← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5178/2015allowed

Darshani Devi v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-03-28Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

  

        

  !"#$#%&'&()*  !+',!(&#-& #"&"&(#+ '

.#+'/'

0"!"#/(1!2!($",#+'

 #'3($#(" '

)  45  0 6 50  +#'#(")7 +0/+&($#+ !+89$-%!"#9+",#3#"&"&(#+ '.!($!(!!:,"+!9$$&"&(!:$-%!"# #(#+!:9/(1!2  ,#",#+",# #3+"#+':%!:(#;'3!3#+<!=2#!::;#$" '##",#1/$8<#(">  2#+##++#$"",# #3+"#++(" * ,#",#+",#1/$8<#("',/:$2#+#3+"#$&(",#$&8#'"> 77 77 50 

5 ,#3#"&"&(#+,!'&(-?#$",#;+&"1/+&'$&%"&(",&' /+"

/($#++"&%:#'@ ",# ('"&"/"&(($&!+&''/!(%#!;+&" %#+"&+!+&  +  A/!',&(8  ",#  +$#+  $!"#$  

C  3!''#$2=+#'3($#("!($/+",#+!;+&"<!($!</'+!::;&(8",# 3#"&"&(#+"%,!(8#",#$!"#3"&(;&",##%"+<BB9&('"#!$ B /+",#+9! ;+&"<!($!</' ,!' 2##('/8," +$&+#%"&(8 +#'3($#("'"+#/($",#+#%-#+= '9C 79##%"#$+<",# 3!=<#("8+!"/&"=",#3#"&"&(#+ ,#',+"%("+-#+'=&'",!"",#3#"&"&(#+;!';+?&(8!'!

:#+?&(",##3!+"<#("$/%!"&(/($#+",# -#+(<#("/(1!2 ( B9",#+#;!'!8#(#+!:'"+&?#2=",#/(1!2 -#+(<#("#<3:=##' 33!+#(":=9&(+$#+"+#;!+$",##<3:=##' ((78!E#""#$#<3:=##' 9 ;,$&$("3!+"&%&3!"#&(",#'"+&?#9",# -#+(<#("/(1!2,!$$#%&$#$ "8+!("!'3#%&!:&(%+#<#(""",'##<3:=##';&",##%"+<B

77 (",#<#!(;,&:#9(!%%/("",#/(1!2 &-&:0#+-&%#'

#-&'#$0%!:#'

!=  /:#'9BB9",#3!='%!:#'",#/(1!2 -#+(<#("#<3:=##' ;#+#+#-&'#$;&",##%"+<B ,#3!=",#3#"&"&(#+;!' !%%+$&(8:=&D#$9-&$#+$#+$!"#$B ((#D/+#77@ 9"!?&(8",!"

',#,!$ 3"#$ ++#-&'#$ 3!='%!:#' ;&", ##%" +<B ,# 3#"&"&(#+!%%+$&(8:=%("&(/#$"$+!;",#'!:!+=&(!%%+$!(%#;&",",# +#-&'#$3!='%!:#',#3#"&"&(#+9(!""!&(&(8",#!8#'/3#+!((/!"&(9 +#"&+#$+<'#+-&%#!'''&'"!(" #8&'"+!+ D!<&(!"&( (* 

 33!+#(":=9;,#(",#3#('&(%!'#",#3#"&"&(#+;!'2#&(83+%#''#$9 '<#!(<!:=%!<#"",#("&%#",#!/",+&"&#'%%+$&(8:=9!',; %!/'#("&%#$!"#$

@ ((#D/+#77 ;!'&''/#$9'"!"&(8",!"",# 3"&(  8&-#(  2=  ",#  3#"&"&(#+  ''&'"!("  #8&'"+!+9  D!<&(!"&(  + &D!"&(,#+3!=;&",##%"+<B9&'("%++#%"";!'("&%#$ ",!"  ",#  0"!"#  -#+(<#("  ,!'  8&-#(  !  '3#%&!:  &(%+#<#("  "  ",'# -#+(<#("#<3:=##' ((78!E#""#$#<3:=##' 9;,$&$("3!+"&%&3!"# &(",#'"+&?#(B,#'!&$'3#%&!:&(%+#<#("%!(("2#"+#!"#$! (+<!:&(%+#<#(",#+#+#9,#+3!=&':&!2:#"2#&D#$+<B9 &('"#!$B ,#+#!"#+9",#3#"&"&(#+%,!::#(8#$",#'!&$("&%# 2#+#",&' /+"2=;!=&:&(8  *@

@9"&":#$!'

!+',!(&  #-&  .#+'/'  ,#  0"!"#   /(1!2  !($  ",#+'9  ((#D/+#77

::= ;&",!3+!=#+"+#:#!'#",#+#"&+!:2#(#&"'!($21#%"&(8"+#7 &D!"&(,#+3!=,#'!&$;+&"3#"&"&(;!'%((#%"#$;&",!(",#+  CC

9"&":#$!' 6!+(!&:0&(8,.#+'/'0"!"#/(1!2!($ ",#+'9 ((#D/+#77 ::= ",",#;+&"3#"&"&(';#+#$&'3'#$( *C C98&-&(8:&2#+"="",#0"!"#"3+%##$&(!%%+$!(%#;&",",# '"!"#<#("<!$#2=",#:#!+(#$0"!"#%/('#:

7*7 (-&#;",#<!""#+9",#3#"&"&(#+'/2<&""#$!+#3+#'#("!"&( $!"#$  ((#D/+#77B "+#'3($#("'"#+%('&$#+&(8",# '!<#9+#'3($#("'3!''#$",#&<3/8(#$+$#+$!"#$

C

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

7C7 +$#+$!"#$B ((#D/+#77@ 9,#+3!=;!'&D#$9"+#!"&(8,#+$!"# 3"&(!'B,#3#"&"&(#+%("&(/#$"$+!;",#'!:!+=!%%+$&(8 "",#'!&$'#%($3"&(";!'(:=!"#+",#+#"&+#<#("",#3#"&"&(#+ (* 

;,#(",#"+/2:#!+'#33!+#(":=9;,#(",#$#3!+"<#(" '/2<&""#$",#%!'#",#3#"&"&(#+"",#%(%#+(#$!/",+&"&#'+3#('&(9 ",!"#+++;!'$#"#%"#$!($%('#A/#(":=(;,#+3!=,!'2##(+#7&D#$!' 3#+,#+&+'"3"&(;&",##%"+<B ;9",#A/#'"&(;/:$!+&'#+%('&$#+!"&(2#+#",&'

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

  ;9 +#'3($#("'+#7&D#$ ",# 3!=  ",# 3#"&"&(#+9 %('&$#+&(8,#+&+'" 3"&(;&",##%"+<B,#3+#'#("+$#+',!-#2##(3!''#$( 

 !<",#-&#;",!"&",#0"!"#%!(+#%"&='/%,#+++!"#+C =#!+'9",#3#"&"&(#+%!(!:'2#!::;#$"#D#+%&'#",#3"&(+<",#$!"# ,#+%,&%# ,#&$#("&%!:<!""#+;!'%('&$#+#$2=",&' /+"&( 

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

'!+!'+#/'&(8",##D#+%&'# +#',3"&(2=",#3#"&"&(#+9&'!:' A/!',#$!($",#3#"&"&(#+&'3#+<&""#$"'/2<&"+#',3"&(+",#$!"# &(%+#<#("9;&",&((#<(",+<",#$!"#+#%#&3"%#+"&&#$%3= ",&'+$#+!($'/2<&"",#'!<#"",#$#3!+"<#(""#+",#+#',3"&(&' '/2<&""#$9",#3!=!($3#('&(",#3#"&"&(#+;&::2#!%%+$&(8:=+#7&D#$ !:(;8&",  %('#A/#("&!:  2#(#&"'   ,#  3!=    ",#  3#"&"&(#+  ;&::  2# ("&(!::=&D#$+<",#$!"#3"&(!($(!++#!+'',!::2#3!&$ ,#3+#'#(";+&"3#"&"&(&'!::;#$

50     *  '1?' ,#",#+'3#!?&(8 +#!'(#$ ) #' ,#",#+ #3+"!2:# ) #'