Harish v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS
#
&'( )* #$
* (+,-,).
/ 0
*
" +++
(,"
"
! "
!"
# # " "" $ % & "
'(%
) %
& )
& & " "
( ( " " - . '/01 $ ) ) . . !
" "
# "
!) ) ''5 # ) " ! "" ) & !
!
!)
" $
" "
-& # 2 34* & & '9 " - )
%! 0 '5 '3" ) & & "" - " "" " ) &
-& # 2 -
,
'
'0 $ $ " &
" ! !
!
!) ) " /
& -&# !
" % !) " & - !
&
" " ! & & "
! "
, 7 8 95: " '0 # "
-"
" , & - 6!
" $
# 8 9
/0 '
! ( )! * + # *
! ,$ -'
!
!
#
'
%
!
! !
'
%
! #
!
-'
! !
.
!
! "
! !
# #
$ $
%
! &
'
!
!
0
!
'
!
! %
!
!
!
!
!
! !
1 '
!
!
!0
3 2 !
!
3
!
!
! 5
%
!
!
%
!
!
%
4 ;
- - , & "!) $ & )! !)
- 6!
" $ , & $
# $ - ! " %& '()* *)+&", , $
- ! "
! ) < ( ( "" & " /=-*. " " ) & "" &
-
" " &
'9 !
" & "" "
& > "" # & & " - !
)A "" &
&
) ?
" ) ) " . 5 "
" ) " & )
3 4 4* )
) !
( !
! $ B )
)
'' C
!
!) " -" , &
$
@2 .
4 ./ $ +" 3 4 5 & 3 6*
--0 # # -1 , - " ! & ! "
! ") " - & C
/
! & & ) !)
!
(
" "
! ' ' 3 '5 '0 ! "
! !)
C
/
0' 07: ? B
) A<5 . &
" % " - !
" ! ! ! ") ) " .
." /, ! & " ) !
" ! '3 .
. &
! ?
? "" & " " & &
"" & " " ! # # >
& "
) % "
! && # ) " " ! >
'
# #" "
"
!
! )"
! &
)
C " "
! % % "
1
&
/
# " " "
!
) & ! & ) !
!) " ?
? "
! ) & ! & " " " B ) ''3 & ?
!
) ) " (
C /
# "
" " &
) ! """ & /
! & "
# # ! & " & ) &
) !) & "
!
50 7 7<: B ) ''3 3 " )
# 8 9 165
; 888 888 888 $&
! !
3
% !
78
9!
:
3
4 3 $ B ) & ) $
7 @$B$6: & ) E$B$ & ) B
"" ): & ''
F & 5' 5" C ) & & & 53 " !
& # & ! & 8 9 9 ! 0 ",# &) " 3 #" #!"3! , " 7, 30"8 ,
8
! !
!
8
! &
!
! 1$" =
3
!
!
8 ! /0 0
0 0
!
$
!
3
! <
,
0
$
0 !
$
3
! <
,
%
! !
!
$"! ' <
8
$= <
0> 78 / 0 ? !
8
. !.
0- ",# &) " 3 #" #!"37, 3 08 ,
8
! !
!
8
! & !
!1$"=
3
! !
#
8
!
!
!
0
!
=
!
=
!
!1$" !""" 0A
!=0A
""
"""=
' <
!
8
0
!
!,,"""=
!
= !
!
!1$"= =
0,
!,,""" """= 0"
!= 0 "
"
=
4 ?-!= !
@
* -=@*
<
8
!
/
##
( () @*= !
= = *
-< *
1 B , , ,""= ""= $6
, ""= A" $
""= AB 1 $ $ $""= B, A 1 1""= ," 61 A 6""= , ,"A $= <
0> 78 / 0 ? !
8
. !.
888 888 888 , " # # &) " 3 ),) #" & &/"! #8 , %
!
!(
!
! !
7
! !
#
!
!
% !
5
8 0
! C
C
% #! & #5&C
!
8
%
.
7
' 7
!
! /0
!
8
! C !
!
C
#
!
!
C !
!
1A
$
!
1 ) !
7
! $6 1" 1,
!
/ D 7
!
3
A '
! $6 1" 1, !
!
7
4 4
#0
; # # " 9=-*.( $ . =93/' 5 '0 ' &
C )
# =-*.
.( $ . =9'3/'' & & %
00 ? $05'
' 33 $$
A3 ?
" ) &
$ % "
& !
&" !
!
" !
! ) < - - " ) ) "! !
" ! ) !
) ) )
! % #"
) & ! ) !
) & & 5 # # $ !)
) & ) % "
! &
"
"" !
!
& & )"" & & &
"
! !
?
!
8" C ! & & C ! !
"
?
! ) C "" > !!
D
#
!)
! & & & & "
& !
& "" " "!, ! " # " ) " & &
?
"
<9' ""
" & ""
9 )
!) " #) > ) & &
0 .
. & !
)!
&
A ?
?
"
" ) E$ " ) / / 9 -
&
G " .& B " )$
B " ) 2% && !) $ .&
6 % G 7 &
:F )',*,+& &',).
) #12234.2 #2
3&'(3 # #1 ! !) " 9 =-*.( & "
/ 9 # 8 9
#/
;<((% %=% %>?4> >(% >:%2
@(>A> %(>@ @ -1 2$ -
- 9 9% 9:894
(
0$1 - 7 7
#
0 ,BBA
7
0 ""
F-G=) !
F
- - G3 = )! * D
20
- !
61
)! 7
*
7
E D
D ! '
* D !
!
! ! 1.
- G3 = )!
!
F-G=)
!!
<
D
F-G =)
7
* *
,B (
!
)!
!!
2.
%
!
0
!
F
)!
!
)! 3.
!
0
#1
!
!
F-G=)
F-G=)
'
!
2
2 $ '
F-G=) !
!
0($ # #%,, B @ !
!
/0 I.
A",, B8#
! !
II.
8A" %,, B8#
! !
@ !
0
/0
!
(a)
! (b)
!
(c)
3 $###, /0 '
/
!< 0
#
I.
# # !
)! II.
* *
@
0D ' ?' III.
* *
D ' ? ' !
IV.
D
D (a)
( (b) * ( '
'
!
/0 1
3 3)" "$ > A"% %,, ' *
3 !
7
*
,B ?
?
/0 ?
# ,"""
!
)! (
/0'
""1
: -
F-G=)
!
!
>> A "%,, ' !
/0
#$
(A) @ (a) & & 3
D
@
,BB$4
7
*
,B B b) @ A , " % ,B8 (b
8 3
!
(c) 7
!
$6 (d) ?
?
# ," ""
E E 0
!
!
)! (B) D @ (a) & & 3
D @
, ,BB$4
7
* *
,B (b) @ @ A , " % , B8
(C) '
@ (a) & & 3
D
@
,BB$4
7
*
,B (b) @ @ A , " % , B8
8 3
!
9.
*
& @
0D ' E? ' ! /0 (I) ?
?
(a) '
' *
3 !
7 7
*
, ,B (b) ?
/0 ?
?
# ,""
"
!
)! >>
A"%,, (A) @ & & 3
D
@
,BB$4
#
7
*
,B ?
?
# ,""
""
E 0
!
!
)! (B) D @ & & 3
D @
, ,BB$4
7
* *
,B (C) '
'
@ & & 3
D
@
,BB$4
7
*
,B 10.
, ,)"6/*( CA) )"" )3 , (I) A"%,, (a) ?
/0 ?
?
# ,"""
"
!
)! (b) 9
# ""
:
* *
!!
!
F-G=)
(II) ) )?
* *
!!
!
F-G=) '
7
*
, ,B * *
?
# ,""
""
E 0
!
!
)! 11.
* ! *#A"%,, C
8A"%,, F-G=) !!
<
F-G= =)
!
0
'
7
*
,B -
!
F-G=)
, * ! C 8A"
*! 33" #-0$#A"%,, "%,, '
0
!!
,1 7 7
*
,B(
!
!!
,1
7
*
,B
! !
,1 ! !
!
! -
!
F-G=)
- ( () $#, # , ) &! " ,$ ""&)B8 3 $ ($ # ., >! 3 3 , 3 ,,
# @## , %) $ ? ", )! * #
#
# ! (75D *75D
7
0 0 #
#
" 0 0 (75D (75D ?
)0? " 0 0 * #
#
>7)5D *75D 0 0 #
0 0 #
(75D >7)5D ?
#
"$ *
? * #
*75D &
(75D @
!*7 D ' E?
0
"1 0 0 0 0 #
#
(75D (75D ?
!*7
)0? #
#
"A 0 0 *
*75D >7)5D
!*7 "6 0 0 0 0 #
#
"B *
? #
#
*
*75D (75D &
!*7 D ' E?
! *
," 0 0
0 0 #
#
(75D ? (75D
!*7 )0? #
,, 0 0 * #
>7)5D *75D
!*7 0 0 #
, 0 0 #
(75D ? >7)5D
?
!*7 , D
* #
#
*75D (75D
!*7 0 0 #
#
, 0 0 ? (75D (75D
)0?
!*7 ,$ 0 0 * #
#
*75D >7)5D
!*7
0 0 #
#
,1 0 0 ? >7)5D (75D ? #
,A D
* #
) (75D *75D
!*7
!
,1
0 0 #
,6 0 0 #
(75D (75D ?
!*7
)0? ,B 0 0 * #
#
>7)5D *75D
!*7 0 0 " 0 0 #
#
>7)5D ? (75D
!*7
- *,)#, # #, ) !7
H# !2@
D ' 2?' I 1.
!7 702'
(@5 ,
(
78
2.
7!
!
3.
( ( @ 5
D
9
?# D
D E A G
78
/
7!
# , ,"""""20 E
%
< ! 3
- % !
!
!
!
E
!
@ D
1.
(@5
!
>7) ," /0 (i) * ?# ( (ii) * D
D ( (iii) * D
9
( (iv) (
E
(v) (
2
(vi) #
*7 ( (vii) @
( (viii) *
!
2.
* *
>7)
E
(75D!
!
A (i) @5G
( (ii) J
D @ *
( (iii) *
( (iv) )
2
3.
* *
(75D
*75D!
"
1
4.
* *75D 7
* *
0,BE
5.
* *
(75D
?
2
6.
)?
)!7
# !2
2 D '
*75D
(B) *, ) # " 3 A , " % , # ,)" 6/ *( CA)"" ) )3 , *
(7
?
!
2
D )!7
(C) D
! * D
D '
!
!
/0 D
!
1. 5 5
!
5 5
@(*59K 7
%
(@5
: (
D ( (
D ! (
9 #3 3 (
(
2 !
!
2.
*
(@5
D
09
?# #D
D G
(@ (@5
# ,"""""20 3
!
) * ?# (i i) * D
9
(i iii) (@5K
! !
(i D
v) D <
(i
5
(0
>7) # ,""""
""20
% < ! $ * *
(@5
% !
! !
!
@
1 '
'
"A *,)# ## ", / 1.
(@5
0 (i) * * ?# (ii) * * D
D (iii) * * D9# (iv) ( (
2 !
(v) D !
$
!
!
!
< D * * =
@ @! J J
(vi) D *
# 9 * '
*
(vii) * *
7
K *7
!
(@5
D
D ?# D
9
# (
* *
7
2.
?
? !
*
(@ (@5
>7)
3.
* *
>7)
* 5
4.
!
!
>7 7)!3
@(*59K
7
%
!
5.
'
'
@5D 6.
?
? )!
"
!
@(B8 ( #) , ( ) # # > ,, # / 3 "
#)) D! #, ) $ > ,3 > , ,) #
) ! ,, #, &$,
$E) "" '
'
F-G=)
'
'
G @
F-G=)
! "
"B"$",A ) 33 9 % < *,/)"F ' ?
?
" " )
" & & & &!
!) )
& ) $ & "
#"
" " & & )" ,
"
" " "
! " " " ) # & & " !
(
"
B
) ''3
! &
" % &
" & .
.
& /" !) " ! "
)"
#
" )
! 8 8" ) !) "
)" ! ) "';
&
/" & & ""
) & " " # #" " " & ) 565-'
/ 7&8 &7)7&
& & 0
7
"
&
!2 / &
/ /L
2) /L
2)