Malkeet Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS
! "#$ %!&'()*+,# - "#$ .%/)01
**% 2'3'
1)%! 34%,51'
'*6'
!" #$%&'"#"% '
(!
!" #$%&'" '&!
)))
'( . %%4)01.%1%-6&% !1*
77777 '&!*# 1'1*61*'8*'811 1+'&+*9&'1*8'&!636'3,: '&;
<!)& !1 34%,.3&*%*%&-#=>?;! '1-#=>?&<9601,36%'!.3&*%*%- %%61%,@&3608%0'-%+@-)3! 6- 1+%*3- %6*3- %%- *3- )%'%*3- 1%- %0*% A%% A1%- A13'*3-)3,1%%%6 18% . %%4 )01 .%1%- %6 &3' *'0 1 *'3,+61%%'*1+*306!&%-1'3,@ 11.3&*%*%8%'*%''6
"
"# !9601 ,36%'!1.3&*%*%-,3%&8%'%/1 %!+6'3 8%'@6!&%6%6"
"
"#> ''3636)& !#=>?&-1,4&'B'300'86
1+%81&11%!+6%0'%'301,&366 '81@38%%6%8 1'0%43'!&%!&3'! 1%0'1.3&*%*%-%%61%%'1+*306%& 836 6* 1 %0' ! ** *'% 1 !+ ! % .3&*%3&!/0%!1' 1'*6'1% &'661'3,+'''+%6,@8%@!,4&'B'300''1% 1+*306%&8%6'@%!!&1%0&33*3'3' 8%'9&661%+'!1'6'%,8 *@%61166*6'3*'+%8/-6%@!%+0 & 113''% :
+%%'!%6 1%+ %&1%@%'-%'* 1'&1+!1+-%*608/4,''*** %6&3'!1%!+6%0'-1@836,6*6! ,!! )&1+ 1% 1%6 1 %6 &3' ! 1 * %6 %**%'61*%*,/
'@1'0%61%'%%6@,'%',@1 '&1!1'3% + ,-,./, 0 .1 .2.%,
,3, ,, 0 .*
4 *6&66 # #"
"# - 81 &'60 1 4360+ 66 ,@ C, 1 )3*+3 ,0 % 5/, 0 .1 .2.%, +,6/, ,0 ./, 0 .*'47%4*811%',16%&! 1+!@0&'3!1.3&*%@960 '+'%0'%!3&-81&16'D3%@**3@! 1%0
)3,:'&;
<!)& !#=>?&%6'%'36(:
E;
<1%%%''*&!6%'%%03,%%%36
'3,:'&;#<-1+'1%-,@%!&%1 !!&%%F-&'3%*%!'3&1%% G
+ 1 *% %6 '+* %60 ! 1 %!+6 *'- ' &% 1% 1 + ' '6 81 *8 *+30%1+3&*%@%61'*'!%!!60%@ **3@
)+%**'&%+,6,%63*14360+ &6'3*%-81-81&01%6&66&3631 4360+661- - 8,+ , 6/,3,* ,
,9,,
.1 .2.%, 2 9,:, 0 .*
7
* 6&66"
"
"# -1%',161%**3@!
1%0!1*3*'!960'+&'3!.3&*%@ 'D36,01&%%%',0%0'%!3& 0'%%&'1&%%6*+30%!%0%3!&63& 813!&*%&3%&%''-81%'%%6+'%%&'1 +%/0%6''3!%'*&!&6&1%**&%!%0%3 % *%&3% &%' %&&6%& 81 1 D3+' ! *&@
'3 ! .3&*%@ %6 &' ! .3&*% 3& ,@ %660!8%0'.3&*%*%'16+%!1 0'%3%6-13'-&%,D3'6 1'%/!,@-% *!14360+%6'13'(:
E!%&-%'&1!1'3 #>
!
""$6%+ %&1%@%-.%.%4%%61' )% ! 34%,%61'-6&66"
"
"# -1%'%'161% '%,'1+ ! % .3&*% ++ ' % 0'% !3& 1%9%&!+1'%64360+%6'%' 36(:
E)+%'18!1114360+'6
3*,@%6&3'!1*' .%6%H% )%! 34%,-;
""=< ;< ?%66% )3&' H+6 )&%@- *%+ ! H&% 6'-;
""?< ;< ?
14360+'!6 ,@1%6&3'!1**&6 1 %''3+* 1% % !&% &'30 % .3&*%@ 960 ' +3&*% +' ' %6+'%%3 )3&1%''3+*8%'*,%,@ !1%'1%1*''!1&&+*% % **3@ ! 1%0 ! 1 4360+'
!6,@1%6&3'!1*-1 6'& ,8 1 %6+'% %6 0'% !3&'8%',3011&!13-81&1 1%','3,4&+%!&'6%,!1%0 &1'!1I,)3*+3 '*&!1 .3&*%'%'%'1%%03'*''- 1 3&14360+'!1'31%%/1 '+%8 1!-%&!1%6&3' !1*1'&14360+'! 1' 3 1 4360+ !1 )3*+ 3 %6)01%6''
)%!+%&1% %6'1%6 '- #=$>)#
=-'!1** 1 4360+ %6 )01I' &%' ;'3*%< 1%' , &'661&%''%61%',6'03'16
1!-8!61%%&!1)%+ !@0&'3!1.3&*%@960 '+'%0'%!3&%61'%+-6' D3%**3@!1%0 3'&1'%3 &+*%'%**3@!1%0-103! 0%!**3@!1%0'1'%+%'' D36!%%6+'%D3%'436&%!3& '3&1**3@&%6+&36**3@! *'%1%0 13'-8!61%%!&%&'30.3&*%@% !&%%,'10.3&*%@'%%&!0'%%6
13'&% ,+*3061036'81&1%%%%, ! %6+'% D3%':436&% 6' &0 1 6!!&,810'%%6%6+'%!3&- ' &1 %+ %&1%@%- .% .%4%I' &%' ;'3*%<-,'6%'36(:
E8!1%,-&%,161%%0'%%& '1&%%6*+30%!%0%3! &63&813!&*%&3%&%''-81%'% %6+'%%&'1+%/0%6''3!%'*&!& 6& 1 %**&% ! % 0% 3 % *%&3%&%'%&&6%&811D3+'! *&@ H0'%'1*&''3'3%@*%0 !33- %6+'% ' 1 *&'' ! *!+0 *%&3%%&'-!''30*%&3%6'!+%/0 6&''81&1%**@0%3'*%&3%&%''
%6436&%-111%6-%**''*&!& 663%''3%'
3-1'%@%,%6 6'&'
1 ,4& ! 1 3- 1 %&1 ! ' %**&%-101'%6,0%'%'03!-' 66!!&*%'-*'%6!33'-' !+-1+%!'*+30%%'+!%&' 81&1+%@1*6%801,80'% %6 :0'% %&'
1 '%6 !%&' 1% , %**6!1601%1!9%!*&361 *''!1''%++6'&%!! 361&&@&- ""
-%0'%%3
)3&1*&*'1%,%**6'*&!1 &'3!1.3&*%@9'!'+'- 1!&'3&14360+''+%61%! *%!+1%!'%64360+-%'&1 %+ %&1%@%%'')/1% )%! 34%,%61'- ;
""=<# ;<
-1%'%'%/1'%+81%%& !&'3!%.3&*%@'0'%%&
%'!61%%*%!+1!%&1%4360+1 &%'!2 A%*;'3*%<1%',!36,636%,@
; 1 )3*+ 3 ,3 1 6'& ,8 % %6+'% !3& 1 0'% !3& 8%' ,3011&!1314360+'!H%0 &1'!1I,)3*+3%'&'66%+
%&1%@%-.%.%4%I'&%';'3*%<8!6!1 *3'%!13 1!-1'%64360+6'%@ 68%,60*&6!1'3
'D3@-86!6%@+1*' 8*
'+''6
1%'''%6%,-&%'!!&'+%6 3 '3%@-8*'%6'6'+''6
<#"% '
(!= < '&!= #$(8"
#$(8"
% > +:
* ,+ ./ / .> ,- 5? ,.
@ .?
/ > ,:
@ .?