← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25363/2017dismissed

Ashish Chopra v. The State Of Punjab And Others

2017-11-07Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh11 pages

 

   

  



!"

#!

$!% " "! %#& ' #("

! )! #(!#" 

      !!#"* +

,, - ./!# (01 "!- +20 #( % #/(01 "!

"

#!     !!#" # '!!#

.!(%#(!"

1.!  #( !#"

"%"

#(  % #1!  - !# "%! 1!"

4% 

#, %,#!((!( "!(67 ##!8%!*/0 (!

/"

'!!#( !( 5!0 1! %"

!  9! . '!!# 5 (!  % #,( !1"

# ""

#(!#" " ..- "

#!"1#"

#%!#"

" $1 "

! 

#%1 (!

'!!# :

.9/"

1" !1 ! 5 (!%" !!#" !"

!5"

#!/# 5!.9/5"!!" :%( - -  -;

#, + "

+ "! #20!#5!#"!# !1#( 91 ./$ .%/  1"!<!

% !( !(#7

-

.! #!0 1! #!

 '!

!!.(!"#

!( 15

#"5!#"#6 

! .

19 !" "!20!#5!#" #(%

!( .."

!(1%5!#"  !4% !('9! #(!#"  #(15 .!"!( .."

5 .

!=-!0!/ !1.

5 #!- #"1# (!!(   (

0!9!  5 !( "! %'5

#% (/"

#!

14% !(

!4% .

.!1"

1 .#, #!!

#, #("

"! , !!#"!("

!(!

"5!#" #(%'5 ""!( !

##

6

#"5!#"# 15 # "!,%#(  "!0!

#  !! .

(1%5!#"/"

#!-  . ;!(" %#

!.

(!1.  "

#>%#(!" ;

#,, #, .9 1%.  #(

# #1 ." "% .#, (!"

. 50! '.! #( 550! '.! !"

!/-

-!!%'5 ""!( # ?."

5 "!.9/"

!1 ! #!- 1# (!!( #( - 

#"!(#"

" $1 "

!#!,%. '  0 (!(!

( "!(    "!- !#"

!1 ! #!- !, (" #5 .9 9, (!1 5!";#-.!(,! ! #(!#" / .!""!

- - ""!#""

!=! (5 "!", #" 91 .!""

#!  '!!#, 0!#""

!$1 "

!" .1 5!""

!#"

1! ! #(!#"* %"

!"

#"5!#" #!""

"

$1 "

!- #" # 11( #1!- !)%.!( "!(677 #( -#,.9'!!#, 0!#1 .! )

* @6

A@

#"! (

) 7

* 

A@

 #   /"

#!-  %!(1 ,! !!"5!#"

#" "! 1!!( #, , #"

5%#(!!1"

#6 %#& ' !0 1!%# 5!#" #(

! .)%.!/7  "!!

!!("  B"

!)%.!/7 B/"-

/"

#!%'5 ""!( (!"

.!(!

.9 #( %'5 ""!(  "

" 

  5"

!  ( !(  #  7

 #( 

!( 

  15

#"5!#"#6 

  !1 !5! !9! 



1 '.! 

#"5!#"#15 # "!'   "! (!"

.!(

#4% 9- 1#(%1"!( ""

!.!0!. !

.(  #( 1"(%1 "



1!/!<!

%";#-"

!(!"

. .9 #(

# #1 ." "%/ #/ "-  %#("

#!-  #!0 1! ""

!"

5!

(! "

!(!1! !( #(!0!# ""

!"

5!

#"5!#"/  !-  ,!""

#, !#  /  !5#"

?."

5 "!.9'9, #, #

"%# "9 #,/"

%,#!((! (  . 5!0 1!-  !(# 67 /- #/ "- 5!#"

#!("

" (!"

.!( #4% 9- 1#(%1"!( #("

#!- 

(!( #

"%# "9 #,# 7  (! (  .-  !(" "

"  .!

"- 

.!( #(-#, 5 "

#- %

!("-  .5!#"

#!( %,#!( (!"

#!- #" #,4% .

$1 "

#(  -   #"  !.

'.!  "  '! 

#"!(    %1  '9  1# (!

#, 

4% .

#  %,#!(  (!    (  .    %'&!1"  5 ""!  

..!#,! !!#" # C! #!(!# 1%#!. "

#!1#"!#("

- #1#1! .5!#"5 !

!!#" "

##"

" #! #( #!

!1"

0!

"%# "9 !# . #,- , 0!#"

5.. 1" #( !.!0 #" 5 "

#-!!%

!(""

#(!#" #( "!0!

!  (1%5!#"/  "

#"5!#"  .!""!  -   %!(  " "

#! C! #!(!# 1%#!. %"

!1#"!#("

" ""

!"

5!

#"5!#"

!- #" #20!#5!#"D' #(- #.9,!""

!# # =! ("

! ,%5!#" (0 #1!('9.! #!(!# 1%#!. #! #( 0! .,#!"

%, %,#!((! (  .

@ #("

!(1%5!#" 0 . '.!#"

.!  1"  !. "

#,  "  (! "

   5"

!   #!  # 7

/%'5

# 15

#"5!#"""

! #(!#"#6 

 #(

#"5!#" #!#"

"

$1 "

! !#"( %"!("  .#"( %"!("

"1 ,! !!"

-  %!(""

#!/"-

/

.!(!

.9 #(%."

5 "!.9"

%,#!((! (  .-  

.!%'5 ""

.

##6 

'9"

#!/ .9 "- 5!#"

#!("

5"

!- -;

#, + "

+ "! #( !( !(#7

 #( !'!

#"!(#15 # "!

,%#(    !  .

19   !  " "!  20!#5!#"   "!  #"

#- %'5 ""!(# 

@!

"! "

! 5! 1" #('9 5 "

# !4% !(! .

!"-  .5!#"

#!("

!-  !!.(!"# .9 #(- "

! 1"% ..!, .

5"

!#

"- 

.!('9 #!#



@/- #/ "-  5!#"

#!(  "

"  !!#"  %1!    .

0!.

(    %' #,  #.9 #  "

!# #  !1!

0!(  "  -   .  5!#"

#!(  #  "

!  %#(!" ;

#,  ( "!(  "

"5! ! 5%#" , "% "9 #(2-  !#"#"

"%(9 !1

.(!# #(5!- !"%#!(""

!!. "

0! , #". #'%"

#""

!1.%5# 50! '.! !"9/#"

#,- 5!#"

#!(!, (

#15! !5 ""!!5 #!( !#( ..7  - !# #

- %'5 ""!('9"

#!" "

!'! 0 (!(&'

#,-

(";#1;"

!( !%"#! #!"#%5'!

#%'5 ""!('9"

#! #(

1#"

#%%!

" #1!

!9! 

/%."

5 "!.9/"

! #"!1!(!#" #! #(

!#" -!!0!

!('9"

#(!#"*" "!"

%, !)!0!#%!

.

  !<!

% !!

"( "!(   %'5 ""!('9"

!!

.( #"

'   #4% 91#(%1"!('9"

! "- /(!1! !(5"!!" :%( - !0 #, + "

+ "! #(-  #,"-# #( %' #(-  ( - #, !# # "!

!"

!5!#" 5!0 1! "!"

!1 !

#!   

#"5!#"  #  "

"    $1 "

# .  ! 1 !  -  1# (!!( #("

#!-  ;!(" %#

!.

(!1.  "

#>%#(!" ;

#,, #, .9 1%.  #(

# #1 ." "% .#,  (!"

.    50! '.!  #(  550! '.!  !"

!    !   (  !.

(!1.  "

#>%#(!" ;

#,- "'!%'5 ""!( .#,-  #

", ..  (!"

.   11( #,.9/  #  %#(!" ;

#,  -   , 0!#  '9  !  

#!# " "

"!(! "

-

!/"" .

5%#"-

- !1!

0!("- (2%#( #()2- ""

!"%#!

 / /

>*"-  ." "!(

"%" "" . 5%#"/ # 5%#" / /

>*- !"%#!(""

!!. "

0!/-

- " ;!#  . #//

/

>*-  !#"#"

!!

%! #(!5 #, 5%#"

-  !#"#"

!"%(9 !1

.(!#"-  .5!#"

#!("

!1!

#,

>* !5#"

  !# # 5"

!5!#"

#!((!"

./

! "

0!9" 1"

%..9, 0!# #%#(!" ;

#, - #, 

! 5%#"

!#"#"

!"! "5!#"

-

!- " ;!# 5"

!!. "

0! #(-  !"%#!( ! 5%#"-

- !1!

0!( "!(! "

-

'!!# -#'%"#"

#, '!!# -#"- (

#15! 5%#" !1!

0!( "!

!"

!5!#"&%"" -

1 !"'!0!9,!#% #! 5%#" !# # #("

!'!#!

"!1!

0!( "!(! "

-

0!

'!!# -#" 0!'!!# !#" #%1  5 ##! 

(% " ( - #" #!0 1! !% .  (1%5!#"%'5 ""!('9"

#!

 

55!( "!.9 "!"

!(! "

5"

! -"

"#- !! "-  5!#"

#!("

!-  . #!0 1!"  .#"15!#!1( #!- #"! ( #,-

!#""

!#"-!!#"

! ( #,",!"

!- !! 15!#!1( "- 9"

#!

- #"0 . #"" %%!

1 ! 5"

!9! 

" "

!  !"

#, 0!'!!#5 # ,!(- #(!#" #("

!5 ""!-  ;!

!#( #, "

..  "

! !"

!5!#"  

  ! &%" "  ,!" "

! &'   ,! !!"- ! #(!('9"

#! #("

"!#"

!'  

#4% 91#(%1"!("

%,#!((!-  !( !5 ""!1 5!""

#"

1! ! %"

!1#1!#!( ""

!"

5! !50 ! #5 .9 9, (!"  !1

1 ..9'!!#5!#"

#!( %,#!((!"

!"

5! (! "

5"

!/"

#!-  .-;

#  "

!  

1!     1"  ! %9  #(  "

#!  -   #"  4% .

#    "

"  #  -

!  -   "  '! 

#"!(  

.

19> #"%1"

" "!20!#5!#"( "!(

- !#5"

! #(

!'"

 ! #20!#5!#"&'



!""# " $ %"&'(

"  &  ) "*'

  "  #+  "   )   $',+  $ $&

 -'

! 

)) "* ," 

"*

#$  &.

#" )) "* ,- (("./!

  5 ""!- ;!

!#( .. "

""

5! "- ( 1.!('9"

5 "

"#.9%1! #15! "

.9 !# #/- !! /

5!.

-  #20!#5!#"&' !

1!

! %9 !1.

5 #!1%.( 0!'!!#!&!1"!( !9!



@ "!.

  ! #"%1"

#( "!(

 

1 '.!'%" "- ;!

!#( #, +!0!/    !  )%.!  77 /  "

!  4% .

#  !4% !(  $1 "

! 5 "

1 #("

!1!"

1 "!%! #+"+!1

5     "

# .  %#1 .    $1 "

# .   #,  $   "

# .

 

!#"

1!

%! A01 "

# .  # %"!#, #!!

"!1 1 ." (! 5" "!: ( (%1 "

# !1 #( ( "!- -!!

!!9! "! 1

#,>  1"

1 .!8 !#1! !1#1!#!(" (!-!!

"'!, 0!# !!#1!% !9! 

@/"

#!- #" 4% .

#  ( " #(!0!# ""

!"

5!

#"5!#" !- 

#,(!,!! :!1 .!1"

1 .  !!1%!("

"(!,!! !9!



  

#( #,  !1(!(  (% #,  !,%.   #4% 9 !  !

(%1!(   %#(!* E#"

! ..!, "

# #! !1" 1 ,! !!" %!("   

   /  $1 "

# .  ! 1 !/  20!#5!#"  =

;

/!<!

%/

""!#(!!('99%# ( "!(



@9% 0!5!#"

#!("

"#.9 #15!%1!

5 ;

'"

!#(5!!" .9 !# #/- !!/ ""

5!9% !- ( #,20!#5!#"&' #( !"

!(# ( "!(7 ..!, "

# 0!( #( 11( #,".

"

..!, "

#           

  (  !1%!( 

!(%1 "

# .4% .

# :!1 .!1"

1 .#, #!!

#, !9! 

/-

- #"!.

'.! "

" 01 "

# .

! 1 ! # 11( #1!- !)%.!( "!(677  F%

0!!1%!("

&''9"!#(!

#, .!

"'91## !  !5 .9!!>

1!     1"  (%1 "

#  

1!/ !<!

%/ 0!155 ""!(,0 . "

#(%1")%.!/

 ..!, "

# 0!( %!"!1!

" #15 .!"! #( %#1!.  5 "

# "(!. 9!(" ,! 5 1"(%1 "



1!  /  !<!

%/  (!

"!  (!5 #( #,  5 

5  # ! "!(11  #!, ( #, 0 ( #, 5 "

(! .

6 !5 .9!!>

1!(! .

#,-

1 !/

! "

!! 1## 0 #1!  1"(%1 "

#

1!/!<!

%

1 !

 1

# 9  1"

#    "  '!  "!(  , #"  %."9 !5 .9!!>

1!1#1!#!(-

1 !G :91# (!

#( #, #4% 9!

" #('9,

"%# "9 #, #!/"

%,#!((! (  .

-   . 1#"0!9- "

!!'!

!=#H'.!"

! !8%"

!1 ! 

" + #  # #"

0(#1.

.) 

@  /- # "-  !.("

"(!

!#(!#" (!1! !(20!#5!#"

!5 .9!! #"!#"

".!("!5 .95!#"#15 # "!,%#( #1 !

#!

!#"  .

0! #( #20!#5!#"!5 .95!#"#"

"1 !

#"5!#" #(!#"- 5 (!#15 # "!,%#( 1#" 9" .

19 15

#"5!#" "!"

!(! "

!/ !! /5"

!-  #20!#5!#"&'?."

5 "!.9/"

#"5!#"

#(!#"- 1 #1!..!('9=#B'.!"

! !8%" #  &%(,5!#"     #  :!#1  

  %"  #  "

!  1 !

!.)'#

'#/!0(

" + #  #"

(

 / !  15 # "! 

#"5!#"  -   1 #1!..!(  #  "

!  ,%#(  "

"  "

#"5!#"  -   1#" 9  "  "

!  %.!  #(  - %" 

0 .   15 !"!#"  %"

"9 #  "

"  1 !/  "

!  5"

!  -   !5 .9!(    D: "! 1 ! !1 #( ( "!1#"!#(!("

!( (#"5 !

!!#"155 #9  %( 

#"5!#"- 5 (!'9 ,# ! (0 1!, 0!#'9 

!1!" 9"

#!- #"!#"

".!( "

! 5! 

#"%1"

#"-  !.("

#"5!#"- , #"!( #1#" 0!#"

!%.! #1## 0 #1!- !(! .

#,

1!- 5 .

(! #"!#"

# #(

7 %."!

5"

0! ! 1"

#(!#" %"

"9-  !.("'!

'

" 9 #(%#! # '.!"-  . !.("

#!1 ##"'!

, #"!( #9!.

%#(!"

!!4% " '.! #(!8" ( # 9&% ( 1"

#%#(!

"

1.! > !#"

"%"

#- !#( #!"1#(%1" "9 !! # #"

!&%(,5!#"

%" !1 !  '#/!

0(

" .#% & #"

(  C) 7/"

#!- #"

! #,5 5%5!(%1 "

# .4% .

#'%"- 

#"!("- 

!.("

"-  1 !  %(# %'.

1"

#" !#- 4% .

#%#.!4% .

1"

#-!!!. 8!( #( "1 !

- #" !.(!#"

".!( 15

#"5!#" # #"

!&%(,!5!#" !.

= %" !1 ! !

'

 

1 (!  0(  ! '

$ #2 $'#'(

   -   ,!'  .#'3') , ".#3',

!.

 7 / "-  !.("

"5 !

!!#" "

# "!.

5%#""  %( #"

"1 ! .!

"- 

.!('9"

#!

#" "

!!- # #(!

!#(!#"%1! #15! #(

5"

!- (!1. !("'! %!-

!'%". "!# "-  %#("

"-  1 !  %("!1%!!5 .95!#"#15 # "!,%#(11( #,.9/ #!.

- , #"!(""

#! #("

#- (  . .9 # #"

!&%(,5!#" + ( 9  (! = %"

!1 !  %*

! 1+ 0(

"  #"

(  CCD

/ "-  !.("

"#1  1"!0!

#/ "-  %#("

1"" "!( '9 #!  #  0!

#  5 -!!  .!  #(  #1!1"    ( % !!(  1""

"1 # .1 !- !, "!!( , #"

5

.!('!

!+= %"- ( !(#"

!,%#(  %( # #"

!&%(,5!#" ..

' (= 1%" !1 !

  ! # .

 .

$0(

"  #"

( @ 6/15

#"5!#" "1 !- 1 #1!..!( #  "

!  ,%#(  "

"  "

#!B  !.(!  '"

!  .! (9  '"

#!(

#"5!#"%#(! 9 #, # = #! )%.!/ 7@  "#!- 

#(%1"!( #( 1

# 9%#

5 1!- !!1  1"!- %"5" #!"9 - !4% !(

#"5!#" #!- 1 #1!..!('9 .( "  "

#"5!#"  -   '"

#!(  "

%,  %(  '9  %'5 ""

#,  .!

" #("

#!( (#"(!!0! #9!.

%#(!"

1" #( 1%5" #1! !1 ! #("

#-  11( #,.9(  .  %!- "

!!'!

!) & "

#= %" 1 ! 

'#/!0(

" % ( ! #  776@/ .#','#/!!

#0(! '

$ #4 # /'#/'

%$

0'!+

0'

#     %$

 #  "

(  

@    C)   / .

+ 

1 (!

) !+ +0(0'3 ! #3 ,,"

 #'*

('

+ # #"



@ 

/?""  ;

#(= %" !1 ! 

) 15.$ 0( 

"

#3! , #"

(

C)  #( "# = %"

!1 ! $ &.5.$ 0(

"'!

 #"

(

 :CD)7 #  "

!!#"  1 !  ./  "

!!    5 !

!!#" "

#  #( 1#1! .5!#" 1" #!- #"!.

'.! 

#"5!#"""

"    $1 "

# .  ! 1 !    !  -   #"  ! #,  "

!  !4% "!

4% .

#- !#

#- 5 (! !5 ""!- ;!

!#( #, .#, ( #(# ""

!4% .

#/ !

#-  %'5 ""!( "#.9 .!

'!!#

.!('91#1! .

1"

!, ( #, . 9 #!'%"#- !! "- 5!#"

#!( "  "

!   #!  -   .  #  20!#5!#"  &'   

 %#(!" ;

#,-  %# !( #%1  5 ##! 5-

"1%.(#"'!

!!("

" #9"

! .95!5'!- ! # #,"1 #!  .9'!5 (!

%"  "

" "

#"5!#"  '!!# 1%!(  #   (%.!#"  5 ##! '9 !

!!#"

#,  "

!  5 "!

.   1"  #(  '9 1#1! .5!#"   1"% .

 #  #!(!#"(!!0!"'!!"

#!(#"

"

$1 "

! #( "1 #'! ("

%,#!((! (  .

".9'!!# 11( #,.9/"

!! #5!

! ,%5!#" (0 #1!('9 .! #!(!# 1%#!. "

#! #("

#'!

#,(!0 (  #9 5!

!!'9( 0!5'! /  6  7

&    ! ! ;

#,>! #!( F!  !!

" '.!

F!