Amarjeet Singh v. Deputy Commissioner And ORS
!"
#$% &%'()(*+ ,
!+ - .!// .
0%)%*$+ !0#*1#2#(*3&4'#$% 0$5%6%$($(*%0 !0(7%)5 5#0&8#23 %69$:&4'#$%%*%0#739*2#; #2%)5 (* 5%6%$($(*%05#) (7%&$5%60%)%*$ 6%$($(* (<69=*(*=$5% 0&%0&#$%&
36#))%&;: %69$:<<())(*%0>'9<>0%)(&(*=
('%0366%77#$%0(;9*#7//#=#00%)6*&%*$ "'*)$($9$%& 9*&%0$5%!#(*$%*#*'%#*&%7 #0% #0%*$)#*&/%*(0($(?%*)'$3
@ 0)50$3-$5%'$-"34(&%85('5$5%#66%#7 (7%&;:5(<5#);%%* &()<())%&#)*$<#(*$#(*#;7% .%#0*%&'9*)%7 0$5%6%$($(*%0)9;<($$%&$5#$0%)6*&%*$ A (7%%$($(*9*&%0/%'$(*@0%#&8($5/%'$(* A $5%'$ 0 '#*'%77#$(* 0%=()$%0%&&'9<%*$%B%'9$%&;:0%)6*&%*$A(* #490 $5%6%$($(*%0#*&$5%00%7(% );:$#1(*=&(
%0%*$=09*&)385('58#) &()6)%& 4(&%0&%0&#$%&A
;:0%)(&(*=
('%03!#(*$%*#*'% 0(;9*#7>'9<>/9; (4()(*#7 !#=()$0#$%3 C5#0#0 0%)6*&%*$ " =#(*)$$5%0&%06#))%&;:0%)6*&%*$ 3$5%6%$($(*%060% %00%& )$#$9$0:#66%#7 ;% 0%0%)6*&%*$ 385('58#)&()<())%& #)*$ <#(*$#(*#;7%85(7%0% %00(*=$/%'$(* $5%'$ 5%# 0%)#(&)%'$(*'#<%96 0'*)(&%0#$(*;% 0%$5()
'90$(*#0#<2($/#0:#4*(* *&(##*&#*$5%03
9*2#;"
385%0%(*($8#)6(*%&#)9*&%0+ D8'<(*=$$5%'*)6%'$9) $5%&()'9))(*# 0%)#(&3 8%5#4%*&9;$(*90<(*&$5#$8%897&;% #'%&8($5 $5% )%0(9) '*)%E9%*'%) E9#)5(*= )9'5 # 604()(* 85('5&%60(4%)$5%0(=5$ *%6#0$:$$5%#66%#70%<%&:3 85(7%'* %00(*=($*$5%$5%0%)6%'(#77:(*$5%'*$%B$
$5%$5%0604()(*) $5%)#<%/%'$(*#)8%77#) $5% )#(&'$%5#4%$#4(&$5()5%*7:8#:$#4(&($() $ 60%)) (*$ )%04('% ;$5 $5% 60(*'(67%) 6906)(4% (*$%060%$#$(* #*& '#)9) <())9) 5% #07(#<%*$#0: &()'9))(*)*$5%$5%0604()(*) $5%)#(&'$&*$ '*4%: #*: (*$%*$ ;: 85('5 $5%0% () #*: (*$%*$ $5% #07(#<%*$$'0%#$%)9'5#&(
%0%*$(#$(*5%0%()* 6(*$(*0%6%#$(*=85#$8%5#4%)#(&3;9$)9
('%$)#:$5#$ ( *$5(*= %7)%3#$ 7%#)$$ =(4% # <%#*(*=$ $5% (0)$ 604() /%'$(* " $5% )#(& '$3 $5% *7:
(*$%060%$#$(*'#*;%$5#$$5%0(=5$ #66%#7()'* %00%&* ;$5$5%)(&%)$()#'#)% #*#''(&%*$#7<())(*#*&*$ '*)'(9)%B'79)(*59)3(*0&%0$=(4%#'<67%$% %
%'$(4%<%#*(*=$$5%)$#$9$0:604()(*38%5#4%$ 0%#&$5%80&)(*$($3$5%'90)% #'$(*%4%*)9==%)$%& (*
'#)%)960#"(*6#0#
8'#* $5%08()%$5%604()$)9;)%'$(* ";%0%'*'(7%&8($5 )9;)%'$(*($)%7 * #'$3$5%0%897&;%**%%& $5% 604()85('5897&;%<#&%$()%#*&0%&9*&#*$$() )#79$#0:07% '*)$09'$(* $5%)$#$9$%$5#$*604()(* )597&;%<#&%)96%0 799)5%0%()**%=#$(4%604()(* (*$5%'$&%*:(*=$5%0(=5$ #66%#7$$5%$5%06#0$(%) 5%$5%0604()(*) $5%'$#*&4#0(9))9;)%'$(*) &()'9))%&# 0%)#(&897&)58$5#$*$5%'*$0#0:#*
A #66%#7 0<;$5)(&%)()%*4()#=%&*7:%B'%6$(*$$5() '90)% #'$(*()$5%(*($(#780&) )9;)%'$(* "
/%'$(* $5%)#(&'$85('5*%%&$;%)9667#*$%&$ =(4%#<%#*(*=$$5%(*$%*$ $5%'$3$5%0604()(*)
$5%)#(&'$#)#7)$5%0)9;)%'$(*) $5%)#<%/%'$(* $5% )#(& '$ * #'$3 (* !"
'#)%)960#"3%4%*85(7%'#9$(*(*=)9667:
'#)9)<())9)3($5#);%%*)$0%))%&(*6#0# ,$5#$$5% '*)$09'$(*85('5$%*&)$<#1%#*:6#0$ $5%)$#$9$% <%#*(*=7%))0(*%
%'$(4%<9)$#78#:);%#4(&%&#*&$5% '*)$09'$(*85('5#&4#*'%)$5%0%<%&:(*$%*&%&;:$5% )$#$9$%)597&;%#''%6$%&5()()$5%*7:8#:8%'#* 5#4%#'*)()$%*$%*#'$<%*$(*$5% 0< 857%)$#$9$% %#0%$59) $5%4(%8$5#$/%'$(* " $5%)#(& '$()4#7(&3;9$<9)$;%0%#&$604(&% 0$5%0(=5$
#66%#7$#*: $5%#
%'$%&6#0$(%)F *4(%8 $5%# 0%)#(&(*$%060%$#$(*=(4%*;:$5()'90$3 $5%#66%#7 (7%&;:$5%6%$($(*%0#=#(*)$$5%0&%06#))%&;:0%)6*&%*$ 8#)<#(*$#(*#;7%#*&$5%&()<())#7$5%0% ;:0%)6*&%*$ <%0%7:*$5%=09*&$5#$*#66%#78#)<#(*$#(*#;7%9*&%0/%'$(* $5%'$&%)%04%)$;%)%$#)(&%0&%0%&#''0&(*=7: 5%<#$$%0()0%<($$%&;#'1$0%)6*&%*$ $&%#7 8($5$5%#66%#7*<%0($)# $%0#
0&(*=660$9*($: 5%#0(*=$;$5 $5%6#0$(%)5%6%$($(*%0)5#77#66%#0;% 0%0%)6*&%*$ *
A
0$5%6906)% 5%6%$($(*)$#*&)&()6)%& #2%)5 (*"
9&=%
,
<1