Joginder Singh v. Punjab Agro Industries Corp Ltd And ANR
!
"#$ #%
# &##
# #% #
' ( ') **+**,
,
- (,
) .
, *)( (
- ** , ))*
*((( -/
% .
%-- 0 (11 234 5 672-8 696- !-:
;9:< -
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9
2 >2;6
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9
3-6 >2;6 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 ( (
#3< >726 76
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 * 3- 5-87
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 *(
$78A % 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9
((( B3 =?
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 (*,,( #3< 7- 76
111--6
=62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 ( ( 3-6 5-87
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 (((( 52B79 5-87
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 ( ( 52B79 5-87
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 (
(
%9B >2;6
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9
5-87 76
111--6 =62
--6< .
2;6 #..-6+ ! 24:- %-6-42- 76
11 9 ,
56?9 5-87 $-
111--6 =62
- .
-
76
111 9 ) &79:
796
111--6 =62
- .
-
76
111 9 * @?:< 76
111--6
=62
- .
-
76
111 9 *,( 52B73A 5-87
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-</$6 .
%-66+ 7 234 #86 26- 691 76 111 9 *(
2667 5-87 76
111--6 =62
7 ! 696- .
- 76 111 9 ( (
6-76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 (
762 ;
111--6 =62
234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
76
111 9 (**
#863 5-87
111--6
,
=62
- .
- 76
111 9 (
6?-6 5-87
111--6 =62
234 #86 26- 696- 76
111 9 (
=-B6;
5-87 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 ** ,
7 234 5 696-? 5299:< 6B-8 !6- !-:
;9:< - 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 ,(*
3 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9
*
$-B6;3- 5-87 76
111--6 =62
5 .
234 76
111 9 , )
$:3 5-87
-::
111--6 =62
234 5 #86 26- 691
76
111 9 *
$:3 5-87
-::
76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 , ( >2:A 5-87 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 * ) * 52B7?
5-87 :- 76
111--6
)
=62
- .
- 76
111 9 ***
6473 % $7- 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 *((
#! !-:
;9:< - 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 ,, $42 5-87
111--6 =62
7 234 #86 26- 691 @1 76 111 9 )(( ;
6?7
111--6 =62
7 234 #86 26- 691 @1 76 111 9 (( *
*
B7 5-87
111--6 =62
7 234 #86 26- 691 @1 76 111 9 (), *
29-6 5-87
111--6 =62
7 234 #86 26- 691 @1 76 111 9 >-B6 5-87
111--6 =62
- .
- 76 111 9 * "8-6 5-87
111--6 =62
7 234 #86 26- 691 @1 76 111 9 ,,), ( 3-6 5-87 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 )( C4:
5-87
111--6 =62
- .
- 76 111 9
) ,
7 234 5 672-8 !-:
;9:< - 76
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
111 9 * 67;
@:
111--6 =62
7 #--:
7-.
566<2;!--:
;;--6 76
11 9
(, , 8:
5-87 76
111--6 =62
7 234 5 672-8 691 76 111 9 , 3- 5-87
111--6 =62
$6 .
%-66+ 234 #86 26- 69 76 111 9 ,* ) 96 5-87
111--6 =62
234 #86 26- 691 76 111 9 ,(
26?
5-87 76
111--6 =62
7 ?-A-8 #276-<+ 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 696- @1
5 76
11 9
(
>;:
>-76 111--6 =62
234 5 672-8 696-
76
11 9 ),(
526-6 5-87 111--6 =62
--6< .
2;6 #..-6+ 76
11 9 ( ?9 5-87 111--6 =62
- .
- 76
11 9
, -- "-:
111--6 =62
- .
- 76
11 9 ((
#;9 D#;9
29
76
111--6 =62
#99:: #276-< 5 76
11 9 *
57-??
5-87 76 111--6 =62
#99:: #276-< 234 5 -?-:
5299:- 691 @1 76
11 9 ((,( 5-7 >2;6
111--6 =62
234 5 -?-:
5299:- 691 @1 76
11 9 )
=62 >2;6
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:-
691 @1 76
11 9
),
#3< >2;6
111--6 =62
234 5 -?-:
5299:-
691 @1 76
11 9 ,
89 5-87 111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:-
691 @1
11 9
#B7 =6; 111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 5 -?-:
5299:-
691 @1
11 9 ,((
89 5-87
89
111--6 =62
--6< .
2;6 #..-6+ ! 24:-
%-6-42- 76
11 9 ( )(
(
36 >2;6 3-6 >2;6
111--6 76 =62
--6< .
2;6 #..-6+ ! 24:- %-6-42- 76
11 9
5267 >2;6 76 111--6 =62
- .
- 76
11 9 ( 29-6 5-87
111--6 =62
7 #99:: #276-<+ 7 234 #86
26- 696-
111 9 #0
E$@
1 " 5
# 5 # 5
!"##"$!"%&' !"%#()!"%&$ !"(("$!"%&*
!$"$+!"%&* !$)*'!"%&* !'#+'#!"%&+ !
$'&&!"%&( !&(*)&!"%"% !#$)'!"%"% !"%&'(!"%"% !"$)#'!"%"& !&$'%#!"%""
!*#)"!"%"' !&)%#)!"%") !&")&#!"%")
!&$')'!"%") !&$)))!"%") !&$)#&!"%")
!'&*)!"%") !"$"(!"%"$ !&"')$!"%"$
!"+*%%!"%") !"'##!"%"$ !&&&+!"%"$ !"(($!"%&* , !"'#*!"%"$
- !&#'%"!"%") , !&#'%"!"%") . / !&&"*$!"%"& 0 1
!"))$#!"%&(
- 4
1 32
5 6 1
!&&%&&!"%"% !&"&%&!"%"& !&"(#"!"%"& !&)$%*!"%"&
!&$+'(!"%"& !&('"!"%"&
!")((!"%"% !#"%$!"%"% !"##"$!"%&'
!+")#!"%&( 32 / !'*)(!"%%#
&#$(% ""()) "%&' !&*'%& $*($ "%&+ !")+*'
"%&( !&'#()!"%"% !")&)'
, ")&$# "%"'
/2 1 1
1 /44 . ) !"##"$!%"%&'
.
32
!&$+%%!"%"% 4 32 1 2 . & , "
!#$)'!"%"% -
4 !789 !#"%$!"%"% , !"&'+'!"%"'
!"#%&)!"%"' !')#)*!"%") , 8!"&'+'!"%"'
- 4 32
!&)(**!"%") 02 1 , :
!'*%"!"%&) !**+*!"%&) , !'+)"!"%&#
; 1 , < ;
!&$*&"!"%""
/;
1 2
!&$*"%!"%"'
1
1 6/ ;
= 1=
< !7.17 !")&$#!"%"'
,
1 !7.17 !&)(**!"%") , !')$$!"%") < 1 . $ > -3?@6 !"(($!"%&* -
!01 !&$'%#!"%""
;
4
1 . )$ ,* !7./-9.
!&$*"%!"%"'
!7.17 !&#'%"!"%") - ; 1 4
!7.17 , ;
= 9 5 3 3 / . '
) !$'&&!"%&( .
!9- !#$)'!"%"% !&'#()!"%"% !'#+'#!"%&+ !&$'%#!"%""
, !*#)"!"%"'
1 3 /
12 .
. # !
&(##(!"%%(
. + !"))#$!"%&( 12 / !;
= !&#$(%!"%&'
1 4 1 4 !?9 7 / , 02 !')&&+!"%") 1 . )
!&)'#$!"%"&
. *
#
!""())!"%&' !'*%"!"%&)
!"'*%*!"%&#
1 B7.17 . &$"(% "%&' !'*)(!"%%# !"#%&)!"%"' !&$')'!"%") !&$)))!"%")
!&$)#&!"%")
2
1
!1 !$)*'!"%&* . 4
1 /44 !1 < 4 !7.17 !*#)"!"%"'
6 < / !7.17 . ")&)'
"%"' !*#)"!"%"'
!&")&#!"%") 1 < 6 1< . '
) !"%#()!"%&$ 6 < 4C !9- !"##"$!"%&' !"$)#'!"%"& !"$##$!"%"'
, !+)+"!"%"'
;
. *
# !'+)"!"%&# 4
1 4 4
. &!789 !$"$+!"%&*
**+**,
,
*)( (
))*
*((
") C
4
44 **,
- (, ,
4 = 4 = 4
. &!
1
4C C
3
2
4
4C =C
4
44 5
. &!
1 4
2
)
=
!"
4
= = =;
; E 2 22
4 <
& 9 = 4
=
= =C
24C
? !1 ;
=
;= 4
4C
? 9
4C =C /2 9
"" &% "%"&
4
= 2
44
4C 4 '% %$ "%""
=
4
44
44
2
2
4 =4 4C 4C
"
=C
!1 ;
= C
!24C
C 4
2 4 =
4 2
= F
= =
24C
2
B4
2
2
=
=C 24C <
2= C
2
*
'
") %+ "%&"
!"
#
$ %&#'
(#)(##*+ #
4
4 24C
= F
44
C
2
44
2
2 2
24
=
B4
4C
= 2
EG
) 742 4C
= 4 =C 1 4
?
E 2 9 4 4 -
H9-G
2 E F
B4
= 4B
"" &% "%"&
'% %$ "%""
. "$& , "*( 4C
=C 4C "" &% "%"& 22 E 22 E 2
4B
= 22 9-!90@
24
44
4B
4
= 4
4C 2 2 %& && "%"&
4 4 '% %$ "%"" 4C "" &% "%"& = =
4
2 - = < "%"'!"%") $
242 4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
=C /2 9 C 2 ?
=4 6= F F
= * 5 4
=
=2 4C F
2
B4
= = 4 2
= <
4C "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
4C
=
4 =4 F
4
2
44 4C =
4 44 4
4 4C
4 ; 24C # 5 4
= ? =2 4 4CB
"" &% "%"&
'% %$ "%""
=
4 =4 = ?
24C = ? =
= =C
= E
2
4C "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
+ 5 4
= ? 1 ;
= =2 1
<
4C 242 4 1
7
( 5 4
? 9
=2 <
4C
E
4 =C ?
4C 2 =;
=C ? 9
? F
B4
4
=; = 4
= 2
E
2 4
=
=; = 4C 2 4C "" &% "%"& &% 5 4
= ? 1 ;
=
2 4 4 ? 9
4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
= 2 =
24C 4 2 = 2 && 4 4
=4
&"
F
= 2
4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
= 2 =C 1 /2
E
=C
?
=
4 =4 4C
C = 24C
= ?
4 2 = = 4 &'
=
4 < 2
=
4 2 4C F
=
2
=
4 =4
B4
2
4
= 4
=C E 9- 8 22 E 4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
= 2 =C /2 9
8 = 44C
4C = = 22 /2 4C =
4 =4
E = 24C
?
=
4 = =C /2 9
9 =
4C
=4
= 4
4 4C
2
2
4
4
B4
4
= 4 =C < 2 4C 2
4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
&)
B4
2 2 4C
4C
= ? 4
? 9
? /2 ;
=
= 4
4CB "" &% "%"&
&$ ? 4C "" &% "%"& =C /2 9
4C
4 =4 4C
44 2 = 24 4C 24C 24C
"& &% "%"& 24 2
44 = 4
2 24C 24C 2
44
24
F
2
=
4
"& &% "%"&
44 = 4
44 4C ; = 24 4C 24C
; = 2
=
4C "& &% "%"& 4C &*
E =
=C 4C "" &% "%"& = 2
B4
4 =
2 2 "& &% "%"&
4C "" &% "%"& C 2 =C 4C
B4
< 2 =C
4C 4C
44 =
= C
44
44 = 2 C
= &# ? 4C "" &% "%"&
C =
E
=
=4
= <
4
B4
242 2 =C 4C "" &% "%"&
<
242 4C
4
2 E4
(
24C
4
24
44
= 4C
=C 2
4 C =C 4C "& &% "%"& &+ 9 = = ? 9
=;
B
2 C
4
2 =;
=C ? 1 ;
=
44
= 24C
4 2
4C =;
2 &( 9
C
44
24C
B2
4 = = 4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
= 2
=C E
=C
4C
44 =
4 =4
=
C ? 9
44
=C ? /2 ;
=
44
4 2 = =C 24C
C =
44
2 24 F
B4
2 C
C 2
= 2 2
44
4C
!
4C = 2
4 C
=C 24C
=
44
4 =
; 24C
44
44
2 2 2 =
4C "" &% "%"& "% 3
2
=
C 24C
C
=
2
4C
44 = B =;
<
2 F
B
B4
C 24C
=C 4
44
44
2
44
2
C 4C
= =C /2 9
"" &% "%"&
=
4 =4 2 "& 9
C
=C 24C C
44 =
=4
4<
B =C 24C 2 4CB "" &% "%"& /2 9
<
C
B =C
C
4CB "" &% "%"& 9 =; =C 24C
2
= <
4 C
2 = =4C 2 C 2 <
2
,
4 4C F ""
?
=; = < =C ? 9
=
24C = 2 =; ? 9
44
4 = 4< = 4CB
"" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
= 2 = =C E 9 =; ? 9
4 2 4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
44 = < =C ? /2 ;
=
44 =
44 =
4 4C "" &% "%"&
9 ? 9
C F
!
4 2 =C ? C
4
2C =
?2 "'
9 ?
=; ? 9
; =C ? 9 C
44 =
4 2
2
") ? 2
44 4B
"" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%""
=C /2 9
"$ 2 4 4
=2 44
4C F
4
44 =
4 4C 4C
4 C =
4 =C =C
4 2 =
4=C
C
2= C
4
2C "* ?
2 2 2
24C
44
=
24C F
B
= =C
24C
C 24C
=;
2 2 =C 4 4 4CB "" &% "%"&
4 '% %$ "%"" 44 4 2 =C
= <
2 0
C
44 =
242 "# 9 = 4C
'% %* "%"$
44 = 4< =C
2 "+
= 2 "( 4 244
4
C
4 '% C = 4 4 < (+
# 5 # 5
" %