High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3439/2012disposed of

Kamla And Others v. Krishna Tupe (K.B. Tube) And Another

2017-11-13Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh5 pages

!"#$% &'(&)*% %+!*))$

!" ##$$ %

!&'

($)!(*$ #

%+!*))$,' , ##$ - ", ",# . /& ""

($ , + /*$ $.$ 0 + /*$0 - 1, , !

"*$""

#$"

2 (*$ ##$$ */, + $ # "& * 1 2 2345 $

* 5 *$ ", " 6137745#, 1 7 ' *" #$8# 4 9* **##" *$ #$

,* 1 45 " ! /& $& " * ;&(,# " '# '" )!,<,#$&1*$

7 = 1*$> 1 ?3245 # , $$ " - *#* ?2& $ /,/$ *" * , / - $ - & ",# 9* $ # "& ;.! , ! / - ,* 1?

45. $$!

" " *, 1

45 ""* *$ 8# $ " *, , -$",# 17

45#&/$.

:#*, # $$$ (*$ ##$$.*$ *- + .-$& $ ,* 1 $ /$/ *" * ",# /& (* */, , /& "*$ + $$. 9*",# * "! $ (*$# - # "&.*$ $& " .*$ / $ " ! ",# " * 1*$ , .

#&/$ ",# , @*

" ", ",# , * A ! "*$ # #* ##5/ " " . -*$ ,#$& '

;& @$

-, =';B >##&$ # ,

%#,/

2<8

-#&.137745#, *$ $& . 137745 8 C 1 7 45 +8 $ / $ &

", 137745 ", 17745 * ", ! $/$ ",#* -$ # "& 1

? 7 45 " . / 3 " "*,<83 .##8 ,$& 2& - ,

* * , A !

. $ @* -, ;>/$ %*#, (*

!" ##$% &#'& '()*&'+$ ,-&'. #% /( *&'&. $#0 &'% #0$*(1 %$+%$% ' 2!! !3 ** ##" 6 : ", 177 45 + - $& ##$ ,*$ #$ *" #$ 8# 8 4 A

, $ # "&",1 ?45D1 73 3451

? 7 8E 12

45 ** ##" F 1?3 3?45 4 *" . #$8# #* " . -*$ ,#$& % ;& $& $

$ " * 1*$ % ' 1@ G41" H# ,

" <8"* !<- ';B $.$.8, ;# *" " "*,<8?3A

"8, # , 1, ." !

-137745# , .

. " !

$ " 1 ?3245 # , * .

. .*$ / $

$ " $$ - , 1,*# - ??& '"*, <8? " .

$ " /&

') '

$.$ !

"$"*$ - ,*

$ " $" <8? $& " . $ ,* 1??

45 $$ - ??& 1, *#"

?(*$ ##$$

#9*&/& (* , @/ " .# /$*$ @* -, $&'+$$'$*&'()*&'+$ #%/(0&(00&*,&1 !4" .*$ !$ ;>/$ #8(* ! * 1*$ 8 - " $& " ,#$& / 8 " $&.*$ !/ $ # 8 ?

$ .#&# $ # $. # & /

! $/$ $& " ,#$&,/$ *" ",#* -$ # "&I "

"*," " *" 8 1??

45 $$. 1*$

7 .*$ # #@* "

$$& - , "* - $ # &/

$& " . $ $$ - *#* .

" /# 1*$ @* -, ;>/$ %*#,(* #!

"$"#!

- ",# !

" , $&

/!$$- $ , .

!. "

$/@""

! A - !" $&?

: ,*! $/$ $& " * 1*$

7 ,/$ *" , $$ / $ $$.

- ",# * "! $ $ - @* -, *&'&.$#05(+&($ *#5

G " *, 1

*$8#4$ 1?

G 1?

A !

. /! $ ",# #&/$ "$ , *" -133?345",17 45 " ",# 1?

4517 45517

45 " ",# $$ "& 3?: # *, # $$$ J #&/$ , . # /& + /*$ ##$ #$&$$. , /6 !21 !3 76 =')*$ > K # -4 &4 K #/$ &4