← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5127/2015allowed

Gurbir Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2018-05-03Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri10 pages

 

     

!" #"$%&%'( ) *+

,  

             ( - ./     - ./ / 0"&"'!(

  

   !



 

"

   

 

# 

  !

   $%

   +   &'  

 !

 () 



!

*+ ,  

  

         



  

              

! "

#   $  "  



"   #  %  "  &'() *     "

  "   &     

      ""    " 

%   " +,-. ///.   0

 - /



    . /0 &

  &

! 1        

    !+ . /0  &

 !2

   .



    

       .

 3  4 .56! (7+))8  !   

  9 '   

 

             

  

   :

      !    .

1  ;

.    

 

  

   

 

   

     !

!     (<))   =           !  

  8             



    >&

 ;

.  = 8 ;

.

'    > &

 ;

.   . $?)@+?%) )() 0.8 0. 

  (<)%)()  . !     

        '#"020""!  /%'34 5 46'  7"0&8&  /! !"  

8'9 : '#!4"0& 3))76(( ..%?7 

!   ;

.    :

 .  ' ;

. 

'

0.  8 0.



     ! 

*

'  



  

  

'   +  8 0. !

 !

   + 1

!=

 *+ ,/ 1  2

"  

  

$    "

"

$ 

# "". 

 $  1   1+



  

 3

   

"$   

  

 "$ 

+

 

,++4         2  +





      "" 

 "

 5 



  3 

0"  "&   /

$ 2

"  





" 

$   2 "

 0 2  

       

 

"  "    "     

"        "      

2 

"   "   



"

  " 2    

" "   

 1+

 

 "3" 

  

  

$  "

2       "      3        

  6   



 

  

      

 2 "3"



  





 

 

""  "



   //'2

" "

 ""

-  

!    0.

+  !=  8   

  !  +  8 =



         !



  ' =' 

/ :

        

     

                 '    

     

;

    +% 0.5

   

  (<)%)()     '     0  

   

!  '

         

   +    1  &

B 

    )())()3

0+76!

  

 C)?))< .  .A $)77% )) ;

  

      8  

  !     ' 0 .  +% 0.5

    

  (<)%)()  +%   )())() 3

0+76;     +@   !       (<)%)() ' 0.  

       )())()3

0+760  

  ! 

'

   :



   

                    0    

  

!  '

    !

 ' 

           '

  !

  ;

.>

'

          

! '      '     '     

               

'         

         

   0.5

!

    '        8    

    +%       

    (<)%)() 0.    '!

 !        

           

 '   

     ' $

 

            

  :

    )())()3

0+ 76        

!

     0.8 '   '     /   A

        

A

    





'    :  

0.

  



         8 0.



     %

  *+ , 7      0

  "   

     

"  





 7 

"

 "         

  "         "

 

 



7  

<     

" "  

   

 

 (+

   ( "    







   )  

   "

 

      "     -    

         

              )())() 

 #   ;   1  +:&

 !

*+ ,!



 $

% 

1 (

 -  -  "8.    6    ,  !

     

   

9 " $  1   1+

   

+,-.:



//'2///   

  

 */71 9 " $  1   1+



 $   *4'" +6;



 0 1  ,,   , 

 $   

 +, -. 0 

    */

, !

  6 

"  



 $   *4'2, !

   *'2   ;

44'0-"*0*&2 *'  

    */   



""

+,-.:

   0     

$ <0   

  ,  ,    = $,. $  !

 ,%""

 =0"  & -  > =0"  4 ( ; "

 ?  > * (  , '   ( /  -  %>  ? "

 , >  !

"

  >  "$, =0"   @ 3 > %  "

=0"  & ( >  (  "

=0" 

  

 4 -  ,  ?

  !

$A  * > >  ,"

=0"  ' = $("

 " / !

,  , 3$     ,  =  ",  . "> % " "

& , !

"

=0"  4 1  ,,  6   

   *'

, !

2

 

 "  " 

    



$

" 

0 2      

       





 "  

    

2  "

 

  ;

 

  

 

 

         3  & 6 1 9 ",

+



8  $   '" + "(

 ";

4&04

(



,@+;

''0'&

'01+



 $  1   B, 

 $   ,@+;

''0''&' ,@ +;

''&0''4/  "   1 9 " $

1   1+

2+     *4' 4 6  , !

    " 

 $  '  1 9 ",

 +



8 2

" 2 

""

&   0

    

$ 7  



 ""

)    

1 9 ",

+

7



"  "     

 "         "  



   



$

7  

  



"  





(+

   ( " 



""



"" 







   )  

   " 

      "    <0   

  = $,. $  ( ; "

 ?  > & (  , 4   (  , >  !

"



,   

 * -  , ' = $("

 " / !

,  , 3$     ,  =  ",  . "> % " "

& 1  ,,  82  2 "   0



  +,-.:

"" 

$    

+    2

 "2   2 



= ! "2 $  1   1+

 ,0   

 !" #! !$% & ' #( )*

  *   $  +, ++!-.(! C ;

44'0- "0&'% 2+  2& ( 

  

     

""

 

  

          

  

!

";

44'0- " &042 /<0 7= 2 $ D1   1+

2+     

   "    

 +,-.:

  "  7(

 ! "2 $ 2+   (""



 ,0 / %, 01- 

0+7 

 





  

     '

!   +%    '   '    



 9       

  !

!

  +

!    

 

     9

     !  +@   0 

=



      !   '  

          !



 !

 

'

   !

   (<+(+))) :    

 +%  

0+7



 !   '  '

       !

      ' 

= '

       

   A    

' 

 

              

    '  

  

0+7'    % @     '    $ 



 '    !

'           

     !

     '   

   

;

.       

  !

   ' :

  '    ! !  

      '        

A     

 !                     +%           )())()3

0+76' 



!

=    = 

   

'    ':

 !

   A 

9 !

*+   36 

    '   !*+ ,  

  

        

     

            

! "

#   $ 

"  



"   #  % 

  "     &'  ()   *  

        "

   "     &        

    ""    "   %   " +,-./// .   0

 - 36 $           /    ) *+

,

   9

D  * ED$   * ED$