Om Prakash Gupta v. Union Of India & ORS
!" # $ %"&'()*#+, # $ -. #+
+ ) %/%'012%
3'1'
"4%,0150.&%6,-'6""&70'
'24'
!" #$%&'"#()$ '&&!
!" #$%&'" '&!
***
'( - .0%)%,4&%" -
.0%)%,4&%, "02
99999 '&!+#
) %/%'012%'%554"044%4
# $:;1 < =44*60%4)'%*1%, 0%45%0&0:"'0>?= #@#A##B#BA # @,C0*6 0"C5"'150*60),0%'*4&4(< >
!
! "# % $$ & ' ()* +
, , - . / ! "#
$
'0
! '
$
' + 1 ! )
2
' '
1 ! )
2 +
&34
$ $$
$ $
'
+ 1 ! ' 5 6 ' - 1 ! ' 5 6 ' -- 1 $ !
' $! $6 1
!
' 1 '
6 7 8 '
! $$6 1
!
' ' $$ $ '
!
9 "%450'1*)'''"0%4&1'" 02,C14*%222%5*""%&1%)%;"0 &'64
B
B@#, 0 2 D4 0 ""& " 0 '24'%'.124A %4<%4C%'2)4@
B@
%'.124A %4< 0&%4".16C%')54C00 55 %4 12 0 " '''% .16 " /'
B@ C,!
B$+,)"4%,44%&&20 )5"0%4%444"'4<)5 '20'6' ''1444%4 B$+,0%)"02%''''% %4<"514%. B!
3444%4
B+#,4<)5C%'
&%&4
B+#,%0'6'C%'2)15%4,C0*6 2E'%)C%''0C%. $BC0%'0'D1"514% B+
B
B+ ,D12''C551%2)%''''% .16"/'"6% 554"0'%),02 2"4
AA BB *" 0 " <";% " 0 '602'".16'''%%4<0*%''"0'4% "%''1)5%22)%'.16'''%%4<:.1245< A < =%45%"%&'F1%*"'"2)02'" '''%.16"/'
04')''40%")4 5%22&% $
## '20"%&'&141")0 5%22&%,
&0% .50,C0 C%' ))4%' 02%4 C%' %4 ')%6, 2"4 !! " BB!
34 4 4%4
BB , 0 '%4 5% 22&% C%' %C4 *6 0 % 4)'%*1%,%/11)&0*655*"0*%''" 0D145)448'0%0%4E'&%' 042%),%" )2)%"048'0%0%4E'&%',445%*" 0')%6'1%42''
0'5%4,.0%%%4.0%)% 2"4
" BB# .&0C%'4""&"2,0 )%C%'"40 1&00&%'" 8 %D4%.50 3'1' "4%%40'
3444%4 +
BBB,0 1 &0"0*1%4'2'4"0''1%4&%)0&&1'0% 04<)5"055%4%4&'1"C'2%% %4'"55%4.16"/'21'1%04%4 B$+"0)"4%,2'C4*41&4 .16"/'%4%'202C "
B$+
- .0%)% 4&% %22%5 *0%" " -
.0%)%,%4&1'"02'1*)40%%'20 4&'44*60 1&0,441%&%'',/"0%22&%, C%'4&4*&'444246 0&%'"8 %D4% .50 :
1 &0= C%' "C4 *64"" &0' " 0 % 4)'% *1% %4, 0", C " 0 %")4 4&',0%22&%)4 C22&% !!A "'/5 )4"&%"044%4$
## 0'%4 C22&%C%'
4'2'4"C0%4&0&)2%106</%0 5%&"0%22&%<2C"0D145),
# !,0'24'2%''4%'2%/54D&50&%)"
0%22&%"<";%"0'6C "
B+ %4%0 &'F1%*"',/2)%''''%.16/'%4 .16/'C "
B+$
0 %22&%<2 &0%54 0 %")4 '2%/54*6"5 #@#A##B # ,C0&0C%'4'2'4"*6 0444%4
%40)%C%')40 '24'C0%4&<'0)21544050" 04&'5*60*1% C22&% !!A *6 %""450)0'E) 0'24'2%''40'2%/54 4%4$
# @:;1< =%4%5%D&40&%)"0%22&% "<";%"0'60%4".16'''%%4< ")@
B@ 1"0%";4*60'24'")%1%6, B+ %' 2"'025*60%22&%21'1%&"04%4
B+#
C%'1540%0&))45%6%42'6 4')''50&%)"020514")%C01 &50"%&0%415%0'),514")%C%' %/ 00%4%40 C22&% C0 ''154&'0'24'<'0)%,01',"'0&%1' "%&%&&1402<%22&%%4,0",0)2154 4'%**'<%'4
0%0%40%4&1'"02,%22%'4 02%2*/%4%"0C0%0'"&%4)0 '1*)''' " - .0%)% 0 %22&%<2 0%4 4 C "
BB$ '12%1%,0%22&% 0%4&%)4<";%" '6 0 2' " .16 '''% C "
@
B@ %4 %
&'F1%*"'"2)%''''%.16"/'C "
B+ %4 2) %' .16 " /' C "
@ B+$ C0 %%' " '%%6 %4 ' " 2'%6 *"' 0 %
AA BB C%'4')''4*5*%4*6)% "'0 &%1'"%&%&&1402""5 C22&%
%"4')''%"0 5%22&%%'04D&50' &%))%41&0%54
0&%)"020%4%%46*&);&C "04')''%"0 5%22&%" BB 06% ## 0 '&4 5% 22&% C%' 2%%6 %C4 *6 0
)' 6%'0%%2'45%450&%)"'6 "
@
B@ %40C%'4%6"! 6%'C05%402) "
B+
020%'*%*5%6'%'"%&6 ;2%%*"00'1"'1&04%4%6;&2 150%')02''0%450*"%)' #6%'%" D&"0'&%) ## ,C0%'00%4406% BB$
C14*%2241&0%2"04 4%4$
## ,;%&4*60,2%%5%20' !, %4 C0 4')''50 5%22&%" BB
0'%)%4'01'(< > :
$ ! * $ , 6 ' '
' 1 '
$
1
- , $
' !
6
1
$
' 4 1 ' '' $ 6 $$ $! * 6
$
! $, ' $!
- 5 ' '
' 6 )1
' 2, ;! ' < '
, /-- = >1 6 , ' ' '
, ! $ 6 $ $$ % <?: 6 $ - 6 $ ' -
6 6
6 6
$ 1 ==- $!,
'
$
$ $$
$ "6 , ( : $$
$ :
, ? $ & , @ 3- $!
6 1 - ? $ & )1
' 2 $ 1 6 <?: '! !
6 1
' $ !
6 1 $!, 1 6 <?:
6 $ 1 $ 6 6
1
!
- -/ 6 6
$ 1 --
$ #
' 1 6 <?: $ 6 $ $$ !
$ ,
$
$$6 $
' '
1
6
- -/
@
6 '$ $! ; , --/ , $ / >1
' ,
$ $! $ ' ? $ & ' ( : @ 3- $ *
' :
, >
& ' $ +
*
*
, ' ,
$ 1 $$! ; 1 , *
' '
$!
6
5 1
*
' :
, A 6 & ' @ ? +* B C ' 2 @ D3--
43 *
' :
, ? $ & '
+ +
5
'
$
6 ' ? $ & A 6 & '
:
9 02&%*2)4<%5%0)%%" 6%'*6"50 C22&%
0'"%&'0%* ;%)4 %4 &4 *6 0 C0 4')''5 0 5% 22&%,C0&0&%*"%14C0
'%12'0"1"45',C4"4%65%6%4 2'60)21544 514""&')%41
2'%4'4')''4 :#()$ '&&!- . '&!- #$/0"
#$/0"
3+ 41 6 6 57 48 9:
;
( 5:
6 6 42
( 5: