← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4059/2016allowed

Sukhdev Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-07-08Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih9 pages

 

     

   

  !

"# $# 

 %&# "'(              

  # )#*  !)#+,  #(# )#'%#-./+,,-+ %&+

##(  )#0%1# !+,  ##(2  ##(## //((#4.&//1 % !45

 0&# ###(###5  #% !4 /&#(#!5 

  ,1# # ###(#. #+6  ##+   7,8

9+ 1#)!!

44&/ /(# #(# #.#+  #.( &  ,&# ##  /(# ## !//&8( : 2 +(#4 ; /

((/  (/. ##(#+/& ##! !#$ ( &/1((#+#1# #4 

  (/.0(#+1( #(#&/!&/+ &4# //4 /& ##!1# ;#+&1#  & /1+1!1#  -#)# 7)<#9= #4 (/.+ 2 +  !##&##  / /4#+%&&8 &.## /  #+        8    /4#+    #  #(# !## > +(.(#!//

4+ #11# 1!(#+1&##  / /4# 0 (? ##1// (#+//# #@//4# (## #1# 4+/.1 //4 8 1# =//!# 1#&!(/.

 ((#&.(#1!//!(//(#.(1#

 %&= ((# #+(#  ((114( &/1((#+  

7,8 #   9       7,8 #  9+  #( /.  # //! 4//##!4 ##(#  !#+ &     

/  #(              1#  ##     (##( #(# 4#(#<4(/ # #+&  /;1+(#(# ##  / #    2  + & #    #+    !   #

/#(//14##. 1# + / #(# !6  #. #48 01# (  1  (    &.     #+    ##    2 

7,8 #9+ #/# / #

/#( #

  #( 1# ##//& ((/(#  #! # .,+(#///&#//

/8 #(# (# / #      4 #(& # # / )6 /.+##//#7#(9+ /#   # 9+#6 #(#&#! #     A1 #+# /  # # - #  -#  &  &.  #  4#       +  #  1   1(#(#( &/ #  %&+# //.+ (# /(/.# ! #(      A1 #+  #(  +    /#      

7,8 #9+#6 #(#(# #  

  4+# #  > + #4 +    /#       7,8 #  9+  (#  ! #6 #(@(#+ #1 /(# #  #4/.##> +

/#(+ ##

  29+&/ /(# #(# 2.# ##  #  #.4 + # #1#  1(###!4(# # # (.8 1#  # #+ # !# 7=09+   91 +1# +1 //(#+1!# :!+ (#((# # + /# 2  + /##   29+/(#. 1# 44 #!#(//14##.  1# 

 0 #+ ##+   9+ ## 1(#1&/ /+ # #   /(# ((# . #!(#& # (!##,#!#!# ? # 1#!/.1#1# (# #(+1&# ? 1#  / #(# !#+4 /&/

(  # .#  / !        

 /.   &.  (#0/ ## # 

   !!"

#$!%"&"! ! '(")%*+('!,""(*--') "

*( '&&')!.( !$  '-  ," (/  %"*)  ,"-')"  &*++ (/  !%"  ') ") '- ,#*01# +! (/  %")"  *)"  +"2")*#  '!%")  &')!*(!  *+&"0!+ 3% 0%)"4. )"0'(+ ")*! '( "0 + '(3%"!%")')('!!'

,#*01# +!!%"&"! ! '(")0*('(#$,"!*1"(!%")"*-!")!#"*+! *+  -*)  *+  !%"  ( ! *#  (*, # !$  !'  &)' .0"  !%"  !).01+  + 0'(0")("

&) *5-*0 "!%"&"! ! '(")3*+&)"2"(!"

-)'

' (/  +'  -')  ('  -*.#!  '-  % +  '3(  ,.!  (  2 "3  '-  !%"

+!.),*(0"+ (!%"!*!"'- .(6*, 78 (  !%"+"  0 )0.+!*(0"+  !%"  &./("

 ') ") +  +"!

*+ "  !'  !%"  "9!"(!  !%*!  !  ,#*01# +!+  !%"  &"! ! '(")  *(

-')-" !+  !%"  +"0.) !$  "&'+ ! +  3" (!"(  )"0! (/  !%"

'-- 0 *#)"+&'( "(!+!'*--') !%"&"! ! '(")*%"*) (/,"-')"

!*1 (/*($*0! '()"/*) (/!%",#*01# +! (/*( -')-" !.)" 3" '('! (!"( &*++ (/*(') ") )"0! (/!%"'-- 0 *# )"+&'( "(!+  !' )"!.)( !%" +"0.) !$  "&'+ ! *! !% + +!*/" *#!%'./%!%"') ") +4.*+%"



  77 (!%"+"0 )0.+!*(0"+!%"&"! ! '( + +&'+"

'-,$ 4.*+% (/!%" &./("

*0! '(-')-" ! (/!%"+"0.) !$ "&'+ !

*( ,#*01# +! (/!%"&"! ! '(")3 !%# ,")!$%'3"2")!'!%" '-- 0 *#)"+&'( "(!+!' ( ! *!"&)'0""

(/+-'),#*01# +! (/ -('&)'0""

(/+*)" ( ! *!"

-')-')-" !.)"3 !% (-'.) 3""1+-)'!'

*$!%")"+&'( "(!++%*##)"-.( !%"+"0.) !$ -')!%3 !%  !%")"*-!")  -  &)'0""

(/+  -')  -')-" !.)"  *)"

( ! *!"

3 !% (-'.)3""1+-)'!'

*$!%"+"0.) !$+%*## *, ",$!%"') ")*( !%")"+.#!'-!%"0%*##"(/"!%")"!' - *($  :5;  <     :5; < =  # ####&. >+

  9+

#((# . #! (#+ #+ /#   9+ #6 #    (#    ((#  & #    #  #//#       #  &4   / #(/.           9A1 #+#)!!44+     ##        7,8 #  

9+  ##    #/# + #(#1&/ / #(# 2.#  #.4 1 01+& +(# & # # B#   /  #   (#   &4     

/ #( &/ /(#+//1# 0#

C /+4#&##.4#+1!(//(# #

 A &4+(//##!4+1% (&/ # (#(/.# (  #(+&   #  #&  %&+ #!(# ,((+/# / ##( &4 (#(((# 

#(#+ / (#     #6   #       (      4+      # #A &4 #!4(#+##(## (/# /#+ +%  &!##&.

(#1//.4   #/# / #(#(#  ## 0#& ! 6 1#6 #& #4&. #1?#(#  ##!4 #6  4&# #  ##(#

!#+ .+11!/1##(#&/4(# /  +4+1 &/!# !  #(> /.+    (#    &  1# !  1   (#4##  A1 #&/ /&. (#4      !#       /    (#     /  #(#     !#  )   & #     #      (## &/ /!+   7,8

9+  /#  

9+(#

#/  # 1##!# 4&# #+11 ##!4#!#4/#.#1#

1#8 1#  4 +(( &/ #(#+

 11//!!#  #(+###6   #(#  #.+ . 1#D + #(/.   9+ &4 #+ #!

 # (#/#!+4E 

             

   

 

              

   

       

   !!   " !!

                

       

    !

  !  (&!+ # ///#6 # (#

#.#4#/ ./ >      +  (&/.  & +    #(  1#        (##6 ##!48 1# 0 1+ #)!!44  # (+1/(!## &/ /!0 +/ ##  &. #+(# /(# #6   4&# # +1//.##  =4# 44 1/!6 

 # #- # -# &&.#4#  //!-1+   +#11(#(# ( &/ # %&$/# ( # (# 

+1(#1# //(/ #!# //.+!1. 1#&/ # ,# /+(# /! #  #((    ,+ /#       7,8 #  9+    8(#    &/.    

  #&@(#+(# /#/.1  +   #! 1##(#  #  (/+    1 /# %& #    ! /.+ #+  /#   #9+ 1/!# 1// #>+& //#6 #(#(# #  8.  ,!+(#+ /# 

7,8 #9+8(/ # 4&# (/+#

 1# (#&&/ &. //!#0 +// (#1# !+1 !#  /-# 4#   //+   #       (#    (#     #      +  D8 + #1#

//.

  (# #& .#6 # (#(# # ++  //.

(##&/ /!(#+   #  290##/..%  +/(/ &/+ #   8&&.#(## 4 #'#1   1!#4+- #4(/. (#4/#. #,4##+B */#  #/844/  & //!&.(#+ ##(#!14 //!4/  &##.(#.#. (#.#14   #! # #! 0#!

4& &./# /

##(?##(##1#&/(/.# / +# #+(/&! (&.(#14 +/ /  ;#+1(&/# /1#

  &!(/1#1#1#(1&## + 1## ##!&.(#&&# ! #4# # ! #&##&/4#/1&# !##1 # 1 (

/   #4 4  #

 #   /4 #!#/ (# =(  (+  & +1# ###+   7,8

9+&!

1//. % #&##.,#!/.+1#(//1+ 6 +##   7,8

9 0#//&## ;  <;

 <     8?8@A87B

*6*(