High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25346/2017dismissed

Resham Singh v. Surerintending Canal Officer And ORS

2017-11-08Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

!!!!!

"#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&()*$+,$- *$+,$- *$+,$- *$+,$-.

./ / / / !!!!!

!!!!!

!!!!! $'0"+&(10 $#&#&($- 2' 0$34$-&(#$(5&(1"("6

&%$-/$-7$43-"(5#0$-' $'4(5$(#' !!!!

!!!!

!!!!! 8) 8) 8) 8)9 :8 ;;8

9 :8 ;;8

!!!!!

!!!!! -$'$(#) 8-$$-"<8"5"(/ 5*%"#$/

-#0$4$#&#&($- !!!!!

!!!!!

!!!!! ;;8

/ ;;8

/ 0$4$#&#&($-0"'%0"66$(1$5#0$-5$-5"#$5 4"''$5 ,= #0$ &*&'&("6 "("6

&%$-/ "'#$-( "("6 &*&'&(/ $-7$43- >0$-$&("

#$--$ $--$5#"'?#0$9@"(5#0$-5$-5"#$5 .4"''$5 ,= #0$ 34$-&(#$(5&(1 "("6

&%$-/ $-7$43- "("6 &-%6$/ $-7$43- >0$-$&("

#$--$ $--$5#"'?#0$9@ :$"-($5 %3('$6 - #0$ 4$#&#&($- 0"' '3,+&##$5 #0"# #0$ 4$#&#&($-&'"'+"666"(5A($-/0"*&(10&'#3-( A"#$-"#- A"-","(5&/'0A("#4&(#?

9&(#0$'&#$46"(0$4-&*"#$-$'4(5$(#'"-$ "6'0"*&(1#0$&-#3-( A"#$-'"(%#&($5"#4&(#?

9 3#6$#

B: "<,"0";"6$A"6""(5#0$66$%#-(#0$"446&%"#&( -$'4(5$(# 4-4'$5 #0$ A"-","(5& ,= "+$(5&(1 #0$ #3-( A"#$- ,3# #0$ $43#= 66$%#-*&5$0&'-5$-5"#$5 C 5$%6&($5#0$4-4'$5A"-","(5&( #0$ ,<$%#&( -"&'$5 ,= #0$ 4$#&#&($- 0$ '"&5 -5$- A"' %0"66$(1$5 ,= -$'4(5$(# &( "44$"6 ,$ -$ -$'4(5$(# $'4(5$(# "66A$5#0$"44$"6A&#0#0$ 66A&(1-5$-)

44$66"(#A0%"+$4-$'$(#"(5-$'4(5$(# A$-$0$"-5&(5$#"&6'/-$%-5A"'$E"+&($5/

&$65 '#"

"44-&'$5 #0"# #0$ 4-4'$5 A"-","(5& 3(5$- $%#&( . 4-53%$5 ,= #0$+ ,$ -$ #0$ $43#= 66$%#- A"' &( *&$A ,$##$-&--&1"#&(/&#A"'-&10#6=+"5$ "(5$E%$4##0$"44$66"(#/(#0$-%'0"-$- 0"' -"&'$5 "(= ,<$%#&( -$1"-5&(1 #0$ #3-( "(5#0$D"FF"'GA$-$"6'%"-*$54-4$-6= 6"(5 &( #0$ A"-","(5& 0"' ,$$( 6$ # # A0+ A"#$- 0"' (# ,$$( 4-*&5$5 ' '#"#$5,=#0$ &$65'#"

/#0$-$%-5A"'"6' $E"+&($5

#$-$E"+&("#&( #0$%"'$"(5 F$$4&(1 &( *&$A ,$'# &--&1"#&( "(5 "' '#"#$5,=#0$ &$65'#"

-$%-5A"'$E"+&($5/ "' 4$- -$%-5 #0$ 5$%&'&( -$(5$-$5 ,= $43#=66$%#-&'(#&(5$#"&60$-$ -$/ A0&6$ &(&#&"#&(1 4-%$$5&(1' "%%-5&(1 # '$%#&( .H I #0$ "("6 %#/ A0&6$ "66A&(1#0$"44$"6 #0$"44$66"(#"(5#0$ 5$%&'&( -$(5$-$5 ,= $43#= 66$%#-/ "'#$-("("6&*&'&(/$-7$43-/5$%&'&( 5"#$5 C B &' ,$&(1 '$# "'&5$ "(5 "%%-5&(1 # #0$ 4-"=$- #0$ "44$66"(# A"-","(5& "# #0$ #3-(

"6<&(5$- ;"3- B 30F%0"&( &(10 0"' ,$$( "44-*$5 - "%-$' "-$" #"F&(1 A"#$- "# "FF" &$ ;&66" 83-",,"/;&66" 83-",," "(5 1&*&(1 A"#$- -+ ;&66" 83-",," "(5 "# '$-&"6 B #0$ #3-( 8"(<&# ;"3-AB3F0#"<&(10 - "%-$'"-$"

- #"F&(1 A"#$- "#;&66" 83-",," "(5 - 1&*&(1 A"#$- "# ;&66" 83-",," / ;&66" 83-",," 0"',$$("44-*$5G

11-&$*$5"1"&('##0$'"&5-5$-/#0$4$#&#&($-"6' &6$5"44$"6 ,$ -$ #0$ ,3# 0&' "44$"6 A"' 5&'+&''$5 ( . A&#0 #0$

66A&(1-5$-) D0$$(#&-$-$%-5 #0$%"'$A"'$E"+&($5 *$-= %"-$ 366= 8"4 #0$ '4# A"' "6' $E"+&($5

#$- $E"+&(&(1 #0$ -$%-5 J3&#$ " A0&6$ #0&' 3-# 0"' 3(5 #0"# #0$ 4-"=$- #0$ "44$66"(# &' (# "%%$4#",6$ ,$%"3'$ "%%-5&(1 # #0$ 5$+"(5 "44$66"(# $'0"+ &(10 $#% #0$ 5$%&'&( A0&%0 0"' ,$$( -$(5$-$5 ( 5"#$5 C B ,=$43#=66$%#-/ "'#$-( "("6 &*&'&(/ $-7$43-/ '"&5 5$%&'&( &' (# &( 5$#"&6' "' 4$- -$%-5 "(5

"%%-5&(1##0$5$%&'&(+"5$,=&*&'&("6 "("6

&%$-/ "'#$-( "("6 &*&'&(/ $-7$43- -#0$&--&1"#&( #0$"-$" #0$ "44$66"(#/ #3-( 0"' ,$$( &E$5 "# 4&(# ?

9 "(5"%%-5&(1##0$-$%-5 A"-","(5& 4&(#?

90$0"'1# +&(3#$' &6&(1 =

&E&(1#0$#3-( #0$"44$66"(#"#4&(#?

9/ #0$ "44$66"(# A&66 (# '3

$- "(= 6'' &( &--&1"#&( 0$ 5$%&'&( -$(5$-$5 ,= &*&'&("6 "("6

&%$-/ "'#$-( "("6 &*&'&(/ $-7$43- A"' $E"+&($5 "(5 #0$ 3-# 0"' -$(5$-$5 ",'63#$6= %--$%# 5$%&'&(F$$4&(1&(*&$A ",*$+$(#&($5

"%#' 0&' 3-# &' "1-$$' A&#0 #0$ '"&5 5$%&'&(0$-$ -$/-#0$-((5&"("("6 "(5-"&("1$ %#.. "(53(5$-$%#&(

.H I #0$ 3(<", +$(5+$(# %# C - #0$ ,$##$- &--&1"#&( #0$ -$'4(5$(#' ,$&(1 "1-$$ A&#0 #0$&- 5$+"(5 "(5 A0&6$ 5&'+&''&(1 #0$ "44$"6 #0$ "44$66"(#' "# #0$ #3-( "6<&(5$- ;"3- B 3F0%0"&( &(10 0"' ,$$( "44-*$5 - %$-' "-$" -#"F&(1 A"#$-"#"FF"&$;&66" 83-",,"/ ;&66" 83-",," "(5 -1&*&(1A"#$-

-+ ;&66" K 83-",," "(5 "# '$-&"6 B #0$ #3-( 8"(<&# ;"3- AB 3F0#"< &(10 - %-$' "-$" #"F&(1 A"#$- "# ;&66" 83-",," "(5 -1&*&(1A"#$-"#;&66" 83-",," / ;&66" 83-",," 0"' ,$$("44-*$58$"(&(1#0$-$,=#0$-5$-' 4"''$5,=&*&'&("6"("6

&%$-/"'#$-( "("6 &*&'&(/ $-7$43- 5"#$5 &#'$6 &',$&(1340$65G :$"-($5%3('$6 -#0$4$#&#&($-0"'*$0$+$(#6="-13$5#0"# #0$"(50"*$4"''$5(('4$"F&(1"(5%-=4#&%-5$-' 3#"

#$-" %"-$ 36-$"5&(1 #0$&+431($5-5$-'"(54$-3'"6 #0$'&#$46"("44$(5$5 A&#0#0$4$#&#&(/0"*$%+$##0$%(%63'&(#0"##0$-$&'($---&(#0$ &+431($5-5$-'A0&%0%"66' -"(&(#$- $-$(%$ #0&'3-#"(50$(%$/#0$ 4-$'$(#4$#&#&(&'0$-$,=5&'+&''$5 H ;;8

I H ;;8

I 28 28 28 28 .

./ / / / 0$#0$-'4$"F&(1B-$"'($5 $'B 0$#0$--$4-#",6$ $'B