 
- 
8% #
 
*"
  %

9
*
/--

--10+1+/
< 
% 
;$
 


 $


 
   

     !" # "$$ %  &"' " "$  (") #  

 ! "  #  *!+ *)+  , -'   *!+ , -    + *!+ , - ) " (

  !" # ! "."$$ 
 / 0"$ .!" 0 % 1 2) 0"
 #    ' $ ' "$  !" %  &"'  !" .

 #  *!+ *)+  , -' *!+, -  +*!+, -" )" ) "32' ! "  2)4"$ # "$! '2#  $   "#!"#  $$  (4  !  0 ' )"

 4"

"""

$  !  32   5'  !"

(#  " 0  4"0  # "$! 6 6 > 

$

%


  
 $ 9

 $99 
9 " 
 

 



 .

 $

 
 % 
 
  
9 " 
 
 

/ > 
$

%
 "
 %

   
*
+

 
%9 
 

$ $  $

 
4&
 
%%
 
 

2

$ 3 %
$ "
 "
3 

7 
4 %%
) $
 
8 
 
9

?

   



  

@


           ! "#  $ $ "

%   & '

 






8 /" "

'   $  (      )(  $ 0"4(! ( " ( "

"9  !"4 :"8
"$ ; / "  !!    (  "4   " 4   ( "!"    :"   $' ' <" !)(

"$ !"

 "$  "

<" <"   

"$-

<

=  2 (  )     (       * '5"7(  >  2' ? ! 

##"

!  

 "$ "#!"#    $" "40 4"

@ / $ "

"$-

) !"!"

4! ' ! $ 0!'(  4)  "$$ "4 ! "$ "6

  / !"4 " " "#!  -

   )

"$)-

 -



! "  #2" (

  (

"  !!"    "  ) " 0' 9! "   "    # !"' 

 

"$4"

  ($"'9 "$

 !   $  !"4   )     4 

6

"0 "+"$"#!

"")

"$-



A  &"#(0"'( !"$:"

="$  ;' "  "

   #'  4  "4 !"4 :"8
"$;

  / "#!"# '   #"

 "'     " "$ #"   "   ()"

 2   "

 "$ -

   $  !"4  :" 8
 "$  ;

"

"#!"# 4' '  " # 

 $"'  <$ "

 "$-

<* !

 4)0

##" 

" '  " # '"##  "  "

 #   $  (   4 (  "

 ( 9 0 !"4 :"8
"$; )"$"#!"# '(  "" !"4 # "

 /)(

0  " ! (9 "$

!"4' ! (  "$!#"" "$"  ! )   4  

 "$ -

 # "4 !

0  "

  "$  0"

  / "  )(  "

" $"#  (")



"   "  "(  ; 4$$!"4"$ "

 :" 8
3 ' #"( # "##"   "    "

    4  !"4 " B   

/

!" 0 )  ""#!"

(  "$$ "4  0  (  :"
 "$  ;'  "  " !)  (

 "$ 4   "    

 "$ -



  /!"4 :"8
"$; "( 9 C9*(?

"!)(

"$!"

"$ "

/(9

) " $ !#  " (   50 "

")"+ " 9    !"4  2 4   4 ! !"  $    #  "$ /!"4 :"8
"$ ; " # 5"4)'50"

4 9 

!0    4 #"

     " / 9  "$ !"4 "(4 # !"  /"

 )  9" $$)  #"#   ""  "  "  / "

  !  "  "$ !#"

 #!"  )0 !' #"   )  0 "0   "  "

" "$ 

!

 ( 4 "$  "#!"#  (4 4" 40 0"

!

' $"' "

  ##    !"#! " "$  "

 4

"

  )"

 " 0) $  $$ "  #  

 "#!"#  ("" 4$ "#!"

""$ "" 4"

!"#" )0 5 
%"%
 $%

%
'


3  "
 
 "9 
'
% 

.
 
A %
 9
8 
 
9

,&(

7

.&(45 /!2'6' .  ! "# 6(78 ($ (" 5!21  9  . ,
%%

 #
 
 $%

;$  "
 
'


$
60+
'
99C
.
 
A %
 9
8 

 
9
 +  

,  - %   %  



  .  

/" &!

0

12&+
0 &

 
 

'
 
9$ %
 % 
 
 
9 " 
 
 #


%
  
' %


.
$ 


  
$ " 
<

  $
 
$ "

%%.



' 
  $%
9
 
 



$ $

$ $ 
D 
A %
 9
8 

%

 
9
 +$%3 

4 (  

5 &

*   6#2B#
 
 
9
'

$
$ 
$"C

  %
  

  
9

'

$  

  


;

 
9 %
.

$99 




$
 $

  
 
3  "

'

$ ' %



%$
  #
 
8 
$
3 
4&

'
 %9 


9 " 
 
 
< 
 

 
A %
 9
8 

;$


 A=  

# !   "

    "!!"

 " :"
;4"

  0

( "#!"#  (4  !    ! "$ "$$ D"#!"

( E 4 

 " $#4"+'  9" !"4-" !"50"

 :" 8
 ; " )      "

  ,  A
 "$  "  "'()"+ (" #  ("

"$

5

:"
;&" 

'4

!"4 "$4 #! 

"

0"(9 $ "9 "$B  0# !" 0 '(0# @ &    $$ "$  "$$ "  " "

 "$  "F  :"



 "$  - ' $ F  G"

   "$ "#!"#  (4  

    )#F  ) "

 "$  

 ! " ' !" "   $  "  "$  !

!"  "$$  ." "  ) "

" 6 -1 %%' "
% 
$
9"
9
 %
 
$ 

'%%



3 
%9 
%9  "

$ 

 $  
'


$
/+0
 
) .
*"
  


#
+1+2
  /

!

  !#  #"       "#!  0 

 $

#  ;" &"A "   "$ '        "$ 0  !)    "  #  " 4  

 )!

" "!" 

0 "$ " "( 0" 4  4"+!   /32B "! "

 ) /"$$B ""(  "("

" "$$4"

"+" "

"$ "" !

(  02 ""(#  " "+0 "" "$"

F

0

) " ""$!" 0  $"0! "

0" 0"

  "$ #  !" 0  " +  "

( ) 0!

(  F ) /!" 0  +  "   $  $" 4"$ ! "

!!" "$!"

 "F ) &" 0!

( !

!"

4"

( ) (" " "$!" 0 F ) ; ""

$$#    ) " 

0   

 " #   

0  ! "$ "$0 ""$32 9 /"#!  " + "

!!" "$ !"

 " " " "$  !" 0  +  " (  4  "$ -

  # / "(- "$ 4  4 

)  4  !   " )  $$   ""

"!$ "9   )#"  -- &
'
 

 
= $%
" 
- 
8% #
 
*"
  %
 
 
 $%
%
'

.
 ;
8 

E.

  4  

7

" & & 

# ##

'%%

E$%3 

4 (  

F


 & 

 *    6#2
 
% 
.
 
4 %%
) $

 
8 
 

  

4  

#


 !"# $ $"

%  & '#
 
  


%%'
< 
  
4&
 "
*56

--17+1+6


$
617#
6+1#
-+1)
 & 
 %
8#
-071
 
$
+6
 
&99" $#

%$

D


  --#
 
*"


 
% "'
%%
 
$ 3 %
$ "
  "
  9

 .
3 
3 
 
 


 
 
%9 :$99 
"9 

-7-++1+6


;


+
A'#
 
9
' %

$

.9 

$ 
  -1#111:
$


 
.
$
 
' 
?


8    
%
4

#
$$


*11-D2611-111/0D#




8
) #
&48
<811111-D@#
' 
'
9  9
$

$ 
$.
 
#
% "
'

$ #
 
  

9


 9 


-+ 





/
 .* 0

* +*     0 :0  
 ":  



H :*
 
 %

H :*