Janak Raj v. Central Administrative Tribunal And ORS


 

       


    

   

    

      

 

  


 

  

!   !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2



  



 



 



  



  

 3

" 

"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%5+56 5&7"5..#+)#,$"#1*0')+#(-%(#% 05,,#(/8.#5%+#( #+$%5.(*1+1,$%5$19#%1/'+5. "5+(1)5%"#+7":;-% ,"-%$  <%1/'+5.<=  %#&#7$1+)  "1,  0.#5  ;-%  >'5,"1+)  $"#  -%(#%  05,,#(  /8 %#,0-+(#+$- -+

%#9#%$1+)"1*$-$"#0-,$-; -7-1.-$ :5,,#+)#%=;%-*$"#0-,$-; "1#; -7-+,0#7$-%



"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%45,,#%91+)5, -7-1.-$:5,,#+)#%=4 # ;

@  ?

 #,0-+(#+$- 1,,'#(5 1%7'.5%(5$#( 75..1+);-% -0$1-+,;%-*$"##.1)1/.# '++1+)$5;;5+( -7-1.-$,"591+)*1+1*'* (%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;C $-$"#0-,$-; "1#; -7-+,0#7$-%1+$"# 058/5+(-;
?
3@41$" %5(#58-; 
3A  "#4%1$0#$1$1-+#% ,'/*1$$#("1,500.175$1-+-+ ;-%$"#0-,$-;

1,500.175$1-+45,;-%45%(#(/8"

'*5%#+1-%'/-%(1+5$#41$"

$"#7#%$1;175$#$"5$$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%"5($"#57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;


 "#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%45,,#.#7$#(5+(0-,$#(5, "1#; -7- +,0#7$-%-+C  5+(7-+$1+'#($-,#%9#1+$"5$750571$8$1.."#45, %#9#%$#($-$"#0-,$-; -7-1.-$:5,,#+)#%=;%-*$"#0-,$-; "1#; -7- +,0#7$-%-+

5;$#%1,,'1+),"-475',#+-$17#(5$#(  



#,0-+(#+$,- 5+("59#7-+$#+(#($"5$$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#% "5(0.58#(;%5'('0-+$"##05%$*#+$1+7-++195+7#41$"" '*5% #+1-%  '/-%(1+5$#  4"-  7#%$1;1#(  ;5.,#.8  $"5$  $"#  4%1$  0#$1$1-+#%  "5( 7-*0.#$#(  57$'5.  (%191+)  #B0#%1#+7#  -;  C   6*,  4"#%#5,  $"#  4%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%"5(7-*0.#$#(-+.83 CA@6*, ,"#45,+-$#.1)1/.#;-%$"# 0%-*-$1-+$-$"#0-,$-; "1#; -7-+,0#7$-%;-%"#"5(+-$7-*0.#$#( 57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;C 0%-0#%,"-475',#+-$17#45, 1,,'#(5+($"#%#5;$#%"#45,%#9#%$#($-$"#0-,$-; -7-1.-$:5,,#+)#%=

!#"#5%($"#,'/*1,,1-+,*5(#-+#1$"#%,1(#

"#  7-**'+175$1-+  (5$#(     ;-'+(  500#+(#(  5, ++#B'%#
1,,'#( /8%#,0-+(#+$-  75..1+);-%-0$1-+, ;%-*$"# #.1)1/.# '++1+)$5;;75$#)-%85+( -7-1.-$75$#)-%8(1,7.-,#,$"5$ -7- 1.-$,4"-"59#)-$5*1+1*'*57$'5.#B0#%1#+7#-;C 5.-+#75+ 500.8 ,;5%5,$"# '++1+)$5;;1,7-+7#%+#(#9#+1;$"#8(1(+-$"59# %#>'1,1$#57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;C $"#,"-%$;5..1;5+8 4-'.(/#*5(#)--(/8$"#*/8/#1+)(#0.-8#(-+;--$0.5$#('$1#,0%1-% $-$"#1%/#1+)57$'5..80-,$#($-4-%65,

$1,5+5(*1$$#(0-,1$1-+$"5$$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%;#..'+(#%$"# 75$#)-%8-; -7-1.-$5+(+-$'+(#%$"#75$#)-%8-; '++1+)$5;;

#1+)5 -7-1.-$"#,"-'.("59#)-$57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;C 5, 7-+$#*0.5$#( '+(#%$"#5/-9#7-**'+175$1-+  ++#B'%#
45,$"#


500.175$1-+,'/*1$$#(/8$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%#B#%71,1+)"1,-0$1-+;-%$"# 0-,$-;  ,;5%5,"1,#B0#%1#+7#45,7-+7#%+#( "

'*5%#+1-%'/-%(1+5$#"5(;-%45%(#("1,500.175$1-+41$"5 7#%$1;175$#  $"5$  $"#  4%1$  0#$1$1-+#%  5+56  5&  "5(  )-$  57$'5.  (%191+) #B0#%1#+7#-;C

#,0-+(#+$,- 5+(3"59#(#$#7$#($"#;%5'(/#1+)0.58#( /8  $"#  0#$1$1-+#%  1+  7-++195+7#  41$"  ,51(  " 1+(  '*5%  #+1-% '/-%(1+5$# $1,1+;-%*#($-$"# -'%$$"5$(1,710.1+5%80%-7##(1+),"5( /##+1+1$15$#(5,5)51+,$"

'*5%;-%)191+);5.,#7#%$1;175$#$"5$$"# 4%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%"5()-$ 57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;C 4"#+ 57$'5..8"#"5()-$57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#-;3 CA@6*,

@

$1,+-4+-$(1,0'$#($"5$$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%"5(+-$7-*0.#$#( -;57$'5.(%191+)#B0#%1#+7#5,-+$"#(5$#0%#,7%1/#(/8 %#,0-+(#+$  -   ;-%  #B#%71,1+)  $"#  -0$1-+  $-  $"#  0-,$  -;  "1#;  -7- +,0#7$-% "#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%5.,-75++-$7.51*#B#*0$1-+5,7-+$#*0.5$#( '+(#%++#B'%#
5,"#(1(+-$;5..'+(#%$"#75$#)-%8-; '++1+)$5;;

!#5.,-;1+($"5$5;$#%1,,'1+),"-475',#+-$17#%#,0-+(#+$ - "5, %1)"$.8%#9#%$#($"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%$-$"#0-,$-; -7-1.-$ :5,,#+)#%=  

!#(-+-$;1+(5+8*#%1$1+$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+ "#%#;-%#$"# 4%1$0#$1$1-+,$5+(,(1,*1,,#(

#$  !   #0$#*/#%

#  

!$ '.5$1  !